MacOS X An Unsuitable Platform for Web Development

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
To be honest, I don't even know who the hell this guy is but he is funny and has some very interesting opinions on using OS X for web development. :eek:

I used to be a big time Mac fanboy. In fact, I even had a letter published in Macworld magazine when I was 15. However, at some point, I started writing code to put food on my table, and found that the Mac just does not cut it. I'm generally all for developers using the tools that they want to use and feel the most productive with, but tools like MacOS X cause more problems for the rest of the development team, and are a net negative.
 
He treats OS X like it's UNIX/Linux when it isn't UNIX or Linux. That's probably the issue.
 
How did I know that the one reply would be phide?

Seriously though, we doesn't he just run ubuntu on it if he has so many issues? Hell, he's running a VM of Windows, why not one of Linux too?
 
This appeared on /. as well and the comments basically ripped the guy a new one.

If you are developing for a production system you develop on or as close to the production platform as you can. Thus this tool should have been running a dual boot with Linux or Run it in a VM for development.

Even when I was doing programing, I would often load the SERVER edition of the target platform in a VM to develop on to ensure I would get the same behavior.
 
I read it. Essentially his complaint is that OS X isn't Linux. He wants it to be, but isn't. Such is life.
Yeah, that's what I got out of it too. Anandtech did a much better break down of OSX issues a while ago, this guy is just being a whiny little bitch.
 
I read it. Essentially his complaint is that OS X isn't Linux. He wants it to be, but isn't. Such is life.

Being different is not an excuse to be bad. His complaints aren't limited to "it isn't linux", far from it. He points out several things that OS X is simply bad or terrible at. OS X sucks for development, such is life.
 
I honestly don't know what the fuck this guy is talking about. I work on PHP/MySQL websites all day, every day. SSH FTP and WebDav are requirements in my work environment. This is the only reason I use OSX 10.6.4 on my Asus Laptop in a hackintosh configuration. Because there is literally no better application then Coda for doing PHP web development in any operating system.
 
About the only legitimate argument he has is the fact that the mac is overpriced for his needs. Even then he pointed out the fact that the company bought it for him, so that point is moot.

This guy knows how to run VM-ware, why isn't he running a virtualized linux install? Better yet, the mac hardware is x86 capable, why isn't he dual booting or triple booting (OSX, Windows, Linux)?
 
It seems that his beef is with Apple in general. What does the price of a Macbook Pro have to do with developing applications? He also mentioned that Ebay gave him the laptop so his ultimate goal seems to be to focused on getting Steves minions riled up. If so then mission accomplished! I can picture the army of hipster zombies rushing Ebay headquarters as we speak!
 
If you are developing for a production system you develop on or as close to the production platform as you can. Thus this tool should have been running a dual boot with Linux or Run it in a VM for development.
What's strange is that he even said as much in his post:
This is one of those lessons that it will take you a few catastrophic failures to learn. Your development platform should be as close as possible to your production platform.
In effect, he seems to be agreeing with himself yet disagreeing with himself at the same time. It's a bit odd.

Being different is not an excuse to be bad. His complaints aren't limited to "it isn't linux", far from it. He points out several things that OS X is simply bad or terrible at.
I'm not saying that he's wrong on every point. His problem, however, is that he takes a very "I will do things the same way I do it in Linux" approach to development and then finds that things don't work to his liking. Like I said, OS X isn't Linux: You don't approach things in the same way as you would in Linux and I can't imagine why anyone would even try to.

OS X sucks for development, such is life.
Google seems to be okay with it.
 
He starts out complaining that its not like Linux in how it functions then in the end concedes that being based on BSD it will behave differently than Linux. Shock of all shocks, OSX doesn't act and isn't supported the same way as Linux, or Unix, or even BSD as it is its own unique fork. The question does remain though. If he's developing for Linux why is he trying to hamfist it using a different operating system? That to me seems like trying to develop a bicycle by using a garage fitted with the tools to build light aircraft then wondering why most of the tools are unsuited for the job.
 
He treats OS X like it's UNIX/Linux when it isn't UNIX or Linux. That's probably the issue.

Thats the thing, at its core OS X is UNIX, they've just mangled and abused it to such an extent that most of the good things about UNIX have been thrown out and replaced with brushed metal.

Although on the point of the development platform being as close to production as possible, I wish someone would tell my company this so they'd stop using legacy Windows to develop for *nix.
 
Oh yes, my favourite quotation - "what is this shit, Gentoo?"
Except it isn't. In gentoo he would be able to do USE="-xml" on whatever package he was installing. This guy sounds like a true moron. (Everyone that uses emacs btw) vim > emacs.
 
I honestly don't know what the fuck this guy is talking about. I work on PHP/MySQL websites all day, every day. SSH FTP and WebDav are requirements in my work environment. This is the only reason I use OSX 10.6.4 on my Asus Laptop in a hackintosh configuration. Because there is literally no better application then Coda for doing PHP web development in any operating system.

