Microsoft Wants A Global Patent System

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft’s Corporate Vice President and Deputy General Counsel is pushing for a global patent system. What do you think? Is it good to have a global patent system with one application and a single governing body?

Over 3.5 million patent applications are pending around the world, including over 750,000 in the U.S. Pendency periods are extending to three, four or in some case five years before final patents are issued. The cost of this workload to patent applicants and patent offices is too high, and the delays in securing patents are too long for entrepreneurs and large enterprises alike.
 
I doubt this will fly. Hell, they (the nations) can hardly agree on who should have control on the internet elements.

I think it would be a great idea, but I just don't see it ending well and all the countries participating
 
Laws can be written, but enforcement is difficult. I had a similar situation with regards to a design I had for refrigeration.

In drafting an OEM agreement with overseas manufacturers, I could get my lawyer to draft anything, and the manufacturer would sign anything I wanted. But in the end my lawyer wared that it's up to the local governments to uphold the laws. Standardizing the practices and standards of government and/or courts (be it that they exist or not in the area in question) is extremely difficult.
 
If nations could all agree on things, we wouldn't have global conflicts. Microsoft can "want" a global patent system all they want but it won't happen... Differences in international law alone would prevent how it gets handled nation to nation.
 
I guess lawyers wont' be too happy if we have this kind of system. When I was applying for patent in EU, Korea and U.S., I had to pay them boat load...
 
The end is neigh....The day of Judgment is coming. Repent Now and be Saved from the Fires of HELL!!! aaaaaggghhhh
 
I would be good, but then they would have to hire a patent enforcement court, etc..etc .
.02 It just won't happen.
 
sure lets charge poor countries 100$ for prescriptions hahaahaaa never will happen sorry. last thing we need is pirated medicine and other shit.
 
good things: patents help reduce fraud/fake products
bad things: raises prices, decreases innovations.

half the products we buy from other countries are at one time a patent violation. do you want bill gates saying he invented toys and patent the shit just like when he invented "Sticky notes" and patented those 20 years after their invention?

sorry but half the patent crap is not even new, its just some rich guy trumping a not so rich guy.

most countries respect international patents or use them for leverage... such as...
stop pirating windows, we'll lower the windows costs... etc.
 
Just think, if that poor dude in Japan that actually invented the Segway had patented it globally - instead of just in Japan - we would have never heard of Dean Kamen.
 
if the patent database is in one area and gets hacked by the chinese... then they have access to everyone else's howto's and patents.

its putting all the eggs in one basket. if the chiense want to buy a shitty mach polooo shirt, then let them.
 
if the patent database is in one area and gets hacked by the chinese... then they have access to everyone else's howto's and patents.

its putting all the eggs in one basket. if the chiense want to buy a shitty mach polooo shirt, then let them.

You arent quite up to speed on the whole patent system idea are you? The idea is that you patent the idea, and the elements of the design become transparent, others can inspect and improve upon the design, however you get x number of years of control and protection on the idea. It isnt a black hole where all these patents get locked away and their secrets shrouded as "trade secrets"
 
Bill gates probably has a patent on the world patent system, then he will sue the world and take over!
 
It would suck if the extreme software patents found in the US, that are pretty much only used for patent trolling, would find it's way elsewhere.
 
I think patents approvals should be limited to working prototypes. It’s not right that someone can think up an idea and patent it without a single working prototype or technology of how to make it work. Then, 5 years later, a company invests tons of money into development and suddenly they are infringing on a patent based off an idea.
 
k... end of discussions...


stop it asshole, you don't own the world.....


nuff said
 
You need either a worldwide system, or no system at all. There is no logic to the idea that if someone is a different country copies your idea, they aren't ripping you off. Ideas don't recognise the arbitrary geographical boundaries the current system is based on.
 
/trollfail

Not really a troll... They've been throwing the term "New World Order" around quite a bit... Not just Obama/US, but the Queen/Britain is involved with it too...

