MW2 Something "YOU" should know

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've got a novel idea for those of you who don't want to be "forced" to play the role of a terrorist, if indeed this truly is what happens in MW2:

Don't play MW2.

Same goes for your hypothetical game where the player would have to assume the role of the Holocaust-causing Hitler. Don't wanna be the Holocaust-causing Hitler?

Don't play the hypothetical game.

I never said I wasn't going to play the game. I never said it should be censored or banned. I don't think anyone in the thread did. They are simply discussing the merits or lack thereof of this scenario. The Hitler example was to show how just because it's pixels doesn't mean it has no demonstrative power simply because it's not "real."

I know "arguing on the internet yadda yadda," but people really need to drop the "it's just a game," "don't play it if you don't like it," and "just pirate it" arguments when trying to discuss video games. This is the reason why Roger Ebert rips the shit out of anyone who tries to claim games can be art. The game can still be played and discussed without resorting to the usual flame war of "don't play it then."
 
I don't take any issue with the freedom fighter/terroist dichotomy, but terroism as a tactic is pretty much universally reviled. Civilized countries do not kill civilians. Hell, they don't even kill captured soldiers.

How many Japanese civilians did America kill in World War II when they bombed Tokyo, then nuked Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Oh wait..................:rolleyes:

Honestly it's actually not a bad military tactic no matter how distasteful it can be. Yes it's horrible to shoot, bomb, blow up and kill defenseless people but nothing puts and end to a war faster. In the long run you can sometimes argue that it actually saves more lives than it takes. In WWII when we bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki the Japanese surrendered quickly. A protracted and drawn out war between our two countries would have been far more costly in terms of lives lost, property destroyed, resources wasted, etc. Yes those lives taken to get the job done are non-military and not necessarily aggressive, but in the long run you may end up killing fewer people. You can even take it further and say that surgical strikes designed to kill only military targets is less effective because it allows aggressors and combatants to blend in with the populace and appear to be an innocent civilian. This works VERY well when using guerillia warfare. We did it to get rid of England, the IRA did it to get rid of the British, the Scotts did it, and now people living in the Middle East do it to get rid of us and our allies.

As for not killing captured soldiers, well I'll leave you to continue to think that.

I am not saying that any of this is right or that this is how we should "do business" but get real, this shit happens all the time. War is ugly, plain and simple. No one escapes it with their hands clean.
 
So... they already have an attack on washington, DC... in the game...

In WaW, you play as Soviet soldier...

Soviets lost 12mil... only 3 mil because of the Nazis... the remaining because of a Red Army...

Who the hell cares? It's a video game. For all you know, this low quality cam vid is just a fake.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

True, but please show me the mission in WaW where the goal is to kill as many Soviet citizens as possible. It's a great example but that aspect of it is not in-game.


How many Japanese civilians did America kill in World War II when they bombed Tokyo, then nuked Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Oh wait..................:rolleyes:

Honestly it's actually not a bad military tactic no matter how distasteful it can be. Yes it's horrible to shoot, bomb, blow up and kill defenseless people but nothing puts and end to a war faster. In the long run you can sometimes argue that it actually saves more lives than it takes. In WWII when we bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki the Japanese surrendered quickly. A protracted and drawn out war between our two countries would have been far more costly in terms of lives lost, property destroyed, resources wasted, etc. Yes those lives taken to get the job done are non-military and not necessarily aggressive, but in the long run you may end up killing fewer people. You can even take it further and say that surgical strikes designed to kill only military targets is less effective because it allows aggressors and combatants to blend in with the populace and appear to be an innocent civilian. This works VERY well when using guerillia warfare. We did it to get rid of England, the IRA did it to get rid of the British, the Scotts did it, and now people living in the Middle East do it to get rid of us and our allies.

As for not killing captured soldiers, well I'll leave you to continue to think that.

See above response.
 
I don't take any issue with the freedom fighter/terroist dichotomy, but terroism as a tactic is pretty much universally reviled. Civilized countries do not kill civilians. Hell, they don't even kill captured soldiers.

American civil war; guerilla/terrorist tactics were the normative. American expansion, the ‘US’ troupes handed out diseased blankets to natives to thin their ranks and weaken the strong; after it took its toll they ran through and slaughtered the remainder, women, children etc… Vietnam; if they talk a funny language they could be VC; kill them to make sure they don’t warn the others…

History is wrought with examples of what one society would see as terrorist actions while the other side sees it as ‘fighting the good fight’.

In any event, you and I both know how John Q. Public will take this news, and it won't be with any of deeper reasoning, and I can't necessarily blame him. IMO, this was just a dumb move from a business standpoint.

This is very true; there are plenty of knee jerk reactionists out there that act before, (and in many cases without,) thinking.
 
