Microsoft's See-Through 3D Desktop

And when I thought no more new ideas that are worse than the mouse could be invented, this happens. First touch, then Kinect, now 3d floaty mouse!

I seriously think this is the wrong way to go for user input. The efficiency lost by using your body or hands to interact with a PC for work related task is just too high. A keyboard and mouse my still not be optimal, especially form an ergonomics standpoint, but having to move your body in any 3D space mapped to a 2D is going to be slow and cumbersome, not to mention stressful.

This type of technology makes sense in a true 3D to 3D space, as if it was done with projectors, commonly known as holograms.

The reason a mouse beats this technology handedly, is because it is a 2D to 2D mapping making precision absolute in both spaces.

This of course is my opinion, and the coolest thing here is the clear OLED display, which would be great for HUDs and the like.
 
And when I thought no more new ideas that are worse than the mouse could be invented, this happens. First touch, then Kinect, now 3d floaty mouse!

I seriously think this is the wrong way to go for user input. The efficiency lost by using your body or hands to interact with a PC for work related task is just too high. A keyboard and mouse my still not be optimal, especially form an ergonomics standpoint, but having to move your body in any 3D space mapped to a 2D is going to be slow and cumbersome, not to mention stressful.

This type of technology makes sense in a true 3D to 3D space, as if it was done with projectors, commonly known as holograms.

The reason a mouse beats this technology handedly, is because it is a 2D to 2D mapping making precision absolute in both spaces.

This of course is my opinion, and the coolest thing here is the clear OLED display, which would be great for HUDs and the like.
Looks like someone completely missed the point of it and the obvious applications regarding it. It doesn't have to be useful in an office TO BE useful. Yeah, it's not like it couldn't be used anywhere else. :rolleyes:
 
So if you're playing a game or watching a video that takes up te whole screen then you're touch typing? I'm a decent typist so that's something I could get used to but that's not the case for everything.
 
They say that they're using head tracking. That would only allow 1 person to use the display at a time.
 
I give them even more respect for showing the people behind it, and not some abnormally attractive marketing girl, perhaps women in the recent news stories this week need to rethink their "overly sexist reality" of the workforce.
 
I give them even more respect for showing the people behind it, and not some abnormally attractive marketing girl, perhaps women in the recent news stories this week need to rethink their "overly sexist reality" of the workforce.

This.

Some people might nitpick the English, but they'd be morons. Who cares how a person looks when it comes to technological stuff.


If I want a pretty face, I'll watch main stream advertising.
 
Put that in some goggles or glasses please. That would make for some awesome augmented reality.
 
Looks like someone completely missed the point of it and the obvious applications regarding it. It doesn't have to be useful in an office TO BE useful. Yeah, it's not like it couldn't be used anywhere else. :rolleyes:

When did I say office? I am merely pointing out the idiocy of making such an inefficient input system. These inefficiencies will apply to every application. We already have 3D motion capture systems for use in 3D space applications. The combination with a monitor and keyboard is the part I see as a move backwards.
 
When did I say office? I am merely pointing out the idiocy of making such an inefficient input system. These inefficiencies will apply to every application. We already have 3D motion capture systems for use in 3D space applications. The combination with a monitor and keyboard is the part I see as a move backwards.

BUT, right now holographic display is still sci-fi. What I see this as is a step toward the system that was shown in Iron Man, where he was using his hands and verbal commands instead of a keyboard and mouse. Granted, he had a 3D holographic projection system, but development always comes in stages.

The most outstanding thing about this video? I could understand these two foreign people better than I can understand a lot of the American youth where English is SUPPOSED to be their first language...
 
Awesome, this is the closest thing we'd have to a holographic display right now. It looks cheaper and more reliable than head tracking with a headset. It actually looks practical.

The main problem is that it requires you to watch a huge screen within elbows length, that can't be comfortable.
 
And when I thought no more new ideas that are worse than the mouse could be invented, this happens. First touch, then Kinect, now 3d floaty mouse!

I seriously think this is the wrong way to go for user input. The efficiency lost by using your body or hands to interact with a PC for work related task is just too high. A keyboard and mouse my still not be optimal, especially form an ergonomics standpoint, but having to move your body in any 3D space mapped to a 2D is going to be slow and cumbersome, not to mention stressful.

This type of technology makes sense in a true 3D to 3D space, as if it was done with projectors, commonly known as holograms.

The reason a mouse beats this technology handedly, is because it is a 2D to 2D mapping making precision absolute in both spaces.

This of course is my opinion, and the coolest thing here is the clear OLED display, which would be great for HUDs and the like.

fatty :p
 
Good to see Microsoft actually innovating and creating actual NEW technology than that fruit company...

Either way it looks cool, but as JosiahBradley pointed out, for MOST everyday tasks, if not ALL tasks, mouse and keyboard are still the best.

