Little Demand for Microsoft's Surface RT Tablet

Status
Not open for further replies.
Windows RT is censorware in which Microsoft gets to dictate what you can and cannot install on their tablet (it is not yours because in order to own the tablet, you must be free to install whatever software you want on it including other operating systems; in essence, you are paying $500 to lease a tablet that you never truly own).

Which is why I just bought an Android tablet.
Android is currently the only "open" tablet OS that lets me load whatever I want.
 
That makes no sense.
Why have an app available on Windows RT that can't be run on Windows RT?

I get that one could purchase an app on Windows RT designed for Windows 8 (x86), is that what you mean?

There are some Metro apps, Windows RT apps, Windows Store apps, pick whatever name that you want that only work on x86. The first version of the Google Metro app for whatever reason was only x86 compatible. The vast majority of Metro apps in the Windows Store will run on Windows RT devices but there are some exceptions that are related to DX 10 games.

The simply way to put it is that some of the Windows RT API only works on x86/x64 and from what I can tell that involves at least some of the DX API which is supported in the Windows RT API.
 
The simply way to put it is that some of the Windows RT API only works on x86/x64 and from what I can tell that involves at least some of the DX API which is supported in the Windows RT API.
It sounds like Windows RT is more of a half-assed ARM-compiled variant that's not really complete, at least in a technical sense.
Yeah, I agree with the others, Microsoft is at least 5+ years behind in this area, and their high price tags are not helping the situation.
 
It sounds like Windows RT is more of a half-assed ARM-compiled variant that's not really complete, at least in a technical sense.
Yeah, I agree with the others, Microsoft is at least 5+ years behind in this area, and their high price tags are not helping the situation.

UNIX will always be ahead in this regard since portable code is big in the UNIX world.
 
That's not marketing material, that's the fine print. It is not present at the place of sale and chances are that it isn't at any B&M store. At any point in the print ads or the numerous television commercials does Microsoft mention the restricted nature of the Surface prominently?

So a page that says in big bold letters "Help Me Chose" between a Surface and Surface Pro and the FIRST thing that's mentioned on that page about the Surface RT is that it only runs Windows Store apps is fine print and isn't marketing material?
 
Critics have also noted that Windows RT is relatively closed platform in comparison to Windows 8 and other consumer-oriented versions of Windows. While Microsoft's mandate that certified Windows 8 hardware must ship with a secure boot feature enabled by default was met with criticism (despite the fact that users must be allowed to disable the function as needed), the requirement that Windows RT devices have secure boot permanently enabled was further criticized for harming user choice by preventing the installation of alternative operating systems such as Linux, despite its consistence with other consumer electronics which use similar protection measures.

Oh wow, fuck that.
Oh well, at least it's only locked down on Microsoft hardware, not PCs.

Yes, Microsoft is just as bad as Apple.
If I ever need a tablet, I'll definitely be going with a Droid.

Windows RT tablets and iPads, like I've been saying for years now, it's just mindless computing; guess that's what the masses want though, sad.
 
UNIX will always be ahead in this regard since portable code is big in the UNIX world.

Not to mention it doesn't use that awful registry that Windows utilizes.
/off topic

At least Office can still be used on Windows RT, I know a lot of individuals that functionality would assist quite a bit.
 
From Microsoft's website:
Surface with Windows RT is designed to run apps from the Windows Store, so you know you’re finding trusted applications that help you see more, share more, and do more. Let Windows Store help you discover the apps that keep you in touch, up-to-date, and in the know.
Until of course, that they deem said apps to be unsafe/unsecure/dangerous to their precious OS, and will then dump them all together.

I'm sorry, but unless this has proven support and backing for the future, Microsoft could dump this at anytime, and then boom, those apps you just purchase are now worthless and unsupported.
I'm not seeing a whole lot of reasons to trust Microsoft at this point, at least for this.


