Looking at possible upgrade for christmas...

Private_Ops

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
1,870
1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
--- Web Browsing/Gaming (nothing high end.. CoH/CS:S/DoW)

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
--- Upwards of $400 (no more than $500)

3) Where do you live?
--- Ohio

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
--- (*Possibly* Board) / RAM / Video Card / PSU / Case

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
--- reusing Athlon BE-2400 / 80GB SATA HD / IDE DVD burner / SB Audigy (maybe)

6) Will you be overclocking?
--- no

7) What size monitor do you have or plan to have?
--- I'm currently using my LCD TV (1366x768), but will more than likely go back to my 19" WS (1440x900)... so go with the latter.

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
--- *Stated in Thread Title* Around Christmas

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
--- Firewire


I'd like to stick to SFF so I can reuse my current board (Foxconn 780G).
The only parts I really have included in any list that I definitely want is this.

So what does the almighty [H] recommend?
 
CPU - Intel Core 2 E7300(2.66ghz) for $120 w/free shipping
Mobo/Ram (Combo Deal) Asus P5Q Pro + OCZ Fatal1ty edition 4gig DDR2 800 for $133
Video - Sapphire Radeon HD 4850 for $150($20 MIR)
Case/Psu (Combo Deal) - Antec 300 case + Antec NeoPower 500W for $90

Boom ---> $493

Nevermind your Athlon BE-2400/Foxconn Mobo. Sorry not SFF though. But, pretty kick ass for under $500.


Hmm... what about this?

Intel Core 2 Duo e5200
MSI P43 Neo3-F
Transcend 4GB (2 x 2GB)
eVGA 9600GT 512MB
COOLER MASTER Centurion 590
Antec Neo Power 500

--> $414 (might go up since some things are on sale)

Man, didn't know I could do that under 500 :eek:
 
You would be better served spending the extra money to get the HD4850 over the 9600GT.

You might as well get the more expensive RAM as well; the shipping costs of the Transcend kit will mostly negate its potential savings.
 
You would be better served spending the extra money to get the HD4850 over the 9600GT.

You might as well get the more expensive RAM as well; the shipping costs of the Transcend kit will mostly negate its potential savings.

It's not like I'm ordering this tomorrow... I've got time. I'll have to keep an eye on the shipping and stuff or any deals.

I'll look up on the cards... but since I plan to eventually dual boot Linux I'd like the Nvidia card... like I said though, I'll look up on the cards.


Alright... I've switched to the 4350.
 
SHows the 4830, which is = to the 9800GT. OP fails, reread the model number.
 
Not so good actually. Here's why.

The build I posted earlier is pretty damn solid although it costs more than what you listed

CPU - E7300 vs E5200
E7300 (2.66ghz) with 1066FSB and 3MB L2 cache
E5200 (2.50ghz) with 800FSB and 2MB L2 cache
10% overall faster performance with the E7300 cpu over E5200

Mobo - MSI P43 Neo3- F vs Asus P5Q Pro
Asus P5 Q Pro uses P45 chipset has an extra PCI-E slot and more features such as RAID, onboard Firewire which you mentioned you needed on a Mobo, 6 x USB ports and Coxial out.
MSI P43 Neo3-F uses a P43 chipset which has less features. 1 x PCI-E slot, No RAID, No Firewire onboard, 4 x USB ports and no COAX Out.


RAM - 4gig Transcend vs OCZ Fatal1ty Edition 4gigs
I wouldn't trust a generic cheapy brand such as Transcend. You can tell these are cheap. They don't even come with heatspreaders. OCZ FTW!


Video Card - 9600GT vs HD 4850
The 9600GT fails to compare with a HD4850. HD4850 will blows the 9600GT. I don't thik you should be paying over $100 upfront on a 9600GT.

Not bad the HD4830. It's performance is definitely better than a 9600GT and for a little more its worth it to get the HD4830 over that EVGA 9600GT video card. I would tweak what you had listed to this:

CPU - Intel Core 2 E7300(2.66ghz) for $120 w/free shipping
Mobo/Ram (Combo Deal) Asus P5Q Pro($15 MIR) + OCZ Fatal1ty edition 4gig DDR2 800 for $133
Video - PowerCooler Radeon HD 4830 for $120($20 MIR) w/free shipping
Case - Coolermaster Centurion 590 RC for $50 w/free shipping
PSU - Antec NeoPower 500W for $55 w/free shipping

Boom ---> $478




Hmm... what about this?

