MW2 Something "YOU" should know

Status
Not open for further replies.
What up with the "innocent civilians"?

It's PIXELS!

Say after me:
P
I
X
E
L
S

Holy %#%"#%"#%
 
What up with the "innocent civilians"?

It's PIXELS!

Say after me:
P
I
X
E
L
S

Holy %#%"#%"#%

This is the biggest cop-out argument ever for discussing the way something is portrayed in the media. It's a narrative story trying to put you in the place of the characters. This argument could be made for anything:

The Bible? JUST INK!
Televsion? JUST FILM!

You're basically saying all form of criticism is worthless because media is not reality.
 
What up with the "innocent civilians"?

It's PIXELS!

Say after me:
P
I
X
E
L
S

Holy %#%"#%"#%

Anything represented on a tv is made up of pixels. If you only see the pixels and not what the combinations of pixels represent than theres something wrong with you.
 
It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

I think this is actually the point.

Sometimes the best way to show how truly repugnant a certain act happens to be is to have people experience a simulation of that act.

By the time you finish that part of the game (which is presumably and intro-level), you will probably have a strong feeling of disgust in your belly and will be filled with a greater certainty about how vile terrorism is than you had ever expected to feel. You will in fact, have a bad taste in your mouth. You will want to play the rest of the game to defeat the terrorists who's evil you received a small taste of in the intro level.

While I do see the issue with this, I also see the intent, and I think it is something that might be worthwhile to help people learn about themselves and to help them understand terrorism better. It also might teach a few people about guns rights and why "Gun Free Zones" are so incredibly dangerous. Personally I think this would be a much safer world if the only places where guns weren't legal with a concealed weapons permit were those that had checkpoints with armed guards, primarily meaning courthouses and airports past the security area. (Sorry about the politics, ignore the last sentence if you like.)
 
i see what you are saying, but couldnt you make the same argument about games like GTA and Saints? half the fun in those games is killing innocents.

i see why you find it immoral, maybe its just my generation but killing civilians is in no way new to videogames, and im cool with it
 
Maybe your negative reaction to a negative situation (murder of innocents) was the reaction they want? It's not a good story if it doesn't tug at the heartstrings and elicit emotion. Wouldn't you say that maybe terrorists might be viewed in even a more negative light after a game like this comes out?
 
How is it any different from terrorists killing civilians on 24? I don't remember any uproar... It was even called riveting story telling and dramatic. But put a controller in hand and all of a sudden it is an immoral murder simulator created by an irresponsible developer run amok.
 
A few posts heading down am infractious* path. Keep it civil or don't post it.

*Yes I know it is not a real word.
 
Now that I have had a chance to actually see the video I am not sure what is happening. Is it a fight and some civilians are caught in the crossfire? Or is the point of the mission to kill civilians? The latter would imply a reward for doing so.

There is a huge difference between showing a clip of the bad guys doing their thing (as in the first MW and the president scene) and having you play that role and rewarding you for doing so. Personally, I draw the line at that difference. Show me what the bad guys did so I have a reason to get some payback. Don't tell me to point a gun at civilians and perform the act in the first place.

The "it's just pixels" argument doesn't float here. It is the intention behind the scene that matter.

I still won't be purchasing it for my business (because of the server issue) here in the sandbox but this scene will probably determine if my son is given this game as well. I'll wait and see what people say of the scene.
 
I'm sure most of us have been killing civilians for years now in things like GTA. However, something about that part where the man is shot while dragging the wounded lady kind of hit a soft spot for me. I'm not saying IW should have left this part of the game out; I am a firm believer in games being as much a form of art as movies/books/etc, and, as such, the developers have the right to include whatever they wish to include to have their vision of the game realized. However, with this in the game, no matter if its only 5 min or less, IW has opened themselves a can of worms. Just look what happened to Bioware over a 30 second clip of characters having sex (which didn't even show anything more than some kissing really, but the overtones we're obvious). The media is going to have an absolute field day with this game in the next few weeks.
 
