looking for upgrade options

nekrosoft13

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 4, 2005
Messages
1,618
Looking for upgrade options.

I have 3 PCs that I kind of want to upgrade to add USB 3.0 and SATAIII options. Basically looking for CPU/Board. trying to do it on budget, not spend to much, but also not buy crap.
CPUs and boards that I replace I will sold to recover some of the cost. Have not payed attention to computer hardware recently.

Each boards need USB 3.0, SATAIII and eSATA.

Basic Specs for Main Rig
Intel I920
12GB DDR3 Ram (have one more 4GB stick to complete 16GB in new system)
EVGA x58 SLI (Missing USB 3.0, SATAIII)
Geforce GTX480 (will stay for now)
Corsair 90GB SSD + 2 2TB hard drives, 2 optical drives

For main rig i'm looking to stay with Intel, just can't decide if I should go for 2011 socket X79 or downgrade to 1155 socket. With either options I will just have to buy CPU and Board, Ram I'm covered. Anyone know if CPU cooler (original Thermalright True 120) from I920 be used on 2011 or 1155?

Basic Specs for Server
AMD AM3 6-Core CPU (not a bulldozer) (forgot the actual model number)
16GB DDR3
Gigabyte 890GX Board (Missing USB 3.0)
Onboard Video
Intel SSD, and 8 Hard drives + 2 optical drives

For server i'm looking to stay with AMD, I believe there is a new version of bulldozer coming out called piledriver that will be on AM3+ socket. Anyone know when will that happen? Can AM3 CPU be used in AM3+ socket while I wait for that new piledriver. Anyone know if AM3 CPU cooler can be used on AM3+?

Basic Specs for HTPC
AMD AM2 4 Core Athlon 640 or 630 series
8GB DDR2 (will need to get DDR3 also)
MSI 760G board (missing USB 3.0, SATAIII and eSATA)
Nvidia Geforce lower end 500 series
Patriot SSD, and 1TB hard drive, 2 optical drives

For the HTPC I will also stay with AMD, Looking for miniATX board and will be buying miniATX case. Will have to upgrade to DDR3 also. Using 939 cooler that was adapted to AM2, anyone know if AM2 compatible cooler will work on AM3+? Was thinking about the A series AMD CPUs, but will have to keep the Nvidia card, because ATI (at least 4 cards that I tried) have problem playing H264 Multisliced files.

Advice will be appreciated.
 
Last edited:
  • TRUE 120 does not come with mounting hardware for 1155 or 2011. I know they make an accessory that adds 1155 support, but I don't know about 2011 support.
  • Yes, AM2 coolers are compatible with AM3 and AM3+, they all use that weird lever thingy, they are interchangeable.
 
Go LGA1155 unless you absolutely need more than 32gb RAM or tri-SLI/crossfire.

As for the HTPC, go with FM2 (when it comes out). Or go with FM1 clearance stuff. It uses the same mounting system as AM2/AM3+, and it'll allow you to get rid of the nVidia card if the iGPU works out.
 
Go LGA1155 unless you absolutely need more than 32gb RAM or tri-SLI/crossfire.

As for the HTPC, go with FM2 (when it comes out). Or go with FM1 clearance stuff. It uses the same mounting system as AM2/AM3+, and it'll allow you to get rid of the nVidia card if the iGPU works out.

Does the 1155 or 2011 have better usb e3.0 and sata 3 support?
 
Does the 1155 or 2011 have better usb e3.0 and sata 3 support?

Current LGA 2011 chipsets (including the X79) still require third party controllers for USB 3.0 support. Most 7-series chipsets for LGA 1155 have native USB 3.0 support for up to four USB 3.0 ports.
 
What are some decent 1155 boards? Z77 chips seem to be the best. Trying to decide between gigabyte and Asus. One asrock extreme6 looks nice but performance seems spotty.
 
What is your budget?

My brand recommendations are usually:
MSI
Asus
Gigabyte
 
Asus P8Z77-V PRO/Thunderbolt, MSI Z77A-GD80, and Gigabyte GA-Z77X-UP5 have thunderbolt and are around $250.
 
Hate buying a new board all of them are flawed....

any recommendations with sata 3 usb 3 and esata minus the thunderbolt that don't have gimped pci-e 3.0?
 
Hate buying a new board all of them are flawed....

any recommendations with sata 3 usb 3 and esata minus the thunderbolt that don't have gimped pci-e 3.0?

Actually, PCI-e 3.0 support depends on the CPU that you're going to be putting on the board. If you're going with only a Sandy Bridge CPU on a Z77 motherboard, the PCI-e controller on the CPU is only PCI-e 2.0 compliant.

On the other hand, current LGA 2011 platforms do not officially support PCI-e 3.0 although some motherboard manufacturers "unofficially" enabled this support.
 
Hate buying a new board all of them are flawed....

any recommendations with sata 3 usb 3 and esata minus the thunderbolt that don't have gimped pci-e 3.0?

The Z77 Extreme 6 is actually a really decent board which has all your mentioned features. The advantage of the Z77 chipset would be native USB3 support and more USB3 ports than any other chipset.
 