At any point in the print ads or the numerous television commercials does Microsoft mention the restricted nature of the Surface prominently?
They have no reason to be honest or upfront with their customers, it might make them "look bad" and potentially lose a profit (when in all reality, it would give them more trust from customers).
Also, they've been pushing Windows RT as an "ARM variant" of Windows 8, rather than a stripped down, lesser-version of it, making it more akin to an iPad at best.

I get that not everything will work across two processor architectures, but Microsoft isn't even trying at this point.
 
It sounds like Windows RT is more of a half-assed ARM-compiled variant that's not really complete, at least in a technical sense.
Yeah, I agree with the others, Microsoft is at least 5+ years behind in this area, and their high price tags are not helping the situation.

It's complete enough to support multiple monitors, a desktop, run desktop apps the complexity of Office and work with a large variety of printers. I don't disagree that there need to be cheaper devices but where talking about a lot of brand new stuff here, as production ramps prices will go down.

Proponents of Metro on the desktop have made the point that a standalone mobile OS from Microsoft would not have a great shot, and weakness in RT sales makes the point of why Microsoft put Metro on the desktop. The hybrid approach has a much better chance of success.

Windows RT is a hedge, the main platform for Windows 8 tablets will be Clover Trail. Yes, those aren't cheap either but in the same price range of iPad with similar amounts of storage and they can actually run a lot of desktop software and they have similar battery life, pricing and size as RT devices.
 
I'm sorry, but unless this has proven support and backing for the future, Microsoft could dump this at anytime, and then boom, those apps you just purchase are now worthless and unsupported.

Microsoft has poured billions into Windows 8 and tied practically its entire corporate future to the product and strategy, there's no way for them to turn back now.
 
I'm typing this from a Surface RT and love it! I really don't get all of the negative press as I've owned every major tablet OS and can say that this is nearly a perfect laptop replacement...which includes Office for free. That said, if they priced the RT at $499 with the Type cover, they wouldn't be able to keep them in stock.

I think a major obstacle is the demo exclusivity at Microsoft stores. With so many cheaper options, you really have to try one to see if it's worth it.
 
Microsoft has poured billions into Windows 8 and tied practically its entire corporate future to the product and strategy, there's no way for them to turn back now.

I sure hope so.
If not, it will leave a lot of very unhappy end-users.
 
I'm typing this from a Surface RT and love it! I really don't get all of the negative press as I've owned every major tablet OS and can say that this is nearly a perfect laptop replacement...which includes Office for free. That said, if they priced the RT at $499 with the Type cover, they wouldn't be able to keep them in stock.

I think a major obstacle is the demo exclusivity at Microsoft stores. With so many cheaper options, you really have to try one to see if it's worth it.

Price is the most important issue to someone looking at tablets. That and change is difficult.

If people are used to the Android or iOS interface, moving to a Windows 8 tile-based interface may seem off-putting. That and for a comparable price, one can get Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 or iPad, both have a more established ecosystem, larger app store, and familiar programs that'll run in either brand's OS-- Android or iOS.

Microsoft has to work harder with marketing the Surface RT and Surface Pro. It shouldn't just be about new ways to use Windows, but clearly state what the tablet offers over an Android or iOS-based tablet. Office is a good start, but that's only a small start.

Another is confusion. Many will think they can run their Windows desktop programs on Surface RT. And, Surface Pro is just slightly cheaper than a Samsung Slate at $1099 versus $899 for the Surface Pro. It's a very commanding price to ask for a new product.

Myself, I'd get the Surface Pro because I know already that my programs from my computer can run on it. It'll be like a touch-based laptop replacement for me. And, it's cheaper than the Samsung Slate. But, to normal consumers, they won't know that. A Surface RT and Surface Pro to a regular, non-[H] user may look the same to them. And, one is just "cheaper than the other, but both run Windows" and may end up getting the cheaper one.

Consumers are more likely to buy something more familiar to them and more than likely go by brand recognition. It's still going to be a while for consumers to be familiar with Windows on a tablet than being a really expensive Windows-based tablet or convertible laptop. That and consumers still believe, if going by one survey by the NY Times, that Windows has no place in the mobile space.

