MPAA / RIAA Ponder Suing Persistent Pirates

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
As much as I want to rip on the RIAA/MPAA over this, it's pretty hard to considering they will be going after people that have exhausted their first SIX STRIKES! :eek:

In the coming months U.S. Internet providers will begin to warn and punish copyright infringers. Since the “six strikes” plan was announced, a lot has been said about the temporary disconnections and throttled connections subscribers might be subjected to. But there is an even scarier outlook for persistent BitTorrent pirates, as the MPAA and RIAA have negotiated the right to demand the details of repeat infringers should they decide to take legal action.
 
This entire system has me concerned. If they are just going through BT trackers and identifying IP addresses... whatever.

If they are doing packet inspection on everything you send... then I have some real privacy issues with this. It's essentially wiretapping if they are doing packet inspection.
 
If you get caught 6 times doing the same thing, and didn't adapt enough, you probably should retire from doing said thing. It's a system I call survival of those who aren't sillifools. :p
 
This censorship and espionage is really getting out of hand. I just hope it does not get this way in Canada too.
 
Sure, whatever they want. Piracy is stupid anyway. I have to ask though, do they honestly think there's 6 of anything in movies or music that's interesting enough to be worth getting (paying for or stealing) in the first place?
 
We have no basis as to what constitutes a "strike", so them suing could just as easily blow up in their faces if they pick the wrong instances.

The whole ISP tracking it's customers while maintaining common carrier status just means they can do whatever the hell they want and you can do nothing to them due to common carrier. So their process is probably going to be less than stellar on identifying piracy in the first place. I just assume them catching people often means they are fulfilling the goal of the project, not that what they catch is actual infringement....just that they want their "catches" because they are either a) getting paid for catching or b) getting something else in bonus from it. No one in content creation should really give a shit about content protection because it costs them money to try to police it with no benefit/gain at all, it's not their job to police for other people's content. Much like google shouldn't have to filter it's results because someone says so.
 
That's no one whose NOT in content creation, and even then if they are..they should only care about what they make. They just to have to be aware of other people's stuff so they don't infringe when creating their own stuff....meet the level of parody or satire, keep your clips short during reviews, etc.
 
As much as I hate the RIAA/MPAA, this is a somewhat fair policy. Honestly I think six warnings is more than anyone should get anyway. Piracy is rather stupid all things considered, just buy the stupid movies, games, or whatever.
 
Just watch, you'll download a 10-episode season of a show in one torrent and suddenly you'll get a letter saying, "Sorry, you just got 10 strikes against you, lawsuit time!"

The precedent of this is what is most worrisome.
 
If you get caught 6 times doing the same thing, and didn't adapt enough, you probably should retire from doing said thing. It's a system I call survival of those who aren't sillifools. :p

:eek:Surely people are not using BitTorrent with out using a Proxy Server Address!

:cool:The use of a good Proxy Server Address should make it near impossible to track, unless they come up with some new laws to overcome that one.
 
I think most people would want something free (hence the downloading in the first place). Are there free proxies...?
 
In New Zealand they passed an Anti Copyright infringement law, and you only have to be accused 3 times to potentially get a fine/lose your internet (infront of a tribunal)

The issue here is, the fact that an IP holder correctly fills in a notice, is deemed sufficient PROOF that the offense occured... can anyone here, on windows, PROVE they didnt download X Album from Y artist yesterday? everyone ive talked to says its impossible
 
The first six will be accusations with no way to argue. They will be both the pitcher and the umpire.
 
Why can't these idiots just let it go and instead embrace online tech and provide a product that people will want to buy at a reasonable price? :confused:

:rolleyes:
 
Coworker was bitching that he received five citations for running the same red light near his house.

He was turning right on red, but the camera detects whether or not you came to the complete minimum 3 second stop or not, and if you don't it counts as running it.

Problem is, it takes 5-7 business days to get the citation mailed to you, so by the time he received his first citation, there were already four more citations on their way.

So I have a feeling we will see something similar happening to these "offenders". Someone will download seven torrents on the same day, and that will count as the seventh strike even though it was really just one warning.
 
Why can't these idiots just let it go and instead embrace online tech and provide a product that people will want to buy at a reasonable price? :confused:

:rolleyes:

No kidding. Guess they make more money through lawsuits then the actual product they are trying to sell so it makes more business sense for them. And the government backs up everything they do and even helps them by passing new laws. It's pretty sad the corruption going on in that industry.
 
Coworker was bitching that he received five citations for running the same red light near his house.

He was turning right on red, but the camera detects whether or not you came to the complete minimum 3 second stop or not, and if you don't it counts as running it.

Problem is, it takes 5-7 business days to get the citation mailed to you, so by the time he received his first citation, there were already four more citations on their way.

So I have a feeling we will see something similar happening to these "offenders". Someone will download seven torrents on the same day, and that will count as the seventh strike even though it was really just one warning.

The US DOT says a legal stop at an intersection just requires a state of zero forward travel, the duration could be 0.01 seconds. Source, having 2 red light cameras at a right turn tossed out in court.
 
Why can't these idiots just let it go and instead embrace online tech and provide a product that people will want to buy at a reasonable price? :confused:

:rolleyes:

Don't use common sense there, you're going to confuse them.
 
Piracy is rather stupid all things considered, just buy the stupid movies, games, or whatever.

Really? http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones. Supposedly, Game of Thrones is one of the most pirated things ever. Now if only.....
Originally Posted by beowulf7
Why can't these idiots just let it go and instead embrace online tech and provide a product that people will want to buy at a reasonable price?
. I'm sure more people would purchase a short season/one show pass should HBO come out with a reasonable offer. Why should we have to pay for more crap just to support cable shows/stations I think are a waste?
 
