Microsoft: Bringing Games To PC Won't Kill Xbox

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Xbox obviously isn’t going anywhere since many still insist consoles are the easier or more comfortable gaming solution, but Play Anywhere has, in fact, killed the concept of owning a Microsoft system for me. This guy makes a decent argument in regards to co-existence, but it’s meaningless to me since I don’t see a point in not restricting your gaming to your single, ideal platform.

"Today, if you play games, you're playing games on just about everything you own," he added. "You're playing games on your phone, you're playing games on your console when you want to lay back in front of that big TV, and you're playing PC games when you want that keyboard and mouse, up-close, highly customized kind of experience. Even guys that are diehard console gamers, we know they play on their phone and PC." Similarly, there are hardcore PC gamers out there who also play on console and mobile. "So to me, the idea that you're bringing games to the PC suddenly means that people don't want consoles anymore...it doesn't ring true to how gamers really behave," Penello added.
 
Yeah. I play games on the PC and on the PC only.

I haven't owned a console since my NES back in the 80's and once I got my first PC in 1991 I barely ever touched it again.

I don't have or want games on my phone, I don't have or want a console. I don't even want any PC games on my TV like Ms and Valve seem to be trying to push. I don't understand the appeal at all of playing games in the livingroom.

I want games in one place and one place only, and that's on my PC at my desk.

That being said, I don't understand why Microsoft's "Play Anywhere" would upset anyone. What's the problem with having more choice? And if console exclusives go away, that's a GOOD thing isn't it? Since when has being restricted to a given platform ever been a good thing for users? For companies maybe, but for users, no.
 
Well it's nice to see Microsoft finally start behaving in a way that doesn't give them a conflict of interest towards PC gaming and keeping games OFF the PC. Only took them 15 years!
 
This is what they should have done from the start, but hey, better late than never.
 
This Play anywhere idea is what could win console war vs playstation. Since you buy game once and you get it for xbox and PC makes big selling point.
 
Microsoft bringing games to PC just means one more company to boycott for me. Yea, I haven't forgotten how they screwed us over with GFWL, DRM disguised as a service. They tied my GFWL games to my email address, an address I no longer use.
 
Microsoft bringing games to PC just means one more company to boycott for me. Yea, I haven't forgotten how they screwed us over with GFWL, DRM disguised as a service. They tied my GFWL games to my email address, an address I no longer use.

That's good and you do not have to do so. The only thing I wish is that it had been done sooner so I could have Quantum Break and Gear of War: Ultimate Edition on my XBox One.
 
I just wish they would take back MechWarrior online, fix it and make it good again. The only other game I can think of with slower development is Americas Army.
 
Yeah, that's what they say but if Xbox sales slump they'll be gone. If they bring everything out for PC, I don't care if they still make Xboxes. I'll never buy one, but if anyone else wants one they can just go ahead.
 
This Play anywhere idea is what could win console war vs playstation. Since you buy game once and you get it for xbox and PC makes big selling point.

Not when the PC version is UWP-wrappered (feature stripped and breaks third party tools and doesn't support mods) and walled-in by the Windows store.

And it'll mean jack for beating Playstation 4; that war is already lost.
 
That's pretty sad news but do they tell what will? We need to concentrate on that.
 
Of course it won't kill the Xbox. Microsoft is doing everything it can to kill the PC with Windows 10. They said 10 is the last version of Windows and they presumably mean it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DPI
like this
Microsoft have been sabotaging PC ports, just like Sony. Of course they are not worrying about their consoles.
 
Of course it won't kill the Xbox. Microsoft is doing everything it can to kill the PC with Windows 10. They said 10 is the last version of Windows and they presumably mean it.

Completely agree... PC gaming will be dead soon just like the automatic transmission killed cars... Oh wait cars are still around and most people have automatic transmissions, heck some are even better than manuals.

I believe a majority could care less of what you believe is "killing" the PC, outside of what we techies run around and feed everyone who doesn't know enough to make their own decision. Vista is a good example, right or wrong after sp1 it wasn't the horrible OS history would have you believe. A good portion of that is vendor fault just like a lot of the compatibility/upgrade issues lately.

I won't say Win10 is without issues. Over the top upgrade tactics, Privacy settings confusion, bumps in the single rollup updates (Webcams, intel bluetooth etc), and what I would consider half-baked features like Edge and UWP are all complaints that are justified. Half-backed as in imo are good but should have been refined before becoming pushed/default. I love the idea of virtualized/containered apps and lighter browsers... they just weren't/aren't quite ready yet.

Though these issues are NOT going to kill the PC market or OS. They are definitely the growing pains of taking the OS to where it probably has to go to stay relevant and that is more like the mobile/console area of walled gardens and app stores.

DPI said those apps are locked to the window store... he is only partially right. I believe the vendor has the option of locking it to the store otherwise appx/UWP apps can be sideloaded with a GPO tweak (similar to android).

I agree options should be available, clear, well organized. I have no objection to defaulted to on in most cases but ability to disable fairly easily needs to happen. These are small changes and not dealbreakers except for very specific niche cases (aka not going to kill the OS).

One thing I believe us techies/devs forget is that openness is just as dangerous as it is "Freedom". A lot of update issues I have seen lately has to do with vendors doing things they "Technically" could do but probably shouldn't have. MS closed the hole or fixed the behavior and THEY get the bad rap for breaking stuff. MS is usually more responsive and faster to fix their software to fit around vendors junk and yet here we are bashing them.
 
Last edited:
I have been saying this for past 3 years... MS will have one OS to rule them all strategy. Multi-platform ecosystem instead of being stuck in a console cycle.
Sony, will need to either partner with valve, so they can have a multi-distribution platform, or get back to the old days with an exotic console, that pushes the hardware envelope to bring an experience not found on PC's, however, that will only last a few months, then PC tech will leap forward. MS see's the writing on the wall, hardware tech is growing too fast, and having an ecosystem that can expand with mobile and pc hardware will win the day.
 
I would like to point out, I'm not playing Hungry Shark on my PC. I'm also not playing Fallout 4 on my phone. Even further, I'm not fiddling with settings on my phone, but I am optimizing them on my PC.

I honestly think the only thing Play Anywhere will do is make console gamers sometimes play on a PC. Most PC gamers aren't going to buy games through the Windows store, unless there is some exclusive they can't live without.
 
If only Microsoft had dumped all its XBox R&D time and money into further expanding PC gaming under Microsoft Studios, they could have kicked Nintendo and Sony square in the nuts by propelling the PC as the far superior platform...instead of setting things back a decade and left PC gamers with shitty console ports for the past 15 years.
 
Back
Top