Actually, PCI-e 3.0 support depends on the CPU that you're going to be putting on the board. If you're going with only a Sandy Bridge CPU on a Z77 motherboard, the PCI-e controller on the CPU is only PCI-e 2.0 compliant.

On the other hand, current LGA 2011 platforms do not officially support PCI-e 3.0 although some motherboard manufacturers "unofficially" enabled this support.

Intel really did drop the ball with x79....

With z77 I meant that installing 2-3 devices drops the pci-e to 8x and 4x...
 
Intel really did drop the ball with x79....

With z77 I meant that installing 2-3 devices drops the pci-e to 8x and 4x...

Which doesn't matter as far as real world performance goes.

And it's not a gimp. The CPU physically only has 16 PCI-E lanes for graphics cards.
 
The Z77 Extreme 6 is actually a really decent board which has all your mentioned features. The advantage of the Z77 chipset would be native USB3 support and more USB3 ports than any other chipset.

I was this close to buy that board. But then I found few reviews comparing that board to other z77 boards and it's 10-20fps slower for some reason...
 
Which doesn't matter as far as real world performance goes.

And it's not a gimp. The CPU physically only has 16 PCI-E lanes for graphics cards.

How will that affect my gtx 480 (later gtx 680) when I install raid (or something) card that required pci-e 4x into bottom pci-e slot. And it cuts my video card bandwidth to either 8x or 4x.
 
How will that affect my gtx 480 (later gtx 680) when I install raid (or something) card that required pci-e 4x into bottom pci-e slot. And it cuts my video card bandwidth to either 8x or 4x.

Short answer: it won't. And you should be installing the RAID card in the second PCI-E 16x slot unless you plan to put another graphics card there.

Long answer: no current generation cards are bottlenecked by PCI-E 3.0 8x. This includes the dual-GPU cards like the GTX 690 (dual GTX 680s on one card). Even PCI-E 2.0 8x barely has an effect on GTX 680 performance, and that is equivalent to PCI-E 3.0 4x. And the primary PCI-E slot will always, at minimum, run at 8x performance.

Additionally, the CPU will always have at maximum 16x lanes to communicate with the graphics cards, raid cards, etc. How boards like the Premium get more lanes is to have a duplex chip that doubles the amount of lanes coming out, but the amount of lanes between the CPU and that duplex chip will always be 16x. Not to mention, the duplex chip does add some latency.
 
I was this close to buy that board. But then I found few reviews comparing that board to other z77 boards and it's 10-20fps slower for some reason...

I can't understand that how can a board be measured in frame rates?
As far as I know, there's no such thing as that, must be a fluke.
 
Few boards that I'm considering, looking for advice.

AsRock Fatal1ty Z77 Professional
Pros:
16+8 Power Phase Design - should result in better power management and OC
Dual Nic with teaming...
Virtu Universal MVP
6 SATA3
4 SATA2
eSATA3
8 USB 3.0
Realtek® ALC898
Ok price, around $220

Cons
PCI slots
only 2 SATA3 support RAID
eSATA disables one SATA3
Broadcon NICs (Intel is better)
IDE? WTH for
Floppy? WTH for
Fatal1ty branding
no thunderbolt

AsRock Z77 Extreme6
Pros:
Virtu Universal MVP
4 SATA3
4 SATA2
eSATA3
6 USB 3.0
Mini PCI-E
Realtek® ALC898
Good price, around $180

Cons
PCI slots
only 2 SATA3 support RAID
eSATA disables one SATA3
Broadcon NICs (Intel is better)
Floppy? WTH for
questionable performance according to some reviews
no thunderbolt

Asus P8Z77-V DELUXE
Pros:
4x PCI-E 1x
Dual Nic
Intel Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
4 SATA3
4 SATA2
2 eSATA3
8 USB 3.0
USB 3.0 Boost UASP Mode
thunderbolt header for future expansion
dual band wi-fi (not really necessary, but not bad)
bluetooth 4.0
Realtek® ALC898


Cons
no NIC teaming
high price, around $280

Asus Maximus V Formula
Pros:
3x PCI-E 1x
mini PCI-E
Intel Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
6 SATA3
2 SATA2
1 eSATA2
1 mSATA2
6 USB 3.0
USB 3.0 Boost UASP Mode
dual band wi-fi (not really necessary, but not bad)
bluetooth 4.0
Realtek® ALC898


Cons
eSATA disables one SATA3
no NIC teaming
no thunderbolt
high price, around $280

Asus Maximus V Extreme
Pros:
5x PCI-E 16x!!!!!!!!
mini PCI-e
Intel Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
6 SATA3
3 SATA2
1 mSATA2
8 USB 3.0
USB 3.0 Boost UASP Mode
dual band wi-fi (not really necessary, but not bad)
bluetooth 4.0
Realtek® ALC898
Thunderbolt


Cons
no NIC teaming
no thunderbolt
Someone dropped ASUS on their head price, around $380

EVGA Z77 FTW
Pros:
5x PCI-E 16x!!!!!!!!
Marvel Nics
Dual Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
4 SATA3
4 SATA2
2 eSATA2
6 USB 3.0
Realtek® ALC898