Why should we have to pay for more crap just to support cable shows/stations I think are a waste?
Because the channels that you think suck likely cater towards the lower class, and it keeps them pacified to have their TV subsidized by you avoiding LA riots and the like.

Think of television as the colloseums of Rome; its paid for by the gentry to keep the mob at peace. So pay up, just block the unwanted Telemundo channels and the like, and appreciate that it keeps them in front of the tube after work and off the streets.
 
No kidding. Guess they make more money through lawsuits then the actual product they are trying to sell so it makes more business sense for them. And the government backs up everything they do and even helps them by passing new laws. It's pretty sad the corruption going on in that industry.
Yeah, it makes me sad and angry that the gov.'t backs up these corrupt organizations, wasting our taxpayer $. Not to mention them wasting $ in other ways, like suing Bonds, Clemens, and Armstrong for 'roids. What a waste, just very pathetic. But I digress.

Don't use common sense there, you're going to confuse them.
LOL, yeah, common sense and MPAA/RIAA/gov.'t are mutually exclusive

.... I'm sure more people would purchase a short season/one show pass should HBO come out with a reasonable offer. Why should we have to pay for more crap just to support cable shows/stations I think are a waste?
Yeah, I'm sure they would. It's also like when a site like Amazon has an MP3 sale, like buy an album for a buck or 2, people get them in droves. Very few have the desire to "pirate" anything at that price. And they're DRM-free MP3s.

I'm using the word "pirate" in quotes b/c true pirating is what Somalians do as a profession at sea.
 
Not sure if they are actually going after "downloaders" or just "uploaders/sharers" like they ahve in the past.

I got a warning once for something I had downloaded... but it was because I had forgot to tell the BT client to shut down right after the download and it ended up seeding it.

I'ave also had to download ISOs before for stuff I actually own. sometimes because the CD/DVD for some reason will not read anymore or because a CD/DVD had been misplaced/lost.

Now when I download, I have it exit right after the download... only download 1 thing at a time, and cap my upload to like 3KB/s.

No reason at all to go after downloaders like that. It is just stupid... but that is the MAFIAA/RIAA for you.
 
Not sure if they are actually going after "downloaders" or just "uploaders/sharers" like they ahve in the past.

I got a warning once for something I had downloaded... but it was because I had forgot to tell the BT client to shut down right after the download and it ended up seeding it.

I'ave also had to download ISOs before for stuff I actually own. sometimes because the CD/DVD for some reason will not read anymore or because a CD/DVD had been misplaced/lost.

Now when I download, I have it exit right after the download... only download 1 thing at a time, and cap my upload to like 3KB/s.

No reason at all to go after downloaders like that. It is just stupid... but that is the MAFIAA/RIAA for you.

It doesn't matter because if you use BT you are still made an uploader regardless of how slow you cap it. That's all they really care about...you could have uploaded one byte, you're still guilty to them.
 
Put yourselves in the Artist's viewpoint. What if you had a creation and there were hundreds of thousands of people stealing it.

BT has it's uses, whatever the percentage is of people that use it likely wouldn't buy it anyway and that's fine. But BT is getting far too known. Not to sound like a devil's advocate, but it does need to contained before it gets out of hand.
 
Still of the mind that these strikes are nothing more than symbolic. Nothing has shown that what they consider is a strike is actual infringement in any way. And one cherry picked example if they provide one probably still won't cover the method the person used to infringe (BT, Newsgroup, download from their own remote server, etc). If they can actually prove what they downloaded was what they think it was (meaning they have to download it too) and not just named to match filters.

I mean it's far too easy once you know how their filtering and detection works to set people up to be caught by it intentionally to force the issue that their system is highly flawed.


I can't help but think it's all theater perpetrated for the purpose of intentionally setting themselves up for failure so they can go back to the government for more power to "detect and contain" at the cost of every single person who uses the internet. It has some similarities to the TSA, big bold claims, lots of huge numbers and "catches" that everyone wonders how they figure it was worthwhile given the huge numbers and doom and gloom they purport.

I mean they did after all wait like a solid 7-8 years to do anything significant about mp3 downloads and had internet based companies with links to "free songs" and reviewing piracy programs for years before anything even began to happen. Looking back, either they were completely clueless, failed to monetize it and held out hope, or let it happen with the intention of blowing the problem up to large proportions so they could finally win the "infringement" fight they've had every decade for the past 30 years. Cassettes, VCR, CDR, DVDR, DVR, Cell phones at live performances, video cameras in theaters, selling of used copies (mostly games, but I am sure the music industry complained at some point and Im just forgetting), Youtube "infringement" they did themselves, ........on and on and on.

They've taken the idea of crying wolf and ran with it, they should have died a long time back if it was so dire. And if the push is still to drive them out of business, maybe someone should see the trend and tell them to piss up a rope.
 
Competing with free is impossible.

Yes, this is true, but there are also quite a few who would pay, myself included, if a better, practical option were presented to us.

I made a case and point about Game of Thrones earlier, but I read an article somewhere that overall, HBO doesn't really care for the time being. They have nothing in place to start to offer something like that and it would go against all their contracts set up with cable providers. This would be bad b/c HBO makes far more money in subsidies (oh the nasty word holding those other wasteful channels up as well). It's just not worth their time to chase down illegal downloading.

All things being said, there is just some material out there not worth what it costs to buy. Starcraft 2 is an excellent example. I looked forward to it coming out, but I'm not a huge RTS guy. Luckily my friend bought it so I ganked his copy for a short while. I like the story, albeit very short, but the rest of the game was not for me. In my eyes, it's just not worth $60 (may be less now days).
 
Back
Top