Little Demand for Microsoft's Surface RT Tablet

Status
Not open for further replies.
But if someone says "A Clover Trail machine is too slow to use desktop software on." and that's what I've been doing with a Clover Trail device for the last month and it actually does work pretty well for things that I've tested, what's the problem with me saying so especially if that person have never used a Clover Trail device?

It's one thing to say someone is wrong flat out, it's another to say "I just did the thing that you doesn't work and it seems to work pretty well for me and others I've talked to about it."

I use a single core Atom netbook and though I really like the design ideas beind Atom processors being power-efficient and running cool with simple, inexpensive motherboards, I'm pretty sure this thread is about the Surface RT tablet.
 
It's one thing to say someone is wrong flat out, it's another to say "I just did the thing that you doesn't work and it seems to work pretty well for me and others I've talked to about it."

You should try working on a tech support help desk sometime.
 
MY GOD eggs over easy are tasty. Does anyone else like eggs over easy?
 
MY GOD eggs over easy are tasty. Does anyone else like eggs over easy?

I like scrambled. And if you don't, why would you say so? I don't like people saying things on the internet that I don't agree with.
 
Well, Diablo III sold like madness and everyone now agrees it sucks. Initial enthusiasm has nothing to do with the quality of a product.

The opposite is true, too. Win8 on tablets can still be a huge success, or not. Only time will tell.

I don't know why every single tidbit that comes out around Win8 has to get all the hate from people who simple don't like it because "o no gimme back ma desktop", "o m$ teh sux greedy bastards", "o no it is not leenux". It's the same thing when people troll Apple threads just for the sake of it - you may be right, but it adds nothing to the discussion.

I don't see why should I get rid of my cheap chinese Android 7' tablet and get a Surface - but I don't see why should I get a iPad either. So iPad is teh sux... yes?
 
Well, Diablo III sold like madness and everyone now agrees it sucks. Initial enthusiasm has nothing to do with the quality of a product.

The opposite is true, too. Win8 on tablets can still be a huge success, or not. Only time will tell.

I don't know why every single tidbit that comes out around Win8 has to get all the hate from people who simple don't like it because "o no gimme back ma desktop", "o m$ teh sux greedy bastards", "o no it is not leenux". It's the same thing when people troll Apple threads just for the sake of it - you may be right, but it adds nothing to the discussion.

I don't see why should I get rid of my cheap chinese Android 7' tablet and get a Surface - but I don't see why should I get a iPad either. So iPad is teh sux... yes?

My eggs are better than your eggs.
 
I like scrambled. And if you don't, why would you say so? I don't like people saying things on the internet that I don't agree with.
How much experience do you have with over-easy? Unless you've had forks-on experience with a variety of incredible eggs in different settings (and on a multitude of different plates), you're really in no position to come to a reasonable conclusion as to whether you like scrambled better.

Over-easy is the most powerful, most capable egg cooking methodology ever concocted.
 
How much experience do you have with over-easy? Unless you've had forks-on experience with a variety of incredible eggs in different settings (and on a multitude of different plates), you're really in no position to come to a reasonable conclusion as to whether you like scrambled better.

Over-easy is the most powerful, most capable egg cooking methodology ever concocted.

Doesn't matter. There are NO eggs on the market to compete with scrambled. You're going to be eating scrambled one day anyway, so you might as well get used to it now. I mean, it's up to you what you want to eat, but you're clearly just afraid of change.
 
You also go to a hardware enthusiast forum to read reviews and browser through benchmarks to see performance figures, yet you're quick to dismiss those if they don't line up with your own perception of said product. Because, according to you at least, a CPU review using data and benchmarks is quite fine but as soon as it's applied to a Win8 tablet it's somehow misconstrued, beguiling, and doesn't truly represent the product.

I've never disputed these benchmarks because guess what? I ran them and got the same numbers. Why the hell would I dispute something I can see right in front of me?

Synthetic benchmarks are good at giving one a general idea of top end performance but they don't tell you when you have adequate performance when the top end is on the low side. And a on device like the 500T show me the benchmarks for the performance of touch gestures like pinch zoom or flick scrolling or how well the pen and ink technology work. I’d love to see them. I wasn't quick to dismiss anything, I spent lot of time testing a lot of things with this device.

