NASA Eyes Moon for Future Space Base

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
NASA isn't quite finished with the moon just yet. According to documents from a White House NASA briefing obtained by the Orlando Sentinel, NASA is planning a near-moon floating space base to be used as a staging platform for future missions to Mars and beyond. So NASA hasn’t gotten out of the space flight business, the agency is just catching its breath before bolder ventures. :cool:

The proposed space station would be situated at what's called a Lagrangian point, or L-Point, a place where the gravitational pull of two large bodies—in this case the Earth and the Moon—are at an equilibrium, making it possible to place a spacecraft in a fixed spot in space at relatively little expense
 
What happens when your mom's house rotates in line with the space station?
 
UGH! Why on Earth (no pun) would you want to put it at L2? So that astronauts there would be able to either look at the Moon or the darkness of space, yeah that'll be awesome for moral! Also it'll pose some interesting problems when the Moon is New, and they'll get a lovely tan because they're pointing right at the Moon.

The L1 position would be much nicer because you at least can always see home. Plus it's quite a bit closer to Earth.

Also not sure why not a Moon base on the MOON. then you get the best of both worlds, you could bury your base to protect from radiation. You could potentially have limitless room to plant food crops. Sunlight for 14.5 days straight is also a bonus, although I would advise a smaller nuclear reactor just so the other 14.5 days you have energy :)
 
Also not sure why not a Moon base on the MOON. then you get the best of both worlds, you could bury your base to protect from radiation. You could potentially have limitless room to plant food crops. Sunlight for 14.5 days straight is also a bonus, although I would advise a smaller nuclear reactor just so the other 14.5 days you have energy :)

keeping food/water/plants and other things that are on earth in close environment (with glass to keep plants safe from radiation and let sunlight in) won't work, as all the experiments done on earth has proved that no matter what energy will leak no matter how close/protective the environment is. so after year or so you'll need to get more plants/food/water (or or lease one of them) up there which might cost more than just sending food with astronauts might be cheaper and more efficient than growing there.
 
UGH! Why on Earth (no pun) would you want to put it at L2? So that astronauts there would be able to either look at the Moon or the darkness of space, yeah that'll be awesome for moral! Also it'll pose some interesting problems when the Moon is New, and they'll get a lovely tan because they're pointing right at the Moon.

The L1 position would be much nicer because you at least can always see home. Plus it's quite a bit closer to Earth.

Also not sure why not a Moon base on the MOON. then you get the best of both worlds, you could bury your base to protect from radiation. You could potentially have limitless room to plant food crops. Sunlight for 14.5 days straight is also a bonus, although I would advise a smaller nuclear reactor just so the other 14.5 days you have energy :)

i wonder if they want to build it in space so that they can reduce the gravitational effects on building future space craft... you know, things like how a perfect sphere can't be built on earth, because of the gravity.. overcoming things like that
 
keeping food/water/plants and other things that are on earth in close environment (with glass to keep plants safe from radiation and let sunlight in) won't work, as all the experiments done on earth has proved that no matter what energy will leak no matter how close/protective the environment is. so after year or so you'll need to get more plants/food/water (or or lease one of them) up there which might cost more than just sending food with astronauts might be cheaper and more efficient than growing there.

14.5 days of direct sunlight. Yes, Energy will leak in an energy-free, closed off chamber, but there is tons of energy from the sun coming in that mathematically puts the moon-based terrarium in an energy surplus.
 
A moon base? I'm all for the idea, but that's gonna take a lot of coupon clipping for the government to save up enough monies to fund it. I guess they could cut out the domestic Internet monitoring programs to save some cash since Google and Facebook are doing a fairly complete job of it already.
 
keeping food/water/plants and other things that are on earth in close environment (with glass to keep plants safe from radiation and let sunlight in) won't work, as all the experiments done on earth has proved that no matter what energy will leak no matter how close/protective the environment is. so after year or so you'll need to get more plants/food/water (or or lease one of them) up there which might cost more than just sending food with astronauts might be cheaper and more efficient than growing there.
all the experiments done on Earth? We're not talking a completely closed system and letting it run it's course, of course water and other nutrients need to be added plants grow, it's not made of magic. The thing with the Moon is that it does have water, albeit in ice format. Water is the big key though that would more likely than not make a Moon base much more favorable then a space station which needs constant supplies, which if your know a bit of history is the reason Alcatraz shut down as a prison as it was too costly to keep bringing supplies and that was a 30-40 minute boat ride!
 
i wonder if they want to build it in space so that they can reduce the gravitational effects on building future space craft... you know, things like how a perfect sphere can't be built on earth, because of the gravity.. overcoming things like that

Well most likely yes it's a gravitational issue because with a Moon base you still need to lift off (spend energy). However the benefits on being on "terra firma" outweigh energy considerations of a space base, at least initially. Sure in the future when we get our Death Stars, Babylon 5, Deep Space 9 level of technology for space stations then it'll be fine. But next 50 years or so? Bleh... no hope. They still didn't spin the ISS to give a bit of artificial gravity because it was too complex for them!
 
Given the aggressive and criminal tendencies of the US government, I can see any peaceful moon base project being hijacked for military and/or "intelligence purposes" (e.g. spying on other countries). As such, I'd really rather leave any moon colonization to peaceful private individuals.
 
