Microsoft More Secure Than Apple, Adobe

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Do we really need a former hacker to tell us that Microsoft is more secure than Apple and Adobe? I mean, isn’t it obvious by now? Thanks to Marcus F. for the link.

Apple has only taken security seriously in the last six months, with the Mac maker now playing catch-up. "It's even a little scarier with them because they try to market themselves as more secure than the PC, that you don't have to worry about viruses, etc. Anytime there's been a hacking contest, within a few hours someone's found a new Apple vulnerability."
 
This old news, but people still just don't know and its scary. Oh yea and Adobe has never even been thought of safe no surprise there :p
 
Security through obscurity. I don't think so. I'm happy to see more Macs out there. Just means that they too will be a target and then they will shut their pie hole about how secure they are.
 
When Windows and Office were the butt of all the security jokes a decade ago Microsoft was FORCED to step up. Their competitors instead of trying to learn simply tried to cash in thinking they were immune to the laws of computer science.
 
Windows has been secure as Fort Knox since Vista/7. Almost all of the security problems you see these days are from people browsing porn websites on Windows XP SP2 and IE6. I haven't had a Windows machine "just get infected" ala the old 98/ME/XP days in at least 5 years.
 
Windows has been secure as Fort Knox since Vista/7. Almost all of the security problems you see these days are from people browsing porn websites on Windows XP SP2 and IE6. I haven't had a Windows machine "just get infected" ala the old 98/ME/XP days in at least 5 years.

++ to that.

Haven't had any malware since XP SP1 back whenever that was current. Since XP SP2 I haven't had a single infection. My friends and family are the same, no infections since moving them to Vista and Win 7, and god does that make me a happy IT guy.
 
I was trying to find an article that I vaguely remember reading in early 2002 when Bill Gates did the then infamous Windows shutdown and security review and then made security priority #1. This person at the time said that he thought this is the right first step and that in about 10 years Microsoft would reap reward if they stayed the course and it seems to have been a rather prophetic article.

Makes those "I'm a Mac" ads look even more stupid.
 
the only thing i like about mac's are the battery life honestly...but couldn't see myself paying 1000 for a laptop worth 600 bucks, also love windows 7..haven't got one virus since xp sp2
 
Windows has been secure as Fort Knox since Vista/7. Almost all of the security problems you see these days are from people browsing porn websites on Windows XP SP2 and IE6. I haven't had a Windows machine "just get infected" ala the old 98/ME/XP days in at least 5 years.
I use Windows XP Pro SP3...

I don't have any anti-virus installed (haven't for a number of years)...

I haven't gotten any virii...

What are you talking about?
 
not having AV is just silly, i don't care how safe you think you are, wait until a site you trust gets exploited and next thing you know you are a zombie for some spam bot, but since you got no AV, how you would you know anyways.

i don't think people should be bragging about not running AV this day in age.
 
not having AV is just silly, i don't care how safe you think you are, wait until a site you trust gets exploited and next thing you know you are a zombie for some spam bot, but since you got no AV, how you would you know anyways.

i don't think people should be bragging about not running AV this day in age.

well said
 
I use Windows XP Pro SP3...

I don't have any anti-virus installed (haven't for a number of years)...

I haven't gotten any virii...

What are you talking about?

Wow, really? No I mean that you would post this..

Nobody said EVERY single XP install was infected, so please give us a break about you run XP and don't have any infection. It's just much more likely that an XP box will be infected than a Windows Vista/7 box, that's a fact, best not to be a jerk about it and just accept it.
 
I use Windows XP Pro SP3...

I don't have any anti-virus installed (haven't for a number of years)...

I haven't gotten any virii...

What are you talking about?

I don't have any cameras or an alarm, and I leave the door wide open all day long, but I know that nobody ever comes in, much less steals anything. :rolleyes:
 
Playing devils advocate, while OS X isn't more secure, Apple users are probably safer (for now), because there aren't that many of them, so malware groups get more bang for the buck by attacking XP (and to a lesser extent, Vista/7). However, as XP goes away, the difficulty of attacking Windows goes up and the Apple user base increases, they will become less safe. They already are less safe than they were 5 years ago.
 
