LinuxWorld Sucking is Good News?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Since when has it ever been a “good sign” when your big tech show of the year is a bust? I hear people like this say stuff like this but only when it's convenient. If no one showed up for Apple’s big shindig would he be saying the same thing? Ummm, no. If CES bombed would the tune be the same? I doubt it. Am I wrong on this one? Is low turn out for Linux events really “good news?”


Watching the scene from a less crowded vantage point, Cluster Resources president Michael Jackson found an inverse correlation between the dwindling number of people attending LinuxWorld and the spread of Linux into the mainstream. "The more mature the technology, the less relevant the show," he said. "This is just the medium that people used. Now, you can go to the Web or to your local retailer."

Personally, I have no idea how this can be "good." I think the better attendance, the better it is for Linux. It means people are showing an interest in Linux. More people means more companies will get involved which leads to higher brand awareness / product recognition among the general public and so on. Making fun of the companies that are supporting Linux now by saying they sent their “Linux pitchmen” probably doesn’t help much either.
 
They lost all credit with me when Ubuntu won "Best Desktop Solution." OpenSUSE is better in every aspect, and still gets beat down due to the lingering FUD over Novell's agreement with Microsoft. It's espeically funny because OpenSUSE is more true to open source than Ubuntu (Ubuntu includes proprietary kernel modules, OpenSUSE's kernel is 100% OSS).
 
Since when has it ever been a “good sign” when your big tech show of the year is a bust? I hear people like this say stuff like this but only when it's convenient. If no one showed up for Apple’s big shindig would he be saying the same thing? Ummm, no. If CES bombed would the tune be the same? I doubt it. Am I wrong on this one? Is low turn out for Linux events really “good news?”

You know that Apple marketing would say that it was a good thing if nobody showed up though. Something along the lines of "They're all too busy using our products."

Something about the alternate reality world they all live in ;)
 
They lost all credit with me when Ubuntu won "Best Desktop Solution." OpenSUSE is better in every aspect, and still gets beat down due to the lingering FUD over Novell's agreement with Microsoft. It's espeically funny because OpenSUSE is more true to open source than Ubuntu (Ubuntu includes proprietary kernel modules, OpenSUSE's kernel is 100% OSS).

I prefer Ubuntu over SUSE to be honest. Just have had better luck with hardware compatibility using Ubuntu than any other Distro, including Fedora and SUSE. Maybe it's just the particular hardware I use.
 
They lost all credit with me when Ubuntu won "Best Desktop Solution." OpenSUSE is better in every aspect, and still gets beat down due to the lingering FUD over Novell's agreement with Microsoft. It's espeically funny because OpenSUSE is more true to open source than Ubuntu (Ubuntu includes proprietary kernel modules, OpenSUSE's kernel is 100% OSS).

I've used both, and I can't *stand* openSUSE. I almost hate the thing. Ubuntu also doesn't include proprietary kernel modules, it just has them in the repositories. It also notifies the user that they are using a non-opensource module. I honestly think it is the best compromise since many people are likely going to want the official drivers - at least for video, anyway. Ubuntu just makes it easy.

Of course, Ubuntu's kernel is also 100% OSS - modules are plugins, they aren't compiled into the kernel ;)
 
Ubuntu also doesn't include proprietary kernel modules, it just has them in the repositories. It also notifies the user that they are using a non-opensource module. I honestly think it is the best compromise since many people are likely going to want the official drivers - at least for video, anyway. Ubuntu just makes it easy.

Of course, Ubuntu's kernel is also 100% OSS - modules are plugins, they aren't compiled into the kernel ;)

Wrong:
http://fasmz.org/~pterjan/blog/?date=20060609#p01
 
WHAT THE HELL IS WITH THE OLD LADIES WALKING AROUND!?!?!? GOD! I wanted to refuse to give them anything. Literally you could watch them walking around and see their eyes scanning the tops of tables looking for free stuff. Then they'd come up and just take it. WTF!?!

Last year seemed pretty good... this year seemed kinda pointless.
 