American civil war; guerilla/terrorist tactics were the normative. American expansion, the ‘US’ troupes handed out diseased blankets to natives to thin their ranks and weaken the strong; after it took its toll they ran through and slaughtered the remainder, women, children etc… Vietnam; if they talk a funny language they could be VC; kill them to make sure they don’t warn the others…

History is wrought with examples of what one society would see as terrorist actions while the other side sees it as ‘fighting the good fight’.



This is very true; there are plenty of knee jerk reactionists out there that act before, (and in many cases without,) thinking.

Good points.
 
So it's ok to play mobsters terrorizing civilians and shooting innocents, but not terrorists?

It's story telling. It happens. You can play a blind eye to it, but that doesn't help the problem. You have no idea how they are going to fully play this out in the game. I know with the intro to MW 1, I thought it was pretty powerful being a hostage driven around the city to only get shot. They may very well have the same thing going on here.
 
So it's ok to play mobsters terrorizing civilians and shooting innocents, but not terrorists?

It's story telling. It happens. You can play a blind eye to it, but that doesn't help the problem. You have no idea how they are going to fully play this out in the game. I know with the intro to MW 1, I thought it was pretty powerful being a hostage driven around the city to only get shot. They may very well have the same thing going on here.

Yet more good points. We may simply be taking this out of context. Did the video work for anyone besides the OP?
 
Yet more good points. We may simply be taking this out of context. Did the video work for anyone besides the OP?

There's another link somewhere in the thread that worked for me.

Yes, there are many example of terrorism throughout history, and when I used the term civilized, I meant to say modern. The modern day thought is you are at war with the regime, not the inhabitants of the country. The US military wouldn't roll through the airport of some country shooting everything in sight (I hope). Terrorism is merely a tactic of war, not a group. The "war on terror" does not really making any sense from that standpoint. It's like saying the "war on bullets" or the "war on tanks."

Like someone said above, the difference is, there is no game where you get to nuke Japan. The other big difference here is choice. Although we don't know, it appears you may be forced to play as a terrorist, and may be forced to shoot civilians. In other games (Fallout 3 nuking Megaton, GTA, etc.) you are not forced to kill civilians. It is your choice.

I don't know what IW's message in making you play as the terrorist is, and maybe there is some way this experience makes the narrative more meaningful, but it's certainly going to cause a firestorm either way.
 
Now that I have had a chance to actually see the video I am not sure what is happening. Is it a fight and some civilians are caught in the crossfire? Or is the point of the mission to kill civilians? The latter would imply a reward for doing so.

There is a huge difference between showing a clip of the bad guys doing their thing (as in the first MW and the president scene) and having you play that role and rewarding you for doing so. Personally, I draw the line at that difference. Show me what the bad guys did so I have a reason to get some payback. Don't tell me to point a gun at civilians and perform the act in the first place.

The "it's just pixels" argument doesn't float here. It is the intention behind the scene that matter.

I still won't be purchasing it for my business (because of the server issue) here in the sandbox but this scene will probably determine if my son is given this game as well. I'll wait and see what people say of the scene.

I don't know a lot about the game...what you're supposed to do, who you're supposed to be, whether you can choose sides...but if indeed you play as terrorists, then maybe that is what you're supposed to do. How many people have I seen wanting to be The Joker in Arkham Asylum? Some games let you play as the bad guys, and unfortunately the do BAD things. But as you kind of said, if that offends you, then it's your right not to play it...or if possible choose not to play as that side.
 
I don't know a lot about the game...what you're supposed to do, who you're supposed to be, whether you can choose sides...but if indeed you play as terrorists, then maybe that is what you're supposed to do. How many people have I seen wanting to be The Joker in Arkham Asylum? Some games let you play as the bad guys, and unfortunately the do BAD things. But as you kind of said, if that offends you, then it's your right not to play it...or if possible choose not to play as that side.

Did you just compare playing as the Joker to playing as a terrorist?

Yeah, plenty of people want to play the FICTIONAL bad guy. I don't think many people would want to play Pol Pot's Cambodian Massacre Adventure 2010.
 
i dont play games in order to measure my currently morality levels or ethics. i want complete freedom to murder and destroy everything that i can find.

its just a game bro.

it's like saying that modding fo3 so that you can kill all those annoying children in little lamplight is a bad idea.
 
Although we don't know, it appears you may be forced to play as a terrorist, and may be forced to shoot civilians. In other games (Fallout 3 nuking Megaton, GTA, etc.) you are not forced to kill civilians. It is your choice.

This entire phrase self-contradicts.

We don't know

You are forced (it's a video game... get over it).

You are not forced (it's a video game... unless if it has physical dominion over you, you cannot be forced to kill people)

It's your choice (???)
 
This entire phrase self-contradicts.

