MadOnion Pwns U!

As far as I can tell it doesn't sound like a BS excuse at all. It appears at some point Futuremark is going to use "Pwnage" as a brand name or slogan in future product(s). In order to do so they need to trademark it before someone else in the industry does. It is similar to registering a domain name for a product or company name BEFORE that product or company name becomes public knowledge so cybersquatters don't claim it first.

Yes, I understand you are doing what is probably best for your business. In my opinion in this case it comes off as following the herd mentality which is something which HardOCP has taken pride to avoid, at least in its benchmarking articles.

So how long have you been employed with FutureMark? :p
 
we would all have to write the feds saying its common verbage.. if anything is public knowledge, public domain etc... its illegal to copyright. we would have to show examples pre 2008.
 
we would all have to write the feds saying its common verbage.. if anything is public knowledge, public domain etc... its illegal to copyright. we would have to show examples pre 2008.
You, sir, are obviously an IP lawyer. You also obviously read the whole thread.

Thanks for your help!
 
I see outrage over the trademark of a silly word like "Pwnage" but where was Kyle to protect "the community" when "3D Gamers" was trademarked, or when "PC Gamer" was trademarked", or "hardcore gamer" was trademarked, or "gamer" or "gamers"? Has Kyle sued to bring these terms back to "the community"? Did anyone mention "ROFL", "OMG", "WTF", "FTW", "LOL", and "noob" are also trademarked? It appears some people are confusing trademarks with copyrights. Not surprisingly it appears Kyle's rant was meant generate controversy and therefore page hits, rather that bring any enlightenment at all to the issue.

Find more of your favorite words and/or phrases that are trademarked here: Trademark Electronic Search System.

You left out "Windows". And "Apple" for that matter.

Yeah, this is the community (trademarked) getting up in arms (trademarked) about l33t (dead trademark) stupidity (trademarked) within the community. And a company (trademarked) trying to make money (trademarked) off of that stupidity.
 
whats up with the douchebags on hardocp lately? if you post comments you get doucehbag replies... just like all the guys who went to the apple store yesterday to pick up chicks saying that its better than being married. did they get laid? no. did they get snow on their trenchcoat? probably.
 
whats up with the douchebags on hardocp lately? if you post comments you get doucehbag replies... just like all the guys who went to the apple store yesterday to pick up chicks saying that its better than being married. did they get laid? no. did they get snow on their trenchcoat? probably.

Douchebag replies usually come when you post offtopic, incorrect information that has already been covered earlier in the thread.
 
Well.

They say they're trademarking it so that no one else can trademark it and sue them for using it.

And you buy that? Do you really think they're not going to try to sue when they see the first person with a multimillion dollar wallet use the phrase?
 
Well.

They say they're trademarking it so that no one else can trademark it and sue them for using it.

And on second thought, isn't this them admitting it is common a well known phrase and therefore untrademarkable?
 
And on second thought, isn't this them admitting it is common a well known phrase and therefore untrademarkable?

Common, well-known phrases are trademarkable.

Windows, Apple, Gateway, Target, Virgin, Lonely Planet, Bimbo, Community, and Dole are all common words that are also trademarked.
 
Common, well-known phrases are trademarkable.

Windows, Apple, Gateway, Target, Virgin, Lonely Planet, Bimbo, Community, and Dole are all common words that are also trademarked.

And surely you are absolutely correct but you seem to be ignoring the one big issue here, and that is the fact that all the examples you have given above had no affiliation with the genres they were trademarked into. I would suggest that "pwn" is fully a gaming term and there are currently companies using the term in and on products in the gaming industry. JUST like the simple example I gave earlier.

I really don't give a shit whether they TM it or not. If I did, I would have called our IP lawyer this morning. The funny thing to me is that here is a company worried about creating new and exciting games and they can't even put together a title without ripping off the community. I bet the game will be awesome. :rolleyes:
 
I really, really don't consider adopting a common community term as a trademark for a product or line of products "ripping off the community."

No one in "the community" is getting ripped off of anything. No one in "the community" is going to lose money or otherwise be put out by a simple trademark on a product.
 
This thread has achieved a rating of 8,569 Pwnage Marks.

It's bottlenecked by it's "teh funneh" score, but the real world entertainment value is still satisfactory.
 
