MacBook Pro Overheating GeForce 9600M Issues

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Engadget says they have a sneaking suspicion that all the reports of overheating GeForce 9600M video cards in the new MacBook Pro might be fan related. Supposedly NVIDIA and Apple are still working on the issue.

Granted, all of this is just speculatory at the moment, but it seems that some users have noticed that their fans aren't kicking into high gear when they should. 'Course, some folks have seen those RPMs spin up while the funky lines and psychedelic colors remain, so it's still hard to pinpoint a definite root cause. We're told that folks from NVIDIA and Apple are spending their weekends working to figure it out, but we can't help but be reminded of an eerily similar string of events with overheating MacBook Airs just last year.
 
While it might be fan related, I wouldn't doubt if it was a chip problem with the way things have been going in recent times for Nvidia...

Besides, isn't the 9600GT just an overclocked 8600 in notebooks? I know my 9800M GTS is just an overclocked 8800M GTS...
 
Gee, I wonder if I disassembled one of the new MBPs would I see this, again?

rowofshame2ul.jpg


I wonder...

"It just overheats..." :D
 
Ouch...this gotta hurt... that being said, it's not surprising considering how poorly ventilated the macbooks are.
 
What's that? Apple churning out more overpriced crap? Is this really a surprise? Obscene margins and they can't put enough testing in to find an overheating issue? It really is as simple as providing units to your staff to use for a while. Sell them as refurbs after if you really want to cheap out.

Doesn't matter. The Apple zealots will keep buying their garbage.
 
I just laugh about this then I cry knowing my laptop has an 8400m in it. :( Loved the solution to my 8400m...we'll spin the fan longer and more often.
 
What's that? Apple churning out more overpriced crap? Is this really a surprise? Obscene margins and they can't put enough testing in to find an overheating issue? It really is as simple as providing units to your staff to use for a while. Sell them as refurbs after if you really want to cheap out.

Doesn't matter. The Apple zealots will keep buying their garbage.

You must not have been following NVIDIA's mobile chips lately. The 8000m series have been dropping like flies, in all brands of computers (Apple, Dell, HP, etc.). Because the 9000m is just rebranded 8000m cards (wouldn't be NVIDIA if they didn't rebrand :rolleyes:), they probably have the same problems with these "new" cards.
 
They do have the same problems. A friend of mine just bought two different laptops in a row, both with a 9600M chipset. Both had numerous video issues.
 
You must not have been following NVIDIA's mobile chips lately. The 8000m series have been dropping like flies, in all brands of computers (Apple, Dell, HP, etc.). Because the 9000m is just rebranded 8000m cards (wouldn't be NVIDIA if they didn't rebrand :rolleyes:), they probably have the same problems with these "new" cards.

And?

So it's Nvidia's fault Apple didn't properly test their setup? The fact remains that Apple of all companies should have some serious testing in their products considering their absurd margins. The fact that Nvidia fucked up doesn't mean Apple didn't, or that Dell didn't, or that anyone else didn't. The problems with these GPUs aren't exactly discrete.
 
*sigh* WTB: Edit.

The point is, Apple has always tried to push this "our products are stable/just work/etc" that most of us recognize as bullshit. They could at least use part of the huge margins the tools give them to make these claims remotely true.
 
ive never bought a Mac in my life, though ive considered it at one point.

im starrting to think that maybe its not worth the extra $1500 to buy a laptop thats pretty just to end up with it broken and possibly outside of warrenty.

honestly when was the last time apple came out with a product doesn't break or get replaced by a newer version in a few months?

i wouldn't even let steve jobs do my laundry, hed prolly ruin that to...
 
ive never bought a Mac in my life, though ive considered it at one point.

im starrting to think that maybe its not worth the extra $1500 to buy a laptop thats pretty just to end up with it broken and possibly outside of warrenty.

honestly when was the last time apple came out with a product doesn't break or get replaced by a newer version in a few months?

i wouldn't even let steve jobs do my laundry, hed prolly ruin that to...

qft


some of the apple computers are decent, but yes, more offen than not they seem to break in some way or another, it's like having a ferrari with plastic engine mounts.
 
Isn't this for accidental damage by yourself?

I think he meant "complete care warranty" - no edits here methinks.
I'd love to buy complete bear warranty (never know when they may attack) :D

I think there should be a sticky here:
Do not buy 1st gen Apple gear. I know someone is going to quote/mod this :D
 
I think he meant "complete care warranty" - no edits here methinks.
I'd love to buy complete bear warranty (never know when they may attack) :D
Right, but, the standard warranty covers GPU failures. Complete Care is an additional warranty if the user bets against themselves.
 
And?

So it's Nvidia's fault Apple didn't properly test their setup? The fact remains that Apple of all companies should have some serious testing in their products considering their absurd margins. The fact that Nvidia fucked up doesn't mean Apple didn't, or that Dell didn't, or that anyone else didn't. The problems with these GPUs aren't exactly discrete.

Yes it is Nvidia's fault for not properly testing their chips and publishing operating specs that are inaccurate for said device.........
 
some of the apple computers are decent, but yes, more offen than not they seem to break in some way or another, it's like having a ferrari with plastic engine mounts.

id say a closer comparison would be to a lexus. a few curves here and there, a shiny logo, a huge markup.. and under the hood its no different than any random toyota. :rolleyes:
 
My previous MacBook Pro with a 256MB 8600M went 2+ years developing video sims/tutorials. Never had a single problem with overheating or anything else. No problems to report with my new 256MB 9600M equipped MBP, either. I must be the only one, huh?
 
I'd relate it to a poorly designed heat transfer and intake/exhaust system. The fan in the new MBP seems really weak to me, at least compared to my 9500M fan in my Asus. Maybe since Apple was going for the the slim silent appeal, they could have just barely met the heat transfer specifications for the chipset in their notebook design.. that and bad thermal paste jobs. Just my 2cents..
 
So it's Nvidia's fault Apple used improper amounts of thermal grease and improper heatsink + fans? And that Apple rarely likes to use Fans because they want all their products silent even if this later causes malfunctions in their products such as the constantly overheating MacBook Pros?
 
I don't know about this particular issue, but my GF had to have her white first gen Macbook RMAed about six times because of heat issues on the board. Finally they gave up and upgraded her to a unibody, so at least bravo to apple for their applecare if you can get them to enforce it.
 
I don't know about this particular issue, but my GF had to have her white first gen Macbook RMAed about six times because of heat issues on the board. Finally they gave up and upgraded her to a unibody, so at least bravo to apple for their applecare if you can get them to enforce it.



That has nothing to do with Applecare. That has to do with the law. If they got to 6 repairs then they were well past the point where you could demand and full cash refund on the original purchase price (or depending on where you live, as much as 3 times the purchase price). 6 repairs is legally unacceptable and runs very much afoul of lemon laws.
 
Back
Top