LSI 9201-16i replacing M1015 under Linux JBOD Raid issues?

Pinnocchio

n00b
Joined
Feb 5, 2010
Messages
6
I currently have a setup using an Asus Workstation board with an IBM M1015 and 8 x Seagate 2TB drives in Raid 6...running Fedora 19 the drives are seen as JBOD and i'm using Linux's Kernel Raid setup...system works fine without problems and gives me about 11TB usable storage.

I want to increase the setup and while I was originally thinking of buying a DS380 chassis and doing a new build I've now decided to instead get a LSI 9201-16i and use 11 or 12 Seagate 3TB drives in RAID6, this should give me 24-27TB usable which I can't see me outgrowing for 3+ years. Part of the reason for the change of mind about the DS380 is that I already have a Coolermaster Tower case with 3 x Supermicro SATA HotSwap Chassis with the cooling fans....drives never get toasty and it's all one self contained unit with space for 15 drives cooled.

Reading around the LSI 9201-16i would seem the obvious choice but I haven't seen anywhere that it supports JBOD setups which I would need to be able to configure the Linux RAID....I have a fallback option of the Intel Expander Card but don't want to give up another PCIe slot if I can avoid it as I only have one spare in that machine.

The plan is to install the new 9201-16i and the drives temporarily outside the chassis on the floor, configure the RAID6 array (empty so should be a lot quicker), then do the data copy from the existing array. Once I'm happy that everything is OK remove the existing 2TB drives and put aside for 4-6 weeks as backup....remove existing M1015 and put the new 3TB drives into the Supermicro Chassis Slots....power up and cross fingers.

Are there any other cards I should consider and can anyone see any problems with the plan?

Thanks
 
The 9201 is a host bus adapter and not really a RAID card, so I can't see any reason it wouldn't do this. It's meant to do this as compared to a real RAID card. It seems to be based on the same SAS 2008 controller as the 9240 / IBM M1015.

There is some mention of using it for ZFS (which would be used in the same way you want to even if you are going with LVM or whatever) for example at http://zfsguru.com/forum/buildingyourownzfsserver/21

I do recommend to always flash the latest LSI firmware as soon as you get the card and verify that it works. Preferably before you actually set it up (though that's not really that important - you can flash firmware even if you'd already been using the card - I just like to do it first thing when the option is there). Firmware updates sometimes improve drive compatibility.

Also, I'd reconsider on the Seagates and get HGST or WD instead.
 
Last edited:
I have a LSI 9201-16i in one of my linux software raid servers here at work for a few years. No complaints at all. I will most likely purchase more of these when I need to expand the 70TB of storage we currently have. In this case the 9201-16i is used with mdadm raid6 with btrfs as the filesystem. I would use zfsonlinux raidz2 vdevs or raidz3 in future servers.
 
Thanks guys.

Are there any other (low cost) cards that will support at least 16 devices as JBOD I should consider and how much would I get for my M1015 2nd hand.
 
If you want low-cost, you should probably just get a second M1015 (if your board has another PCI-E slot).
 
As stated in the OP I don't want to give up my last spare card slot as I will need it for something else.

I already have another M1015...but as you'll remember I want to configure 11 or 12 drives into the new array and the M1015 only supports 8, thus the need for the 9201-16i (or appropriate alternatives as per the description).
 
Back
Top