Not that Mad Onion hasn't been a dick in the past, I just don't see where this merits any publicity or is an issue. Intel has already sued several times for the use of "intel" in a name (http://www.theinquirer.net/en/inquirer/news/2007/02/01/intel-sues-man-over-intel-name, http://www.volesoft.com/?article=34283). Technically they (Mad Onion) haven't done anything yet, so it would be presumptuous to jump to any legal conclusions at this point. It is a sad state of affairs however that our legal system has been, and can be so easily abused in this sense. Personally I don't care if they tradmark the term Pwnage or F*cktard, as long as it doesn't interfere with my right to free speech (intel doesn't sue people for using the word "intel"). If Mad Onion is "up to no good," I would rather take the high road and let them dig their own grave.
 
I remember the words uber and pwnage years ago in games like everquest, wich was launched March 16, 1999 around the same time madonion was just getting started, and im pretty postive madonion didnt have anything to do with inventing those words, uber was invented as a word to decribe leet gear, and pwnage was invented when totaly owning a person in a FPS or a very hard world boss in mmo base games, well at least thats how i remember those words in the gaming world
 
I remember the words uber and pwnage years ago in games like everquest, wich was launched March 16, 1999 around the same time madonion was just getting started, and im pretty postive madonion didnt have anything to do with inventing those words, uber was invented as a word to decribe leet gear, and pwnage was invented when totaly owning a person in a FPS or a very hard world boss in mmo base games, well at least thats how i remember those words in the gaming world

Yeah.

Problem, though, is that it's totally irrelevant who "invented" the words.
 
I remember the words uber and pwnage years ago in games like everquest, wich was launched March 16, 1999 around the same time madonion was just getting started, and im pretty postive madonion didnt have anything to do with inventing those words, uber was invented as a word to decribe leet gear, and pwnage was invented when totaly owning a person in a FPS or a very hard world boss in mmo base games, well at least thats how i remember those words in the gaming world

Uber is a German word that when used in some contexts as a prefix means 'super' (a simple one being ubermensch for superman.) It has other meanings though, and when used alone properly it does not actually mean super.

Lets not give the gaming culture too much credit here. The closest they get to inventing words is using a certain meaning of another word, or replacing letters in words with other letters or numbers.
 
You know, Kyle, you really can be equivocal sometimes. It would be nice if on occasion you just came out and said what you think instead of being so diplomatic and sensitive! :)

Keep up the good work, this site stands out from the crowd.
 
If donald trump can trademark "youre fired" then anyone can trademark "pwnage" and theres not a single damn thing anyone can do about it. People who think they can somehow reverse this so something stupid like "pwnage" is some how exempt to trademarks are idiots.
 
Also, an unbelievable amount of words and things like colors/images are trademarked, yet the world still manages to revolve and people manage to not get sued for using the english language. People who spread trademark FUD generally dont have the slightest clue what trademarks actually are. There are better things to worry about, trademarks dont affect people in any way shape or form unless they are trying to think of a name for a product they want to patent (and even then it has to be very similar to the trademarked product for it to be considered a trademark infringement).

Theres nothing wrong with trademarks, if anything they are a good thing since they avoid confusion in the marketplace so there arent 12 different companies trying to trick you into buying their iPod. Nobody gets sued for using a trademarked word in casual conversation, its not possible. When you make a product you trademark the name, its how the world works so someone doesnt come along and make the same kind of product with the exact same name. Every product you own that has a regular word as a name is trademarked. Every. Single. One.
 
Your our hero Kyle!!! (not)
I will agree that calling anything.. be it product, service or whatever "Pwnage" is stupid but trademarking it as it was explained is nothing to rant about..
 
I couldnt really care less if they get a trademark for pwn or not. Its not like it will stop a bunch of really good products from launching, because they needed to use "pwn" or some derivate of it in their name. :)

It is good to be reminded that [H] isnt pretending to be unbiased though.
 
I've just benchmarked that trademark with 3DMark08. It tells me it is at the level of jump-in-front-of-a-moving-18-wheeler retardness.
 
I'm not totally clear on this situation, as there are more important things to think about in life, but let me see if I understand this:

1) The company is attempting to TM the (possibly most immature and retarded phrase next to "l33t") phrase "pwnage".

2) [H] covers the news because it's gaming-related (in a community sense) and because it's simply ridiculous.

3) Said company -and here-in is where I think the point lies- they make a point of it to contact Kyle about the issue. Hence, the company making it an issue, when Kyle/[H] has nothing to do with anything, except for the fact that they reported it?

WTF!?

So why the fucking "Kyle bashing" then? Kyle has nothing to do with it.

He started this thread because it was the company that made it a point to contact him about the issue, simply because it was reported in an article on [H].