How is it any different from terrorists killing civilians on 24? I don't remember any uproar... It was even called riveting story telling and dramatic. But put a controller in hand and all of a sudden it is an immoral murder simulator created by an irresponsible developer run amok.

The difference is one of watching it happen, thus providing the incentive to kick their ass, versus making it a mission that I have to perform in order to pass the scene. I have no problem putting a bullet in a combative, I draw the line at killing a civilian, game or not.

...and no, I never killed the hostages in Counter-Strike - but then, the mission was to keep them, not kill them.
 
I've been playing violent video games for 20+ years and still haven't launched my own private Columbine on any schools, shopping malls, churches, sports stadiums, etc. I think I can handle MW2.
 
I've been playing violent video games for 20+ years and still haven't launched my own private Columbine on any schools, shopping malls, churches, sports stadiums, etc. I think I can handle MW2.

This isn't about people "handling" it, or saying it will cause people to become terrorists. It's the concept of the player being forced to play the role of a terrorist to complete the game (if that is indeed what is happening, but we do not know yet), a concept which many people will be justifiably opposed to doing.

Imagine a third person game, where you played Hitler, and your mission was to start the Holocaust. Would your response be the same? It's all "pixels," right? The message behind the pixels is what matters.

The responses to the MW2 outrages have really shown why gaming is still treated as the bastard child of mainstream media--the response from its audience to anything is largely incoherrent and illogical. For every person that makes a reasoned argument about something, twenty others come out and "lol I'll just pirate it" or some such nonsense.
 
This is the biggest cop-out argument ever for discussing the way something is portrayed in the media. It's a narrative story trying to put you in the place of the characters. This argument could be made for anything:

The Bible? JUST INK!
Televsion? JUST FILM!

You're basically saying all form of criticism is worthless because media is not reality.

What he is saying is more like, Fiction is Fiction regardless of how you interface with it...

This I would have to agree with.
 
The difference is one of watching it happen, thus providing the incentive to kick their ass, versus making it a mission that I have to perform in order to pass the scene. I have no problem putting a bullet in a combative, I draw the line at killing a civilian, game or not.

...and no, I never killed the hostages in Counter-Strike - but then, the mission was to keep them, not kill them.

You don't have to kill the "civilians" in the game, you can just walk though the level and not shoot any of them. I don't think they are armed. I highly doubt one of the level objectives is to kill 20 civis. I bet there is an achievement for not killing any of the civis in the first level.
 
or every person that makes a reasoned argument about something, twenty others come out and "lol I'll just pirate it" or some such nonsense.

so say we all 1+
 
What he is saying is more like, Fiction is Fiction regardless of how you interface with it...

This I would have to agree with.

Yes, Fiction is Fiction, but that is again not the point. If video games are ever going to rise above the cheap thrills level in the media and compete with film on an artistic level, you cannot forego critique because it's "just pixels," which he seems to be suggesting. All artistic works are fiction, even the ones based on reality like documentaries have a degree of fictiious fact-twisting and spin.

I'm still withholding judgment until I see the final product in context, but to just dismiss it now as "being only a game" does a disservice to the medium. Uncharted 2 is just a game, but I find its narrative and story-telling to be better than quite a few blockbuster films that have been released recently.
 
What he is saying is more like, Fiction is Fiction regardless of how you interface with it...

This I would have to agree with.

Within that context, it seems like you're implying that fiction has no significant bearing on people's emotions or their psyche in general.

There have been countless works of fiction that have played roles in history whether as a footnote or a major player. Shit, Scientology exists because of a science fiction novel.

So, to say things are just pixels or to say that it's just fiction is narrow minded at the very least.
 
With film, something like this would be artistic - the viewer is a passive observer, not partaking in the acts. The character(s) are to blame. With gaming, the gamer is seen as an accomplice to the acts by the public eye, despite what little control might be allowed with the plot, or the means to advance the plot.

IW is opening a huge can of shit with this, moreso if it's absolutely required that the player kills civilians in order to advance. A game this popular with a scene that cuts this close and is ostensibly "senseless" and "unnecessary" is going to get blasted and blamed for every problem with youth today. I can imagine FOX now.
 
