Need 22" LCD for Photo Editing

Phimp

Gawd
Joined
Dec 9, 2006
Messages
596
I'm looking for a 22"-ish LCD that's going to be used for many things, but mainly photo editing. I'll be printing images with a high-end Epson printer, so color representation is fairly important. I'll also be using it for 4-5 hours of web browsing per day and probably a nightly DVD (via the pc, not a separate player).

So I don't need much more than DVI for input.

I'm hoping to get away with this for under $300.

At a few friends' houses, I've used some of the newer Samsung LCD's and they've all impressed me after they had been calibrated. I love the Samsung 226BW in particular.

So looking at just Samsung, here are five LCD's I'm looking at.
226BW
2220WM
220WM
2253LW
216BW

It doesn't have to be a Samsung, those are just where I've started the search after finding nothing appealing in the [H]ot|Deals sub-forum.

If I can't be swayed from it, I'll probably pull the trigger on the 226BW.

Suggestions are much appreciated!

Thanks

------------------------------------

UPDATE: (so you don't have to read the entire thing to throw a quick reply at the bottom ;))
These are the LCD's I'm looking at, for a budget display to work with photos/design work.
$390 - BenQ G2400W
$420 - Samsung 245BW
$330 - LG L226WTY-BF
$320 - LG W2252TQ-TF

------------------------------------

UPDATE #2:
I've decided to go with the Dell 2007FWP.
I guess I should just buy it from Dell.com? $426 w/ S&H.
 
just to clear something for you.
you need to forget all these models, cause all of them a TN Panels,which is not suitable for Photo Editing. case for its "poor" color representation "mainly".
but if you work with one if them and you got satisfied! with its quality..just wait for the recommendation.


sure you will get the Advices you'll need from all the experts members here.
 
All 22" monitors with the exception of 1 or 2 on the entire market use TN panels (and those 1 or 2 cost about an arm and a leg ~ $2000).

In short, don't waste your time with 6-bit TN Panels if color reproduction is important to you.

Go for a SIPS panel, the Dell UltraSharp's (those which made use of SIPS technology -- most of them did in fact) for example are known for their quality.

My monitor for example. the 20" Dell 2007FP UltraSharp runs around $400 these days.
http://accessories.us.dell.com/sna/productdetail.aspx?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs&sku=320-4687

The quality of that panel would destroy any 22" TN on the market, it's a night/day difference.
 
I would strongly prefer to get a widescreen display, not absolutely needed, but it would be a huge help with web design and programming.

And I would like to stay below like... $350 shipped...
I'm hoping the perfect monitor pops up in the [H]ot Deals sub-forum sometime soon, but I'm aiming at making a purchase by next Monday.

So, what if I'm not needing absolutely top-notch color representation and such? How bad are those TN Samsungs I listed before as far as all that stuff goes? They seemed HORRIBLE out of the box, but after some calibration they seemed spot on to me... :confused:
 
All 22" monitors with the exception of 1 or 2 on the entire market use TN panels (and those 1 or 2 cost about an arm and a leg ~ $2000).

In short, don't waste your time with 6-bit TN Panels if color reproduction is important to you.

Go for a SIPS panel, the Dell UltraSharp's (those which made use of SIPS technology -- most of them did in fact) for example are known for their quality.

My monitor for example. the 20" Dell 2007FP UltraSharp runs around $400 these days.
http://accessories.us.dell.com/sna/productdetail.aspx?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs&sku=320-4687

The quality of that panel would destroy any 22" TN on the market, it's a night/day difference.

those dells are already listed as a non color critical panel not suitable for accurate photo editing. they are PVA panels with way too much black crush.

to the OP:
your not going to find a photo editing panel for $300. the only panels suitable for that are IPS panels. without accurate panel colors, your printer photos will be fubar'd
 
I would strongly prefer to get a widescreen display, not absolutely needed, but it would be a huge help with web design and programming.

And I would like to stay below like... $350 shipped...
I'm hoping the perfect monitor pops up in the [H]ot Deals sub-forum sometime soon, but I'm aiming at making a purchase by next Monday.

So, what if I'm not needing absolutely top-notch color representation and such? How bad are those TN Samsungs I listed before as far as all that stuff goes? They seemed HORRIBLE out of the box, but after some calibration they seemed spot on to me... :confused:

no, avoid TN panels like the plague. they are NOT and i repeat NOT color accurate monitors by any stretch. 6 bit color is not even close to accurate colors representation.
 