I'm not sure on how proprietary software that is still free is a bad thing. :confused: Maybe I'm just not understanding what the big deal is in general?

as far as the LinuxWorld attendance being lacking, well, to be fair, cost of travel has gone significantly up.
 
Seriously, does it matter if some modules are not open source if it encourages adoption of the OS? I'm not a huge Linux supporter, but I use it. Its the hardcore free/open source/or die crowd that really gives Linux a bad impression to many.
 
plain and simple my motto is and always will be

"free is me" if its free i'll take it regardless if i can use it or i want it
 
It is good news, and I think I can actually prove that with just one letter and one number.

E3

There is no doubt that the video game market is growing by leaps and bounds. Nintendo's broke records selling the Wii, Blizzard's broke records selling World of Warcraft, and Microsoft's broke records letting people down with bad technology. (sorry, couldn't resist the dig at Vista and the Red Ring of Death)

Anyways, when the ESA retuned the E3 convention for 2007, then again for 2008, the result was a complete flop. Many publishers and developers in the video game industry have blasted the ESA for the timing of the convention, the location, and so on and so forth. One of the major problems with holding the convention late in the year is that many of the year-end release schedules are already known as retailers are being prepped for the promotions upcoming later in the year. I remember when going to E3 meant finding out not just about what games where coming and the latest tech, but also about getting the upcoming promotional materials, schedules, and all other information that would be used at retail.

Since the retuning, attendance has dropped dramatically, with even the invited press declining to attend. Almost all of the major publishers have announced their own smaller tradeshows, with EA and Ubisoft running their own specific conventions such as Ubidays and EA3. Nintendo announced 2 years ago that it would focus more on events like PAX and Fusion Tour.

If one were to judge the video game industry by the ESA's E3 event only, you'd come to the conclusion that video games were dying.

LinuxWorld is pretty much in the same exact boat. The convention has been retuning itself to, borrow the term, speak to the choir. However, many vendors such as Red Hat, Novell, and IBM are constantly running monthly seminars all around the world.

Speaking as somebody who does run a small gaming website, and is ESA registered, and was invited to E3, a variety of factors kept me from going to E3. Exampling myself specifically, there was the travel cost. There there was another convention on the east coast that I was much more interested in going to. Given that I couldn't make E3, there was little chance I would be able to make LinuxWorld either.

I also know that I'm not the only person in that boat. When you have limited financial resources, you go to what's important and available. Many of the small business's and reporters that used to fill LinuxWorld to capacity, are finding they can get the same content elsewhere, more than likely on a local or regional basis,

Now, if LinuxWorld were the only convention of it's type, it would be just like the E3 of a few years back. You would have to make plans for it, and you would have to go.

Like E3 though, as the market has grown, the need for a single, large, convention that answers to everybody for everything? That need goes away.

Just think about on the Comics / Anime side of things. You have the mega-event of ComicCon each year. It's the biggest. But you also have Anthrocon (trust me, it's more about comics than Reuters and AP would like you to believe), DragonCon, MomoCon, Connecticon... actually, just visit : http://www.animecons.com/

For a lot of people, the regional cons make a lot more sense than trekking out to ComicCon, and for many, regional is all they can afford.

***

The point is that LinuxWorld attendance going down is nothing to be worried about. Given the rocketing rise of Linux on laptop and desktop sales worldwide, there's little doubt that at retail, like Video Games, Linux is selling.

Like Video Games though, judging the state of the entire industry by one Con? Is a bit stupid.
 
Using E3 is a bad example.

The only thing E3 is an example of is how one governing body could shoot themselves in the foot. Period. It's not like no one was going to E3 so they made it smaller. We covered many E3 and the event was as big, bad and off the hook as you could get in 2006...heh...booth babes and million dollar booths be damned. That was the problem, it was too big, too loud and not enough clothes on the women. ;)

The ESA shot themselves in the foot when they "retuned" E3

Going to the new E3 meant I had to take 20 cabs in two days to ten different hotels for 15 meetings all just hours apart. And that is just the MINOR inconveniences. E3 is horrid now as a result of the ESA's actions...not lack of attendence. I haven't been back.