It's easy to criticize others for being judgmental, but claiming that they should try the product, actually buy the product and spend hundreds of dollars, when hardware review and tech sites have been around for decades providing a service so you don't have to spend your money, time and effort senselessly, somehow belongs on a hardware enthusiasts forum?

Who said anything about buying something? I didn't. Overall I've agreed with the reviews I've seen for the 500T, though most of them have been pretty high level and brief that I've seen thus far. I think the only thing that I've completely disagreed with in a 500T review was an issue about the device locking up and not allowing other tasks to be done while downloading files. I've specifically tested multiple times downloading large multi-gigabyte ISO files with two different Internet connections while web surfing, playing video, inking, using Word, etc. and I never saw this. Some minor pauses here and there but the machine remained perfectly useable for other tasks.

It's not uncommon for two different people to see two different results on two different units of the same hardware. But really, do you think the device is supposed to lock up when downloading a file? I would think that’s not supposed to happen and if I and others can do it then there's something going on with that particular device or setup I'd say. I'm not saying that the reviewer in this case didn't have the problem, I'm saying he shouldn't have the problem and that's completely logical and fair.

You're being disingenuous, to say the least. Apparently we can derive performance of Intel's 2500K via benchmarks and how it performs in actual applications but as soon as we do that with a Windows8-based tablet your instinctual response is: try it first then form an opinion.

I don't have to. That's why we have review sites.

I've never said that reviews weren't a good thing. So you see a review site that says if one downloads a file on a 500T it locks up, period, can't multitask and that's that. I can easily demonstrate that I can indeed download large files and do other tasks without issue. So I'm supposed to believe a review site that says something doesn't work when it's working right in front of me? And when someone repeats this, never having actually tried it themselves, well of course it's going to be challenged in a place like this, that happens all of the time and there's nothing disingenuous about it. It could just be a defective unit, old drivers, router conflict, etc.

What’s more disingenuous? “I’ve seen some benchmarks and read some high level reviews so I know all there is about this piece of hardware.” or “I’ve been using this device for a number of weeks now, running a mix of desktop and Modern UI apps, connecting Bluetooth devices and an external monitor, watching 720P and 1080P local and steaming video and using it to create medium sized Office documents and overall the device should be capable of handling a lot of desktop needs for those that need office automation, basic non-game desktop apps, note taking with a pen, those types of things. It wouldn’t be any good for heavier and more demanding things like games and other intensive tasks.”
 
Both Gizmodo and ET noted the I/O inconsistencies and lockups. In fact, so have some owners of the devices themselves on review sites' forums.

It isn't a single person claiming that it's an issue, but two well renowned sites plus quite a few users.
 
ITT: People who have never used device discussed and feel because they read reviews online they are now all knowing and their opinion matters.



I would enjoy using a win8 rt tablet. And I am quite confident I would only need 30 minutes to say I would buy one. Quite a nice product.
 
Both Gizmodo and ET noted the I/O inconsistencies and lockups. In fact, so have some owners of the devices themselves on review sites' forums.

It isn't a single person claiming that it's an issue, but two well renowned sites plus quite a few users.

Quite a few........meaning?


Links to your information?
 
Both Gizmodo and ET noted the I/O inconsistencies and lockups. In fact, so have some owners of the devices themselves on review sites' forums.

It isn't a single person claiming that it's an issue, but two well renowned sites plus quite a few users.

Quite a few........meaning?


Links to your information?

I've had a Surface RT crash on me. Granted, I don't know how it was being used before I started playing with it. Still, a crash is a crash.
 
I was referring to the 500T that heatless is going on and on about, claiming it's a decent performer, refuting that there's a serious case of first gen-sies yet refusing to provide us even with little snippets of performance info.

In short, don't trust Gizmodo or ExtremeTech, but you should definitely listen to heatless.
 
I have some years ago. And indeed different people having different outcomes with the same thing is why the job is "interesting".

Probably too interesting for you. You'd just keep asking "It's fair enough that your screen is blue, but mine is just fine, so I don't know why you're wasting time telling me about it."
 
I was referring to the 500T that heatless is going on and on about, claiming it's a decent performer, refuting that there's a serious case of first gen-sies yet refusing to provide us even with little snippets of performance info.