I check every 6 months just to be sure. I use online scanners such as Eset's @ http://www.eset.com/onlinescan and TrendMicro's Housecall at http://housecall.trendmicro.com/. I also run ComboFix (and check the logs to see if it caught anything), Spybot S&D, CCleaner, SpywareBlaster, and MalwareBytes scanner. ;)

I get nothing. Now if you say that even that isn't enough, I don't know how you can say an AV program (installed) would do any better. I can't say that I've always been invincible, but over the years I have gotten to where I don't really browse the internet much and use stuff like NoScript, Flashblock, and Adblock with Firefox, as well as a router (should be common thing for most people).

I mentioned this in some other thread...without saying the part about running AV...and responders came up with logical reasons as to possibly why (which I think are quite accurate and precise to my situation).

However, I don't recommend other people to follow my example. ;) It's not good practice to advocate my kind of living.
 
Playing devils advocate, while OS X isn't more secure, Apple users are probably safer (for now), because there aren't that many of them, so malware groups get more bang for the buck by attacking XP (and to a lesser extent, Vista/7). However, as XP goes away, the difficulty of attacking Windows goes up and the Apple user base increases, they will become less safe. They already are less safe than they were 5 years ago.

There are plenty of Mac users, just not as many physical machines in use.
 
i don't think people should be bragging about not running AV this day in age.
Let alone bragging. I gave into the temptation here, and I admit, I shouldn't have. :( I myself don't look very much on bragging and avoid doing it. I really need to stop with this "I've gone years [specifically 2 to 3] without getting infected and have no AV" pride thing (pride's bad!).
 
it use to be nice to be able to brag, but as said, so many everyday sites, any think is safe, get exploited and code injected that users then get, then you got ad banners on sites that could feed in code and so on, there are so many indirect ways "safe browsers" could get infected these days.
 
Still no in the wild osx viruses as far as I know. Trojans, yes there are a couple, but no spreading self propagating viruses.

The other thing about the pwn2own security contest, is they have all year to find their exploit, so if it's hacked "in a couple hours" that tells you nothing. So you got sniped 5 seconds after you crested the hill. Doesn't say anything about how long the sniper was preparing.

Osx isn't perfect, but average users don't seem to have the malware/virus problem with osx like they do on windows. The fact that the securing osx guides by the NSA if I remember right, don't say anything about adding antivirus crap to osx. That says something right there.

Two years from now, there may be 100 osx viruses, but I highly doubt it and I'm guessing the number of in the wild viruses will still be basically 0. The bigger security issue that osx has in my opinion, is that a lot of users have macdrive installed on their bootcamp windows partition. What's to stop a virus or malware in windows from blowing away the mac side or bypassing it's secuity altogether, then running on the mac side undetected. I know quite a few people with real ip adresses on their macs and no antivirus software, don't know of any that have gotten pwnt yet though. When random mac users get pwnt for surfing the web or just leaving their computer on with a real world accessible IP, then I'll expect to hear some "I told you so's" until then though, I still think osx is the more secure choice for most users.
 
Still no in the wild osx viruses as far as I know. Trojans, yes there are a couple, but no spreading self propagating viruses.

The other thing about the pwn2own security contest, is they have all year to find their exploit, so if it's hacked "in a couple hours" that tells you nothing. So you got sniped 5 seconds after you crested the hill. Doesn't say anything about how long the sniper was preparing.

Osx isn't perfect, but average users don't seem to have the malware/virus problem with osx like they do on windows. The fact that the securing osx guides by the NSA if I remember right, don't say anything about adding antivirus crap to osx. That says something right there.

Two years from now, there may be 100 osx viruses, but I highly doubt it and I'm guessing the number of in the wild viruses will still be basically 0. The bigger security issue that osx has in my opinion, is that a lot of users have macdrive installed on their bootcamp windows partition. What's to stop a virus or malware in windows from blowing away the mac side or bypassing it's secuity altogether, then running on the mac side undetected. I know quite a few people with real ip adresses on their macs and no antivirus software, don't know of any that have gotten pwnt yet though. When random mac users get pwnt for surfing the web or just leaving their computer on with a real world accessible IP, then I'll expect to hear some "I told you so's" until then though, I still think osx is the more secure choice for most users.