All I know is there's some high power folks in high power meetings behind closed doors, and they all use this "New World Order" term. I'm not one for conspiracies but when that stuff happens it really makes me question what's going on.
 
Not really a troll... They've been throwing the term "New World Order" around quite a bit... Not just Obama/US, but the Queen/Britain is involved with it too...

All I know is there's some high power folks in high power meetings behind closed doors, and they all use this "New World Order" term. I'm not one for conspiracies but when that stuff happens it really makes me question what's going on.

I see. It's more of a 'perception fail'.
 
Not really a troll... They've been throwing the term "New World Order" around quite a bit... Not just Obama/US, but the Queen/Britain is involved with it too...

All I know is there's some high power folks in high power meetings behind closed doors, and they all use this "New World Order" term. I'm not one for conspiracies but when that stuff happens it really makes me question what's going on.

I think you're little late to the party, 'Shrub The First' was making these statements wayyy back in the day.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rc7i0wCFf8g
 
One world wide patent system done in a way that makes sense is not gonna happen.
Who would run it, the UN?.. Don't make me laugh or rather don't make me cry, those guys are beyond useless theses days.

The EU? Another bad idea, unless you like the thought of pretty much any American, Japanese, Chinese, or non EU companies patent being overturned for the benefit of some company based in the EU.

The US or Canada? Yeah, that's just what we need, a guy in a tent in the middle of the Sahara patenting "a system that recognizes gestures" in as vague of terms as possible, does nothing with the rather obvious idea, and then sues every one and their cousin 5 years later that built anything that vaguely can be construed to recognizes gestures.

We are stuck with the current system, and need to work on cleaning it up, reforming it into something sensible, and then making more binding treaties with our trade partners to uphold each others patents than we currently have. In the US, the system itself is salvageable, the problem is the patent application and approval processes with the trivial BS they allow to be patented, as well as the sue if you want with no repercussions if your patent is BS enforcement through the court system.
 
We are stuck with the current system, and need to work on cleaning it up, reforming it into something sensible, and then making more binding treaties with our trade partners to uphold each others patents than we currently have. In the US, the system itself is salvageable, the problem is the patent application and approval processes with the trivial BS they allow to be patented, as well as the sue if you want with no repercussions if your patent is BS enforcement through the court system.

The patent system might be salvageable, but the patent application system is beyond hope imo. Someone's gotta rethink that from the ground up, and be given the tools to actually make it happen.
 
I take it that nobody here has heard of the WPO... World Patent Organization?

http://www.wipo.int/portal/index.html.en

Epic Fail BTW. There is a very good reason why an international patent system doesnt exist, and believe it or not, this IS ACTUALLY A GOOD THING. If Microsoft could enforce patents worldwide... well... think about how easy it would be for them to hinder innovation.
 
Can we single monetary system first? That way it will be easier to calculate losses in court cases of patent infrigment across the globe.
 
I take it that nobody here has heard of the WPO... World Patent Organization?

http://www.wipo.int/portal/index.html.en

Epic Fail BTW. There is a very good reason why an international patent system doesnt exist, and believe it or not, this IS ACTUALLY A GOOD THING. If Microsoft could enforce patents worldwide... well... think about how easy it would be for them to hinder innovation.

+10, right on.
 
As a patent holder I do wish there was some kind of globally recognized patent law seeing as both of mine are being infringed on by Chinese companies and all attempts to communicate with these people has been ignored.
 
As a patent holder I do wish there was some kind of globally recognized patent law seeing as both of mine are being infringed on by Chinese companies and all attempts to communicate with these people has been ignored.

In some respects global patenting wouldn't help you, because your problem is Knockoffs . Countries around the world would have to enforce the laws they already have in place, better.
 