Windows Phone 7 and in effect, Windows Phone 8, products are still eclipsed by more familiar brands that use Android and especially iOS for iPhone. Consumers know more about Google's Android or Apple's iTunes than Windows Store or Xbox Music. I wouldn't be surprised that most consumers would just immediately relate any Xbox media service on the PC as being a Xbox 360 Xbox Live service only that needs Gold Membership.

Unfamiliar brand, product.confusion, and unestablished software and media ecosystem are working against Microsoft in my opinion. Their commercials and advertising have to show not only the benefits of Windows on a tablet than they did before with convertible laptops with Windows XP, Vista or 7, but also distinguish between what is a Surface RT and Surface Pro. For example, explain that Windows 8 RT won't run all your Windows programs but similar products can be found in the Windows Store that can run on Surface RT. They also need to distance themselves away from Android and iOS products and show what their Windows 8 tablet offers more than an Android/iOS tablet, and that it's more than a multi-touch based OS that can do fancy things on it. Why? Apple and Google have been able to do the similar things for years on their related products with the multi-touch and the camera and the music and movies, etc. They have to also get their entertainment and software ecosystem better established, connected, easy to use and access, and put more products in them. Why? Because as we speak, both Google Play and iTunes App Store eclipse Windows Store and Windows Phone Store by a lot. They need developers and they need companies convinced this product will succeed. and woo them over to the Surface and Windows 8.

If not, this will end up like vaporware.
 
ive played with the RT... love the hardware, its pretty much perfect(full size USB, thin, light, magnesium alloy, magnetic power connector, usable kickstand that is out of the way when you dont need it, great screen) . Now if only Microsoft could make decent software. I received windows 8 for free and have it installed, but I still boot into 7 everyday. even ended up setting it as my default in the windows 8 bootloader. I find no compelling reason to boot into windows 8.

disclaimer: my work phone is windows 8 and I own an xbox (with gold membership). My personal is still my galaxy nexus. I do have to admit that i like the wireless charging on my HTC 8x though.
 
Surface Pro makes absolutely zero sense. I'd rather get the Acer W700. Cheaper and probably will have more power. It's also available now, while the Surface Pro isn't.

I'm thinking that my next phone will be a Windows phone. Want to see how those phones work out. Would be nice to see Google actually fix crap on Android. Like allow photo sorting via names, instead of the other stupid date, size, etc junk they have. Also playlists for the built-in gallery/video player. Sick of having to search for apps that has some of these features. I find ones with the features, but the apps are clunky. Crash all the time.

I can't imagine life would be much different on a Windows phone, but I've never tried one out, so it's a good enough reason to see how life is there.
 
Not to mention it doesn't use that awful registry that Windows utilizes.
/off topic

At least Office can still be used on Windows RT, I know a lot of individuals that functionality would assist quite a bit.

Isn't that like an anti-trust issue. Microsoft exempts its own software from the WinRT restriction giving it two things. An additional headstart with office software and software that could exceed performance and/or features against competing WinRT based Office software.

And you don't get Live Tiles and full Windows Store support in WIn8 unless you're WinRT, I believe. And the flipside WinRT apps need to go through the Microsoft Store. Microsoft has created an even more controlled sandbox in the WinRT API.

As a side issue, I can't wait until the Live Tiles are used for ads and Microsoft successfully monetized my desktop and my hardware for ad space and I get absolutely nothing for it.
 
Not to mention it doesn't use that awful registry that Windows utilizes.
/off topic

At least Office can still be used on Windows RT, I know a lot of individuals that functionality would assist quite a bit.

Only for home-student use
 
If MS really wants the Surface to succeed, they ought to have them in every single store out there for the masses to play with and touch, not just pop-up holiday kiosks and MS stores in malls. Once you see one in person, play with it a little, and see how well it's built, it becomes so much easier to justify the $100 extra over an iPad it commands.
 
Why would they price this to compete against a shitty ARM tablet that can't do 10% of what this is capable of doing?