LinuxWorld & E3 couldn't be more opposite. The article said no one attended LinuxWorld and that it was the best thing to happen to Linux. Lack of attendence means a lack of interest by the people that would normally attend the show. THAT isn't good and that is all I am trying to say.
 


Uh... what? How am I wrong? Those basically say the same thing I did - the proprietary modules are in the repository, but they aren't enabled by default (debs on the CD still count as being in the repository ;) ) - they are also ridiculously out of date - the newest one refers to 7.04, which is over a year old (there have been two releases since then, 7.10 and 8.04)

Regardless, Ubuntu's kernel is "100% OSS", just like openSUSEs is. The reason for that is simple, ITS THE SAME DAMN KERNEL (configured differently perhaps, and maybe with some distro-specific patches, but still).

I'm not sure on how proprietary software that is still free is a bad thing. Maybe I'm just not understanding what the big deal is in general?

as far as the LinuxWorld attendance being lacking, well, to be fair, cost of travel has gone significantly up.

The reasons are varied. For some, its the principal of the matter. They want the source so they can mess around with it. For others, its because proprietary modules don't exactly have the best rep in Linux. Its usually the proprietary drivers causing the kernel panics and the like, and not the OSS ones. I couldn't give a crap - I'm going with whatever works the best and lets me maximize my hardware - since that is the point of the OS to begin with.
 
I'm not sure on how proprietary software that is still free is a bad thing. :confused: Maybe I'm just not understanding what the big deal is in general?

Seriously, does it matter if some modules are not open source if it encourages adoption of the OS? I'm not a huge Linux supporter, but I use it. Its the hardcore free/open source/or die crowd that really gives Linux a bad impression to many.

QFT. I don't see why it's such a huge issue. I want my video card to work up to its potential. That's why I bought it. That trumps the "open-sourceness" of the OS.
 
I never quite got the whole 'distro-war' thing anyway.
"OpenSUSE is so much better than Ubuntu" etc.

Linux users like to pride themselves on being tech-savvy and all that... But to me it seems they're completely missing the point on the technical level, and are just nitpicking on some out-of-the-box configuration details?
Do they even know what a 'distro' is? It's a distribution of a collection of software. All linux distro's are generally built up from the same main components like obviously the linux kernel, KDE or Gnome as a desktop environment, and the GNU set of commandline utilities and other tools. Then they throw in the most popular opensource packages like xmms, Apache and lots of other "usual suspects".

Now, if I, as a technical user, am looking at these linux distributions, I see that they're basically all the same core technology. So technically there really is no difference. They run the same kernel, same drivers, same desktop environment, same libraries, same compiler, etc.
They're just configured a bit differently, but since linux users tend to pride themselves on the ability to tweak everything to their demands, what's the point in arguing about out-of-the-box settings anyway?
Since nearly all distributions come with the complete sourcecode (or alternatively you can get the sourcecode from the web for nearly everything), there's really nothing stopping you from reconfiguring and recompiling things.

So why all these holy wars about distro's?

Perhaps I just don't get it because I'm a FreeBSD user, and there is only one distribution for me (although still largely based on the "usual suspects" that linux distros also use), and I'm more used to tweaking things to my liking anyway.
 
Of course the spin is just damage control. The real question is asking why commercial support (and be honest, that is what is driving Linux based OSs from the top) is not growing as it has in the past.
 
Welp, there is a lot of newbs (not to confuse with bewbs) here - you can tell because they are arguing over the validity of a distro being true OSS or not.

You can't win. The only true free distros with out a single license issue are 100% GNU, like GNU Debian. If you install one of those distros then install something like the Flash plugin - you just lost the game son - again. I have used linux and unix (solaris and other BSD's) for almost 10 years now and I know better not to start fights like these because you can't finish them.

