MySpace Suicide Trial Underway

One thing I think a lot of people are overlooking is just how bad cyberbullying can be. I see some think of it as a gentler form of physical bullying, and something that can be ignored, when the reality is much, much worse. It's not a simple case of the perpetrator disclosing his identity to the victim and calling him names...

Imagine, for example, if someone you know would make a Wikipedia page with your real name and address (picture included) and label you a child-molester with a record, make a fake Facebook page with a load of 15 year old girls as your 'friends', a fake blog from one of your 'victims', a fake blog from you defending your actions ('they were asking for it'), and any number of other ways they could think of. Then they proceeded to forward all those details to your family, friends, co-workers, boss, all your old classmates, and pretty much anyone they could dig up.

Think you could easily live that down? 'Cause that was just off the top of my head.
 
So since they managed to charge her under what amount to BS charges, I guess this means I can start having users who break the Terms of Service on the Game forums I run arrested.
 
One thing I think a lot of people are overlooking is just how bad cyberbullying can be. I see some think of it as a gentler form of physical bullying, and something that can be ignored, when the reality is much, much worse. It's not a simple case of the perpetrator disclosing his identity to the victim and calling him names...

Imagine, for example, if someone you know would make a Wikipedia page with your real name and address (picture included) and label you a child-molester with a record, make a fake Facebook page with a load of 15 year old girls as your 'friends', a fake blog from one of your 'victims', a fake blog from you defending your actions ('they were asking for it'), and any number of other ways they could think of. Then they proceeded to forward all those details to your family, friends, co-workers, boss, all your old classmates, and pretty much anyone they could dig up.

Think you could easily live that down? 'Cause that was just off the top of my head.

That was classify as libel and your ass would be in court promptly. :p
 
how?

alot of people with depression issues dont go around telling the world about it, or even new friends, depressed people usually keep it to themselves because they are affraid if people find out they wont accept or like them.

I believe in this case, there's testimony, from other involved in the my space page, that indicates that the 39 year-old mother said that she was worried because the girl had some sort of mental illness (whether she specifically said depression or not, I don't recall, but I think it was in the last article that steve linked to on Tuesday).
 
I believe in this case, there's testimony, from other involved in the my space page, that indicates that the 39 year-old mother said that she was worried because the girl had some sort of mental illness (whether she specifically said depression or not, I don't recall, but I think it was in the last article that steve linked to on Tuesday).

Yes the so called "adult" knew that the girl was battling depression yet instead of stopping her daughter from creating the false Myspace page she helped them and then bragged about it.

I'm glad they convicted her. I just wish they could have done more then a few misdemeanor's.
 
Yes the so called "adult" knew that the girl was battling depression yet instead of stopping her daughter from creating the false Myspace page she helped them and then bragged about it.

I'm glad they convicted her. I just wish they could have done more then a few misdemeanor's.

If the woman's family has any money, a civil action will be filed. If not, then I suspect the girl's parents would have to get a lawyer willing to take a case that was going to lose money, even if they win.
 
Hope this bitch rots in prison!

Then again, this girl shouldn't of added anyone she didn't know. I use MySpace, but I only talk to people I know! That's the SAFEST way to have it, imo.
 
So I was watching south park the other day and Kyle called Cartman a "fatass" since I'm obese, my feelings were hurt. so I killed myself.

Obviously South Park is to blame
 
So I was watching south park the other day and Kyle called Cartman a "fatass" since I'm obese, my feelings were hurt. so I killed myself.

Obviously South Park is to blame

South park is rated for 18+ population. If you're 13 and watching South Park, that's your parent's fault for ignoring all the signs.
 
whats great about the internet is that you can basically turn off anyone you don't want to talk to , or even listen to, at any time. if you sit there listening to someone telling you to kill yourself then that's your fault.
 
One thing I think a lot of people are overlooking is just how bad cyberbullying can be. I see some think of it as a gentler form of physical bullying, and something that can be ignored, when the reality is much, much worse. It's not a simple case of the perpetrator disclosing his identity to the victim and calling him names...