In short, don't trust Gizmodo or ExtremeTech, but you should definitely listen to heatless.
Gizmodo is definitely on the same credibility level as Tom's Hardware and Endgagdet and all those other useless sites that cater to clueless consumers and not actual techies.

Well, Diablo III sold like madness and everyone now agrees it sucks.
The biggest problem with this site's forum discussions is the example quoted above. Did you just tell me that you talked to everyone that bought Diablo III and ALL OF THEM said it sucked? That data is impossible for you to get so I know that is a crock of shit.

As soon as people understand the statistical importance of knowing the difference between their sample and the total population, these debates will get far more useful and less trollish.
 
I was referring to the 500T that heatless is going on and on about, claiming it's a decent performer, refuting that there's a serious case of first gen-sies yet refusing to provide us even with little snippets of performance info.

In short, don't trust Gizmodo or ExtremeTech, but you should definitely listen to heatless.

Wait, is that the tablet that didn't play 1080p video perfectly smooth? Decent performer... no.. no.. noooooooooo....
 
Wait, is that the tablet that didn't play 1080p video perfectly smooth? Decent performer... no.. no.. noooooooooo....

Yep, that's the one.

People (and reviewers) have been having issues with I/O consistency, where downloading large files and installing large applications causes the mouse to lock up. Intel's WiFi/BT chip takes ages to work upon suspend/hibernate (the fix is still stuck in Samsung QA) and Samsung has issued new firmware/drivers to address certain keyboard lockups people have been having. Oh, and it's using an Atom that's 32-bit and a 3rd party GPU that has atrocious driver support.

Sounds wonderful, doesn't it?
 
Why do we care about a tablet with only 1366x768 resolution that can't play 1080p video that well?
 
Both Gizmodo and ET noted the I/O inconsistencies and lockups. In fact, so have some owners of the devices themselves on review sites' forums.

It isn't a single person claiming that it's an issue, but two well renowned sites plus quite a few users.

I've never said that there weren't some issues with the 500T, but that's a different subject than the performance of Clover Trail.

There are four reoccireing problems that I've tracked:

1. Slow establishment of WiFi connections on a cold boot. I think the problem there is a conflict between the WiFi and Bluetooth stack as I have seen the problem and was able to workaround it be using an external USB RT transceiver and turning off the internal BT radio. WiFi connections totally gone and BT works MUICH better now, far better range and performance.

2. Random lock ups. This seems to be less widespread than the first issue but I too have seen it though not of late since the BIOS update a couple of weeks ago.

3. Loss of sound. The sound will just stop and I seen this one all of the time if the machine has been on for 12 hours or more but it seems to have gotten better after I started using the USB BT radio. I reboot the machine once a day and the problem doesn't happen much anymore.

4. Issues with securing the tablet in the dock. I don't have the keyboard dock right now but I think what's happening to a lot of people is that they are forgetting to pull out the spacers in the clamping ports at the bottom. Once the tablet clamps securely into the ports the problem seems to be resolved.

So yeah, I've tested this thing extensively talked to people and tried to figure things out more than a high level review and have no problem reporting what I see, good and bad.
 
Why do we care about a tablet with only 1366x768 resolution that can't play 1080p video that well?
1080p is in many cases the only format people have available without transcoding, real-time or otherwise.

Sluggish 1080p playback would be a problem for me, as I don't transcode the movies/TV shows I buy to a lower resolution for tablet watching. It's a fixable problem, but drop-free 1080p playback is a capability offered on much less expensive tablets currently available, so it's an expectation with a higher-priced tablet that one would expect to offer greater performance.
 
1080p is in many cases the only format people have available without transcoding, real-time or otherwise.

Sluggish 1080p playback would be a problem for me, as I don't transcode the movies/TV shows I buy to a lower resolution for tablet watching. It's a fixable problem, but drop-free 1080p playback is a capability offered on much less expensive tablets currently available, so it's an expectation with a higher-priced tablet that one would expect to offer greater performance.

Eggsactly!
 
The biggest problem with this site's forum discussions is the example quoted above. Did you just tell me that you talked to everyone that bought Diablo III and ALL OF THEM said it sucked? That data is impossible for you to get so I know that is a crock of shit.