Since they made it an issue, and not Kyle, I'd have done the same thing and started a thread about it, because it's simply fucking retarded that they would have even bothered to make it a point to contact Kyle about the issue. Which must have only been because [H] covered the topic, because neither Kyle nor [H] nor me nor the fucking dog next door has anything what-so-ever to do with the fucking 6-year-old mentality of the retarded "pwnge" phrase.

I think everyone here is totally missing these points and misunderstanding the situation.
 
As far as I can tell, MadOnion did not contact Kyle.

They made a post on the YouGamers forum, which Kyle republished here and then attacked.

A lot of people are grossly misunderstanding what trademarks are. They didn't copyright or patent anything - they registered the word "PWNAGE" as a trademark, which can now be used to market and identify their products.... and which no one else can use to identify their products.

Just like no one else can market "Windows software" without authorization from Microsoft, despite the fact that "Windows" is a common term. Just like no one can start selling "PC Gamer" motherboards without authorization from Future Publishing, despite the fact that "PC gamer" is a common "community" term.
 
As far as I can tell, MadOnion did not contact Kyle.

Reread Kyle's post.

This is in reference to a story that Terry posted this weekend about MadOnion, er Futuremark and it applying for a trademark on the word “Pwnage.” Futuremark let us know that Futuremark Games Studio’s Jukka Makinen had made a post in regards to this.

Futuremark's CEO directly sent me an email (addressing me by name so it wasn't a form letter) in response to my story on Saturday and pointed me to the link in Kyle's post. I sent it to Kyle and he ran with it.
 
I'm not against this trademark because it's just like "Windows", "Apple", "Core", and all the other common works that have been tradmarked.

As others have said, it's a trademark, not a copyright. Everyone is still free to use the word. You just can't release a new product and call it "pwnage".

But Futuremark's post is the ultimate irony:

Our purpose in filing for trademark on the name "Pwnage" is not to charge money or stop people from using the expression. That's not what a trademark is for. Instead, we want to protect ourselves from squatters (or what I call campers) - people looking to trademark the name on false pretenses, just to make a claim against Futuremark Games Studio for its use.

Basically they're saying "we don't want other people to squat on this commonly used gaming word and not do anything with it so we're going to squat on it and not do anything with it".
 
so does that mean there will be benchmark software under that name?

like Futurmark presents PwnAge and consequently PwnAge: FTW!!, ?
 
Here is what I don't like (and correct me if I am wrong) if/when they TM Pwnage then that meens no one can use it on there product right? So if a company lets say Asus wants to put Pwnage on one of there laptop boxes to describe there product OR to apeal to the gaming comunity they have to get mad onions permision. If a new game comes out and they want to put on there box Pwnage to describe there game then they have to get mad onions permision.

The real question is not about TM or copyrights or anything like that its how far is mad onion going to go to stop other company from using that word (for discription only).
 
Kyle, this is what you wrote

That is nice to know since there is no way in hell Futuremark or its gaming studios can charge you a damn thing to begin with for using a term that BELONGS TO THE COMMUNITY.
Agree here, and it's a good thing they're not trying to.

There is no doubt in my mind that should even a little bit of legal resistance be given to the trademark application, that it could be defeated.
What would be the legal basis for that resistance, Kyle? Remember, this is a trademark, not a copyright. So in order to contest this, (brief legal explanation here, not meant to be exhaustive) a current trademark owner would have to show that they are an existing provider of goods/services/products which Futuremark is attempting to provide, with the mark Pwnage, that, if the USPTO were to grant a mark to Futuremark, would cause confusion in the marketplace.

So what resistance can be provided Kyle? There is no doubt in your mind, so I'm interested in hearing this.

Oh, and a gaming store doesn't necessarily count. There is no confusion between a mom and pop shop selling games, to a computer gaming developer. You can review their application here:
http://tess2.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=83u8p9.2.1

Futuremark has made a business out of selling YOUR information about YOUR computers for years now.
Well WE did install THEIR program (usually free). Nothing wrong with this, right?

It does not surprise me that they now think they should have legal right to a commonly used word in the enthusiast and gaming communities. Their rationale of trade marking it before the “bad guys” do is bullshit on its best day. Futuremark plans to use the term in an upcoming title, it wants to protect "its property," and it is that simple. It intends to profit from this commonly used term. At least if you can’t be original, do not try to own what is community property. I am sure the uninformed at the patent office will not identify this unless the mark is disputed. So take that and “suck it down.” Maybe this makes another top 25 dumbest moments in gaming? And no, I am not going to pay John “my bitch” Romero for typing that.
Again, it appears you are confusing trademark and copyright. They want to create a gaming software and entertainment services (i.e. games) and use the word Pwnage. Nobody did it first, so they have a right. No word is owned by the community. And they aren't copyrighting it. if they tried to copyright it, I could see the uproar. That would prevent others from using it unless it fell into fair use. They want to provide goods and services, and call it pwnage. This prevents others from creating a game, calling it pwnage, and then trading on Futuremark's products.
 