I think you're running the StopCyberBullying.org website ;)

Imagine, for example, if someone you know would make a Wikipedia page with your real name and address (picture included) and label you a child-molester with a record, make a fake Facebook page with a load of 15 year old girls as your 'friends', a fake blog from one of your 'victims', a fake blog from you defending your actions ('they were asking for it'), and any number of other ways they could think of. Then they proceeded to forward all those details to your family, friends, co-workers, boss, all your old classmates, and pretty much anyone they could dig up.

Think you could easily live that down? 'Cause that was just off the top of my head.

That's not even close to Cyberbullying, that's defamation of character which can be turned into a lawsuit based on the terms of agreement on the websites used to defame the victim and if the victim is financially hurt from the accusations.

Were you not picked on as a kid to realize the difference? Bullying is severely direct.
 
myspace became the kid's parent. the kid also had an argument with her real mom before she killed herself. if u are gonna blame drew then blame the biological mother as well jesus
 
If she walks free with no time spent in the slammer , then there will be surely more to follow . When someone dies things never just simply go back to the way they were. I expect to hear more regarding this story in the future.
As for myself I think an adult bullying a child is child abuse. Hence punishable. Severely.
 
//[T.0.P]//;1033373438 said:
That's not even close to Cyberbullying, that's defamation of character which can be turned into a lawsuit based on the terms of agreement on the websites used to defame the victim and if the victim is financially hurt from the accusations.

Were you not picked on as a kid to realize the difference? Bullying is severely direct.

That's just the legal definition. Cyberbullying is to defamation of character as physical bullying is to assault, and defamation of character is exactly the main form in which cyberbullying appears. Calling it 'defamation of character' has no bearing on whether it's bullying or not.

There's plenty of resources available on the net describing how cyberbullying works. This very much fits the definition.
 
"as physical bullying is to assault"???

We have a Matlock lawyer in the house. Or maybe you remember Perry Mason? I know the definition of assault and physical bullying is always going to be assault. That doesn't mean you would be convicted of assault, but by definition you could be charged.

Anyway, here are a few corrections since nobody here seems to actually read the article:

The women is 49 ** FORTY-NINE ** years old. Just because one random person in this thread said she is 39 does not make it so. Go read the articles, there are 2,000+ on google news.

The women is facing 3 years in federal prison and a $300,000 fine. Though that doesn't mean that will be her sentence.

We have courts and juries for a reason and the rule of law for a reason. One more pathetic, disgusting criminal can go rot in prison (fun federal prison too!).
 
That mother should have her child removed from her custody. Any parent who acts in such a juvenile and irresponsible manner should not be raising kids. It makes me sick that this mother is going to get away with a slap on the wrist when her actions resulted in the teen girls death.
 
That's just the legal definition. Cyberbullying is to defamation of character as physical bullying is to assault, and defamation of character is exactly the main form in which cyberbullying appears. Calling it 'defamation of character' has no bearing on whether it's bullying or not.

There's plenty of resources available on the net describing how cyberbullying works. This very much fits the definition.

LoL. I guess researchers know all about Cyberbullying... hardly. The way you explained it IS EXACTLY Defamation of Character and nothing else, not even Cyberbullying.

Cyberbullying is, well, like I said direct like Bullying is. It's personal. You would have to communicate online to see the difference rather than just reading articles about it. One way to find out is to play a game online. Or better yet, a perfect example of Cyberbullying is the thread topic itself. Girl killed herself over something direct, not Defamation.
 
Fine, here's a real-life example:
David Knight of Burlington, Ontario
A web site about teenager David Knight of Burlington, Ontario had been active for several months before a classmate told him about it. "I went there and sure enough there's my photo on this web site saying 'Welcome to the web site that makes fun of Dave Knight' and just pages of hateful comments directed at me and everyone in my family." Whoever created the web site asked others to join in, posting lewd, sexual comments and smearing David's reputation. "I was accused of being a pedophile. I was accused of using the date rape drug on little boys," says David. Along with the web site, there were nasty e-mails too. "Here's an e-mail, 'You're gay, don't ever talk again, no one likes you, you're immature and dirty, go wash your face.'"

