Motherboard ideas for Q6600 Processor

Oblivion92

n00b
Joined
Feb 23, 2010
Messages
7
Hey guys, so I'm looking to upgrade my motherboard and case, just so I have some breathing room. At the moment I've got a stock HP build with a GTS 250 graphics card, 5 gigs of DDR2 800mhz RAM, and some extra hard drives. I'm looking for a Mobo with a 775 socket for my Q6600 processor (I haven't OC'd it at all and am hoping to get into that a bit). I haven't been able to pin down if they make 775 socket boards with DDR3 RAM (just for fun). It really isn't a huge deal though - what kind of benefits would I Get from DDR3 RAM vs. 1066 or 1333 DDR2? Would I be able to use those with my processor? I guess the q6600 stock has an FSB speed of 1066, so 1066 is the max DDR2 RAM I could get? Basically, if I overclocked my Q6600 a bit, what's the best RAM I could get? This stuff is all more complicated than I had anticipated. Also I would like to have the ability to SLI my card if I wanted to down the line. I guess my priorities would be: q6600 G0 overclocking, ability to SLI, then think about RAM speed, and finally cool stuff like USB 3.0. I've been considering a 750i, but I know that's a bit older and uses DDR2, but would that be a solid board for overclocking? I don't need the tri-SLI that comes with the 780i or 790i. What do you guys think? I'm looking at maybe some older tech (the 750i) so I don't have to spend all that much. The 775 socket is pretty old anyway from what I understand though.

Thanks guys!
Oblivion
 
We have an Asus 775 board that has DDR3 on it. Can't recall the model since it is at the studio but it was quite pricey when we bought it about 3 years ago. Over $200.

I have the Asus P5Q Pro with my Q6600 and it has been working perfectly for 2 years now.
I run 8GB of DDR2 1066 with the CPU at 3.02Ghz and it runs stable 24/7.
 
I haven't been able to pin down if they make 775 socket boards with DDR3 RAM (just for fun).
They do

It really isn't a huge deal though - what kind of benefits would I Get from DDR3 RAM vs. 1066 or 1333 DDR2? Would I be able to use those with my processor?
Zero benefits. Yes you can use DDR3 RAM with a Q6600

I guess the q6600 stock has an FSB speed of 1066, so 1066 is the max DDR2 RAM I could get?
No, that's not it. There's no real limitation on the highest speed RAM you can get with DDR2 and Intel Core 2 Quads.
Basically, if I overclocked my Q6600 a bit, what's the best RAM I could get? This stuff is all more complicated than I had anticipated.
The DDR2 800 RAM you have now is all that you need for a decent OC with the Q6600:
Stated FSB/4 = Actual FSB
Actual FSB x 4 = Stated FSB
Multiplier x Actual FSB = CPU Speed
1:1 Ratio: 2 x Actual FSB = RAM Speed
1:1 Ratio: FSB = 1/2 RAM speed
1:1 Ratio: DRAM = 1/2 RAM Speed
Note that C2D systems don't see a performance increase or decrease with any ratio higher than 1:1

Q6600:
Multi x Actual FSB, Stated FSB, RAM Speed = Clock Speed
9 x 266Mhz, 1066Mhz, DDR2 533 RAM = 2.4Ghz <== Stock Speeds
9 x 333Mhz, 1333Mhz, DDR2 667 RAM = 3.0Ghz <== Good OC
9 x 400Mhz, 1600Mhz, DDR2 800 RAM = 3.6Ghz <== Excellent OC, About the Max

Also I would like to have the ability to SLI my card if I wanted to down the line. I guess my priorities would be: q6600 G0 overclocking, ability to SLI, then think about RAM speed, and finally cool stuff like USB 3.0. I've been considering a 750i, but I know that's a bit older and uses DDR2, but would that be a solid board for overclocking?
You need an Nvidia chipset in order to use SLI with socket 775 CPUs. However those Nvidia chipsets were not well known for their stability. The best SLI socket 775 mobo out there was the eVGA 750i FTW motherboard. It was the most stable IIRC.

Straight from the motherbaord editor here at HardOCP:
http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1036245836&postcount=10

All nForce 6xx and 7xx series chipset based boards suck. Well except for the EVGA 750i SLI FTW. All others are pretty bad with voltage regulation and other problems. Though failure rates are higher with regard to reference designs, the failure rates on the ASUS/Gigabyte/MSI side are higher than they are for their Intel chipset based boards. At least that's been my experience. The P5N-D is OK for the most part but that poor chipset cooling will have that sucker baking hard all the time. That's not something those chipsets need. Honestly I'd avoid it. I'd stick with higher end single video card configurations if you can. The only reason to go SLI at this point is if you need the power of two of the highest end cards available. Short of that I'd say just avoid SLI all together. I'm a pretty big proponent of SLI on the high end but for lower end setups, I just don't get it. Especially not when you have to down grade your motherboard to do it which is exactly what you have to do with socket LGA775 systems to run SLI. It isn't worth it.
The GTS 250 cards you have are definitely not high-end cards by any means. In addition, no socket 775 mobo has USB 3.0.

But dude, don't bother upgrading your motherboard in general. It's not gonna provide you with any benefits worth the costs of upgrading. Unless you can get a good overclocking 775 mobo for cheap. You're better off saving your money for a newer AMD or Intel i5 build. Socket 775 is old and sinking more money into an outdated and dead platform is just a waste of money, expeically for the little reasons you mentioned.
 