Given the aggressive and criminal tendencies of the US government, I can see any peaceful moon base project being hijacked for military and/or "intelligence purposes" (e.g. spying on other countries). As such, I'd really rather leave any moon colonization to peaceful private individuals.

Dude, I have a few questions for you. Do you live in the US? If yes, why are you complaining about this here on a tech forum 24/7? Go complain to some politicians or get some groups together and complain. Or leave the country and move somewhere else if it is that bad. If I hated this place that much I would already be gone or actually do something about it.

Seriously, you derail every thread into an anti-government discussion.
 
Moon base? Yeah if they know how to be well prepared with staying on the moon for a long time: air, water AND septic.
 
We need a space elevator.

We need cheap mass production carbon nanotubes before that will ever happen.

I don't know why people think NASA is "done" with space exploration with human hosts. NASA couldn't afford to keep the massively expensive space shuttles in use (1 space shuttle launch cost's around a Billion plus depending on the payload , too much money).

I think thanks to companies like SpaceX space in general will drop in cost greatly over the next 10+ years. NASA is working on the "big" stuff like a Moon base and our trip to Mars instead of worrying about its budget to just get into LEO and transport its Astronauts which should be basic and cheap at this point.

Also helps that China , India and Russia still have there own plans for space exploration which will spur the US to beef up our NASA budget to stay a head of the curve.

Don't forget , we landed a 2,000+ pound card with a Nuclear reactor on Mars with a totally new flight system and landing system , we are still the pioneers of space :)
 
I just want my brain constantly backed up every month or two so if I happen to get killed/die I can get a new body in the future and go into space with everyone else. :(

Sometimes I feel that something cool like this will only happen when I'm in my 70-80's and at that point getting our of bed without shitting myself will be my days agenda. Anyway, "Keep looking up".
 
Given the aggressive and criminal tendencies of the US government, I can see any peaceful moon base project being hijacked for military and/or "intelligence purposes" (e.g. spying on other countries). As such, I'd really rather leave any moon colonization to peaceful private individuals.

Nah. We got satellites over every country in the world with a resolution so good we can read a license plate number from space. The Moon is 100-1000x farther away (depending upon the satellite altitude), we can't see the flag on the Moon with the best telescopes we have, there really is no reason to have a "spy base" on the Moon.

As to peaceful private individuals... ehh if any one with those sort of resources exist then sure why not. But more likely than not the only reason to go there will be to get some rare resource on the Moon (Helium 3 maybe? Some other isotope that's abundant there) and they'll strip mine the Moon in no time flat.
 
L1 is crappy place for a station the delta V is almost the same as lunar orbit and its not stable
its better to put it out at L4 or L5 which are stable
 
As long in the near future they don't call themselves Zeon and and do colony drops on us.:p

Zeon colony group was out at L2 which is on the far side of the moon
its part of why they wanted to break off from the feds
its much like when England controlled its colonies from the other side of the atlantic
/gundam nerd
 
Shouldnt we be paying proper referees money instead of moving to the moon?
 
Zeon colony group was out at L2 which is on the far side of the moon
its part of why they wanted to break off from the feds
its much like when England controlled its colonies from the other side of the atlantic
/gundam nerd

Bet you want to move to Side 3.:D
 
And how are we going to get there with no active shuttle program? Maybe we should hitch a ride with the Russians and pay $100 million per person (circa 2008 - http://discovermagazine.com/2008/apr/05-space) ????
:eek::eek::eek:

The shuttle program being shut down does not mean the end of space exploration for NASA. They are working on other projects to achieve future goals. A shuttle didn't bring Neil Armstrong to the moon, a shuttle would never be able to return from the moon either.
 
all our base are belong to us...

(brain still in L1, needs more coffee)
 
I don't know what all the hubbub is about. We've had Moonbase Alpha and transports running since 1999. :rolleyes:

NASA press release: Image #124668.6 18JUN2005
 
Too bad we never landed on the moon. That'll throw a wrench in the works.

Prepares for the slaughter.
 
And how are we going to get there with no active shuttle program? Maybe we should hitch a ride with the Russians and pay $100 million per person (circa 2008 - http://discovermagazine.com/2008/apr/05-space) ????
:eek::eek::eek:

The shuttle program was never design to take human out into the outer space. It was design for frequent space travel to Earth's orbit.

I believe its replacement currently in development will be the right space vehicle to take us back to the moon and beyond.
 
Isn't that because the flag is planted on the dark side of the moon though?

Nope, that would have been a bad choice to land on the "dark side" as it'd make it impossible to communicate with Earth from the surface since there'd be a moon in the way :) (BTW, there really isn't a dark side of the Moon that stays dark, just a side that never faces Earth)

The reason is that it's not that big of an object about a quarter million miles away, if memory serves you'd need the resolution of a telescope that was on the order of a couple of football fields wide
 
Wonder when the land-grab will unfold? It'll be another political or corporate affair, I foresee.
 
I find it odd that we don't have a moonbase, already. I suppose the world is more interested in politics and conflicts between nations than moving forward in the human story.
 
Back
Top