I guess few bothering to attack OS X does add to its security. However if OS X reaches the point where malware authors care, there's nothing that you mentioned that would help. Malware authors have ALL the time in the world, even more than the pwn2own contestants.
 
Right. On the other hand, virus code for windows is passed around quite a bit and there are a lot of malware authors targetting windows, many of them may not ha e a mac to code on or test with, that will also slow down many of them. I do agree that when many virus and malware authors DO target osx that it is likely that they will succeed, the real question is if it will require admin privs and if it will require you to type in your admin password for you to get infected. If they suceed with a self spreading, no admin password required, real virus, then the rules will have changed considerably and maybe it will be time for some serious AV on osx. Until then, the default security is and will likely remain decent for most users. You also don't see many linux viruses or bsd viruses either, despite the fact that many of those machines would be great targets since many are on high bandwidth pipes and have real world IPs, without NAT in the way.
Tons of Linux and bsd boxes are also being used with no real admins or maintainers as well, since they don't have huge security problems, many are just deployed and then basically forgotten about.
 
I basically agree with your assement. The biggest security protection that OS X has right now is Windows 7. When in only 6 months 7's deployment eclipsed the deployments of other non-Windows OSes combined, I don't think that malware authors are going to be giving OS X much attention for a while yet.

Irony at its finest.
 
I don't have any cameras or an alarm, and I leave the door wide open all day long, but I know that nobody ever comes in, much less steals anything. :rolleyes:

Or rubs their genitals on everything in your fridge....
 
i don't think people should be bragging about not running AV this day in age.
Every computer that comes across my desk loaded with viruses has antivirus software on it. I haven't run any antivirus in 6 years and I'm fine. I'll brag all I want...it's a perk for having smart browsing habits.
 
Caught my first virus in years last week. My personal laptop somehow caught one of the Antivirus 2010 clones somehow. Fortunately it couldn't really do shit. All it got to was the .exe assoc. Managed to boot it manually, still scanned for good measure though.

Still trying to figure out how it got in though, must've been a bad advert. I was running Maxthon on the laptop and neglected to update. I run MSE on my personal equipment btw.
 
This is irrelevant, but is Microsoft.com down for anyone too? I get a "Server not found" from Firefox. :eek:
 
I check every 6 months just to be sure. I use online scanners such as Eset's @ http://www.eset.com/onlinescan and TrendMicro's Housecall at http://housecall.trendmicro.com/. I also run ComboFix (and check the logs to see if it caught anything), Spybot S&D, CCleaner, SpywareBlaster, and MalwareBytes scanner. ;)

I get nothing. Now if you say that even that isn't enough, I don't know how you can say an AV program (installed) would do any better. I can't say that I've always been invincible, but over the years I have gotten to where I don't really browse the internet much and use stuff like NoScript, Flashblock, and Adblock with Firefox, as well as a router (should be common thing for most people).

I mentioned this in some other thread...without saying the part about running AV...and responders came up with logical reasons as to possibly why (which I think are quite accurate and precise to my situation).

However, I don't recommend other people to follow my example. ;) It's not good practice to advocate my kind of living.

Glad to hear it, but consider the possibilities of what could be done in the time period of six months to you with your stolen information. Worst case scenario is you get infected with a key logger that actually works and your bank login, or even worse, your email login is compromised. With your email login, they can get at anything they want by simply doing password changes.
 
Still no in the wild osx viruses as far as I know. Trojans, yes there are a couple, but no spreading self propagating viruses.

The other thing about the pwn2own security contest, is they have all year to find their exploit, so if it's hacked "in a couple hours" that tells you nothing. So you got sniped 5 seconds after you crested the hill. Doesn't say anything about how long the sniper was preparing.

