Motherboard, CPU & VGA upgrade

Shago

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 11, 2009
Messages
192
Hey guys

Here's the rundown:

1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Gaming (battlefield 2 & soon 3, MMoRPG's), office applications, light photoshop

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
€ 600 (less is better)

3) Where do you live?
Belgium

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc.
explained below
option 1: motherboard, CPU, VGA
option 2: CPU & VGA


5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing?
Corsair HX620W psu
Gigabyte MA970XT-UD4P motherboard (again see below)
2x2GB 1333MHZ kingston valueram
Coolermaster 212+


6) Will you be overclocking?
Yes

7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have?
24" 1920x1200 BenQ V2400W

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Between september and december (if my graphics card won't break, i'll keep it till december)

9) What features do you need in a motherboard?
Firewire, USB 3.0, SATA 6Gb/s eSATA

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license?
Yes, 32bit windows 7 but It is possible for me to use the 64bit version via a microsoft license pack from the company I work for.

Now, about my situation:

I currently have an phenom II x3 720BE, I overclocked it to 3.2ghz but it fails in prime95 after 1hour. Steady at 3.1ghz though but I'm afraid this will not be enough for Battlefield 3.

Also, my current graphics card is making really strange sounds (XFX 4870 1gb XXX) and the heat has become a concern (76°c idle). I have cleaned the graphics card and changed the thermal paste, but nothing seems to work.

Question: If my graphics card would quit on me, should I go for and Intel sandy bridge config or get an phenom II X4 processor andsave money on the motherboard in stead?
Also, I want a high end graphics card (cost can be around € 300), but ofcourse I don't want a CPU that bottlenecks it.
 
8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Between september and december (if my graphics card won't break, i'll keep it till december)
Well unfortunately, due to your wild time-frame, we cannot give you solid specific hardware recommendations since our recommendations tends to change from month to month due to parts prices and availability changing every month. Not to mention that there are a bunch of new parts supposedly coming out between now and December that might make most recommendations for CPUs, motherboards, and GPUs virtually obsolete/outdated after only a month.
I currently have an phenom II x3 720BE, I overclocked it to 3.2ghz but it fails in prime95 after 1hour. Steady at 3.1ghz though but I'm afraid this will not be enough for Battlefield 3.
At your resolution, probably not enough considering how well BFBC2 scales with multiple cores and clock speed.
Also, my current graphics card is making really strange sounds (XFX 4870 1gb XXX) and the heat has become a concern (76°c idle). I have cleaned the graphics card and changed the thermal paste, but nothing seems to work.
What case do you have?
Are you using the latest drivers? If so, have you tried upping the fan speed on the video card via the AMD Catalyst software?
Also find out where that strange sound is coming from. It may very well be the fan that's dying and therefore the source of the strange noise you hear.

Question: If my graphics card would quit on me, should I go for and Intel sandy bridge config or get an phenom II X4 processor andsave money on the motherboard in stead?
As noted earlier, we really can't tell you what parts to buy since your time frame is pretty wide-open and not specific to this month. Especially considering that AMD's Bulldozer CPUs are supposedly coming out sometime in Q4 2011.
Also, I want a high end graphics card (cost can be around € 300), but ofcourse I don't want a CPU that bottlenecks it.
As noted earlier, we really can't tell you what parts to buy since your time frame is pretty wide-open and not specific to this month. Rumors are saying that AMD is planning on releasing their new HD 7xxx series cards in September.
 
Ah, Danny Bui, my savior once again and thank you for the quick reply!

The Crucial M4 you recommeded was again, a great buy! Also, I couldn't find the Xigmatic you told me about, so had to go with the coolermaster 212+ ^^.

About the case: Antec 300, I'm currently using 1x 140mm on the top (out), 2x120mm front (in), 1x120mm back (out), on the cpu cooler 2x 120mm push & pull. I tried putting a 120mm on the side panel both blowing in and out without any succes. To get the temps down in CCC I have to put the fans on 35% which gives another annoying noise.
I double-checked it and the weird noise is definately comming from the graphics card.

I know the timeframe is laughable in terms of pc upgrading especially since Bulldozer and Ivy bridge are comming but lets say I need to upgrade in september, would the difference between an AMD PII X4 and, lets say an Intel 2500k both oc'ed to 4.0ghz, make a big difference in terms of gaming performance (since this will be the most stressfull task)?
Or would the price of a sandy bridge motherboard justify the upgrade?
 
I'm afraid its only 2 years in Europe and my cards is two and a half years old :rolleyes:. I've sent them an email though, just to make sure.
I've read a lot of the XXX series of XFX having difficulties. My next card will defenitely be from a manufacturer that makes descent coolers, like MSI with their HAWK and twin frozr series.
I just took the graphics card back then cause it was the cheapest of the bunch.
 
I know the timeframe is laughable in terms of pc upgrading especially since Bulldozer and Ivy bridge are comming but lets say I need to upgrade in september, would the difference between an AMD PII X4 and, lets say an Intel 2500k both oc'ed to 4.0ghz, make a big difference in terms of gaming performance (since this will be the most stressfull task)?
Or would the price of a sandy bridge motherboard justify the upgrade?
There's a already huge difference between the 2500K at STOCK and a Phenom II X4 @ 4Ghz. So yeah there will be a big performance difference between a 2500K @ 4Ghz and a Phenom II @ 4Ghz.

But again, I cannot say with 100% surety that the 2500K or even the Phenom II X4 955 will be a good buy in September.
 
A Core i5-2500k stock is better than many AMD CPUs when OC'd. And almost every 2500k will OC to 4GHz without breaking a sweat. Most of them will do it on a stock Intel cooler too (though after market is the better way to go.)

If you're going to upgrade your CPU before Bulldozer comes out then you should go Intel (assuming that AMD and Intel's pricing is similar to their pricing in the United States.)

For your GPU, you can either purchase a new card now for use in a new/upgraded system down the road, or you can wait until the 4870 finally dies and replace it then (knowing that you'll have some downtime until you get the new part.)

There's also no reason why you need to upgrade your CPU and GPU at the same time. You could wait to see how your system handles BF3 with a new GPU and then upgrade in October/November once the game is released.

And I really hope their XXX PSUs aren't that bad... (see sig)
 
I see, thank you guys, was just speculating, always nice to get some good feedback!

I wish you the best with the PSU Tony! I personally think its because my card is "factory overclocked" with a reference cooler on it. :)
 
Back
Top