Link

That's not to mention the countless cases of kids unknowingly being photographed naked in locker rooms and posted on the web, or any of the gazillions of 4chan harassment cases that have already occurred. But if you prefer to stick to your own strict personal interpretation of what constitutes cyberbullying then that's your prerogative. Welcome to the internet.
 
LOL! That's some funny shit. However, it's both. Since it took so long for David to realize what was going on, I bet the creator got frustrated and sent the hate mail. That's cyberbullying, but the website isn't. And I bet those hate e-mails and posts on the site all came from maybe 2 to 3 people, if not just one person. And that ain't Cyberbullying. That's gangster shit.

"Welcome to the Internet". HAH. I've dealt with more fierce demons.
 
As a person who works in the law field, all people who antagonized him to OD, is an accessory to murder. Than is not a a funny matter because even if they are not found guilty, that will haunt them for the rest of their lives.
 
Yeah. I was a fatass through primary and middle school. I took a fuck load of flack, from a fuck load of people. I was told I was worthless, ugly, lazy and the myriad of other things that, TBH, made me laugh. I never had the urge to kill myself.

The mother was *definitely* to blame :rolleyes:

Howabout the parents of the girl being divorced? How about the fact that the 13 year old girl broke Myspace's 14 year old age restriction?

The woman that propagated this is surely fucked in the head, but she didn't kill anyone. It's not a crime to type or use language, no matter how screwed up the language actually is.
 
No matter what twisted freak posts next about gangsters or the victims are to blame, this case at least sent the mother to prison and proves that the little shits who abuse people who can't fight back are soon gonna have to deal with THE LAW.
 
South park is rated for 18+ population. If you're 13 and watching South Park, that's your parent's fault for ignoring all the signs.

And allowing a 13 year old to have on older boyfriend on myspace is different how?

No matter what twisted freak posts next about gangsters or the victims are to blame, this case at least sent the mother to prison and proves that the little shits who abuse people who can't fight back are soon gonna have to deal with THE LAW.

All this proves that anyone can win a idiotic case. Although the fucking twinky defense already showed that. The people in their trial were probably mentally retarded to some extent or just felt sorry for the family for losing their little bully of a daughter.
 
As a person who works in the law field, all people who antagonized him to OD, is an accessory to murder. Than is not a a funny matter because even if they are not found guilty, that will haunt them for the rest of their lives.

Law is a funny thing. I have seen both sides of what law really is. I have learned law can be twisted and manipulated to such a degree that the accused can be turned into the victim. What this women did was shit no doubt about that, but now she is being victimized by prosecutors who in my opinion are border line criminals anyways. Actually the police that lay the original charges are what I call criminals with badges. They lie, mislead, try to cut any corner to get what they want and usually toss in extra charges with the knowledge that some will be dismissed. That is my definition of a criminal. I respect the military but I will never respect a policeman nor the prosecutors that try to convince a judge.
 
Law is a funny thing. I have seen both sides of what law really is. I have learned law can be twisted and manipulated to such a degree that the accused can be turned into the victim. What this women did was shit no doubt about that, but now she is being victimized by prosecutors who in my opinion are border line criminals anyways. Actually the police that lay the original charges are what I call criminals with badges. They lie, mislead, try to cut any corner to get what they want and usually toss in extra charges with the knowledge that some will be dismissed. That is my definition of a criminal. I respect the military but I will never respect a policeman nor the prosecutors that try to convince a judge.

Ever heard of Blackwater(Or the fact they get paid 4-5 times what a normal solider gets and can't be charged with murder and go around killing random people in Iraq(Privatized war))? Corruption is everywhere there is high amounts of money. Everywhere. Religion, economy(financial sector), military, law, and especially the top dog Banks. Police men are mainly good and some times a little bad.

By the way, throwing money into any situation twists/manipulates things out of control or fairness. It's not just the law. Money, money, for the love of money.

Point is, if you don't respect Policemen, Prosecutors, fuck, why respect the military?


Disclaimer: I respect the troops, but they are not fighting for my freedom. They are fighting for oil and reconstruction privileges in other countries.
 
"as physical bullying is to assault"???

We have a Matlock lawyer in the house. Or maybe you remember Perry Mason? I know the definition of assault and physical bullying is always going to be assault. That doesn't mean you would be convicted of assault, but by definition you could be charged.