Osx isn't perfect, but average users don't seem to have the malware/virus problem with osx like they do on windows. The fact that the securing osx guides by the NSA if I remember right, don't say anything about adding antivirus crap to osx. That says something right there.

Two years from now, there may be 100 osx viruses, but I highly doubt it and I'm guessing the number of in the wild viruses will still be basically 0. The bigger security issue that osx has in my opinion, is that a lot of users have macdrive installed on their bootcamp windows partition. What's to stop a virus or malware in windows from blowing away the mac side or bypassing it's secuity altogether, then running on the mac side undetected. I know quite a few people with real ip adresses on their macs and no antivirus software, don't know of any that have gotten pwnt yet though. When random mac users get pwnt for surfing the web or just leaving their computer on with a real world accessible IP, then I'll expect to hear some "I told you so's" until then though, I still think osx is the more secure choice for most users.

WIth respect (or not) you clearly haven't looked very hard.
The first OS X Botnet was discovered and active over a year ago. .

So you've been told. OS X is not more secure. It just lacks enough users to justify putting the resources into developing attacks. That's also why most researchers don't spend much time on it (aside form low hanging fruit)....there's not enough money in it.

However, you (as opposed to the OS) are safer because of the lack of interest. Unfortunately, as Windows becomes harder to exploit, OS X may become more tempting, especially since like yourself, most Mac users mistakenly believe their OS is inherently safer than the Windows platform. It's not. And almost every security researcher has said as much.
 
Right. On the other hand, virus code for windows is passed around quite a bit and there are a lot of malware authors targetting windows, many of them may not ha e a mac to code on or test with, that will also slow down many of them. I do agree that when many virus and malware authors DO target osx that it is likely that they will succeed, the real question is if it will require admin privs and if it will require you to type in your admin password for you to get infected. If they suceed with a self spreading, no admin password required, real virus, then the rules will have changed considerably and maybe it will be time for some serious AV on osx. Until then, the default security is and will likely remain decent for most users. You also don't see many linux viruses or bsd viruses either, despite the fact that many of those machines would be great targets since many are on high bandwidth pipes and have real world IPs, without NAT in the way.
Tons of Linux and bsd boxes are also being used with no real admins or maintainers as well, since they don't have huge security problems, many are just deployed and then basically forgotten about.

Take back the bit about your mistaken beliefs. We seem to agree that it's safety is only due to lack of numbers.

Nevertheless, there was (and probably still is) an active OS X botnet.
 
Every computer that comes across my desk loaded with viruses has antivirus software on it. I haven't run any antivirus in 6 years and I'm fine. I'll brag all I want...it's a perk for having smart browsing habits.

Was the subscription active? Had it been active and running since the OS was installed, with no lapses?

once you have a virus, it's generally too late. With that said, i agree that safe browsing habits are still necessary
 
Every computer that comes across my desk loaded with viruses has antivirus software on it. I haven't run any antivirus in 6 years and I'm fine. I'll brag all I want...it's a perk for having smart browsing habits.

No antivirus? Large and reputable websites have been found to have malware in their ads and they didn't even know it. Bad things are everywhere and you can't avoid running into it anymore, no matter how you surf or how smart you are.

You need to read this one:

http://news.cnet.com/8301-27080_3-20000898-245.html

"Viruses and other malware were found to be lurking in ads last year on high-profile sites like The New York Times and conservative news aggregator Drudge Report.com, and this year on Drudge, TechCrunch and WhitePages.com. The practice has been dubbed "malvertising."
Now, researchers at Avast are pointing fingers at some large ad delivery platforms including Yahoo's Yield Manager and Fox Audience Network's Fimserve.com, which together cover more than 50 percent of online ads, and to a much smaller degree Google's DoubleClick. In addition, some of the malicious ads ended up on Yahoo and Google sites, Avast claims.
"It's not just the small players but the ad servers connected with Google and Yahoo have been infected and served up bad ads," said Lyle Frink, public relations manager for Avast."

Users don't need to click on anything to get infected; a computer becomes infected after the ad is loaded by the browser, Avast said."