Because at the end of the day the tablet is still a tablet.

What can the RT do that an Android tablet cant?
 
filed under cognitive dissonance

Which is still a ramp up since zero Surface RT devices were sold last quarter. But I was referring to Windows 8/RT devices in general. More will be made, production will ramp up the supply chain and prices should go down. That's a pretty normal occurrence if sales start off slow.
 
Which is still a ramp up since zero Surface RT devices were sold last quarter. But I was referring to Windows 8/RT devices in general. More will be made, production will ramp up the supply chain and prices should go down. That's a pretty normal occurrence if sales start off slow.

Which doesn't bode well for OEMs and their Win8 products to be released in 2013.

The Surface RT was a sort of launch pad, along with the other few tablet/hybrids released with touch capability. The MS launch of Surface RT/Pro was meant to spur on the OEMs, and the sales figures of the RT should have created some interest among OEMs in making their own versions.

Of all Win8 machines sold, less than 1% are tablet convertibles. That includes the RT along with the 500T and whatever few remaining tablet convertibles are currently on the market.

If MS can't even sell their own product, how do you think the OEMs are feeling about dedicating resources to making these?

Win8 not selling well is a bad sign, but it's not horrible. Win8 will sell well over the long term for traditional PCs despite a slow start. The bigger issue here is that MS poured billions into marketing and has cut its sales expectations by half. Considering the OS itself was centered primarily around these devices and since they make up less than 1% of sales...
 
I thought everyone loves W8? Judging by the hordes of gloaters in the W8 threads I would have thought they would be all over it.

Nope most of us are waiting for the Surface Pro. I like the aesthetics and build design of them personally. I just see this as good news as it means that there is a possibility that MS will drop the initial price point for the Surface Pros. My Galaxy Tab 10.1 is getting old in the tooth and I'll be selling it as soon as I get the Surface Pro.
 
There's no need to wait for wait for Surface Pro if one wants a Windows 8 tablet and I believe that The Microsoft Store typically carries a number of Windows tablets. And as many have been commenting that more functional device has a number of tradeoffs, notably price and battery life. Person looking at Windows 8/RT devices needs to understand the three major platforms (ARM. Clover Trail, Core Series) and what the pros and cons are.

You replied to me just to reply. You didn't read the part where I stated customers ask about running desktop apps. After being told that no, the Surface can't run desktop apps, most customers say ok, I'll wait for the Surface Pro. It's pretty sad.
 
I'm typing this from a Surface RT and love it! I really don't get all of the negative press as I've owned every major tablet OS and can say that this is nearly a perfect laptop replacement...which includes Office for free.
If the Surface RT includes Office for free, the iPad includes a free Retina display, and inexpensive Android tablets include free money.
 
If the Surface RT includes Office for free, the iPad includes a free Retina display, and inexpensive Android tablets include free money.

Free MS office and slightly bigger screen like 12.1 inch. I wonder what is MS's logic for setting such high price?
 
Of all Win8 machines sold, less than 1% are tablet convertibles. That includes the RT along with the 500T and whatever few remaining tablet convertibles are currently on the market.

Read that NPD report again:

*Excludes sales of Microsoft Surface.

Yes Windows 8 tablet sales are low but there aren't many available at the moment.

Also touchscreen notebooks seem to be doing well:
"The strong performance of Windows 8 notebooks with touchscreens, where Windows 8 truly shines, offers some reason for optimism. These products accounted for 6 percent of Windows 8 notebook sales at an average price of $867 helping to re-establish a premium segment to the Windows consumer notebook market."


If MS can't even sell their own product, how do you think the OEMs are feeling about dedicating resources to making these?

This is a double edged sword, Microsoft is walking a fine line here, they don't want Surface to dominate and crowd out partners but obviously want Surface to be successful but whatever standards those are.

Win8 not selling well is a bad sign, but it's not horrible. Win8 will sell well over the long term for traditional PCs despite a slow start. The bigger issue here is that MS poured billions into marketing and has cut its sales expectations by half. Considering the OS itself was centered primarily around these devices and since they make up less than 1% of sales...

