Manage Pixels, not Monitors

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I have no idea how many of you guys will agree with this editorial but, as the owner of more than one multi-monitor system, I probably shouldn’t comment on this article. :D

My take: there’s an optimal number of pixels you need to complete the tasks you need to complete. Worry about that number, not the number of monitors you have. That optimal number, for the vast majority of people is about 2500x1400.
 
One thing I like about multi monitor is I can full size a window and it will go full screen the monitor it's on.
Can;t do that with a single huge monitor unless you are running Windows 7 and using the windows snapping feature.
 
One thing I like about multi monitor is I can full size a window and it will go full screen the monitor it's on.
Can;t do that with a single huge monitor unless you are running Windows 7 and using the windows snapping feature.

Or the handy dandy AeroSnap freeware for XP and Vista... :D
 
Well, I really wish at this point that the start bar/task bar could extend across two or more monitors. The other thing I really wish for is 30" LCD's to come down to a realistic price in the $500 to $700 range.
 
Multi-monitor + Ultramon on windows 7 is a dream. At work I run dual monitors, at home I run triple. My productivity is much better when I have more.
 
There's something to be said for efficient use of your space over just MORE MORE MORE. I do agree that having things open that you're not currently working on is definitely a distraction. At work I used to have my email open on my laptop monitor while having what I'm working on open on the 20" Dell. But, guess what, I found my eyes roaming to the Outlook every time a new email popped up which meant that I was constantly interrupting my workflow to keep on top of an email that probably wasn't important enough to interrupt me in the first place.

More space is great as long as the more space is helping you with the task you're working on. If the more space is just providing more room for items that are NOT your primary task then your productivity is probably suffering as a result whether you want to admit it or not.
 
Nothing beats developing on one monitor, SQL on another, and email and the other minor programs on another.
 
The article has some merit. But the reality is nobody can afford any single monitor with "2560x1440 or greater" Resolution.

The article writer's talking about using it on a mac. So maybe he's used to ultra-high priced stuff. Even corporate would buy two mid-line $500 monitors over one large $1500 monitor.
 
Well I'm a fan of managing both. :p

I've got 3 U2410's now and I'm pretty happy w/that. :)
 
I vote for mulit-monitor setup. I only run dual 22s right now, and would like to move on over to eyefinity, but 30s with display port are still pretty pricey.

More pixels is great, but you reach a point where everything is getting smaller, and there is still only so much actual screen to fill. Then you need to add a few more screen.
 
Multi-monitor + Ultramon on windows 7 is a dream. At work I run dual monitors, at home I run triple. My productivity is much better when I have more.

Yeah right productivity. you just have to justify what you got. :D:D
 
I don't have a gaming setup to run multiple monitors but at work I have a 24" as my main screen and a 22"(vertically oriented) for email and long spread sheets.

I like multiple monitors. :-D
 
Well you can't run 5760x1200 wrapped around your FOV on one monitor now can you? :p
 
I'm not a multi-monitor/high resolution monitor user myself. I have a single 24" at 1920x1200. I imagine if I ever want to go for more, I'd go for multi-monitor. It just seems more convenient on many levels. I'd rather have 1 monitor at the center of attention (gaming, movies, etc.) and everything else in the periphery. Separating a single monitor's real-estate into halves/quadrants/whatever means there's no central point of focus, and you'd still have to juggle windows around to make it happen. I'd rather be looking straight ahead at a full screen when gaming, rather than at the side or in a corner.

The article also talks about distractions at the very end. Well, if the "distracting" elements are on completely separate monitors, I'll probably be less inclined to turn my head to see what it's about than if it were in the corner of the same screen. Having multiple monitors can help me in situations where I don't need an app in my face at all time, but can periodically glance at without juggling windows around. I'd also rather turn my head left and right than up and down.
 
I could not do without at least dual monitors.

That said, at home I have 3 x 24" and at work I have 2 x 22" and 1 x 17". I need to remember to change my background at home. Double rainbow all the way!!!
 
More pixels is fine if your eyesight can handle it too. Resolution is a factor. You can get away with less resolution on two monitors.

We have a number of people at work needing 1024x768.
 
More than anything I think trying to say 1 universal setup will meet everyones needs is fail.
 
My productivity is much better when I have more.
This. At work I need one monitor for outlook and "second screen" items. Second screen items is like for things you are referencing while working. Like a photo or a pdf of a manual, whatever. Then you've got the main monitor and that needs to be huge. If I'm working with CAD systems, i'm going to lose a 200 row of pixels at the top for menus and ribbon bars and a 300-400 pixel column on the left for trees and such. Put me into an FEA program and those can double. On a 1680x1080 monitor I'll end up with twice the usable workspace of a 1280x1024 monitor, if you can go upto a 24 or a 30" screen it gets even larger. My productivity also increases as I can setup the FEA program to give me several views of the same part at the same time.

Besides, monitors are dirt cheap compared to the cost of even the lowest paid employees. Hell, even if you're looking at a no degree entry level mail department worker, they're still going to make 20K a year, a 300$ 24" monitor is 1.5% of 1 years salary. Look at an engineer and they start around 50K that's less than 1%.
 
Meed more of both.


InfoVegan........that name just really bothers me cause I don't really respect vegans all that much :p
 
Who would take tech advice from a site called InfoVegan?

I assume he's a vegan, and probably brain damaged from lack of essential amino acids and B12.

5760x1200 seems to be a good pixel size. Let me know when a single monitor comes in that resolution.
 
