Microsoft's Project Natal In Action

I just watched this motion control demo by Sony. They just creamed Nintendo and Microsoft with their presentation: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgLN7uOj8Jg

Looks amazing, accurate down to the millimeter, and unlike the other conferences they actually used really compelling examples in their demonstrations (compare the paint demo). They even use shooter examples!

I was really not expecting this, wow.
 
That said, the voice recognition in NATAL looks really great. Gah, why can't one system have everything awesome combined? :)
 
I just watched this motion control demo by Sony. They just creamed Nintendo and Microsoft with their presentation: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgLN7uOj8Jg

Looks amazing, accurate down to the millimeter, and unlike the other conferences they actually used really compelling examples in their demonstrations (compare the paint demo). They even use shooter examples!

I was really not expecting this, wow.
How? Sony had nothing more than a glorified wii remote. Natal used your entire body WITHOUT a remote.
 
I may be the first to say this... but Natal is fucking stupid and going to fail. It's not going to work well at all for hardcore games, and the Wii already has softcore games cornered.

A gyroscope and 3D triangulation system with 21st century electronics and computational techniques might work, but not this ridiculous garbage.
 
Oh and you'd need probably 5 controllers (2 hands, 2 feet, 1 head)
 
This will be wildly successful..... because the killer app will be porn
 
Just a side note and FYI, "Natal" is "Christmas" in Portuguese.
 
Engadget got a little hands-on time with Microsoft’s Project Natal at E3. Apparently it works very well at this point with the Engadget crew saying that it “completely tracked their movements accurately” and that it is "very impressive stuff."
 
Engadget got a little hands-on time with Microsoft’s Project Natal at E3. Apparently it works very well at this point with the Engadget crew saying that it “completely tracked their movements accurately.”

Friend of mine is actually at the show and says it performed just like the demo/ad on Xbox.com......

So for all the naysayers... Stuff it ;)

Microsoft is kicking ass right now.
Windows 7 will be a smash hit.
Zune HD will be sweet.
Natal is just plain amazing.


Nintendo comes up with a device that makes the Wiimote more accurate.
Sony comes up with a Wiimote themselves.
Apple has Snow Leopard.
Apple just has minor updates (most likely) coming to iPod.

Competition ain't doing so well lol...
 
I think some sort of combination of Natal and Sony's motion system would be cool. How exactly is Natal going to notice slight rotations of your hands or fists like Sony's can? I think you are going to need some sort of controller regardless.
 
Soon it will come full circle and be easier to just ride a real skateboard rather than a virtual one.
 
Wow...I was not expecting to actually see this thing work as well as it does. I'm actually really excited about this since this would open a whole new level in terms of gaming. Kudos to MS.
 
Soon it will come full circle and be easier to just ride a real skateboard rather than a virtual one.

Yea I was thinking the same then when I saw the skateboard demo... Get it realistic enough and you're basically mimicking real life, which you could actually do.

Driving a million dollar racecar is obviously something a game could do, but a $50 skateboard... sheesh. You'd spend more on the actual video game.
 
Yea I was thinking the same then when I saw the skateboard demo... Get it realistic enough and you're basically mimicking real life, which you could actually do.

Driving a million dollar racecar is obviously something a game could do, but a $50 skateboard... sheesh. You'd spend more on the actual video game.


but way less broken bones.. less medical bills.. and less wimpy mothers freakin out about their 5 year old kid getting a scratch from falling..
 
i still keep thinking about back to the future 2 when marty shows the kid how to play an arcade game and gets the line "you mean you have to use your hands to play this? thats a babys toy"
 
I'm looking forward to Windows 7, and DX 11 has some cool stay that may eventually pan out well. But I will eat buckets of crow if anything fun ever comes out of Natal.

Zune HD is decent but they need to market it better.
 
Based on the Engadget.com video, I'm wondering when they will get the brilliant idea to port dance dance revolution to this control scheme.:rolleyes:
 
Yea I was thinking the same then when I saw the skateboard demo... Get it realistic enough and you're basically mimicking real life, which you could actually do.

Driving a million dollar racecar is obviously something a game could do, but a $50 skateboard... sheesh. You'd spend more on the actual video game.

Yeah...I have mixed feelings about this. I know everyone is on a fix about more interactive games and games that instill movement/exercise. I love video games and technology, do not get me wrong, but why not just go out and learn how to skate? Or learn some de-tac or hand to hand combat?

I understand that certain games let people live their dreams or enable someone to do something they normally can't for fun or relaxation. However, what really ticks me off is that this is somewhat promoting staying home on the couch and completely negating personal interactions. I mean, what's with the scene where two families are playing a jeopardy type game from their separate homes? Go out, buy Cranium, walk over to your friend's house and bam! We need more time away from the TV and PC, not the other way around...
 
In jeopardy? The world as we know it has rolled over and died.

Natal is going to change many many things if it actually works the way it has been presented.
 
How? Sony had nothing more than a glorified wii remote. Natal used your entire body WITHOUT a remote.

Using the full body is a cool thing, but the accuracy that the Sony controller has is extremely impressive. Nothing else seemed to have that level of control and interaction down to the millimeter. They showed it in a very wide variety of demo situations, I thought it was pretty cool.

FWIW, a friend of mine that I went with got a demo today and she said she was very very impressed by it. I unfortunately had to head out for work before the appointment so I missed out, blah. :mad:
 
I think some sort of combination of Natal and Sony's motion system would be cool. How exactly is Natal going to notice slight rotations of your hands or fists like Sony's can? I think you are going to need some sort of controller regardless.

I agree. Natal has some very cool aspects to it (especially voice and body recognition), but in terms of fine tuned interaction, the Sony controller prototype is magnitudes more precise than what anybody else offers.

A combination of the two technologies would be amazing.
 
FWIW, a friend of mine that I went with got a demo today and she said she was very very impressed by it. I unfortunately had to head out for work before the appointment so I missed out, blah. :mad:

Just so I'm clear, my friend was getting a demonstration of Natal, not the Sony device. She was one of the speakers at the MS conference on Monday, probably my only ticket to look at this thing until it hits shelves. Stupid work getting in the way as always. :)
 
I wouldn't. I don't like the motion dependent games.

I know many who thought this way about Rockband. Not into rhythm games that make them look stupid and childish. Then they actually played it and then they wouldn't let go of the controllers.
 
I know many who thought this way about Rockband. Not into rhythm games that make them look stupid and childish. Then they actually played it and then they wouldn't let go of the controllers.

Everyone has a price, what's yours? :p
 
i still keep thinking about back to the future 2 when marty shows the kid how to play an arcade game and gets the line "you mean you have to use your hands to play this? thats a babys toy"

haha, predicted the future!
 
but way less broken bones.. less medical bills.. and less wimpy mothers freakin out about their 5 year old kid getting a scratch from falling..

Just wait until we get the lawsuits regarding kids jumping around too much and falling through the coffee table or TV... ;)
 
I wouldn't. I don't like the motion dependent games.

I'm sure there will still be controller capability for backwards compatibility on older stuff. Heck, I'm sure some games will actually have the ability to control it both ways.
 
Back
Top