Microsoft Trying To Block Vendors From Using Android?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
DigiTimes, again citing anonymous industry sources, claims Microsoft is charging royalty fees to prevent Acer and Asustek from using Android in netbook and tablet PCs.

Microsoft plans to impose royalty fees on Taiwan-based vendors of Android handsets for using its patents in e-mail, multimedia and other functions, with Acer and Asustek Computer being targets in an actual attempt to prevent the two vendors from adopting Android and Chrome OS for their netbook and tablet PCs, according to Taiwan-based makers.
 
I don't know if I see it as Microsoft blocking them from shipping the alternate netbook options. It's their patent and if Acer and ASUSTek wants to put another operating system on their netbook, Microsoft have every right to collect at least something for their patent. That's what royalties are.

Blocking would be something like Microsoft saying "if you (Acer and ASUSTek) offer Android or Chrome OS on your netbooks, we'll stop letting you use Windows on many of your hot items", similar to how Intel strong-armed HP and Dell into not using AMD products a few years back.
 
As Android is an open platform, vendors of Android handsets have to pay royalty fees of at least US$10-15 per handset for licensed use of the patents concerned, the sources explained. Since Taiwan-based vendors have not been in strict compliance with the requirement for royalty fees, adoption of Android incurs considerably lower cost to them than using Windows Mobile, the sources indicated.
How does this make sense? They want Asus and Acer to pay royalties for handsets to prevent them from using Android on netbooks and tablet PCs?
 
How does this make sense? They want Asus and Acer to pay royalties for handsets to prevent them from using Android on netbooks and tablet PCs?

Umm, if you read the whole article you can deduce the chain of events. The companies are planning on releasing netbooks that they are considering Android for. Currently they are in violation of not paying royalties for handsets they made with Android. Once they realize how much it cost in royalties to use those applications on the handsets, they may think twice about using Android on the netbooks as well.

But really, this is non news and is not so much blocking as asking for what is yours according to patent regulations. Sure it may influence the companies decision in what OS they use for the netbooks, but it is in no way a "block". Nor is it in any way some "evil dirty tactic", it is just normal business.
 
$10 - $15 per handset is insanely huge in terms of added manufacturing cost - it might not seem like much from the consumer perspective, but when that cost has to be multiplied several times through the distribution chain, it is enormous.

Somebody should have patented LOL and OMG so that teens texting those have to pay a fee each time :p
 
Umm, if you read the whole article you can deduce the chain of events. The companies are planning on releasing netbooks that they are considering Android for. Currently they are in violation of not paying royalties for handsets they made with Android. Once they realize how much it cost in royalties to use those applications on the handsets, they may think twice about using Android on the netbooks as well.

But really, this is non news and is not so much blocking as asking for what is yours according to patent regulations. Sure it may influence the companies decision in what OS they use for the netbooks, but it is in no way a "block". Nor is it in any way some "evil dirty tactic", it is just normal business.

But the article doesn't say which patents. It just says "multimedia and email" the only patent that i can think of is active sync....but multimedia could be anything.
 
What about that OS that comes with ASUS motherboards. Something gate. It has mail and media playing abilities. Do they get royalties for that? Express gate! thats it!
 
Articles this vague are irresponsible.

You mean you wanted some proof in black and white saying that if they dont comply with MS demands on keeping their netbook devices windows only they would get blacklisted ?

Maybe because that is not allowed under American law ?
 
You mean you wanted some proof in black and white saying that if they dont comply with MS demands on keeping their netbook devices windows only they would get blacklisted ?

Maybe because that is not allowed under American law ?

You've missed the point.
 
A year too late, as usual..... I could have informed Microsoft about Android's potential a year ago -- or any other techy person.

Microsoft would rather overpay a bunch of old clueless geezers like they have been the past 10 years.... and that's why they continue to fail at almost every marketing attempt.
 
Microsoft would rather overpay a bunch of old clueless geezers like they have been the past 10 years.... and that's why they continue to fail at almost every marketing attempt.

You mean their developers? Android is very nice. Windows Phone just got pretty nice too, maybe the old geezers aren't totally useless!;)
 
Back
Top