So... they already have an attack on washington, DC... in the game...

In WaW, you play as Soviet soldier...

Soviets lost 12mil... only 3 mil because of the Nazis... the remaining because of a Red Army...

Who the hell cares? It's a video game. For all you know, this low quality cam vid is just a fake.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
To the people saying it's just pixels, would it be alright if I made a high quality game that the sole goal in the game was to crash a 747 into the wtc and kill as many people as possible.

You would get two planes to try and kill as many people as possible, you get extra points if people get scared and jump out of the building and fall to their deaths.

Of course, the start of the game would be the actual highjacking of the plane itself, kill the pilots and a couple of passengers and gain control of the plane.

Then the aftermath bonus round is extra points for how many firefighters and other volunteers you indirectly kill.

Should be perfectly fine, I mean it's just pixels anyway right.
 
Cam capture of a video game, low quality video, and on a Chinese site...
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Within that context, it seems like you're implying that fiction has no significant bearing on people's emotions or their psyche in general.

There have been countless works of fiction that have played roles in history whether as a footnote or a major player. Shit, Scientology exists because of a science fiction novel.

So, to say things are just pixels or to say that it's just fiction is narrow minded at the very least.

No but it is a far stretch to go and say that if it is appalling to us than it must be a stimulative to those who would have such a strong emotional reaction to fictional content.

For those who get stimulated emotionally by the act of killing in a video game, the actual target would most likely be irrelevant since they could just as easily treat their in-game target as something other than what it actually is. The depth of one's perception is much more complicated than just black and white comparisons that people wish to cling onto since it is much easier for the majority of readers / people to understand.

To the people saying it's just pixels, would it be alright if I made a high quality game that the sole goal in the game was to crash a 747 into the wtc and kill as many people as possible.

Well it depends... Would you be using a mouse and keyboard as the basis for your control schematics or would you be using a console controller?
 
The difference is one of watching it happen, thus providing the incentive to kick their ass, versus making it a mission that I have to perform in order to pass the scene. I have no problem putting a bullet in a combative, I draw the line at killing a civilian, game or not.

What about Rome:Total War? Blowing up Megaton? Blowing up the Death Star? Running over people in Grand Theft Auto or Carmeggeddon? All have or imply civilians that are merrily killed.

Everything I've read about MW2 has lead me to believe the civilians are panicky civilians and you lose points for hurting them.

Personally, I'd like to see a game tackle a subject like this a realistic manner and not cop out with "It's just a game!" I want to see terrorists killing civilians if you aren't fast enough. I want to see human shields.
 
No but it is a far stretch to go and say that if it is appalling to us than it must be a stimulative to those who would have such a strong emotional reaction to fictional content.

For those who get stimulated emotionally by the act of killing in a video game, the actual target would most likely be irrelevant since they could just as easily treat their in-game target as something other than what it actually is. The depth of one's perception is much more complicated than just black and white comparisons that people wish to cling onto since it is much easier for the majority of readers / people to understand.



Well it depends... Would you be using a mouse and keyboard as the basis for your control schematics or would you be using a console controller?

I'm just playing devil's advocate.

Also, I have no idea what you just said.
 
With film, something like this would be artistic - the viewer is a passive observer, not partaking in the acts. The character(s) are to blame. With gaming, the gamer is seen as an accomplice to the acts by the public eye, despite what little control might be allowed with the plot, or the means to advance the plot.

IW is opening a huge can of shit with this, moreso if it's absolutely required that the player kills civilians in order to advance. A game this popular with a scene that cuts this close and is ostensibly "senseless" and "unnecessary" is going to get blasted and blamed for every problem with youth today. I can imagine FOX now.

100% in agreement ...
 
I'm just playing devil's advocate.

Also, I have no idea what you just said.

Haha fair enough, I have a habit of playing devil's advocate as well, but this is a subject that I actually feel quite passionate about.