As for the tech show - meh. Doesn't mean anything. Its not an Apple or MS tech show where its run just for 1 company, because Linux isn't a company. Its not a front to control the computer world. It is a collaboration of software and minds. There is no leader for it (Linus only writes the kernel, and a kernel alone is useless), and thus you can't just how its supported based on how corporations do business like Apple and MS.

Linux will never go away, because its free and anyone can keep it alive.
 
I never quite got the whole 'distro-war' thing anyway.
"OpenSUSE is so much better than Ubuntu" etc.

Linux users like to pride themselves on being tech-savvy and all that... But to me it seems they're completely missing the point on the technical level, and are just nitpicking on some out-of-the-box configuration details?
Do they even know what a 'distro' is? It's a distribution of a collection of software. All linux distro's are generally built up from the same main components like obviously the linux kernel, KDE or Gnome as a desktop environment, and the GNU set of commandline utilities and other tools. Then they throw in the most popular opensource packages like xmms, Apache and lots of other "usual suspects".

Now, if I, as a technical user, am looking at these linux distributions, I see that they're basically all the same core technology. So technically there really is no difference. They run the same kernel, same drivers, same desktop environment, same libraries, same compiler, etc.
They're just configured a bit differently, but since linux users tend to pride themselves on the ability to tweak everything to their demands, what's the point in arguing about out-of-the-box settings anyway?
Since nearly all distributions come with the complete sourcecode (or alternatively you can get the sourcecode from the web for nearly everything), there's really nothing stopping you from reconfiguring and recompiling things.

So why all these holy wars about distro's?

Perhaps I just don't get it because I'm a FreeBSD user, and there is only one distribution for me (although still largely based on the "usual suspects" that linux distros also use), and I'm more used to tweaking things to my liking anyway.

Well, they don't necessarily all use the same software. Ubuntu may use a different bootsplash program than openSUSE, or example. But you missed the big point of the distro, and that is the package management system. Debian's apt is probably one of (if not the) best there is, which is what Ubuntu (being Debian based) uses. There is also the issue of distros patching software but not pushing the patches upstream. So the Ubuntu version of a program may have a bug fixed that still exists in the openSUSE version, and vice versa (even if the version number is the same). Also, each distro might have its own set of programs that were created by the developers of the distro. While more rare, it does happen.

Its all kind of a big mess, hence the "distro wars" :)
 
Big IT shows are a dying breed in general. Management has decided that there isn't that much value in sending their employees to a conference to party like rock stars on the company dime for 3 or 4 days. I don't know what percentage of people at these shows are actually paying their own way but I would guess that it's not a lot. And then as others have mentioned there is the cost of travel in general, it's much higher with the runup in oil prices.

The thing now is smaller, focused, more localized shows, perhaps given in several regions.
 
Well, they don't necessarily all use the same software. Ubuntu may use a different bootsplash program than openSUSE, or example. But you missed the big point of the distro, and that is the package management system. Debian's apt is probably one of (if not the) best there is, which is what Ubuntu (being Debian based) uses. There is also the issue of distros patching software but not pushing the patches upstream. So the Ubuntu version of a program may have a bug fixed that still exists in the openSUSE version, and vice versa (even if the version number is the same). Also, each distro might have its own set of programs that were created by the developers of the distro. While more rare, it does happen.

Its all kind of a big mess, hence the "distro wars" :)

I didn't say they use ALL the same software, but what I did say was that you can modify them. If you want to use the bootsplash screen of Ubuntu on openSUSE, you can do that, or vice versa. Not that it will actually make a difference obviously. And that's my point.

As for package management... Overrated, if you ask me. A real tech user can download and patch/compile sources himself if he has to, and doesn't have to rely on a distributor. Most of the time it's not a problem for everyday use if you don't have bleeding-edge versions of software anyway. A lot of linux users seem to just install, upgrade and patch software as some kind of game. For a real user installing or upgrading software is a means to an end, nothing more. On my FreeBSD system, months go by without me changing the configuration or installing/patching software etc. But I use it everyday.
 
They're expecting a bunch of nerds, geeks, and dorks to leave their parent's basement? Isn't asking a little too much?:p
 
Back
Top