Looking for a good and reliable External Drive

Oohah

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 13, 2006
Messages
91
Hello,

My laptop is running out of disk space and I'm thinking about getting an external drive to backup all my files. I was thinking about getting the Maxtor 500gb Onetouch4 Plus but some of the reviews (mostly bad) I found on the internet got me worried.

For those of you who have used (or are currently using) this drive, what are your impressions of it? Also, any suggestions on what (USB 2.0) drive I should purchase? I'm looking for something reliable that I can carry in my bag everyday.

Thanks in advance~! :)
 
Are you concerned with bundled backup software and the like? It's usually trash, and until recently the stuff Maxtor and Seagate (same company) where bundling was incompatible with Vista but they happily ignored this.

Were I you I'd pick up one of the newer Seagate externals. 5 year warranty, should be reliable enough, probably a little more expensive but faster. The backup button this has always felt... gimmicky to me.
 
Do yourself a favor and don't buy one of those premade units.

They're just internal drives in an external case and you're much better off buying each seperately and "rolling yur own" by installing the drive in the case. It's pretty much a no-brainer.

With those premades, you can't remove the drive to troubleshoot problems without voiding the warranty.

If you're going to be carrying this thing around, why not get a 2.5" (laptop HD like this 500GB 5400rpm WD unit) and match it to a 2.5" enclosure.

Grab a copy of Acronis True Image for back-ups and you're good as gold! ;)
 
Do yourself a favor and don't buy one of those premade units.

They're just internal drives in an external case and you're much better off buying each seperately and "rolling yur own" by installing the drive in the case. It's pretty much a no-brainer.

With those premades, you can't remove the drive to troubleshoot problems without voiding the warranty.

If you're going to be carrying this thing around, why not get a 2.5" (laptop HD like this 500GB 5400rpm WD unit) and match it to a 2.5" enclosure.

Grab a copy of Acronis True Image for back-ups and you're good as gold! ;)

Totally agree with making you own. I'm using 2 externals.
1 x 3.5" 1.5TB Seagate with a Thermaltake Max-4 for lots of storage
1 x 2.5" 500GB 5400RPM WD for a small "pocket" drive for music, backup, and misc crap.

Definitely get Acronis TI. Just used it last night to move my OS drive from a 5400RPM drive to a 7200RPM Drive (both 320GB). Took about 90 minutes to do the move and it was FLAWLESS!!!
 
Thanks for replying everyone~! :)

The reason why I don't want to get a normal hard drive + case is because I will need to carry around a power connector too. There are some premade models out there like the Seagate FreeAgent that don't need to be powered up via an adapter and that's a plus for me~!

N00B QUESTION: Does an external drive work like a memory card? For instance, if I plug the external drive to my laptop will I be able to select a video from the drive and play it without having to do a transfer onto the laptop???
 
Most of the 2.5" compatible enclosure are USB powered. Full sized 3.5" drive enclosures usually require a power adapter.

Yes, the drive will just show up in the list under My Computer and you can use the files off of it without transferring.
 
This WD 2.5" HDD is prefect for what you are looking for and is USB Powered. It is currently on sale and has free shipping. For this,it will be hard to beat the price (even if you build yourself). Once plugged in, it is just like any other drive. The speed on the HDD is sufficient to play videos from. I store my iTunes foler on it as it takes up to much space on my local HDD and only need it when I have iTunes open.
 
Well, I finally settled for the Western Digital My Passeport Elite 500GB~! It has a 5 year warranty and is just what I needed! Very small and compact!

Thanks to all who have replied! :)

Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go download some porn now. :eek:
 
Back
Top