As far as to what I was saying it's quite simple. If I was let's say "Mentally Ill" and I picked up a copy of lets say L4D, is it impossible to believe that the infected I was killing could not be replaced with lets say High School Jocks in my mind? Granted they may not look the same, if I convince myself they are, I would still get the satisfaction of killing "High School Jocks" when killing the Infected.

Granted I have nothing against High School Jocks I couldn't think of a good reference so I went with everyone's beloved muscle heads. :p
 
It's a game. A GAME.

You ever played Grand Theft Auto? You'd probably throw a real fit about that one
 
Well it depends... Would you be using a mouse and keyboard as the basis for your control schematics or would you be using a console controller?

LMAO. If it doesn't have dedicated servers, pre-order CANCELLED.

It's a game. A GAME.

You ever played Grand Theft Auto? You'd probably throw a real fit about that one

You just don't get it at all. GTA =/= playing as a terrorist forced to kill civillians to advance the game. That's the scenario here. It has nothing to do with the "senseless violence" argument people raise with GTA. You're just using the typical gamer knee-jerk reaction which has no merit to this discussion.

In any event, this has hit the mainstream game news pages, and I would bet we hear from IW whether or not this is legit today. http://pc.ign.com/articles/103/1039382p1.html
 
Can we get some kind of Spoiler warning in the thread title or in the OP? I'm a bit miffed having to find out some of the story details without any warning from the OP. I'm sure others feel the same way.
 
Now that I have had a chance to actually see the video I am not sure what is happening. Is it a fight and some civilians are caught in the crossfire? Or is the point of the mission to kill civilians? The latter would imply a reward for doing so.

There is a huge difference between showing a clip of the bad guys doing their thing (as in the first MW and the president scene) and having you play that role and rewarding you for doing so. Personally, I draw the line at that difference. Show me what the bad guys did so I have a reason to get some payback. Don't tell me to point a gun at civilians and perform the act in the first place.

To me I don't see any return fire until the very end (looks like the cops finally show up?). It looks like a "rack up a high body count" mission. Look at the part where he's on the balcony looking down on the mass of civilians, it's the "shooting fish in a barrel" scene.

+1, the difference between a video clip where you watch it happen and being forced to participate is a huge. What's next, arcade mode where +10's pop up when you shoot them? I can't understand what would drive IW to include this in the first place other than shock factor...

You don't have to kill the "civilians" in the game, you can just walk though the level and not shoot any of them. I don't think they are armed. I highly doubt one of the level objectives is to kill 20 civis. I bet there is an achievement for not killing any of the civis in the first level.

Achievements were released several weeks ago, there is no "don't kill anyone" achievements. And despite the fact that you CAN walk through the level and not shoot anyone it's certainly not designed that way...

Everything I've read about MW2 has lead me to believe the civilians are panicky civilians and you lose points for hurting them.

Umm..."points?" You must be looking at a different MW2 than I am. There's a bunch of guys running through an airport killing everyone, there is no score and no game over for killing all that he can...
 
You just don't get it at all. GTA =/= playing as a terrorist forced to kill civillians to advance the game. That's the scenario here. It has nothing to do with the "senseless violence" argument people raise with GTA. You're just using the typical gamer knee-jerk reaction which has no merit to this discussion.

If I were to believe that the folks at Act/IW had enough original thought behind their money coated vision I would say that this would actually be an interesting approach.

Think of it this way; from a 'terrorist's' point of view is what they are doing evil...? From the point of view of any warring group they believe that they are fighting for the righteous path and what they are doing is for the greater good. Remember good and evil are a matter of opinion nothing more, nothing less; kind of like the old adage of ‘he who wins the war writes the history books’, or something like that.

Given this thought process it would be a good means of conveying a different point of view to the 'same old rail shooter'; and might make people actually think...

Though as I said this would be giving Act/IW credit for being creative...so likely the vid is simply a fake.
 
Think of it this way; from a 'terrorist's' point of view is what they are doing evil...? From the point of view of any warring group they believe that they are fighting for the righteous path and what they are doing is for the greater good. Remember good and evil are a matter of opinion nothing more, nothing less; kind of like the old adage of ‘he who wins the war writes the history books’, or something like that.

