Need a decent cheap board

duncandun

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 13, 2005
Messages
171
While Decent, and Cheap may be a conflict in terms to some people, It's what I'm looking for.

I'm getting a new PC together, nothing BLAZING or even close to It, but good enough to run most games I'm interested in well(DOW2 for example). Main thing Is the lack of SSE2 support in my xp 2200+. Never had this issue till I tried to play DOW2 beta this weekend!

Anyway, so far I have :
HD- http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136320
v-card (4830)http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127394R
proc- http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819116072

I already have 2gb of ddr2 800 ram(ocz)
Antec300 case(kind of small, but supports full ATX)

I plan on running vista 64bit and windows 7 64 when It releases.

So I was looking at micro atx boards(because they are in the price range i was originally looking at(40-60)) but because of an apparent distinct lack of OC support among mATX boards I've decided against this unless I can find one that does.


So what would you guys recommend? I didn't want to spend over 300 dollars, but it doesn't seem like I can keep it below that without taking too big of a hit in the mobo department.

I've extended it to 340 dollars.

Anyone got any ideas?

Oh and I'm not fixed on Intel, I just am not up to speed with AMD at all, so I don't know if theres anything comparable/better in that price range.
 
$340 for what, all the things you listed plus the motherboard? Or just for the motherboard?
 
everything, sorry. That increase puts mobo at around 100 dollarish.

but lower is best.
 
I'll go ahead and recommend the Gigabyte GA-EP45-DS3L - $85 After MIR.

Hmm, seems a little overkill for my setup. Though it does seem sweet!

Curious - Is there a significant performance hit when down throttling a 16x card to 8x? I notice that almost all of the lower budget mobos don't have 16x lanes.

Also, difference between 2.0 and 1.0(I assume 1.0) Pci-E?
 
No I definetly wouldn't say it is overkill. You mentioned you wanted good overclock settings and that board has pretty good OC-ability. Also you would not want to run a PCI-e 2.0 on a 1.1 because that is half the bandwidth, and then if you ran it on an 8x 1.1, then you are getting a quarter of the bandwidth. Besides with that board the total gets you right at $332 which is under your $340 budget. That's about the best you can do if you are looking for quality and cheap...
 
there's an open box ASUS P5Q Deluxe for $99.99 shipped...right around your $340 budget...

even cheaper is an open box ASUS P5Q SE PLUS for $49.99 shipped...just under your original budget of $300...

assuming of course the 4830 shipping keeps it around $100 total for the card...
 
Hmm, seems a little overkill for my setup. Though it does seem sweet!

Curious - Is there a significant performance hit when down throttling a 16x card to 8x? I notice that almost all of the lower budget mobos don't have 16x lanes.

Also, difference between 2.0 and 1.0(I assume 1.0) Pci-E?
How is it overkill? It's just a cheap P45 board.

Going from PCI-E 2.0 16x to 8x has effectively little to no effect on performance. However, you're incorrect in stating that lower-budget mobos don't have 16x lanes. Every consumer motherboard with a PCI-E graphics slot will support full 16x operation. Some boards with two PEG slots will go down to 8x on both when two cards are installed due to chipset limitations, but they are all capable of running a single card at full speed.

The major difference between PCI-E 2.0 and 1.x is that PCI-E 2.0 has twice as much bandwidth per lane compared to 1.x. This essentially means that a 2.0 8x slot is equivalent to a 16x PCI-E 1.x slot, and that a 2.0 16x slot can handle twice as much data as a PCI-E 1.x 16x slot.

Also, if you can spare an extra $5, I recommend you go with this HD: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136319
It uses higher-density platters, so it will perform faster than the one you picked out. Plus, the higher capacity is always nice ;).
 
^^^ That's not entirely true. Some of the IGP mATX boards only have x4 bandwidth on the x16 slot. I was looking at that market a little while ago and noticed.
 
^^^ That's not entirely true. Some of the IGP mATX boards only have x4 bandwidth on the x16 slot. I was looking at that market a little while ago and noticed.
Which chipsets? All of Intel's current-gen IGP chipsets have enough PCI-E lanes to support full 16x PEG slots.
 
How is it overkill? It's just a cheap P45 board.

Going from PCI-E 2.0 16x to 8x has effectively little to no effect on performance. However, you're incorrect in stating that lower-budget mobos don't have 16x lanes. Every consumer motherboard with a PCI-E graphics slot will support full 16x operation. Some boards with two PEG slots will go down to 8x on both when two cards are installed due to chipset limitations, but they are all capable of running a single card at full speed.

The major difference between PCI-E 2.0 and 1.x is that PCI-E 2.0 has twice as much bandwidth per lane compared to 1.x. This essentially means that a 2.0 8x slot is equivalent to a 16x PCI-E 1.x slot, and that a 2.0 16x slot can handle twice as much data as a PCI-E 1.x 16x slot.

Also, if you can spare an extra $5, I recommend you go with this HD: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136319
It uses higher-density platters, so it will perform faster than the one you picked out. Plus, the higher capacity is always nice ;).

Thanks for the advice, and most of the mATX boards I looked at(on the manufacturer site) stated the 16x slots were downthrottled to 8x.

I'm going to get the p5q that the post above mentioned, for that price you can't beat it I think.

For instance the GIGABYTE GA-G31M-ES2L runs the 16x at 8x.

Open box P5q Pro, looking at this now... for 69 it seems like a steal and hardly goes over my budget. I was able to pick up the HD and processor for cheaps from amazon(free shipping), so I saved about 7 dollars there.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131299R
 
Thanks for the advice, and most of the mATX boards I looked at(on the manufacturer site) stated the 16x slots were downthrottled to 8x.