Intel Core 2 Duo e5200
MSI P43 Neo3-F
Transcend 4GB (2 x 2GB)
eVGA 9600GT 512MB
COOLER MASTER Centurion 590
Antec Neo Power 500

--> $414 (might go up since some things are on sale)

Man, didn't know I could do that under 500 :eek:
 
Not so good actually. Here's why.

The build I posted earlier is pretty damn solid although it costs more than what you listed

CPU - E7300 vs E5200
E7300 (2.66ghz) with 1066FSB and 3MB L2 cache
E5200 (2.50ghz) with 800FSB and 2MB L2 cache
10% overall faster performance with the E7300 cpu over E5200

Do you honestly think 10% is gonna make a difference for a casual gamer?

Mobo - MSI P43 Neo3- F vs Asus P5Q Pro
Asus P5 Q Pro uses P45 chipset has an extra PCI-E slot and more features such as RAID, onboard Firewire which you mentioned you needed on a Mobo, 6 x USB ports and Coxial out.
MSI P43 Neo3-F uses a P43 chipset which has less features. 1 x PCI-E slot, No RAID, No Firewire onboard, 4 x USB ports and no COAX Out.

My sound card has firewire onboard (SB Audigy). Don't need RAID either. If I ever had a use I'd be a decent RAID card.

RAM - 4gig Transcend vs OCZ Fatal1ty Edition 4gigs
I wouldn't trust a generic cheapy brand such as Transcend. You can tell these are cheap. They don't even come with heatspreaders. OCZ FTW!

I want something in the 1.8v range for sheer compatibility as far as voltages go.

Video Card - 9600GT vs HD 4850
The 9600GT fails to compare with a HD4850. HD4850 will blow the 9600GT. I don't think you should be paying over $100 upfront on a 9600GT.

I see no reason the 4830 wouldn't suit me. It's not like I'm gaming at super high resolutions.
 
Do you honestly think 10% is gonna make a difference for a casual gamer?
I say yes.

I want something in the 1.8v range for sheer compatibility as far as voltages go.
Then I recommend this RAM then since it has free shipping and is backed by a decent manufacturer:
G.Skill F2-6400CL5D-4GBPQ 2 x 2GB DDR2 800 RAM - $45

I see no reason the 4830 wouldn't suit me. It's not like I'm gaming at super high resolutions.

I would not recommend getting the HD4830 simply due to the fact that it's equal to the 9800GT in price and performance. Since Nvidia has better video card partners (BFG, eVGA, XFX) with better support and warranty than ATI's video card partners, I recommend going with the Nvidia 9800GT if support and warranty matters to you:
eVGA 512-P3-N971-TR GeForce 9800 GT 512MB PCI-E Video Card - $120

With that said, I would go with the HD4850 over the 9800GT/HD4830 in a heartbeat since the HD4850's performance over the those two cards is worth the lower quality in service and warranty length. But the 9800GT will be fine for 1440x900. I have the 8800GT, which is the older revision of the 9800GT, and it plays most of my games just fine at 1440x900. Granted not with as much AA as with the HD4850 but it's sufficient for my needs.
 
If you don't need the additional features of the P5Q Pro...

Mobo - MSI P43 Neo3- F vs Asus P5Q Pro
Asus P5 Q Pro uses P45 chipset has an extra PCI-E slot and more features such as RAID, onboard Firewire which you mentioned you needed on a Mobo, 6 x USB ports and Coxial out.
MSI P43 Neo3-F uses a P43 chipset which has less features. 1 x PCI-E slot, No RAID, No Firewire onboard, 4 x USB ports and no COAX Out.

... the P43 Neo3-F becomes a very good deal. (I take it that you don't really need those features... right?) The appeal of the P5Q Pro is the features it has for its price, the proven reputation it made for itself these past few months, plus the fact that right now it has some of the best NewEgg combo deals around (making it even cheaper than other similarly designed boards). But if all you need is a decent motherboard at a good price, the P43 Neo3-F fits the bill.
 
I take it that you don't really need those features... right?

Nope... anything other than your typical USB/ethernet/sound or whatever is a bonus for me.
The only thing that's in the house that uses firewire is the ipod and I even have a USB adapter for it :rolleyes:
 
The MSI P43 Neo3-F has the lower price, but the Asus P5Q Pro has the better deals (with other items).

Both are good boards, but if you plan on overclocking, and you don't want to spend much money on the board, you may also want to consider getting the Gigabyte GA-EP43-DS3L.

However, take a look at the combo deals for the P5Q Pro and see if they can help you save money on other components.
 
Back
Top