Need a good and fast esata raid-5 controller card

theinv

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 17, 2008
Messages
216
Hi,

I need your help here. I got this Micronet 4-bay eSATA external enclousre recently. The drive came with a pci-express x1 raid controller card that uses the Silicon image sil3132 chipset.


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822204056


I have the 4 drives setup in a raid-5 configuration. The setup went smooth, but what troubles me is the write speed. It is very very slow, barely exceeded 3.1MB/sec. I thought the problem was in the BIOS or the driver, so I updated my system with the latest BIOS and drivers for the controller card, but no changes on speed at all.

Is RAID-5 always this slow? What kind of speed I should expect from a raid-5 setup using the sil3132 cards?

I am thinking of buying a better and faster raid controller card. It has too support raid-5 and have e-sata ports. Do you have any recommendations? My budget limit is $400.


My system:

Motherboard: asus p5w-dh deluxe
CPU: intel quad core Q6600
OS: windows vista 64bit
RAM: 6GB RAM



Thanks!
 
I would return it and get this instead: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16816856004
It includes a hardware RAID card and you will get much higher performance with it. I can't think of any hardware RAID cards that include eSATA and support for port multipliers (which is what your enclosure is using).

Thanks. I am buying it for personal use, so it is too expensive for me. Returning product to newegg is a pain. They charge 15% restocking fee.

How about the Highpoint RocketRAID controllers? I heard that they are semi-hardware and better than the silicon image sil31xx series. Anyone use them?

http://www.pc-pitstop.com/sata_raid_controllers/2314.asp
 
That is an awful write speed. Have you speed tested the drives individually?
 
Thanks. I am buying it for personal use, so it is too expensive for me. Returning product to newegg is a pain. They charge 15% restocking fee.

How about the Highpoint RocketRAID controllers? I heard that they are semi-hardware and better than the silicon image sil31xx series. Anyone use them?

http://www.pc-pitstop.com/sata_raid_controllers/2314.asp
It says nothing about supporting port multipliers (which you need). As I said before, you will most likely not find a suitable RAID card for that enclosure. If I were in your position, I would call newegg and tell them that the product you bought didn't meet your expectations and you want to buy something more expensive. I bet you could easily talk your way out of the restocking fee.
 
That is an awful write speed. Have you speed tested the drives individually?


I just did a test. I am surprised to see that two of the hard drives only get 36MB/secwrite while the other two get 90MB/sec. The drives are all hitachi drives, same model.



Individual disk write speed:
---------------------------

disk1: 37MB/sec (write)
disk2: 90MB/sec (write)
disk3: 36MB/sec (write)
disk4: 90MB/sec (write)


Raid setup write speed:
-----------------------

RAID0: 75 MB/sec(write)
RAID1: 19 MB/sec(write)
RAID5: 3 MB/sec(write)
 
It says nothing about supporting port multipliers (which you need). As I said before, you will most likely not find a suitable RAID card for that enclosure. If I were in your position, I would call newegg and tell them that the product you bought didn't meet your expectations and you want to buy something more expensive. I bet you could easily talk your way out of the restocking fee.



Given that I got slow speed on two of the drives in individual test, I am leaning toward returning it and get one that comes with hardware controller.

But just minutes ago, I found this e-sata controller, Areca ARC-1202. It is a hardware controller and supports port multiplier. Will it work with my enclosure?

http://www.anova.com/pc-264-76-areca-arc-1202-pcie-2-port-external-esata-raid-controller.aspx

http://www.starline.de/Areca-ARC-1200-1202-RAID-Controller/Areca-ARC-1200-1202-RAID-Controller.php
 
Probably might want to email the manufacturer whether or not you can use a 3rd party controller.
 
Given that I got slow speed on two of the drives in individual test, I am leaning toward returning it and get one that comes with hardware controller.

But just minutes ago, I found this e-sata controller, Areca ARC-1202. It is a hardware controller and supports port multiplier. Will it work with my enclosure?

http://www.anova.com/pc-264-76-areca-arc-1202-pcie-2-port-external-esata-raid-controller.aspx

http://www.starline.de/Areca-ARC-1200-1202-RAID-Controller/Areca-ARC-1200-1202-RAID-Controller.php
Well, I think that would do it then.
 
Do you think the CineRaid sub system will perfrom better than the Areca 1202?
That thing actually includes an Areca card, so it will be quite similar. Only limiting factor of your proposed setup is that everything is running through a single port, so you would be limited to 300mb/s (which shouldn't be much of a concern with 4 drives).
 
I believe a problem here is the use of the port multiplier for RAID-5.

I've heard people complain before that using esata with Port multiplier and RAID 5 kills performance.

I am attempting to do a similar setup (external raid 5 array on a budget). Check out my thread (raid 5 here I come).
 
true, the problem for me is i only have PCIEx1 so I'm limited in what hardware raid card i can use. As far as I know the areca is the only pciex1 hardware raid card that has raid 5.
 
Back
Top