Well, what would be the best bet for ~$350?
Because that's pretty much the absolute max that I have to spend on a display right now...

I might be better off buying one of the Samsung wide lcd's to use for programming, web browsing, gaming, movies, etc. and wait for a little while until I can afford an IPS panel...
 
get samsung 2243bwx , very good monitor for many graphics application
 
+1 for the CRT idea. If you cant afford a proper panel for the tasks you do, you don't want to go for it. I use a Samsung TN panel and let me tell you, I do not do any photo work and the poor colors bug me anyway just for my amateurish Photoshop stuff.

You won't be able to find a good CRT in any of the regular retail shops, but there are a few places around the net that still stock nearly-new (or new) CRTs with some form of small warranty.
 
Well, because of limited deskspace, I really can't go for a CRT.

Thanks wawoo for the suggestion.

I'm trying to talk myself into pulling the trigger on the Samsung 2243bwx, but if I can't do it or can't fit it into my budget, I'm going to go for a sub $300 22" lcd for general use, and in a couple paychecks I'll swing for a $500 display that can give me correct colors.

So for now, what monitor will serve me the best for under $300. Buy.com has tons of BenQ, Samsung and a few Acer 22" displays that are all under $300.

For example, the Acer P22WAd is priced at $260 and has all 5 star reviews on their site.
Any users of this monitor?

Thanks for the feedback so far guys!
 
I loved my 216BW :)
I used it for a few hours and was quite impressed.


I had a look at my finances and budget for the display, and I suppose I can push it to $400-ish at the absolute max.

Anyways, a whole lot more reading, here's a list of LCD's that I've seen suggested for photo/design work on a budget.

(I found "The LCD Thread" on AnandTech extremely helpful)

$390 - BenQ G2400W
$420 - Samsung 245BW
$330 - LG L226WTY-BF
$320 - LG W2252TQ-TF

The BenQ is supposedly the nicest out of them all, and I'm really tempted to go for it. Suggestions?
 
Well, because of limited deskspace, I really can't go for a CRT.

Thanks wawoo for the suggestion.

I'm trying to talk myself into pulling the trigger on the Samsung 2243bwx, but if I can't do it or can't fit it into my budget,

you can get it for 300 or 320 $ just search a bit , very good colors and many options , and minimal problems , I checked all your selection , the 2243 was the best for the price, you will appreciates the rotation stand and usb ports , and good size screen , just see it and test it you will understand what I mean .
 
those dells are already listed as a non color critical panel not suitable for accurate photo editing. they are PVA panels with way too much black crush.

to the OP:
your not going to find a photo editing panel for $300. the only panels suitable for that are IPS panels. without accurate panel colors, your printer photos will be fubar'd

That's not true at all.
Those Dell's are SIPS panels for the most part, and are known far and wide for their color reproduction and overall quality.
SIPS panels are the cream of the crop in TFT land.

Dell did have a "panel lottery" in recent years as far as some of their UltraSharp's go (i.e. some used PVA panels and even those are far superior to any TN panel), but most of their UltraSharp's have been SIPS panels nonetheless.

For example:
Dell 2001FP UltraSharp : The 2001FP uses a 16ms LG.Philips S-IPS panel (LM201U04)
Dell 2005 - 2007 UltraSharp line : Dell have built on the great success of the 2005FPW with a new design and somewhat updated specification. Sticking with S-IPS panel technology from LG.Philips
Dell3007 WFP UltraSharp : The screen itself features a 30" S-IPS panel from LG.Philips, the LM300W01
 
Anyone have experience with Buy.com's return policy for dead pixels?
If I see a dead pixel and I can't return it, I'll throw up.
25191896.puke.gif


Because I'm itching to pull the trigger on the 2243bwx

But I've really been hoping to find a display that is in stock in a local B&M store like BestBuy so I could
. a) have it sooner
. b) not worry so much about the hassle of an RMA if needed
. c) i have a BB gift card :p

I'm hoping to have one ordered within 24 hours. :)
 
That's not true at all.
Those Dell's are SIPS panels for the most part, and are known far and wide for their color reproduction and overall quality.
SIPS panels are the cream of the crop in TFT land.

so what dell model that have sips panel and you can get it new now, are this sips panel still available any where and new
 
..My monitor for example. the 20" Dell 2007FP UltraSharp runs around $400 these days.
http://accessories.us.dell.com/sna/productdetail.aspx?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs&sku=320-4687...