Another problem with worldwide patents is that each country has its own system of enforcement and qualification, not to mention, each country with a patent system has its own unique history of patents. I have good experience with international patents, both utility and design. For instance, the US system actually allows you to patent a business management method, like Six-Sigma. Nobody else allows this. Also, lets say you want to patent something worldwide... okay, that assumes that you are the first worldwide inventor. The reality is that someone in India may have the same idea, similar idea, or part of your idea... but years ago. So does that mean you cant get the patent at all, or just not in India? One patent I saw involved a utility patent from Germany that I thought was bogus, but the German office rubber stamped the idea, and sent it to the US. The US decided that the technology they wanted to patent was not new, and rejected it twice... and upon final revision, the initial patent details were lost all together, and the parts that were seen to be unique in fact would allow the company to sue 90% of the competition for falling under the patent for decades, yet assuming it was 'common', nobody ever looked to patent it. Its tricky how a patent in one country is different from another.

If you want to avoid knock-offs, just get a patent in the countries that are importing the goods from China (or wherever). Then you can send letters to those who import and sell the copy. Otherwise, the only answer is that China needs to adopt a patent system (yeah right), or we need to block certain or all imports from China that are illegal. We do this already... they make Toyota knock-offs that are 1/5 the price for instance, but we dont let them import to here. The internet is tricky though, since there are no physical bounds between nations on the internet... unless the service providers step up and block illegal content somehow. Software by definition is almost impossible to protect 100% anyways... just like music... its all 1's and 0's... nothing physical. It wouldnt shock me if in the coming decades, software takes the route music does. If you cut an album on CD, its just publicity and some capital so tour promoters will back a concert tour... and thats where you make your money anyways. So if you can get the promoters and tour bookings anyways by having a good touring record, making albums is almost worthless, and more artists are simply releasing their music for free on the internet, realizing that it means more people can listen to their music anyways, and want to come to the concert which is what really matters anyways. With software, if things are made 'open source', more individuals will make their own applications and custom features... as they already do with Linux and varous game mods. Rather than charge for the actual copy of the game then, they can charge for the server time, like MMO's. Then, who cares if your software is pirated, if it has to connect to a server to play... But for OS's and basic apps... this wont work. This could spell the end of innovation for these things as we know it... then again... what REALLY has changed since Windows came out? Isnt it really just the same with some new features here & there? Otherwise, would it be okay if your OS could 'call in' once a week or so to check for updates and new material, or deactivate? Would it be better if windows itself was free, but then you paid $5-20 per month to use it (cheaper versions would have just 'home' updates, more 'premium' or 'business' updates would have more content uploaded which aids business clients). Should OS's be run like MMO's? Not a bad model... but then MS needs to keep coming up with new material updates to justify it.
 
As a patent holder I do wish there was some kind of globally recognized patent law seeing as both of mine are being infringed on by Chinese companies and all attempts to communicate with these people has been ignored.

Even if they had a patent system, there's a few things:
1) Their legal system (which is not like ours here in the US, you don't have the brances and checks and balances) would have to fine them or something. When the government is as corrupted as one like China, they'd readily accept a bribe then look the other way.
2) Their justice system, along with the first point, would have to actually impose something more than "You're guilty, let's move on".
 
Just throwing this out there, but...

I could see this as something Obama would try pushing from the US Government in order to help set in motion his "New World Order".

/*ducks and runs for cover*

You are no longer allowed to post in this subforum.
 
I don't think it's a good idea. Not only would there be obvious abuses of power with larger countries against the smaller ones (hello UN), but it forces a set of values on countries and people who might not believe in them.
 
Just think, if that poor dude in Japan that actually invented the Segway had patented it globally - instead of just in Japan - we would have never heard of Dean Kamen.

Hey, be careful what you say about Dean Kamen. I'll venture to say that man is indirectly responsible for more patents, inventions, solutions, and engineering triumphs than any other living person.
 
I doubt this will fly. Hell, they (the nations) can hardly agree on who should have control on the internet elements.

I think it would be a great idea, but I just don't see it ending well and all the countries participating

Exactly. Good luck getting Russia and China to play along.
 
Back
Top