Anyway, here are a few corrections since nobody here seems to actually read the article:

The women is 49 ** FORTY-NINE ** years old. Just because one random person in this thread said she is 39 does not make it so. Go read the articles, there are 2,000+ on google news.

The women is facing 3 years in federal prison and a $300,000 fine. Though that doesn't mean that will be her sentence.

We have courts and juries for a reason and the rule of law for a reason. One more pathetic, disgusting criminal can go rot in prison (fun federal prison too!).

that was me, and it's because one of the many linked articles specifically said she was 39. Having looked a several other articles, it's clear she's now 49...apparently 47 at the time of the crime.

Regardless, i don't think it matters one bit whether she's 35 or 60. she was old enough to know better.
 
Are you fucking kidding me? 1 year in jail and $100,000 fine for violating myspace terms of service? Again, are you fucking kidding me? This country is fucking pathetic and every time laws are perverted and used wrongly it makes me sick.

What I find most humorous is how this country's mindset about prison is to punish and humiliate with revenge and hate when they are supposed to "rehabilitate" the "criminals".
I'm sure this lady will be a fine citizen after she gets out after doing hard time for making a fake myspace account and having to live with killers and other actual criminals for a year.

From the article said:
The trial's outcome was a victory for prosecutors despite the lack of a felony conviction, said Nick Akerman, a New York lawyer who specializes in cases involving the federal computer act.

"What you learned is that the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is an extremely important tool in the federal arsenal against computer crime," he said.

Fuck you, you piece of shit lawyer. The only reason you say its an important tool against fake myspace profiles is because its going to let you further pervert the use of laws in this country to stuff your fat pockets full of more cash after it makes your frivolous lawsuits even easier. "Specializing in cases involving the federal computer act" is just code for "I found a sweet and cheap ass loophole and you can't do shit about it now that it has precedent, suckers".
 
What this lady did was immature, stupid, sick and bordering on sociopathic. I think she would do us a favor if she committed suicide. But that's not gonna happen.

We are all so "crime and punishment" and "law enforcement" oriented and yet these three women, and likely Drew's husband, are pretty much screwed in that community. No one will do business with such an amoral excuse for a human being, the daughter probably has no friends now, and that Ashley Grills thing will not do all that well.

So whether or not I agree with the verdict and sentence, it seems that "vigilante" justice in the form of community ostracizing, alienation, and condemnation will probably be worse for these people. At least until they move far away and people forget.

And for all intents and purposes, I really hope that happens for some time. It's a punishment worse than prison.
 
Are you fucking kidding me? 1 year in jail and $100,000 fine for violating myspace terms of service? Again, are you fucking kidding me? This country is fucking pathetic and every time laws are perverted and used wrongly it makes me sick.

What I find most humorous is how this country's mindset about prison is to punish and humiliate with revenge and hate when they are supposed to "rehabilitate" the "criminals".
I'm sure this lady will be a fine citizen after she gets out after doing hard time for making a fake myspace account and having to live with killers and other actual criminals for a year.

Although I don't see how you can rehabilitate someone like this person other than by shaming her (it's not like she's a career cyber bully), but I have to agree that as much as I'm glad she's doing time, I don't like that this law was used to do it. With that said, I doubt she'll spend a year in jail and she certainly won't be doing hard time. She'll be in a minimum security prison...and probably be out in 6 months (or less if the jails are crowded).

"What you learned is that the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is an extremely important tool in the federal arsenal against computer crime," he said.
Fuck you, you piece of shit lawyer. The only reason you say its an important tool against fake myspace profiles is because its going to let you further pervert the use of laws in this country to stuff your fat pockets full of more cash after it makes your frivolous lawsuits even easier. "Specializing in cases involving the federal computer act" is just code for "I found a sweet and cheap ass loophole and you can't do shit about it now that it has precedent, suckers".

what does a criminal case have to do with frivolous lawsuits? The daughter's family didn't need a guilty verdict to sue the defendant, and I'm fairly confident that a jury would find in favor of the plaintive if such a suit went to court.

This may be a perversion of the law, but I don't see the connection to civil actions.
 
Back
Top