mATX vs. ATX

NleahciM

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 2, 2002
Messages
3,517
Hey there - I am building a new computer in the next couple of weeks (just need to find enough time to choose parts). I'm trying to decide if it should be mATX or ATX. Do you lose much/any performance going from ATX to mATX? What advantages (generally speaking) do ATX boards have over mATX?

If it matters - my budget is maybe ~$1500 or so for the computer, not including external peripherals (mouse, keyboard, speakers, monitors, etc.). I already have the hard drives for it (2xHitachi 7K1000s). I am more than happy to spend less than this, naturally.

I want this computer for a number of things:

eCAD
SPICE (electronics simulation, the most CPU intensive thing that I do)
3D CAD
programming
movies/music
maybe occasional gaming - I haven't gamed in years though so that's at the bottom of my priority list

I plan on either getting 2x24" monitors or 1x30" monitor. Haven't decided yet.

The reason ATX is attractive to me is that I'd have more PCI slots - and there are alot of things I want/may want that need PCI (TV card, RAID card, serial card [http://www.lavalink.com/index.php?id=232], wifi card, etc.). The reason mATX is attractive to me is that I have a teeny little room in a shared teeny apartment in Boston and space is at a bit of a premium.

What do you all think?
 
The major advantage ATX has over mATX is PCI expansion. Performance and overclocking is actually about the same these days with Intel's P35 ATX and G33 mATX chipsets. Also, while mATX mobos do have 6 or more SATA ports, usually mATX cases can only hold two hard drives.

So it's up to you. Small footprint or expandability. Also, think if you actually need a TV card and wifi card?
 
RAID card in a microATX case?!? You can get the TV Tuner in USB.

I had a small microATX gaming box when I was in college... I'd bring it to work every night so I could get in a couple hours of gaming when I worked on campus, lol. It served its purpose well. As far as taking up less space in an apt room, a regular ATX case isn't much bigger. My point is, you're not really saving that much space with a mATX case.

To get you started, check out a couple of Danny's builds: http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031412217&postcount=11

For mATX, go with the Gigabyte GA-G33M-DS2R for the board.
 
Back
Top