We don't know

You are forced (it's a video game... get over it).

You are not forced (it's a video game... unless if it has physical dominion over you, you cannot be forced to kill people)

It's your choice (???)

Way to get entirely literal. According to what we knew, if you wanted to play the game single player game, the player was forced to play it that way, unlike the other games I mentioned.

Obviously, no one is literally forced to do anything. Kudos to you for pointing that out I guess.
 
What about the online parts of MW1 and WaW where you play as either terrorist killing american soldiers or Germans/Japs killing American soldiers? Cry me a mother f-ing river.
 
Obviously, no one is literally forced to do anything. Kudos to you for pointing that out I guess.

Then why are you complaining over this? Stop posting, if you hate the game so much. No one is forcing you to post.
 
And we are doing exactly what IW wants, MW2 is being discussed. It elicits a reaction from the audience. That is the job of a storyteller. This more than anything makes you hate the thing you are forced to do. It's an anti-terrorism message and nothing more.
 
Let me start out by saying this not about deicated servers and turning our rigs into nintendos.

This is about Morality.

http://www.56.com/u82/v_NDcyODkxNTk.html

The above video is an exerpt from the MW2 single player campain. In it you play as a terrorist walking through the airport killing civilians. It is some pretty graffic sick shit for a game.

Maybe I am old but, isn't this disrespectful to the people who have lost their lives in terrorist attacks and the police and soldiers of "ALL COUNTRIES" who risk or have lost their lives preventing this type of shit.

It is a video game I understand that but, watch the video it's really fucked up. I fortunatley/unfortunately have worked in several jobs my life where this shit is no joke. I've seen death up close and personal on several occasions(no I'm not a medical guy). Maybe this just hit a sore spot because they are killing innocent civilians.

This just bums me out even more because, when I log into a game and start shredding fools. I want it to be ...I don't know, killing anything but mom, dad, shelly and timmy going to visit grandma for Christmas.

I don't know. I'll probably reread this and wish I had changed some shit around or not said something.

Either way, I posted the video so you can make a choice. I'm sure most people don't give a fuck. That's fine. That's why Free countries are so great. I guess.

Take care


Disclaimer: No I don't think the game should be censored and nobody is going to use this as a training aid to being an active shooter in an airport.

Edit: I can't spell
so? lots more people died in WW2 , yet you probably don't get your panties in a bunch over that.
 
so? lots more people died in WW2 , yet you probably don't get your panties in a bunch over that.

That's what you come up with? Doesn't even make sense with anything the OP said.

Anyways, I'm with the OP on this one as well... I didn't like what I saw, and yes I know it's a game. But for myself, it doesn't really matter what the story is, I don't want to take part in it personally. I was stressed out just watching it, I don't consider entertainment feeling guilty and disliking what I'm doing. And I've been playing FPS games most of my life. I loved Modern Warfare, but I won't be purchasing this one. I wasn't going to spend the $60 on it, but I don't think I'll even buy it when it gets cheaper either.

I'm off to play Torchlight.
 
That's what you come up with? Doesn't even make sense with anything the OP said.

Anyways, I'm with the OP on this one as well... I didn't like what I saw, and yes I know it's a game. But for myself, it doesn't really matter what the story is, I don't want to take part in it personally. I was stressed out just watching it, I don't consider entertainment feeling guilty and disliking what I'm doing. And I've been playing FPS games most of my life. I loved Modern Warfare, but I won't be purchasing this one. I wasn't going to spend the $60 on it, but I don't think I'll even buy it when it gets cheaper either.

I'm off to play Torchlight.

Didn't we already discover that you're not really playing a terrorist, but someone who infiltrated a terror organization?

I wish to fuck people would stop judging games until they came out but then the forums would be dull.
 
Didn't we already discover that you're not really playing a terrorist, but someone who infiltrated a terror organization?

I wish to fuck people would stop judging games until they came out but then the forums would be dull.

So that somehow changes the act of what you're doing?
 
So that somehow changes the act of what you're doing?

I can't watch the video because I can't reach the site (and cannot read it to tell what the problem is). I would imagine it would be possible to play without killing any civilians on your part, since you are after all, a good guy. Maybe I'm wrong though.

edit: and I'm going to wait until I know the full story before making any decisions on what this means for the game.
 
So that somehow changes the act of what you're doing?

What do you mean "you're doing"? You are not doing anything. Its up to each individual player how to proceed though the level. You can either shoot the digital civilians like the dogs they are, or you can play Mr Vagina style and not kill the digital civilians....its up to you.
 
I totally agree with it being just a game. I do believe people should be aware of this though so they can make a choice.

In the long run my opinion is just that. An opinion.

Take care

and i totally respect that, if I came off like I didn't, it wasn't intentional.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top