Hmm, just saw this pop up on TotalFark.com

http://multiplayerblog.mtv.com/2008/03/06/pwnedcom-weighs-in-pwnage-trademark-attempt/

All well and good, but I needed to know where Pwned.com stood on trademarking another word. Forget about “pwnage.” What about “pwned”?

The site doesn’t have it trademarked yet. But this is what I heard back from Andy Briggs, who started Pwned.com last November:

“PWNED.com is a site for gamers pure and simple. We never felt the need to trademark the word we never created. We do this for fun. We are looking into our options because of this.”
 
Hehe, no confusion here. You guys still talking about this? I had forgotten about it....
 
The long and short of it is this:

1. They're going to pour all of their money into this game.
2. Said game will surely suck.
3. "Futuremark" will be liquidated to pay angry creditors.
4. :D
 
Isn't there a link to a gaming related website called "pure pwnage" already posted in this thread. That is where they might run into a problem with the trademark application.
 
Here is what I don't like (and correct me if I am wrong) if/when they TM Pwnage then that meens no one can use it on there product right? So if a company lets say Asus wants to put Pwnage on one of there laptop boxes to describe there product OR to apeal to the gaming comunity they have to get mad onions permision. If a new game comes out and they want to put on there box Pwnage to describe there game then they have to get mad onions permision.

The real question is not about TM or copyrights or anything like that its how far is mad onion going to go to stop other company from using that word (for discription only).

No. Thats not how trademarks work. Microsoft cannot sue window companies for using "windows" in their company names. There are limits to how far a trademark reaches. The product has to be very similair. We dont know what the hell the "pwnage" product is going to be. If its benchmarking software then the trademark will prevent other benchmark programs from using "pwnage" as the software's name. It is 100% impossible to sue someone for casually using a trademarked word, that should be common sense.

Computer hardware vs computer software should be different enough for trademarks to have no effect. Probably even software vs software if they have totally different uses.

This is stupid. Trademarks are not evil. Trademarks are the reason GIMP isnt called "Adobe Photoshop" and why "Saints Row" isnt called "Grand Theft Auto." Without trademarks life would be complete hell since everything would be called the same thing to try and trick people.
 
Quote:

“PWNED.com is a site for gamers pure and simple. We never felt the need to trademark the word we never created. We do this for fun. We are looking into our options because of this.”

I registered at pwned.com after reading the article - gotta say I was instantly put off by the seeming lack of moderation in the forums - really made me appreciate what a bloody good job all the dedicated dudes here at [H] do for us. Thank you Kyle & team for providing an environment that encourages intelligent debate & respect for one's fellow members.
 
did they submit it before cartman said "pownage" on south park? if they didnt maybe comedy central should sue them! :eek::D
 
Thank you Kyle & team for providing an environment that encourages intelligent debate & respect for one's fellow members.


You are welcome sir, we try to do exactly that without stepping on everyones' toes at the same time. The mods and admins here do a hell of a job while working hard to let everyone be "themselves." Thanks for noticing.
 
No. Thats not how trademarks work. Microsoft cannot sue window companies for using "windows" in their company names. There are limits to how far a trademark reaches. The product has to be very similair. We dont know what the hell the "pwnage" product is going to be. If its benchmarking software then the trademark will prevent other benchmark programs from using "pwnage" as the software's name. It is 100% impossible to sue someone for casually using a trademarked word, that should be common sense.

But, if someone makes software, perhaps an operating system, and... oh.. randomly names it "Lindows", microsoft cant sue? <sarcasm> (I said "cant sue", and I mean just that, defined as not being able to file a lawsuit at all). The "Pwnage" isnt a big deal, considering other things that are, or are being applied for trademark... such as the smiley face, by a certain retailer. But any time I see things like this, I think of SCO, speaking of them... they are back at it again this year.

I doubt MadOnion will sell PwnageMark 09, and simutaneously PwnageSpec 2009 will be released by a competetor... But I really do wonder exactly why they decided to trademark that phrase. If trademarks do not matter unless someone else has very similar/identical products.. Either its the NyQuil ive been drinking, or the excuse MadOnion gave seems like faulty logic.
 
Back
Top