Given this thought process it would be a good means of conveying a different point of view to the 'same old rail shooter'; and might make people actually think...

Kind of like Baybars telling the Knights Templar that if they surrender peacefully, he'll give them safe passage, then chopping off their heads as soon as they laid down their arms. He was considered a good king by his side, and was the start of a long reign for the Mamluks, but he was thought to be a ruthless murderer by the Crusaders. Depends on which side you consider good or evil. It's all relative.
 
This isn't about people "handling" it, or saying it will cause people to become terrorists. It's the concept of the player being forced to play the role of a terrorist to complete the game (if that is indeed what is happening, but we do not know yet), a concept which many people will be justifiably opposed to doing.

Imagine a third person game, where you played Hitler, and your mission was to start the Holocaust. Would your response be the same? It's all "pixels," right? The message behind the pixels is what matters.

The responses to the MW2 outrages have really shown why gaming is still treated as the bastard child of mainstream media--the response from its audience to anything is largely incoherrent and illogical. For every person that makes a reasoned argument about something, twenty others come out and "lol I'll just pirate it" or some such nonsense.
I've got a novel idea for those of you who don't want to be "forced" to play the role of a terrorist, if indeed this truly is what happens in MW2:

Don't play MW2.

Same goes for your hypothetical game where the player would have to assume the role of the Holocaust-causing Hitler. Don't wanna be the Holocaust-causing Hitler?

Don't play the hypothetical game.
 
If I were to believe that the folks at Act/IW had enough original thought behind their money coated vision I would say that this would actually be an interesting approach.

Think of it this way; from a 'terrorist's' point of view is what they are doing evil...? From the point of view of any warring group they believe that they are fighting for the righteous path and what they are doing is for the greater good. Remember good and evil are a matter of opinion nothing more, nothing less; kind of like the old adage of ‘he who wins the war writes the history books’, or something like that.

Given this thought process it would be a good means of conveying a different point of view to the 'same old rail shooter'; and might make people actually think...

Though as I said this would be giving Act/IW credit for being creative...so likely the vid is simply a fake.

I don't take any issue with the freedom fighter/terroist dichotomy, but terroism as a tactic is pretty much universally reviled. Civilized countries do not kill civilians. Hell, they don't even kill captured soldiers.

In any event, you and I both know how John Q. Public will take this news, and it won't be with any of deeper reasoning, and I can't necessarily blame him. IMO, this was just a dumb move from a business standpoint.
 
The media will have a field day with this. I can see the headlines now "Murder Simulator, Terrorist Training Brainwashing Videogame 2009"

I saw no video. So I can't say if this is true or not. My response is giving the OP the benefit of the doubt and assuming his statement is true, and I'm taking it at face value.

This is the type of PR you can't buy. It's been ages since a video game made headlines by being controversal out side of the Grand Theft Auto games. It's a good way to capitalize on the media attention and boost sales. On the other side of the coin I wouldn't think about it too much. Whenever you fire up multiplayer in Call of Duty 4 and play as the Opfor team you look like a terrorist (an arab terrorist rather than a Russian despite what the story of the single player game would have you believe) and your goal is to kill as many S.A.S. and U.S. Marines as you can. In any of the WWII themed games you sometimes use an avatar that's dressed like one of the Axis powers in the MP game and shoot at Americans and their allies. If you think about it that way it's pretty reprehensible. However it isn't something that most of us would actually do in real life.

It's just a game.

Personally, I do not find it offensive whatsoever because I can draw the distinction from a videogame and real life.

I only find it offensive because this was probably included in the game as a PR stunt to generate sales and media attention. As for the value of such a scene in a game I can only say that if the writerrs/creators of the game had a real purpose besides fattening their wallets, and had a a truly artistic purpose that adds value to the game's story or enriches the game somehow, then that's one thing. I'm not going to be able to give IW the benefit of the doubt on that one though. I'm betting this is a PR stunt and nothing more.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top