You're lumping too many things together. Windows 8 license sales seem to doing pretty well, upgrades are doing better than 7. Windows 8 hardware sales are not doing well and neither of these is counted with Surface RT sales.
 
You replied to me just to reply. You didn't read the part where I stated customers ask about running desktop apps. After being told that no, the Surface can't run desktop apps, most customers say ok, I'll wait for the Surface Pro. It's pretty sad.

So its sad that there's a variety of devices with different capabilities? And if it is very possible that the Surface Pro isn't even the device that many would want because of cost and battery life, a Clover Trail device might suite them better.

All I was saying is that there are options that need to be explained to people and understood. I bet a lot of people who think they need to runs Windows programs don't even need too.
 
Win8 sales to OEMs are doing well, not the sales to the end consumer. Sales of devices are down overall. There are a lot of Win8 products collecting dust on shelves at retailers. At the same time this year, MS sold more Windows licenses and Windows products to consumers than they have Windows 8 in its first quarter.

Also touchscreen notebooks seem to be doing well:

No, notebook shipments are down 24% year-over-year. 24%!!! The average selling price of touchscreen notebooks is higher but so is the bill of materials. You can't judge success by the selling price if the sales of the products are down 24%.
 
121130_fbr_tablets3_900.jpg


Berger wrote that early indications suggest that the Microsoft Surface RT Tablet has thus far underperformed, with cost—in the neighborhood of $600—being the most likely culprit. FBR projects total sales of 1.2 million Surface RT Tablets in the fourth quarter.

The FBR tablet tracker report also concluded that sales of the Google Nexus 7 and the Amazon Kind Fire HD tablets have been higher than expected, owing to their $199 price points.

"Contrary to what we see for the Kindle Fire and Google Nexus, we believe the first month's sales of the MS Surface RT tablet have underwhelmed expectations," Berger wrote.

It's always about price unless you're Apple. Microsoft can't afford to charge such obscene prices and high markups. They clearly think way too highly of themselves
 
Win8 sales to OEMs are doing well, not the sales to the end consumer. Sales of devices are down overall. There are a lot of Win8 products collecting dust on shelves at retailers. At the same time this year, MS sold more Windows licenses and Windows products to consumers than they have Windows 8 in its first quarter.

But Microsoft specifically said that Windows 8 upgrades were outpacing Windows 7 upgrades at this point.

No, notebook shipments are down 24% year-over-year. 24%!!! The average selling price of touchscreen notebooks is higher but so is the bill of materials. You can't judge success by the selling price if the sales of the products are down 24%.

But how many touch screen notebooks were sold last year. And you do realize that NPD is only retail, no online sales are in that mix. We can bandy this around all day long, the real data won't be out until financials are reported next month by Microsoft and its partners. That's really the first real test on Windows 8 and we'll see then how it looks. My guess is that it will be not great but not bad either, which is what seems to be the consensus at this point.
 
It's always about price unless you're Apple. Microsoft can't afford to charge such obscene prices and high markups. They clearly think way too highly of themselves

You can't compare Microsoft how works with OEMs for the vast majority of its devices with Apple. I'm not saying that prices on RT devices don't need to be lower, but Microsoft CANNOT undercut its OEMs. If Microsoft really wanted to push Surface RT it would have not licensed RT to its OEMs and Surface RT would be the only Windows RT device and they would have sold it all through retail instead of just its own channels.

I'm not saying that Surface RT is doing well nor am I trying to rationalize Surface RT's sales performance. But I do think that if Microsoft went out and truly did an Apple here they could sell many more Surface RT devices. They day may come when they do lower the price and do open up the distribution. But that only creates another set of issues with OEMs.
 
But Microsoft specifically said that Windows 8 upgrades were outpacing Windows 7 upgrades at this point.

With the 40m figure that referred to overall sales, including the all-important volume licenses.