Tell that to people saying Win8 tablets sucks because Microsoft did not sell a billion units on the first millisecond after launch.
 
Wait, is that the tablet that didn't play 1080p video perfectly smooth? Decent performer... no.. no.. noooooooooo....

Yep, that's the one.

People (and reviewers) have been having issues with I/O consistency, where downloading large files and installing large applications causes the mouse to lock up. Intel's WiFi/BT chip takes ages to work upon suspend/hibernate (the fix is still stuck in Samsung QA) and Samsung has issued new firmware/drivers to address certain keyboard lockups people have been having. Oh, and it's using an Atom that's 32-bit and a 3rd party GPU that has atrocious driver support.

Sounds wonderful, doesn't it?

I've tested full screen 1080P playback from YouTube on an external 1080P monitor and that actually works fine as long as the primary display is disabled.

Pick a device, any device, we can all find people experiencing problems with it. I never said the 500T was perfect and didn't have problems but I've been using mine for a good while and it's certainly not been the experience that you're trying to characterize.

Since you don't own the device and don't seem to be buying one it is odd why you'd be so concerned about it and trying to find anything everything on the web about it that sates problems and ignoring everything else.
 
Since you don't own the device and don't seem to be buying one it is odd why you'd be so concerned about it and trying to find anything everything on the web about it that sates problems and ignoring everything else.

Since you do own the egg and like it scrambled and we know that from your endless posting about it in a thread about a Surface RT, it would be nice of you to let us get back to discussing the tablet in question. kthxbai.
 
Since you do own the egg and like it scrambled and we know that from your endless posting about it in a thread about a Surface RT, it would be nice of you to let us get back to discussing the tablet in question. kthxbai.

Eggs or tablets, tablets or eggs, which one to discuss the question begs. People like tablets, people like eggs, both a lot. Eggs you can fry in a pan but a tablet you should not.

Tablets or eggs, eggs or tablets, oh where to begin! I'll start with tablets as all this was written and converted to text with a pen.
 
1080p is in many cases the only format people have available without transcoding, real-time or otherwise.

Sluggish 1080p playback would be a problem for me, as I don't transcode the movies/TV shows I buy to a lower resolution for tablet watching. It's a fixable problem, but drop-free 1080p playback is a capability offered on much less expensive tablets currently available, so it's an expectation with a higher-priced tablet that one would expect to offer greater performance.
I completely understand that. But aren't there 720p options usually available for any media source that offers 1080p?

Eggs or tablets, tablets or eggs, which one to discuss the question begs. People like tablets, people like eggs, both a lot. Eggs you can fry in a pan but a tablet you should not.

Tablets or eggs, eggs or tablets, oh where to begin! I'll start with tablets as all this was written and converted to text with a pen.
Haha, congrats. You have out-trolled the King of Trolling. :D Not that I'm accusing Skribbel as being a troll, just using his words. He's the fun light-hearted type where at least half of his jokes are pretty funny.
 
I completely understand that. But aren't there 720p options usually available for any media source that offers 1080p?
Usually. It's just a question of whether you want to grab the 720p version specifically for tablet usage as a replacement of or in addition to the 1080p version. When I buy HD movies, I download the 1080p version because I have a 1920x1080 desktop display. I wouldn't want to have to download both 1080p and 720p because my tablet doesn't support the former well.

Live transcoding is another option, but I'm not aware of any software which supports that on Windows.
 
Eggs or tablets, tablets or eggs, which one to discuss the question begs. People like tablets, people like eggs, both a lot. Eggs you can fry in a pan but a tablet you should not.

Tablets or eggs, eggs or tablets, oh where to begin! I'll start with tablets as all this was written and converted to text with a pen.

I totally endorse this heatlesssun post! :)

Haha, congrats. You have out-trolled the King of Trolling. :D Not that I'm accusing Skribbel as being a troll, just using his words. He's the fun light-hearted type where at least half of his jokes are pretty funny.

I dunno what you're talking about! I would never troll anyone ever! There's a coat hangar halo over my Skribbel-y head right now. It's hiding the little red horns very well, I think!