You lised the wrong monitor. The Dell 2007WFP is what he needs. Yes, it lists $400 new, IPS and wide screen. If you can't do that or a CRT, then you should look for it on Ebay.

TN + Photo Editing = crap. There is no good 6 bit panel for photo editing end of story. Ad the poor viewing angles and you got a product that is good for web surfing and gaming and that is about it.
 
I would get the Dell 2007FP...that has more real estate than the 2007WFP (1600x1200 vs 1680x1050). Find one on ebay, and ask the seller to verify that the model number has an "L" at the end--that means the panel was made by LG, and is therefore an IPS. That way you can avoid panel lottery and probably get the monitor for $150-200 less. They seem to go for around $200 on ebay.

I have the IPS 2007FP at work (I'm a web designer), and it's great. I could go for more space sometimes, which is why I'm going to pick up a Doublesight 26" for personal usage soon.
 
If you can find it, I would look for the Dell 2005FPW used.

I have one and it is an excellent S-IPS display with an sRGB mode. There are no VA versions of this panel. The only thing missing is HDCP, which you may not care about for PC.

I echo the recommendation of others that TN is not a good panel type for photo editing. Of all the TNs you mentioned the only one with "out of box" accurate colors is the BenQ, but even that is a large stretch, regardless of the fact that it has decent vertical viewing angles (very good for a TN).

See if you can find even a refurb 2005FPW, 2001 or 2007WFP/2007FP like many here have mentioned.

Or the 2007FP new if it's on sale (hopefully soon).

Good luck,

10e
 
Well, I would really rather not buy a used display on eBay..

I've narrowed it down to either the 2007WFP or the 2243BWX.
I can get the 2243bwx for a full $100 cheaper, at only $300, which fits perfectly into my original budget.

The widescreen with the 2243bwx is a HUGE plus.
The extra 2" also makes a HUGE difference... physical size of the monitor is a very big deal to me. Everytime I see that "20 inches" in the specs, I cringe.

I would maybe go for a used or refurb 22" model Dell, if there is such a thing, if it were closer to the price range.

I love that they both come with stands that allow them to rotate the screen 90 degrees to portrait mode.

So I'm just a little torn here because I've heard great things about the 2243bwx from photo experts, stating that it is a great monitor for color reproduction on a budget - which is what I am on.
But then some people are saying that all TN panels are the worst thing ever and should be used to beat terrorists with.


Edit: How about the 2208wfp ???
Edit #2: errr... ^ apparently it is just a nice TN panel. Still... would it be better than the 2243bwx?
 
Why the 2243bwx and not the 2253BW, is there a reason for this?

Just curious because I'm not sure what the difference between the two are.

Is it just because of the more adjustable stand?
 
um.... I'm not 100% sure but from what I've heard, the 2243bwx is aimed more towards office use.

I dunno for sure, but I'm ordering an LCD tonight. And as of now, I'm gettin the 2243bwx.
I need a 22" lcd that is the best for photo editing and such... that is under $400 absolute max.
Tilt is a large plus so I can use it in portrait mode.
 
I'd get a 2007WFP. I have two right now, and they are very well built. Neither has backlight bleed or dead pixels. One of them is an exchange from a 2005fpw that was perfect for more than a year, than developed a dark area. I exchanged it after more than 2 years of ownership and got a new one overnighted (3 year standard warranty).

The 2007WFP is a widescreen monitor that is the same resolution as the 22" monitors.
 
I'd get a 2007WFP. I have two right now, and they are very well built. Neither has backlight bleed or dead pixels. One of them was an exchange from a 2005fpw that was perfect for more than a year, than developed a dark area. I exchanged it after more than 2 years of ownership and got a new one overnighted.

The 2007WFP is a widescreen monitor that is the same resolution as the 22" monitors.

It's the same resolution, but 2" is a lot of extra physical screen to have. it'll be easier to read text at the highest resolution.
It's just... I'm using a 19" fullscreen lcd right now... and when i used the 226bw wide 22" for a month or so, it was so painful going back to this little fullscreen 19"... it seemed so friggin huge compared to it... that's a 3" difference... so I'm thinkin a 1" difference wouldn't be that much larger..
I do admire the quality I'd be getting though.

