Mobile Users Beware: Linux Has Major Power Regression

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
All you Ubuntu users out there need to read this article, especially if you are a laptop user. Thanks to Tuxed for the link.

For those that follow my personal Twitter feed will know that for the past week I've been closely testing Ubuntu 11.04 and all Ubuntu releases going back to Ubuntu 8.04 on many mobile devices in the office. The overall system performance, power consumption, and boot performance have been the principal targets. However, late this week I discovered a glaring regression: Ubuntu 11.04 is viciously going through power.
 
10.x was so bad for me that I pretty much stopped trying to use Ubuntu full time. Since 11.x, I've been hearing nothing but more complaints. Everything's been better since I went back to plain 'ol Debian and stuck to the stable (and dated) packages. Between Gnome and KDE both tying their hardest to fuck up the UI and Ubuntu losing sight of what made their distro worth using... It's pretty sad when you can say an OS 10 years older is still able to provide more stability and features. (WinXP)

The biggest thing, though, is despite how common one base set of hardware could be... how through 4 major versions they can still have dealbreaking bugs. When it comes to the Aspire One netbook (the single most common hardware config of netbook in existence across 3 different brands), it's the dual cardreaders on the first model. Left slot has an SD card, right slot has a multicard reader.

Even as of 10.10, THE CARDS LEFT IN THE SLOTS STILL CORRUPT ON SUSPEND.

The fuck?!

Of all issues you could have with an OS... the LAST you ever want to allow through multiple versions is DATA CORRUPTION.

Bonus: Wake from suspend if you booted from USB often doesn't work because... it decides to wake everything else up first and the USB port... you know, where it has to read the host files... last.

When it comes to Ubuntu... it's pretty scary how quickly they completely lost it.
 
Yea, I gave up on Ubuntu as well. Too many bugs, and issues. Never had a performance problem. Battery life may suck because the power management in Ubuntu stinks.
 
Debian for me also, whether it's a server or a desktop. You can always upgrade selected packages to more up-to-date versions if you need to. If you insist on having new-ish versions of all packages you'll just drive yourself nuts anyway. A system that works right is the key thing.
 
10.10 was a big step backwards on my netbook and 11.04 alphas where just terrible. Everytime I tried easing any concerns about it I got the typical "its alpha" responses.

The last good one on my machine was 10.04.
 
I used to love linux, but at this point it has become more of a hassle to use then it is honestly worth. Frankly we have hit a point where Windows is polished and secure enough that the open source nature of Linux is now working against it.

The linux community needs to get its act together.
 
Yea I found this out on my Eee 1001P. Half the distros didn't work right and the ones that did had terrible battery life. Linux severely needs to implement a full featured HAL so binary drivers work across any Linux distro.
 
I used to love linux, but at this point it has become more of a hassle to use then it is honestly worth. Frankly we have hit a point where Windows is polished and secure enough that the open source nature of Linux is now working against it.

The linux community needs to get its act together.

This is pretty much spot on. During the windows XP days where security was shit and the vista days where everyone hated it linux seemed to flourish. Against windows 7 and probably 8 it just dont make sense. We now have the security and stability we always wanted with windows and get to keep our gaming and compatibility.

I still love linux and would use it on a server long before windows but whatever i saw in desktop linux over the last few years is practically gone.
 
I'm going to put this out there. I don't care what ya'll say, I know I've done my part.

I've used Windows since the days of 3.1 on my first computer (a 20MHz 386SX w/ 4MB RAM and NO floating point capability!). Since then, I've used 3.11, 95, 98, and XP, with the last two getting the most use. I've used 2000, Vista, and 7 a little bit. Never used Me, but from what I hear, that's a good thing.

I've used MacOS a little, mostly to make automated presentations in college because I didn't have enough sense to use Windows Movie Maker. That would be some version of OS X. I also have a Mac SE 30 that I used --once-- just to see if it still booted (it did).