Cons
Realtek® ALC889
no NIC teaming
no thunderbolt
HIGH price, around $300-320

GIGABYTE G1.Sniper 3
Pros:
4x PCI-E two at 16x, two at 8x
Atheros Killer Nic
Intel Nic
Dual Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
6 SATA3
4 SATA2
1 nSATA2
10 USB 3.0
Creative CA0132

Cons
no NIC teaming
no thunderbolt
Higher price, around $280

Gigabyte GA-Z77X-UP5-TH
Pros:
Intel Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
4 SATA2
1 mSATA2
1 eSATA3
10 USB 3.0
Realtek ALC898, somehow supports EAX 5.0
Dual Thunderbolt
OK price, around $250

Cons
Thunderbolt support hindges/disables some SATA, USB ports
PCI slot
only 3 SATA3
no NIC teaming
questionable customer reviews on various store sites

MSI Z77A-GD80
Pros:
Intel Nic
Virtu Universal MVP
4 SATA3
4 SATA2
Realtek ALC898
Thunderbolt
OK price, around $250

Cons
Thunderbolt support hindges/disables some SATA, USB ports
only 4 USB 3.0
only 2 SATA3 support raid
no NIC teaming
bad experience with MSI in past
 
Still trying to fully figure that out.

Pci-e, don't want pci.
Plenty of sata3, usb3.0, 2 esata with port multiplier option.
Intel nic preffered, marvel, atheros, realtek also ok.
Good oc and runs cool
Room For decent cooler
Decent onboard audio. Support for eax 5.0+
Thunderbolt if possible.
Fully functional board, using one feature shouldn't disable different feature
MInI pci-e would be nice.
 
It sounds like the Asus Deluxe is the best fit for you in my opinion. It is designed to have a generous amount of modern inputs/outputs, OC competitively, and be reliable. I'm running the Z68 version and have been very happy with it as well.
 
The boards I listed above have Thunderbolt. Did you look at the P8Z77-V Pro/Thunderbolt?

It seems like Thunderbolt will definitely disable some things, because those things have to share bandwidth with Thunderbolt. IB only has so much bandwidth available in its DMI interface (connection to southbridge), so using a high bandwidth interface like Thunderbolt will definitely reduce the available bandwidth for other things.

Any $150+ board will basically overclock the same.

Pretty much all boards with the exception of the Gigabyte G1.Sniper3 use the same or similar Realtek audio. You aren't going to find any differences here.

You said Intel NIC preferred, but then went on to say everything else is okay. Pretty much means you don't care what NIC you have.
 
Another thing that I'm looking for is driver support. I want all components on the board to have drivers available for download from the company that actually made the hardware. I don't want to rely on good nature of board manufacture to get me the drivers.

Had bad experience with Dell and weird components like sigmatel or alps that don't provide drivers for download and Dell would never release updated versions.
 
Asus, Gigabyte, and MSI are all good for that. ASRock as well, but they have some quality control issues with their boards.
 
The boards I listed above have Thunderbolt. Did you look at the P8Z77-V Pro/Thunderbolt?

It seems like Thunderbolt will definitely disable some things, because those things have to share bandwidth with Thunderbolt. IB only has so much bandwidth available in its DMI interface (connection to southbridge), so using a high bandwidth interface like Thunderbolt will definitely reduce the available bandwidth for other things.

Pretty much all boards with the exception of the Gigabyte G1.Sniper3 use the same or similar Realtek audio. You aren't going to find any differences here.
Yeah I did look at pro/thunderbolt. Pci-e 1x placement is not ideal. Pci not needed. no esata.

Trying to decide if I even need thunderbolt.

As far as realtek I know they are all very similar. 898 seems to be the best. On one board they somehow managed eax 5.0 with 898.
 
It sounds like the Asus Deluxe is the best fit for you in my opinion. It is designed to have a generous amount of modern inputs/outputs, OC competitively, and be reliable. I'm running the Z68 version and have been very happy with it as well.

Yeah I do like that board. Premium is also nice, but premium price is insane. They must have been high when they priced that board.
 
Yeah I do like that board. Premium is also nice, but premium price is insane. They must have been high when they priced that board.

Pretty sure they knew exactly what they were doing. Those duplex chips aren't cheap. At that price point, going X79 might be a better bet.
 
That sniper looks good. Dual usb 3.0 headers are nice.

One for my lianli case. One for my usb 3.0 card reader.
 
asrock extreme 1155 motherboard is very good and quite cheap.

also i advise you look for used 2600k/2700k, they can be usually found for $220-230
 
Damn it.... still cant decide on board...

Maximus v formula is nice... but thats stretching my budget..
P8z77-v deluxe I can get for 230 Brand new.... its a nice board
Gigabyte ga-z77x-ud5h i can get for 130...
 
The prices for those mobos seem off: Are those used prices or what?
 
nope brand new, can get a deal. just bought 3770k and ud5h.

cpu for 290 and board for 130, cooler won't arrive till middle of next week....
 
Main rig been upgraded to 3770k and p8z77v deluxe for over a month super stable so far. Now looking for server and htpc upgrades.
 
Back
Top