Edit: Woah... the Dell site says the 2007WFP has a 16ms response time?! That would suck for movies wouldn't it? And an attempt at playin a little crysis would make me wanna puke..
 
I had a 24" dell 2405 (PVA, I believe) It was stolen, so I upgraded to a 2007WFP.
I like the 2007WFP a lot better. But the 2405 is supposedly one of the worst VA type panels out there, and I haven't used any others since then. All my work and home monitors since then have been IPS or TN.

Will you will be using the 19" as a secondary display?
 
Ya, I'll have the 19" as a secondary display off to the left, so I guess I could maybe talk myself into not caring about those extra 2"... but I watch a lot of movies on my computer from like 5 ft away, so an extra 2" could help...

I wanna purchase a monitor within the hour..

If I were to up the budget to $450. Are there any non-TN 22" available?
 
A Lenovo L220x should be available for around $450. It is an S-PVA panel. Not ideal but certainly far better than TN.
 
A Lenovo L220x should be available for around $450. It is an S-PVA panel. Not ideal but certainly far better than TN.
I really don't like the design of that display, no rotation with the stand either..

I think I might just sacrifice a couple inches and go with the 2007wfp and if i regret it later, then whatever, I'll just deal with it.

Edit: second thought... I just can't talk myself into getting only 20" when my budget is ~$400 or so...
here is a rough comparison of my 19" to screen size of a 20" wide
whereas a 22" wide is about the same height as a 19" fullscreen, just a lot wider.

I'm thinking I'm gonna go with the 2243bwx, and in 3-6 months I'll go all out and pick up a 22 or 24 S-IPS panel for $600-$700.

Should I order from Buy.com, NewEgg, TigerDirect, or BHPhotoVideo.com ?
I seriously can't stand having dead pixels, and I'm finding mixed things about their lcd exchange policies.
 
Well, what would be the best bet for ~$350?
Because that's pretty much the absolute max that I have to spend on a display right now...

I might be better off buying one of the Samsung wide lcd's to use for programming, web browsing, gaming, movies, etc. and wait for a little while until I can afford an IPS panel...


A good used Dell 2005fpw (20" IPS panel) on e-bay will run you around $220, get one with original Dell packaging and a return policy.
 
If it was 22" or hell, even 21.X" or something, I would be all over the Dell Display... but I just can't go with a 20".

I'm gonna order the 2243bwx through TigerDirect (good dead pixel policy) I guess... and in a few months time, I'll be ready to go all out on a large Dell Display.
 
...But then some people are saying that all TN panels are the worst thing ever and should be used to beat terrorists with...
Nah, just for edit their photos.:D

Well you seem determined so its up to you but there two very basic reason why no TN panel is acceptable for photo editing.

1) All current TN panels 6 bit color. In order to display the most basic PC standard, sRGB accurately you need at least 8 bit color. The difference 6 bit = 65,536 colors and 8 bit = 16.7 million colors. To make up for that defecit 6 bit panels us dithering to attempt to blend the image. Its sorty of like taking monkey shit and spreading it across a piece of plexiglass. Or less colorfully, it leads to banding or crushed images (see link on dithering for a detail explanation).

2) Viewing angles. With a TN panel the viewing angles are so crazy sensitive to color shift, particularly the vertical, that you will need a rig like Malcolm McDowell wore in the rehabilitation scenes in "A Clockwork Orange." Or I suppose that head strap the optometrist uses would work as well. The basic point being, don't even move your head an inch up or down or BAM! Color shift.

TN panels are great for gamers and consumers with poor vision or poor taste or have no choice but not for photo imaging. I've used them, ran away screaming. On the other hand I use the Dell 2007WFP at work it simple beats anything else I have seen in the sub $400 market and would be the only monitor in that bracket that is suitable for photo editing.

clockworkbigrt9.jpg
 
Luthorcrow, thanks for the in-depth reply, and I love the image lol
I am going to go with the 2007WFP.

So I have just a few remaining questions regarding this Display...
Best place to purchase it? Directly through Dell? (Through Dell is $426 after S&H.) I do not want a used one.
Isn't 800:1 a poor contrast ratio?

