NAS on the cheap.... maybe?

wizang

Gawd
Joined
Dec 5, 2009
Messages
538
I'm looking to build myself a little NAS mostly for media sharing and possibly some backups from my two personal computers. I want to do a RAID 5 setup but I really don't have the money for a proper hardware RAID card. What would be considered the minimum processor type to get away with software RAID 5 without a huge performance hit? Is atom too underpowered for this kind of job? Low power would be nice because I plan to leave the system on 24/7. I would need to get a board that supports at least 4x SATA devices (perhaps this excludes atom already?) or buy a really cheap PCI SATA card or something. This little guy seems pretty interesting http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16859117003 but I would get more enjoyment out of doing it myself.
 
i'd recommend an am2 or am3 or s775 mini-itx board to deal with your parity calculation overhead using host-raid. atom would likely get it's butt kicked. i assume we're also talking about using onboard GbE, as well, right? rule of thumb is that you burn 1GHz of CPU processing power for each GbE link's overhead. Atom at 1.6GHz + RAID-5 parity cals on host-raid would likely be entirely too much for the Atom to sustain.
 
I would like to spend less than $200 before adding the drives. Perhaps that is foolish?
 
it's doable. an am2 mini-ITX board or mATX board for $60, cpu for $40 (dual core), 2GB of RAM ($40), and a case with PSU (can be had for $60 or less depending on what you want).
 
Where would I get an AMD based mini-ITX board for $60? The cheapest on newegg is ~$100. Is there a good source for mini-ITX related stuff in general? Newegg sort of lacks.
 
Where would I get an AMD based mini-ITX board for $60? The cheapest on newegg is ~$100. Is there a good source for mini-ITX related stuff in general? Newegg sort of lacks.

In general - there aren't a ton of vendors making mini-ITX stuff. With your budget, you might be better off going microATX.

I've always looked at http://www.mini-box.com/site/index.html and http://www.mini-itx.com/store/ for product info/ideas, and then hoped what I liked was on NewEgg :) NewEgg has definitely gotten better in the past year or so, but it's still too much of a niche market.
 
Intel SS-4200 makes an awesome NAS / WHS. I just set mine up running 4x WD 1.5 TB drives, been perfect so far. Running WHS. Getting WHS installed was a PITA, but smooth sailing since.
 
Intel SS-4200 makes an awesome NAS / WHS. I just set mine up running 4x WD 1.5 TB drives, been perfect so far. Running WHS. Getting WHS installed was a PITA, but smooth sailing since.

After BCB, got mine up and running with 6 TB for only $480. :D
 
I don't think Atom is too far-fetched. Probably not fast enough to saturate GigE writing to the NAS, but reads should without problem if you have a decent NIC, and writes should get into the high double digits. Probably not if you're planning on using Windows or motherboard RAID, however.

MiniITX doesn't seem like a good choice to me. It carries a price premium and you're not going to fit many hard drives in a MiniITX case, so you may as well go for a microATX board if you're not going to go Atom where you don't have a lot of choice. Since most Atom boards that will be in your price range only have 2 SATA channels, it probably makes more sense to go with a regular processor.

I would do something like this:

Intel BOXDB43LD uATX board - $77
Intel Celeron E3200 - $53
1GB PC3200 - $20
PSU - $45
Case - $20
2GB USB stick to boot - $10

A tad over budget, but most of that goes into the Intel mobo (for Intel NIC and good quality) and PSU, which you *could* skimp on.
 
What site/drives did you use?

ebay for ss4200 ($149 - 10% BCB)
Dell for WD15EADS ($100 - 20% BCB + TAX)
Newegg for 2gb DDR2 stick later

Actually, coming across that Dell deal of $86 (after tax) for each WD15EADS prompted me to buy the ss4200 to use them in :eek:
 
Back
Top