But how many touch screen notebooks were sold last year. And you do realize that NPD is only retail, no online sales are in that mix. We can bandy this around all day long, the real data won't be out until financials are reported next month by Microsoft and its partners. That's really the first real test on Windows 8 and we'll see then how it looks. My guess is that it will be not great but not bad either, which is what seems to be the consensus at this point.

A majority of sales are still through retail and online shopping isn't going to surpass it until 2020, and that's according to the British chap I listened to this morning :p

Halving the Surface RT orders, falling short of their own internal estimates, for Win8 licenses sold, a -9% desktop and -24% laptop decrease in sales year-over-year and a paltry less-than-1% convertible sales is "not great but not bad either" to you?

1845611_o.gif


They're losing sales in the traditional PC space and not they're not making them up in the mobile segment.
 
You can't compare Microsoft how works with OEMs for the vast majority of its devices with Apple. I'm not saying that prices on RT devices don't need to be lower, but Microsoft CANNOT undercut its OEMs. If Microsoft really wanted to push Surface RT it would have not licensed RT to its OEMs and Surface RT would be the only Windows RT device and they would have sold it all through retail instead of just its own channels.

And that's the problem. Somewhere in the production and planning of these devices, some dumbass at Microsoft forgot that OEMs make them huge amounts of money and that Microsoft has no significant retail presence. So instead of opting to work closely work partners (see Google's Nexus approach) they instead decide to

A - increase the price of Win8 RT by bundling it with Office. Now OEMs are going to pay $85 for an ARM-based tablet that's going up against ~$200-300 Android devices. They were fucked from the beginning.

B - Release their own product, which they now have no choice to price high in order to not backstab their OEMs by undercutting them and allowing a nice gap for them to remain competitive and still make a profit.

C - Prematurely jump aboard the Intel ULV bandwagon and utilize a 17W ULV with no S0ix sleep state and advanced idle states that has a 4 hour battery life.


Steve Ballmer is going to lose his job next year.
 
The true seed of stubborness of "this is all we need" started with Windows XP, but thanks to the 32 bit limit, it blossomed into a beautiful flower in the form of Windows 7 64 bit. Peace out Microsoft, we won't need another OS for atleast 15 years, feel free to continue releasing random garbage OS's no one will use.
 
With the 40m figure that referred to overall sales, including the all-important volume licenses.

....

First you say that NPD report included sales of Surface RT which it COULDN'T have because Microsoft hasn't released those numbers. Secondly you say that end user licenses are down when Microsoft reported that Windows 8 upgrades are outpacing Windows 7 at this point. Then when I quote the NPD report saying that touchscreen notebook sales were strong (NPD's words, not mine) you then point out the 24% year-over-year decline in notebook sales in that NPD reporting ignoring that fact there were virtually ZERO touchscreen notebook sales in retail last year.

Talk about tap dancing.
 
Because at the end of the day the tablet is still a tablet.

What can the RT do that an Android tablet cant?
What kind of question is that?

That is like saying that a car is just a car, and following up with "what can a Ford Mustang GT do that a Camaro SS can't"... yes they compete, but the devil is in the details and they won't in any way feel or work exactly the same.
 
Steve Ballmer is going to lose his job next year.

And 2013 is the year of Linux. Microsoft has it's challenges not doubt, but this company is still growing and routinely making record profits and has only reported one money losing quarter in 25 years which was a write-down where it actually didn't loose money.

Maybe Ballmer will get fired, maybe Windows 8 will not be successful, but it just seems that people who say this every year only look at stock price and not the overall performance of the company. If Windows 8 doesn't do well I would imagine that Ballmer will be in a hell of a lot of trouble. But with only a month into Windows 8 its all guess work at this point as to how this going to play out, that's all I'm saying. If you think this is all going to go down hill then you should short a bunch of Microsoft stock and pray that your crystal ball is working.
 
Of course. Microsoft is too late and people don't care. There are too many other (better) choices, like the Kindle Fire HD, Nexus 7 and iPad and soon to be Firefox OS.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top