But yeah, that is one of the best heatlesssun posts in the history of [H]ard|Forum. We need more of this kinda heatlesssun. MOOOOOORE!
 
Usually. It's just a question of whether you want to grab the 720p version specifically for tablet usage as a replacement of or in addition to the 1080p version. When I buy HD movies, I download the 1080p version because I have a 1920x1080 desktop display. I wouldn't want to have to download both 1080p and 720p because my tablet doesn't support the former well.

Live transcoding is another option, but I'm not aware of any software which supports that on Windows.
Oh yea I forget that they actually charge you separately for the different versions.
 
Doesn't matter. There are NO eggs on the market to compete with scrambled. You're going to be eating scrambled one day anyway, so you might as well get used to it now. I mean, it's up to you what you want to eat, but you're clearly just afraid of change.

There are several kinds of scrambled, some which others might not judge as such. There's the "marbled" style, where you break the eggs direct and scramble them on the heat. That way it gives it a "marbled" texture and makes the flavour less uniform, so you can have variances in yolk.
Then there's "hashed omulette" where you pretty much just cook a thick omulette then cut it up. This makes it less...in bits, and makes the chunk sizes more controllable. However it does lessen the flavor slightly, as there is less surface area in play. Though you can rememdy this by further cooking the egs on their sides or doing it once it has reached beyond a "plastic" (it's a sciency word) state!
These methods show that the same thing can be done right and wrong, and that even though it is all scrambled there is variances and irovements that can be given to it. Plain scrambled just doesn't work often.

Well, Diablo III sold like madness and everyone now agrees it sucks. Initial enthusiasm has nothing to do with the quality of a product.

it's a "market" product, so it needs a big market in order for things like the Windows Store to be attractive to developers. If the developers aren't interested due to the low numbers then the market is going to be less attractive.
 
Speaking of talking about a subject you know little about: about a year ago, or even longer, I remember arguing with you about trackpad scrolling on Macs versus PCs. You kept arguing that it's the same given the software you're using. No, it isn't. No one that has used a Mac would say that. But that didn't stop you from arguing that it's the "same".

Trackpads on Macs versus laptops running Windows are constantly compared. Lenovo and HP have probably come really, really close to finally beating Apple's version. You can argue (again) that MS doesn't make the hardware and can't control the software, and after you're done go back and read my point that the quality wasn't the same.

Hopefully, Windows 8 will be much better in this regard. I've tested laptops at the MS store and some still display the Tron-busy-disk icon while 2 finger right clicking. That should never happen when using 2 fingers to right click.

If you're referring to this I wasn't talking about track pads but gestures: http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1535627

All I was saying is that gesturing was available in 7 and that many of the same things existed in Windows as on OS X but worked differently.



I don't have a new Windows 8 laptop but I do have a Lenovo x220t that got new Windows 8 drivers for the track pad. Better than Windows 7, the gestures are kind of nice, but the pad is just to small for my tastes.

I did get a Logitech T650 desktop track pad, and that thing is kind of sweet. Great scrolling, accurate, some really great gestures for activating the Start Screen and getting back to the desktop. There's no reason for track pads not to be great on Windows 8 but the hardware has to be there and it's typically not been historically in Windows PCs. That should improve hopefully with 8.

That's not the thread I'm referring to. I should look for the thread I'm referring to just to dispute your statements about not challenging others on things others use all the time.
 
That's not the thread I'm referring to. I should look for the thread I'm referring to just to dispute your statements about not challenging others on things others use all the time.

lol, at least he doesn't challenge us in the enterprise or *NIX arenas. :p
 
That's not the thread I'm referring to. I should look for the thread I'm referring to just to dispute your statements about not challenging others on things others use all the time.

This must be what you're referring to: http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1604374&page=6

I did ask about how well you thought the Magic Pad would work with a triple monitors but I don't see where I said anything about track pad scrolling or saying that PC track pad scrolling was better. I've cared much for PC track pads and I've never had a PC track pad that I thought was very good until I got the Logitech T650 about a month ago.
 
I hate when people claim their machine can play 1080p, when it can't play the different types of encodes of 1080p. If I turn down the bitrate, most everything can play 1080p. I can get my P3 laptop with an 8 meg ATI Rage Mobility gpu to play it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top