Honestly PHP makes me want to shoot my brains out whenever I'm looking at someone elses code. What is this trend of not using statically typed languges?

when you have $object=getSomething($c) and I don't nkow what getSomething returns what c and what type $object is, I want to rape someone.
 
Honestly PHP makes me want to shoot my brains out whenever I'm looking at someone elses code. What is this trend of not using statically typed languges?

when you have $object=getSomething($c) and I don't nkow what getSomething returns what c and what type $object is, I want to rape someone.

that has nothing to do with the language, that is that people that normally do that type of scripting don't know proper programming practices.
 
I have been using OS X (10.1-10.6.x) for 10 years now. It is by far the best web development platform I have ever used. For me, everything just works....
 
Thats the thing, at its core OS X is UNIX, they've just mangled and abused it to such an extent that most of the good things about UNIX have been thrown out and replaced with brushed metal.
I'm sure that's true to some extent, but it doesn't take into considering what they've added. Again, it's an approach-it-like-Linux/UNIX-and-be-frustrated scenario. Approach it like it's something different — which it is — and there shouldn't be a problem.

Google uses a modified version of Ubuntu for engineers to develop on, not OS X. So Google agrees with this guy in this case.
You took no issue with anything else I said? This is your only response?

(For what it's worth, I can find nothing to indicate that Google uses only a modified version of Ubuntu for development purposes. There are plenty of articles stating that Google issues either Linux PCs or Macs running OS X to new hires, however.)
 
He treats OS X like it's UNIX/Linux when it isn't UNIX or Linux. That's probably the issue.

I think there's an assumption that when your servers are running Linux, a desktop based on Unix might be better than Windows. In reality, neither OS X nor Windows match your server environment, so the less coding you do on the desktop the better. $EDITOR in a terminal on an environment that matches production is much less hassle; and Windows will get you there cheaper.
 
Someone call the whaaaambulance. Oh noes, another Linux hippie got his panties in a bunch!
 
I think this guy is using his machine to both develop and test. Of course that's going to lead to problems if the architecture isn't exactly the same as the server he's deploying to. His first complaint about package managers pretty much sets the tone for the entire article. I do web development exclusively on OSX and I have never once touched any of the package managers.

Bottom line: It's obvious that this guy is a dinosaur stuck in his ways. If you go to any site like http://www.nettuts.com you'll pretty much ONLY see people developing on Macbooks. If OSX isn't an option, then Mint or Ubuntu is a good way to go also.

BTW... TextMate For Life!
textmate.jpg
 
Bahahahahaha
A basic 15" MacBook Pro will run you $1,800 while you can buy a comparable model from Lenovo for $1,200. An extra $600 for the privilege of running a shitty operating system, where do I sign up?
 
"Part of the process of becoming a new eBay employee is ..." and the other part is the ritual involving the chicken decapitation, right?
 
I get it. He fell into the trap of thinking that BSD was BSD no matter who tried to tweak it to their will (Apple) BSD is different enough from Linux to confuse any NIX devotee but add the fact that Apple has managed to lock down an open platform and it just gets worse.

Look the fact of that matter is that Apple is always going to be a better toaster (appliance) than a PC could ever be. It's not meant to be mucked with just as you don't mess with your toaster or microwave oven. It's made for people who don't want to think about how their computer works or how to make it run better outside of an update from the Apple gods.

So maybe this developer should have looked up from his emacs editor long enough to realize how everything that is Apple permeates every Apple product before diving into it.
 
Being different is not an excuse to be bad. His complaints aren't limited to "it isn't linux", far from it. He points out several things that OS X is simply bad or terrible at. OS X sucks for development, such is life.

OSX isn't meant for development or for any form of creative or productive work. It's meant for the passive consumption of media. There was a time when all the audio, video and desktop publishing guys used Macs, but that was 10-15+ years ago. Now, Macs are just big iPods with keyboards.
 
I don't care what this guys issue with Mac OSX is, this comment is golden: "Bring your pet Rhesus monkey to work if you want, but the first time that little fucker throws feces at me, he's going to the hot dog factory." :D
 
OSX isn't meant for development or for any form of creative or productive work. It's meant for the passive consumption of media. There was a time when all the audio, video and desktop publishing guys used Macs, but that was 10-15+ years ago. Now, Macs are just big iPods with keyboards.

Just no...
 
He treats OS X like it's UNIX/Linux when it isn't UNIX or Linux. That's probably the issue.
You guys always try to come up with some excuse to imply the OP is wrong and discredit him.

It's like you guys have some sort of internal grudge against accepting the truth and reality.
 
What's sad is that this news article is actually news to so many web developers. I feel bad for anyone who wasted so much of their money trying to do simple tasks on a comparable and faaaaaaaaaar cheaper PC.
 
I've never used TextMate. OMG, how do I even code on a Mac?

What a retard that author is.
 
You guys always try to come up with some excuse to imply the OP is wrong and discredit him.

It's like you guys have some sort of internal grudge against accepting the truth and reality.

Just because somebody with a blog says it, doesn't make it true or real...
 
Back
Top