NAS or USB/eSATA drive case?

shady86

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 17, 2003
Messages
148
Im thinking of using my 1 TB drive as a media drive for my setup. Currently I have:

1) Deskop - eSATA, 1xGigaLAN
2) Laptop - USB, 1x 100Mbps LAN
3) 100Mbps Wireless Router with 4 port switch

I dont switch on my Desktop 24/7 so I plan to get a drive enclosure for my hard disk. I will be storing all my BT and media files in that 1TB drive. I have done some research and here are what I found out.

1) USB/eSATA - Fast data transfer rate, 30MB/s for USB2.0 and almost max for eSATA.

2) NAS - Bit Torrent feature looks tempting because I plan to use it 24/7 for BT. But I heard the built-in client is inefficient and will be slower and harder to manage than normal Windows BT client. Is it true? Since I'm using 100Mbps switch, transfer rate between my PC and NAS will be painfully slow, max around 10MB/s. Some NAS enclosures comes with print server function which enables me to share my USB printer with both my PC and laptop.

I really dont know whether it is worth to get NAS which is more expensive then normal USB/eSATA enclosure and slower. Please give your suggestions. Thank you.
 
Thanks for the replies. I plan to spend as little as possible to set up a media server for music and vide streaming between two pc. Gigabit switch looks tempting but expensive for me. I just bought an entry level Buffalo LS-C640L. It doesnt come with bit torrent functionand I'm looking for another one with BT client. How does NAS bit torrent peforms in terms of speed and efficiency?
 
Does gigabit significantly boost speed? I know with 100Mb will bottleneck the hard drive. My internet connection is 100Mb fiber and the modem is connected to wireless 4port router.
 
Does gigabit significantly boost speed? I know with 100Mb will bottleneck the hard drive. My internet connection is 100Mb fiber and the modem is connected to wireless 4port router.

It won't increase your internet connection speed but it'll vastly improve your LAN transfer between two or more PCs.
 
Back
Top