Unless someone here has an idea of where something like this could be used and be more efficient than a mouse and keyboard...was thinking perhaps medical use for displaying scans and what not, however, any ole computer screen and a mouse can more said 3D scan around too so...
 
I think this is great progress towards our holograms we want so badly, this will set a basis for a holographic UI and by the time a true holograph comes out there should already be a strong and steady UI system

i think the big thing we need to work on is integrating voice commands into our OS's. I think that would be huge. Imagine windows 8 on a 24" multi touch monitor with full voice commands built into the system already and the core programs atleast. Computer could be in sleep mode, say "Computer Name" and it wakes up, say open word, then say what you need to say. Save or print or email it directly, then you can use a combo of voice and multi-touch for things like powerpoint (take a layered aproach kinda like PS). You could rule out a keyboard and mouse for most daily tasks, but if you put the computer into an angled enclosure like a drawing board then you could just slide it out server style and it would raise the tilt on the screen to a more natural typing/viewing ratio. Slide it in , screen goes back to voice and touching angle. I think we really need to push voice and touch interface on a large scale before we get to holo's, cuz that way then people will be familiar already with interacting with their 2D desk space physically, then you just have to add a 3rd dimension and bam, were in the next Iron Man movie lol
 
I think we are all missing thus point, that girl needs some make up and she needs to get out into the sun.
 
that looks completely uncomfortable, having your hands under the display and having to awkwardly make gestures with 4 inches of clearance.. no thx, keep working on that Doctorate guys..
 
I give them even more respect for showing the people behind it, and not some abnormally attractive marketing girl, perhaps women in the recent news stories this week need to rethink their "overly sexist reality" of the workforce.
Different industries obviously have different standards.

This is a neat technology, but it looks like it would get pretty uncomfortable using that for hours.
 
My opinion? That guy should try and learn to talk without moving his body like a fish.
 
I felt uncomfortable watching them feel uncomfortable. I felt sea sick watching that dude talk. BUT, that is some cool fucking technology! So where is that connect camera mounted? ;)
 
man their English is horrible .

Anyways, not the point, cool tech. Just don't really see the need for it.

They should be trying to link your mind to the computer. So you can just think it, and balm presto.

Bad thing about that would be, every what 7 seconds or so, there would be a naked chick on your screen.
 
I think some of you are taking it too serious, or not seeing the potential big picture here.

This is just a tech demo, a glimpse of the future. Some day, we may have a screen that covers the wall, and we would be able to use our hands to move and manipulate objects.

Example, let's say you are a company and you want to show your clients of what their next product could be. You make a rapid prototype and now can show a 3D rendered object to your clients. Your clients can move it, manipulate it, and then give feedback on what they want to see done and improved.

This doesn't have to be just a desktop only environment. I can see a lot of things that this can be applied to. Of course in 20 years and we watch this video again, it will all seem ancient. Just imagine how different the computer will be used.
 
Using your arms to manipulate the GUI might be ok for casual users but any seriou computer users will end up with gorilla arms. It is just not feasible for serious computer work and is a gimmick.
 
She is very girl-next-door. The accent sets it off though.

I think we are all missing thus point, that girl needs some make up and she needs to get out into the sun.

I have no problem with the woman in the video. I actually like the French accent, but that's probably because I've taken 4 years of French in high school. It's a wonderful language.

...and the obligatory....

pr0n, finger your favorite celeb. :D

This will revolutionize the porn industry :eek:

If Microsoft/MIT doesn't have a production model out in the next decade, I'm very sure the Japanese will beat them to it. :D

Just look at the stuff Japan comes out with, especially when it comes to robotics (and the sex industry-- they did invent S&M). :p

They'll probably have functional sex-droids/sex-bots and Gundam mechs before we have US Army exoskeletons for our soldiers and robotic military mules.

But that's beside the point...

As with every technology, everything comes in steps. There is still a noticeable lag in 3D interaction whether with current holographic technology and 3D user spaces.

We aren't quite yet at the level of Minority Report or the HUD used in various other sci-fi films. Give it time and sooner or later 3D interaction and interfaces will no longer require physical hardware peripherals like gloves, glasses, keyboards and mice.

We didn't get an Intel Core i7 in the 5 years after the transistor and first electronic circuit board to use semiconductors was invented right?

I think it's been close to a decade or so when ASIMO first came out, then MIT caught up, but robotics has advanced in stages as well. First, human-like walking then running then human arm movements. Later on was head tracking, object recognition, and so on. Then, there were the exoskeletons tested by R&D labs here for use in the Army.

Sooner or later, we'll have human operated mechs or robotic soldiers to fight for us, or do the tedious and dangerous tasks humans currently do day-to-day. (And, the socioeconomic side effects that come afterward when robotics take over human employment in those areas.)
 
Back
Top