Here are the versions of Linux that I've used enough to have an opinion on:
DSL 4
DSL-N 4
Ubuntu 7.04
Ubuntu 7.10
Ubuntu 8.04
Xubuntu 10.04
OpenSUSE 10.somethingorother
SUSE 7.somethingorother Pro (given to me by a friend)
Slax LiveCD (don't remember version)

...now add to that pile *at least* twenty distinct versions of Puppy Linux, each with a different set of strengths, weaknesses, and features, and each optimized for a different need. There is a version specifically for the Eee PC netbooks (Puppeee), there's a version for (essentially) all other laptops and netbooks (Fluppy), there are several versions for low-power computing, for all of you stuck in the horror of It Came From A Mid Nineties Computer (Wary Puppy, Puplite, and a few others come to mind). If you want to expose your children to the wonders of Linux at an early age, there's HanSamBen (the developer's children are named Hanna, Samuel, and Benjamin ;) ). If you're a Mac-lover, there's MacPup (I've no idea whether or not it will actually run on a real Mac, tho...).

I've even developed my own version of Puppy (don't kid yourself, they make it easy). It's for tree-huggers. It's called GreenPup, and it sports a special tool allowing you to dynamically scale your CPU frequency on-the-fly. You set the minimum and maximum frequencies, and it adjusts from there, to conserve (or serve) power as needed.

Yes, you do run as root. Call me naive, but I don't see the problem with that. Unless someone specifically targets and hacks you... you shouldn't have a problem. The Linux filesystem is completely alien to the vast majority of (Windows-targeted) viruses and is therefore immune as far as I can see. (Call me a liar if you will, but back it up with proof, please.)

Further, the somewhat unique option of a "frugal" install to hard drive is another misunderstood bonus. It allows for easy recovery of corrupted user data or from *ahem* users inexperienced in Linux making inevitable mistakes (having reinstalled Ubuntu three times in as many days for exactly that latter problem gives me the experience to say that it SUCKS to have to do that). On top of that, it streamlines the installation of certain programs and sets thereof, allows for "coexist" installs (several Puppies on one partition!), etc., etc.

Oh... and the support? It's wonderfully inclusive. I'm not the only one there who matters, but at least I matter too ;) we get several people who come from Ubuntu and say that they don't understand why Ubuntu forums have the attitude of "Why the #%^^ are you pestering me?! Go back to Windows you dumb &&$!" (FWIW, I've never been on the Ubuntu Forums, and I don't understand it either. I'm just saying what I've heard.)

I'm not going to say that Puppy is the best thing since sliced silicon. All I'm saying is that it makes me wonder, "Why in the %$#@ did I *ever* use Ubuntu?!?!" That, and it might make you say the same thing.

OK, I'll shut up now and ya'll can flame me or whatever :p
 
I used to love linux, but at this point it has become more of a hassle to use then it is honestly worth. Frankly we have hit a point where Windows is polished and secure enough that the open source nature of Linux is now working against it.

The linux community needs to get its act together.

I want to use Linux, just to get away from Windows. Unfortunately, Linux needs a lot more polish. With Ubuntu though, things just need to work.

But yea, the linux community is at fault. A lot of them act like it's their OS, and screw you. When I ask the question of games, the answer is go play an xbox or playstation.
 
I never use my batteries, unless I need to be mobile. I take my laptop to work every day to watch some streaming from Netflix. It is absolutely useless to burn out the battery that way. So, I always wondered if people approach the battery usage properly?

Unfortunately, Linux needs a lot more polish.

That's the beauty of Linux. It will always need more polish.
 
I haven't really noticed any power consumption increases on my laptop... of course now a days my laptop only gets an hour(idle) on the battery(Windows or Linux) but thats because it is almost 5 years old
 
VMWare running ubuntu is a great sandbox for visiting "sketchy" sites. That's all I use it for.
 
Not concerned yet.

11.04 is still in beta. This is why we have betas, to root out problems.
 
Against windows 7 and probably 8 it just dont make sense. We now have the security and stability we always wanted with windows and get to keep our gaming and compatibility.

I still love linux and would use it on a server long before windows but whatever i saw in desktop linux over the last few years is practically gone.

Windows 7 security is better than XP but I still wouldn't consider it "good enough".