---------
Note I get that having an antivirus won't protect you 100%, but if you have no protection I know you will run into something bad sooner or later.
 
Glad to hear it, but consider the possibilities of what could be done in the time period of six months to you with your stolen information. Worst case scenario is you get infected with a key logger that actually works and your bank login, or even worse, your email login is compromised. With your email login, they can get at anything they want by simply doing password changes.
That's inconsistent logic. Whatever material gets on the computer -- what are the chances of it knowing that I'm not going to install any antivirus or if I have any antivirus?

Large and reputable websites have been found to have malware in their ads and they didn't even know it.
OpenDNS + Firefox + Adblock + Flashblock + NoScript + a router behind your modem = win.

Users don't need to click on anything to get infected; a computer becomes infected after the ad is loaded by the browser, Avast said."
This is according to Kyle himself in a private message reply to me: "EVERY instance of Avast pointing out an in issue with HardOCP has been a false positive. Avast is POS when it comes to solid detection."
 
Glad to hear it, but consider the possibilities of what could be done in the time period of six months to you with your stolen information. Worst case scenario is you get infected with a key logger that actually works and your bank login, or even worse, your email login is compromised. With your email login, they can get at anything they want by simply doing password changes.
Let's put this in hypothetical terms:
Today is 1/1/2010. I have run my cleanup routine and am clean. I do not have an antivirus program installed.

The next cleanup routine will be performed on 6/1/2010. Between 1/1/2010 and 6/1/2010, in who's right mind would a virus or piece of malware set itself up on my computer and then delete itself? Let's assume we created that virus: how long are we going to have this virus keep itself alive before terminating itself from the computer entirely?

How do you know how often I, Random Joe User, use a credit card and enter in sensitive information? You're trying to catch me when I do, but how do you know when I do enter in "sensitive" information?

I don't see how a virus could profit anyone in any way if it isn't designed adequately. Please help me understand the logic here.

Users don't need to click on anything to get infected; a computer becomes infected after the ad is loaded by the browser, Avast said."
There are only a few ways content from a webpage could potentially endanger you:
1) Flash
2) Java
3) JavaScript
4) GIFs (I don't know if this applies any more)

Browser vulnerabilities can only be triggered by client-side languages or elements. Java is useless for the most part; this is something you can disable without being affected. If you use Adblock and Flashblock, I guarantee that Flash won't be a problem either. At this point, only Javascript remains, which could be used to execute browser vulnerabilities -- use NoScript.

This eliminates everything I can think of that could possibly be used to infiltrate someone's experience or machine. You CAN'T get infected by plain HTML webpages, even if iframes were used (because you would already have 1, 2, and 3 locked down, so pages iframes would load that contain such would still not be able to carry out their purpose).



As far as e-mail clients like Outlook go, at the very least you could employ an antivirus program JUST for scanning e-mails. That way the e-mails you receive are at least scanned before you open them. Buuuuuut... why would you open an e-mail message containing an attachment from someone you don't know or doesn't validate through your security settings? Etcetera.



The problem with antivirus these days is not because of their resource usage. This is a problem of the past. (1) If you use a mechanical HDD, there will be a noticeable performance decrease in the responsiveness of the system, and (2) the concept of antivirus versus virus is a game of leap frog. There will always be someone smarter.

At the speeds and responsiveness that SSDs perform at, how can you think that as big and complex antivirus software are, that a small and simple virus can't "outrun" an antivirus software? Have you ever actually dealt with a virus that was designed as such? I have (I forgot its name though).

It's a whole lot easier to cause damage and mischief than it is to prevent it. As things get faster and more powerful, the current technologies and methods for antivirus become drastically more and more outdated and obsolete. There is no perfect solution; as said, it's a game of leap frog. There will always be someone smarter.
 
4) GIFs (I don't know if this applies any more)
I would think that this no longer applies, otherwise I would be curious as to why nobody has really taken advantage of this method. We'd all be screwed (unless we blocked *.gif, but that wouldn't be practical). Does anyone know about this? =?
 
Back
Top