There's something to be said for efficient use of your space over just MORE MORE MORE. I do agree that having things open that you're not currently working on is definitely a distraction. At work I used to have my email open on my laptop monitor while having what I'm working on open on the 20" Dell. But, guess what, I found my eyes roaming to the Outlook every time a new email popped up which meant that I was constantly interrupting my workflow to keep on top of an email that probably wasn't important enough to interrupt me in the first place.

More space is great as long as the more space is helping you with the task you're working on. If the more space is just providing more room for items that are NOT your primary task then your productivity is probably suffering as a result whether you want to admit it or not.

Whether or not its a distraction depends on a few things though
My work greatly involves my incoming email and I have my Outlook in one window, along with the apps that I dont always have to interact with, and my main app on second screen. I honestly wish I had 3 monitors at work, guaranteed that my productivity would go up, but short of Win7 snap, and still having to manipulate window locations I couldnt accomplish as much with one large monitor.
Additionally, I think its a matter of how well you multitask, how well your job lets you multitask.
 
I just setup a second old Crt monitor next to my lcd at home, just so i could watch other apps like trillian and steam friends while i play MW2.

Hopeing to get 2 more lcds for some eyefity action tho...
 
2500x1400 eh? That's only 3,500,000 pixels.

5040x1050 is already up to 5,292,000 pixels. I guess that means pretty much all Eyefinity setups are already over this arbitrary number.
 
Without software examples or citations, what good is this article?

For example, many programs have too many buttons, borders, and other useless padding that wastes space. Changing to minimal views and using an appropriate window manager can make extremely good use of even 1024*600 on a netbook while coding and referencing multiple APIs and source files. However, this will not work for a graphic artist.

Moot.
 
Multi-monitor + Ultramon on windows 7 is a dream. At work I run dual monitors, at home I run triple. My productivity is much better when I have more.

QFT, I'll never go back to just having one. My dual 1920x1080 (3840x1080) setup is a blast to work on.
 
And to add to that, no matter how you "manage your pixels," there's always going to be less of them without that extra monitor(s).
 
I have dual monitors at work that combined are close to the "optimum" resolution stated... I would estimate my productivity in some of my tasks has risen by at least 60% because of it.
 
I know I am normally in the minority here at [H], but I am more productive and prefer having a single large screen over multiple.

I share my office with the other IT guy, He runs 3 22" LCDs and I just run a single 30". I've gone back and forth between the setups. I find that I get more things done and work more efficiently on a single large screen than with multiples.

I also find that the separation between the screens is distracting and completely unacceptable. I am also the type of person who can't work on a monitor that has any faulty pixels at all because my eyes will gravitate and fixate on it. Because of that I HATE Eyefinity setups.

Every person is different, and all I can say is that I find multiple monitors distracting and it kills my productivity. It will take bezel-less monitors for that to change for me.

But the reality is nobody can afford any single monitor with "2560x1440 or greater" Resolution.

You mean you can't afford it. I have a 30" at home and at work. I just put 4 of them in our publications department.
 
We do remote desktop support at my job. After acquiring second monitors everyone was happier (and more productive). I have 2 x 22" at work and 22" +19" at home. Both work fine for me. Would have another 19" at home but ATI wants a display graphics port for 3 monitors to work. I think many people would be surprised by how much more they get done on 2 monitors that have never had it before.
 
2 monitors is way better at work. Hell I could use 3 monitors some days.

At home, I have my FW900 (1920x1200/85hz CRT) and a Viewsonic 23.6" 1920x1080 as the secondary display. At home, it's handy for writing papers (Google books windows / Chicago style guide on 2nd display, paper on first).

I actually prefer even to 2 monitors, 2 computers. I have the secondary hooked up to a slave PC. That way if I'm playing a game that I can't mouse out of, I can still use Input Director to tab over to the other PC and do stuff without leaving the game. A lot of games won't let you use more than one screen when it's playing.
 
For work I think multiply monitors are great, but for gaming I think the bezels would drive me nuts. I remember when ppl would bitch about the damper wires on sony CRTs but few complain about the bezels on tri monitor setups. Call me crazy but I'll take one nice high def monitor over multiple monitors.
 
I generally find multiple monitors to be really useful at work when i need to be logged in to a few servers via RDP. I used to use a single 30" at home but since i added a 24" im pretty darn happy. Useful when creating documents with multiple point of reference.
 
Methadras
Well, I really wish at this point that the start bar/task bar could extend across two or more monitors. The other thing I really wish for is 30" LCD's to come down to a realistic price in the $500 to $700 range.

@ Methadras, you can download Display Fusion so that your taskbar will show up on all of your monitors.
 
Whether or not its a distraction depends on a few things though
My work greatly involves my incoming email and I have my Outlook in one window, along with the apps that I dont always have to interact with, and my main app on second screen. I honestly wish I had 3 monitors at work, guaranteed that my productivity would go up, but short of Win7 snap, and still having to manipulate window locations I couldnt accomplish as much with one large monitor.
Additionally, I think its a matter of how well you multitask, how well your job lets you multitask.

If your job is centred around your incoming email then obviously having it front and centre is a requirement. For someone like me (engineer) who has to look at drawings, bills of material, and so forth ... having email open all the time is a distraction as it can put you back five minutes easy if you lose your place. I use a laptop screen and 20" Dell 4:3 ratio. Nothing grand, but it works for me as I can put drawings on the bigger screen and just open up PDF's, spreadsheets, and webpages looking for data to include in drawings or compare to drawings on the laptop screen.

For me, as well, I doubt a single large monitor would be as convenient as I end up opening and closing stuff on the laptop screen on a regular basis. Having to resnap every time would be a pain. I do like the automatic organization of the dual screen setup. The only thing I would like better is two of the 20" Dell's or maybe two large monitors and not use the laptop screen.
 
Back
Top