If XP was shit (which it was) 7 is "slightly less shit".

Wen today whole running MSE you can - without doing anything wrong, like clicking a bad link in a browser, running a questionable executable or giving a questionable process admin access wind up viriid or with malware.

Windows 7 is a step in the right direction, bit there is still a long way to go.

I am still running ubuntu 10.10 on both my laptop and desktop and I have had no problems. Running Linux on mobile devices has always been an issue though as many components don't have good Linux drivers. I was positively surprised when 10.10 just worked on my laptop wifi...

Either way, I will continue to run 10.10 until about 2 months after the 11.04 launch (like I always do) so they can work out the kinks on the silly early adopters machines :p
 
You're right security is not up to *nix/BSD standards but its honestly good enough for the desktop. Most issues arise when users think they know more than they do. Those that turn off UAC and run with no AV etc.

Im not sure what you are referring to about the MSE thing but that should not be possible with UAC enabled. Issues will always pop up though and people love to bash MS for them but if Linux had as many people writing malware for it as windows does all progress would grind to a halt as all resources went to fighting it off, nobody would have the time to add features or fix bugs because it would take everything the open source community has just to stop the malware.

Considering the position windows is in MS does a hell of a job keeping it together.
 
when it comes to power, I usually don't deal with any distro except one that I know for sure I can customize down the bare bone. can't really do that with ubuntu.
 
when it comes to power, I usually don't deal with any distro except one that I know for sure I can customize down the bare bone. can't really do that with ubuntu.

And why cant you? Just like every other distro its a kernel with a bunch of packages. Theres absolutely nothing prohibiting you from changing that kernel or those packages in the exact same way you would any other distro.

In fact its easier than most because of the amount of packages available in the repos.
 
And why cant you? Just like every other distro its a kernel with a bunch of packages. Theres absolutely nothing prohibiting you from changing that kernel or those packages in the exact same way you would any other distro.

In fact its easier than most because of the amount of packages available in the repos.

There actually is.

Just like every DISTRO THAT IS RELEASED WITH A LOT OF INTEGRATED PACKAGES... Ubuntu is a total nightmare when it comes to dependency issues. Just pulling all 27 extra font packages out at the same time causes Gnome to come crashing down whereas pulling each of those 27 font packages out one at a time just means more hard drive space. Ubuntu, as it stands, is an ugly hack of Unity, Compiz, Metacity and Gnome all working (with/against) each other.

Don't even get me started on Network Manager. The way it's integrated into Ubuntu distros is enough to make a grown man cry. Then we have power management... The crux of the issue.

Rolling the exact same packages together with Debian, at least, will allow you to be able to edit conf files as you go BEFORE you throw more packages on top that will eventually depend on it all.

Integration was formerly Ubuntu's strength. Now it is its biggest failing.
 
I want to use Linux, just to get away from Windows. Unfortunately, Linux needs a lot more polish. With Ubuntu though, things just need to work.

But yea, the linux community is at fault. A lot of them act like it's their OS, and screw you. When I ask the question of games, the answer is go play an xbox or playstation.

If you aren't prepared for the answer, don't ask the question.

The honest truth of it is that while Wine is able to run more and more Windows games, it's far from perfect (i.e. Black & White still doesn't run right in it). As far as native Linux games go you definitely have some options and more are coming all the time, but if you want to play the latest games with the highest production values typically Linux won't have them.

If on the other hand you're happy with some MMOs, arena shooters, and the indie scene then Linux may treat you just fine. Also if you play Guild Wars, because Wine runs that without a hitch.

Also note that a lot will be determined by how and where you ask your questions about things with Linux. If it's something trivial to look up yourself (generally speaking when it comes to Linux gaming it is), you didn't try to find a solution first, or you're rude then people will be more likely to ream you. Also, don't ask Gentoo users; they're a little bit weird.
 
Windows 7 is really good enough at this point. The allure of Linux was a secure and stable system. I've had 0 crashes with Win 7 so far (knock on wood), and the security only breaks down with obscure, difficult to create exploits which are patched quickly. I love the culture, but I no longer see the need on desktop.
 
Back
Top