Microsoft's New Browser Won't Enable 'Do Not Track' by Default

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
So much for safety first. Microsoft admitted this week that its new Project Spartan browser will come to consumers without the Do Not Track feature enabled as it was in Internet Explorer 10. This could be problematic for many first-time and non-technical users.

Microsoft promises, however, to make it easy for Windows users to turn the feature on. “This change will apply when customers set up a new PC for the first time, as well as when they upgrade from a previous version of Windows or Internet Explorer,” Microsoft said.
 
Does it really do anything anyway? Isn't the "Do not track" initiative more of an honor system?
 
In February 2012, the major online advertising trade groups pledged at the White House to support Do Not Track by year-end; that promise remains unfulfilled. Efforts to standardize Do Not Track in the World Wide Web Consortium have resulted in deadlock, despite frequent urging by American and European policymakers.

We believe that Do Not Track could be a success, but at this stage, must be implemented through either a legal or technical requirement. In the interim, novel technical countermeasures—like the Cookie Clearinghouse—hold promise for providing simple and effective user choice over web tracking. source

Yup, it doesn't do much of anything really as of now.
 
Wasn't everyone complaining when Microsoft made 'Do Not Track' the default in IE? Microsoft listened, gets more flack. What the hey.
 
DNT was supposed to an "opt in" option for users, disabled by default, per the consortium. By setting the DNT "switch" in Win 8.x and IE 11 to enabled by default the consortium then said "Hey you can't do that! Ok everybody ignore the DNT flag on IE11!!!" which they pretty much do for everything else anyway but were able to officially say they did it on this, making the DNT flag completely useless in IE 11, instead of just effectively useless, all because MS knows all their customers don't want to be tracked and wanted to make the point that DNT was useless because people are going to be tracked anyway.
 
DNT is useless anyway, its optional so website that really wants your info will get it and keep it.
 
DNT is Dead, and it's better off to get other tracking blocking add ons. Hadly any websites, especially the big ones follow DNT.

In fact, Google Chrome Beta has already removed it
 
It's like robots.txt, an honor system.

Advertisers aren't going to give a flying fuck about it.
 
I always wondered like in the dialup days when clicks were spamed to convey you were online, or scripts for online mahjong games, could someone write a url spammer to every once and awhile clutter these guys with 'cover' of what you really are looking at? The classic lingerie cataloge trick at the checkout with a gift items?
 
Like others said, no one honors it anyhow. There is only one feature that will get me to use Spartan, add-ons. No add-ons and no adblock and I'll keep treating it like the plague that is IE. (Obvious exaggeration).
 
Does it really do anything anyway? Isn't the "Do not track" initiative more of an honor system?

Yeah pretty much. "We acknowledge your desire to not be tracked, we just won't request your desire to not be tracked"
 
It's like robots.txt, an honor system.

Advertisers aren't going to give a flying fuck about it.

The only thing I believe uses robots.txt is Google and even they probably just mark their listing as "hidden" in their database and still index the site.

DNT as implemented is completely worthless because NO ONE AT ALL respects it and most of the people you don't want tracking you wouldn't even respect it if it was legally binding. A real DNT implementation would be similar to TOR, it would make it nearly impossible to actually track you.
 
Do they have a good reason to not make it default?

The only reason I can think of was that advertisers threatened to completely disregard the setting if it was enabled by default.

So, if you leave it disabled by default, and enabling it actually results in advertisers honoring it, vs it not being honored at all, that might be a small reason.

Personally I doubt it will have much of an impact at all.

For anything to be effective, we need a new infrastructure from the ground up that treats any tracking as malware, and secure designs intended to avoid it.
 
Back
Top