Mozilla Leader Worries About Internet Limits

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Mozilla Foundation's Chairperson Mitchell Baker (formerly Chief Executive Officer of the Mozilla Corporation), says she worries that legal restrictions could limit Internet expansion. I like the “road” analogy she uses below:

"You suddenly become liable for anything that gets downloaded, whether it's legal or not," she said. "If you said to a municipality, if you build a road, you have to guarantee nothing illegal happens on it — that's what's happening on the Internet now. So that's the kind of regulatory disruption that's going to have some long-term consequences."
 
Governments and Cartels wont stop until they have control of the internet.
Theres no stopping them all.
 
I don't like the road analogy. It doesn't fit.

If a municipality builds a road, there are many Federal, State, and local laws that govern how it can and should be built. Additionally there are many laws that govern how that road can be used. And finally, there are Federal, State, and Local law enforcement agencies that patrol the road and enforce those laws.
 
Phatal; The argument isn't that there are no laws for building or using roads, the argument is that the person breaking the law is the one who gets punished not the owner of the roadway.
 
Governments and Cartels wont stop until they have control of the internet.
Theres no stopping them all.

There is stopping them, IF people would vote and purchase upon principle. But, doesn't look likely to happen.
 
I don't like the road analogy. It doesn't fit.

If a municipality builds a road, there are many Federal, State, and local laws that govern how it can and should be built. Additionally there are many laws that govern how that road can be used. And finally, there are Federal, State, and Local law enforcement agencies that patrol the road and enforce those laws.

Where were going we wont need any roads..

The point/result remains the same though the municipality are the only ones to remain accountable for any illegal activities which is not how it works now and shouldn’t be how it works for a company creating a opensource browser..
 
Phatal; The argument isn't that there are no laws for building or using roads, the argument is that the person breaking the law is the one who gets punished not the owner of the roadway.

Yeah, I totally get that. I just don't think the analogy works very well. Just my opinion.
 
the isp's hold the key - as long as they remain independent and provide access, there is no stopping the expansion of the internet - the community (i.e. people with PC's) can operate anything given a bit of FTP space and someone to connect to!
 
There is stopping them, IF people would vote and purchase upon principle. But, doesn't look likely to happen.

Unfortunately, the Cartels will remain Cartels and will stiff us one way or the other.
They have support in high places and this only seems to get stronger.
Lots of money indirectly and directly buys support.
If the system underlying the government wasnt corrupt, voting could make a big difference.
Sadly. whoever gets into government has to bend to the will of the system to a large extent or they wont get a decent response and little gets done.
And at times when those standing for election arent worth voting for, what choice does anyone have?

Were screwed either way.
 
Unfortunately, the Cartels will remain Cartels and will stiff us one way or the other.
They have support in high places and this only seems to get stronger.
Lots of money indirectly and directly buys support.
If the system underlying the government wasnt corrupt, voting could make a big difference.
Sadly. whoever gets into government has to bend to the will of the system to a large extent or they wont get a decent response and little gets done.
And at times when those standing for election arent worth voting for, what choice does anyone have?

Were screwed either way.

Can't stop the signal, Mal.
 
I like this quote

What advice would the three give to companies trying to get 100 million users?
(snip)
Zennstrom said the idea should also "make consumers' lives easier." And, he stressed, "don't do a copycat of someone else."

Skype's not exactly unique :-P
 
Can't stop the signal, Mal.

Hehe, I like that.
They arent stopping the signal though, they are forcing control of peoples actions through wildly excessive punishment while deliberately not fixing the issues that push people to infringe.
 
I don't like the road analogy. It doesn't fit.

If a municipality builds a road, there are many Federal, State, and local laws that govern how it can and should be built. Additionally there are many laws that govern how that road can be used. And finally, there are Federal, State, and Local law enforcement agencies that patrol the road and enforce those laws.

It fits just fine. Law enforcement enforces the laws on the roads, but they don't force the agencies who built the road to do so.

Nor do they punish those agencies because illegal activities are taking place.
 
SO, I rob a bank, have a highspeed chase down mainstreet, rundover a pedestrian, and finanly crash.

And the police arrest THE MAYOR?

Because he somehow let me do all that. WTF? :eek::rolleyes::p
 
Says the guy who got killed with a sword.

... and he was still right. No matter how regulated certain aspects of the internet become, people will always find a way around it.

I'm not just talking piracy, fraud, etc. The MPAA and RIAA aside, the vast majority of corporations would be against high regulation: compliance is expensive.
 
I'm not quite sure where Mitchell Baker got his information. When has anyone pointed the finger at a browser? Sure a municipality builds the road and ensures (or tries to) that nothing bad happens, no damange etc, but they are responsibile for only so much, that's why we have Police, Highway workers and so forth. I really think Baker is just being paranoid because the MPAA is snooping his telephone lines :D It will never be abou the browsers, only ever up to the domain that houses the infringing content. No browser would ever be responsible for the content.
 
Back
Top