Thanks a lot to everyone who's made a reply so far!

Edit:
I found a review where a user complained about a banding issue with the display when using DVI :( (link to review)
Apparently if you receive a model A00 then it is unit that has banding, any other model and the issue has been fixed.
Should I worry about this? Or are those units probably long gone, because it IS a review from 2006, but I'm just worried I'm gonna get a unit that has this issue...
 
I don't think you would have to worry about banding. The A00 revs are likely very long gone.

Enjoy the new monitor. It's a great screen. Costco sells Dell, as does Staples now, form what I know if you prefer to try and get it retail, but I think it might be tough, because most retail chains only sell the lower end consumer commercial stuff.

Regards,

10e

Luthorcrow, thanks for the in-depth reply, and I love the image lol
I am going to go with the 2007WFP.

So I have just a few remaining questions regarding this Display...
Best place to purchase it? Directly through Dell? (Through Dell is $426 after S&H.) I do not want a used one.
Isn't 800:1 a poor contrast ratio?

Thanks a lot to everyone who's made a reply so far!

Edit:
I found a review where a user complained about a banding issue with the display when using DVI :( (link to review)
Apparently if you receive a model A00 then it is unit that has banding, any other model and the issue has been fixed.
Should I worry about this? Or are those units probably long gone, because it IS a review from 2006, but I'm just worried I'm gonna get a unit that has this issue...
 
...Isn't 800:1 a poor contrast ratio?....
Not for an IPS panel. Right now contrast ratio is the only thing that TN/PVA panels do better but it comes at the cost of crushed darks so its still a loss. Its getting better but contrast will be an issue until the next tech (OLED, etc). Until then blacks/dark colors will look better if you keep the lights on in your room. Turning lights down too low will exaggerate LCD contrast issues.

Apparently if you receive a model A00 then it is unit that has banding, any other model and the issue has been fixed....
You are likely to receive an A04 or an A03 at the oldest. If you buy online I would do it from Dell because they are none for a good return policy and will have newer panels.

If you can find it at Cost Co, etc I would check the revision just to make sure you are not getting an older generation unit.

Enjoy the panel!:D
 
That's not true at all.
Those Dell's are SIPS panels for the most part, and are known far and wide for their color reproduction and overall quality.
SIPS panels are the cream of the crop in TFT land.

Dell did have a "panel lottery" in recent years as far as some of their UltraSharp's go (i.e. some used PVA panels and even those are far superior to any TN panel), but most of their UltraSharp's have been SIPS panels nonetheless.

For example:
Dell 2001FP UltraSharp : The 2001FP uses a 16ms LG.Philips S-IPS panel (LM201U04)
Dell 2005 - 2007 UltraSharp line : Dell have built on the great success of the 2005FPW with a new design and somewhat updated specification. Sticking with S-IPS panel technology from LG.Philips
Dell3007 WFP UltraSharp : The screen itself features a 30" S-IPS panel from LG.Philips, the LM300W01

dells are known for being somewhat cheap also, targeted to the mainstream consumer. i've worked on dells, i'm not that impressed. for printing work, no way. that IS the reason people look for accurate color monitors.
and which part isnt true? the part that says dells dont have a pro line of monitors suitable for color work? that part is very true, it doesnt matter what panel they are using.
 
I love the IPS panels, i have a Dell 2007 WFP i bought for $175. My cousin is selling his, if you want a dell 20.1" IPS 2007 then I will contact him for you. The going price is $250 and I might buy it off him because he wants a $24 inch gaming monitor instead. so just pm me if your interested. As far as ghosting goes, you'll only really see it when your web browsing such as moving the screen too fast or moving the pointer. Other than that theres really no ghosting problems with the monitor.
 
Well, neither my local Staples nor Costco have the 2007WFP in stock.

#1Filipino, although a price that is lower than the $426 through Dell.com is tempting, I'm not a fan of buying main components that I'll be using for several years, used. Especially Displays, I'd be too worried about noticeable wear on the unit - stuck pixels, faded colors, lower contrast, etc.

Well, I'm going to order it through Dell.com tonight. Definitely not a fan of the $426 price tag, but I'll live... or at least try to anyways.

If anyone has any coupons or anything that could help me get it through Dell Small/Business or some other store for cheaper, please let me know before I pull the trigger on this.

Thanks again guys!
 
Back
Top