Actually there are at least 2 boards with USB 3.0 that I know of : GA-EP45T-USB3P, Asus P5P43TD/USB3. I would get either the Gigabyte board or P5Q Pro Turbo. None of those boards offer SLI officially.
 
You can't have your cake and eat it too unfortunately.

There are no SLI boards for 775 that will overclock as well as a P45 chipset which is crossfire only.

If you expect to get any kind of great overclock out of your Q6600, you will have to give up SLI. It's not worth it anyway on the old boards and CPU. If you want SLI, upgrade to an i5/i7 setup.

For the cheapest temporary upgrade, get a Gigabyte EP45-UD3L (only one PCI-E slot) and get a single high performance videocard for it and you are set. You can get the Q6600 to 3.2-3.6GHz easily. I have the UD3P but I find I don't need the extra features.
 
Danny Bui, thank you very much for that comprehensive point by point response. That was inspiring! Okay, that makes more sense. I guess I was putting too much stock in RAM speed. That was a helpful comparison of ram/speed and everything too.

The reason I had considered getting a new motherboard was because mine is stock from the HP build - I can't even find the thing online. It's the most generic board ever, and I've been afraid to try to overclock it. I had only planned on spending like 80-90 bucks on an older board and finding an inexpensive and well ventilated case for another 50 bucks or something. The idea was just to get some more performance out of what I already have (I don't know anyone with a stock clocked Q6600) - And people seem to think the Q6600 is a solid performer when OC'd, so I really don't think I need anything better. I do game, but I don't need top of the line gear.

Also, on a side note, according to CPU-Z, my processor has a multiplier of 6... When it should be 9 I think. Is this thing underclocked?!

CPUZ.jpg


In light of that, if you agree that it's not an entirely pointless endeavor, what single PCI-E 16x 775 socket Motherboard would you recommend that would be good for OCing?
 
Danny Bui, thank you very much for that comprehensive point by point response. That was inspiring! Okay, that makes more sense. I guess I was putting too much stock in RAM speed. That was a helpful comparison of ram/speed and everything too.

The reason I had considered getting a new motherboard was because mine is stock from the HP build - I can't even find the thing online. It's the most generic board ever, and I've been afraid to try to overclock it. I had only planned on spending like 80-90 bucks on an older board and finding an inexpensive and well ventilated case for another 50 bucks or something. The idea was just to get some more performance out of what I already have (I don't know anyone with a stock clocked Q6600) - And people seem to think the Q6600 is a solid performer when OC'd, so I really don't think I need anything better. I do game, but I don't need top of the line gear.

Also, on a side note, according to CPU-Z, my processor has a multiplier of 6... When it should be 9 I think. Is this thing underclocked?!

CPUZ.jpg


In light of that, if you agree that it's not an entirely pointless endeavor, what single PCI-E 16x 775 socket Motherboard would you recommend that would be good for OCing?

the 6x is because it's on speedstep which downclocks your CPU when not at load. It switches between 6x and 9x. You also have a G0 revision Q6600 which usually bodes well for overclocking. If it's an early G0, you might get 3.8GHz out of it. Keep in mind, you don't need to use 9x either. You can drop the multi and do 8x400 =3.2GHz as well. There are alot of options.

Like I said Gigabyte EP45-UD3L
 
WHAT THE HELL IS UP WITH YOUR VOLTAGE? 1.7V ?!!! Fix that ASAP!!! Q6600 is only rated to go up to 1.5V at maximum or it will suffer damage. Stock is 1.3V and under!
 
Thanks Spare-Flare, that was really helpful. I just might get that board! Yeah I have an early edition G0. Very cool, thanks for the info dude!

Yeah I have no idea about my voltage, I haven't touched it. This is stock from my HP build. I'm guessing they did that in the factory...?
 
Thanks Spare-Flare, that was really helpful. I just might get that board! Yeah I have an early edition G0. Very cool, thanks for the info dude!

Yeah I have no idea about my voltage, I haven't touched it. This is stock from my HP build. I'm guessing they did that in the factory...?

It must be an incorrect reading then because 1.7V on a Q6600 would give you like 85° C temps on stock heatsink.
 
Cool. So as a start, I would attempt 9x400 @ 1.4-1.5V for 3.6GHz. Lower it if you can.

On the gigabyte board, use the memory clock divider set to 400MHz FSB setting and divide it down to either 800 or 1066 DDR2. I wouldn't bother with 1333 ram.
 
I wouldn't start with that kind of voltage. Work your way up, rather than down. You'll have a better understanding of your system's limits. First drop your multiplier to 6x. Then try uping your FSB in increments without touching your voltage. Once you have reached your limit that way up your voltage and retry your failed FSB. This way will take longer but you will have a better understanding of your system's limitations rather than just blindly jumping into it.
 
I wouldn't start with that kind of voltage. Work your way up, rather than down. You'll have a better understanding of your system's limits. First drop your multiplier to 6x. Then try uping your FSB in increments without touching your voltage. Once you have reached your limit that way up your voltage and retry your failed FSB. This way will take longer but you will have a better understanding of your system's limitations rather than just blindly jumping into it.

I have the opposite process. I ensure that I have very good cooling and I start at just under the Intel rated maximum spec and work down until the system cannot Prime95 small ftt anymore.
 
Back
Top