I'm going to get the p5q that the post above mentioned, for that price you can't beat it I think.

For instance the GIGABYTE GA-G31M-ES2L runs the 16x at 8x.

Open box P5q Pro, looking at this now... for 69 it seems like a steal and hardly goes over my budget. I was able to pick up the HD and processor for cheaps from amazon(free shipping), so I saved about 7 dollars there.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131299R

I HIGHLY don't recommend buying motherboards (or anything for that matter) open box on Newegg. Newegg apparently sells all open-box products without any accessories that otherwise come with the board. Most important thing being the I/O shield and driver CD.
 
I HIGHLY don't recommend buying motherboards (or anything for that matter) open box on Newegg. Newegg apparently sells all open-box products without any accessories that otherwise come with the board. Most important thing being the I/O shield and driver CD.

I disagree. I've ordered four open-box motherboards from NewEgg in the past two years. Three of the four came as a bare board, while one came in the retail box with the full accessories. All worked fine, and I don't worry so much about missing cables since I have a box full of extras from previous motherboard purchases.

For the bare boards: Price for open-box board + cost of I/O shield << New price.

Asrock charged $5 (shipped!) for an I/O shield, while Asus was $9 (shipped).

A 10-cent blank CD-R, a high-speed connection, and the manufacturer's website = driver CD. In fact, in most cases, you'll get the newer drivers via downlaod rather than the CD anyway.
 
I disagree. I've ordered four open-box motherboards from NewEgg in the past two years. Three of the four came as a bare board, while one came in the retail box with the full accessories. All worked fine, and I don't worry so much about missing cables since I have a box full of extras from previous motherboard purchases.

For the bare boards: Price for open-box board + cost of I/O shield << New price.

Asrock charged $5 (shipped!) for an I/O shield, while Asus was $9 (shipped).

A 10-cent blank CD-R, a high-speed connection, and the manufacturer's website = driver CD. In fact, in most cases, you'll get the newer drivers via downlaod rather than the CD anyway.

I guess that is to each their own, I wouldn't find it worth the savings to have to spend all that extra time/ hassle to order a new I/O shield when I can get everything the first time.
 
I guess that is to each their own, I wouldn't find it worth the savings to have to spend all that extra time/ hassle to order a new I/O shield when I can get everything the first time.

I guess. For me, the hassle of going to the manufacturer's website to order the I/O shield is worth a savings of $30 to $100 ;)

Then again, I'm patient. I can wait a week for additional accesories ... I have five desktop PC's at home to use while I wait :D
 
Also, if you can save up a bit more it is deffinatly worth getting a 4850 over a 4830 for the graphics card
 
I guess that is to each their own, I wouldn't find it worth the savings to have to spend all that extra time/ hassle to order a new I/O shield when I can get everything the first time.

that board is a steal for $50 (basically half price), there's not much time or hassle involved with going to the ASUS E-store and ordering the I/O shield for $10, also, I have all the drivers I need for my motherboards, video cards, etc., in my setup folder on one of my backup drives, the drivers on most product CDs are usually outdated anyway, if I were buying an open box motherboard I would definitely add any files I thought I might need to an ASUS P5Q SE PLUS folder on my drive before it arrived so that I would be ready...
 
there's an open box ASUS P5Q Deluxe for $99.99 shipped...right around your $340 budget...

even cheaper is an open box ASUS P5Q SE PLUS for $49.99 shipped...just under your original budget of $300...

assuming of course the 4830 shipping keeps it around $100 total for the card...

I ended up ordering one of the P5Q SE Plus boards. I'm sure I can use it as the basis for a cheap build ...
 
I ended up ordering one of the P5Q SE Plus boards. I'm sure I can use it as the basis for a cheap build ...

I think I'm gonna order one tomorrow, I'm gonna try to talk myself out of buying it tonight, but damn, $50 for a decent P45 motherboard...? hell, I think I'd jump on that if it was in the for sale forum...
 
Is the difference between the P5q SE plus board and the P5q Pro board that negligible?
 
Is the difference between the P5q SE plus board and the P5q Pro board that negligible?
Not really. The P5Q Pro is built with better components, has more features, better cooling, and a significantly better layout as well. It also has a second PCI-E graphics slot and two more SATA ports. Which one to get depends on which features you really need.
 
Is the difference between the P5q SE plus board and the P5q Pro board that negligible?

IMO, no. The P5Q SE has a bad placement of the 24Pin CPU connector that can obstruct airflow and/or impeded cable management. In addition, the P5Q SE does not have heatpipe cooling on the northbridge and mosfets meaning lower possible OCs. Also, the P5Q SE does not have support for Crossfire and has two less SATA ports than the P5Q Pro. Other differences:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...mpareItemList=N82E16813131347,N82E16813131299
 
Not really. The P5Q Pro is built with better components, has more features, better cooling, and a significantly better layout as well. It also has a second PCI-E graphics slot and two more SATA ports. Which one to get depends on which features you really need.

IMO, no. The P5Q SE has a bad placement of the 24Pin CPU connector that can obstruct airflow and/or impeded cable management. In addition, the P5Q SE does not have heatpipe cooling on the northbridge and mosfets meaning lower possible OCs. Also, the P5Q SE does not have support for Crossfire and has two less SATA ports than the P5Q Pro. Other differences:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...mpareItemList=N82E16813131347,N82E16813131299

Intersting, Guess I'm still going with the pro then, for 60 something dollars you can't beat it for that kind of quality i suppose.

Also crossfire support is A++ awesome, I plan at some point in the future getting another 4830 and crossfiring them to help keep up with the curve. Probably 5 or 6 months down the line.

Oh, I don't suppose either have built in Wireless do they?
 
Back
Top