Linus Torvalds Blasts Intel PR Statement on CPU Security

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
Yesterday LInus Torvalds seemed to very much prop up AMD's Lisa Su's statements about AMD's current CPUs remaining safe in the face of Meltdown and Spectre attacks. Linus also seems to be just as upset as many of our readers are about Intel's ham-handed and deflecting PR statement yesterday as well. Thanks cageymaru.


I think somebody inside of Intel needs to really take a long hard look at their CPU's, and actually admit that they have issues instead of writing PR blurbs that say that everything works as designed...and that really means that all these mitigation patches should be written with "not all CPU's are crap" in mind. Or is Intel basically saying "we are committed to selling you shit forever and ever, and never fixing anything"?
 
I think Intel's statements are more just a matter of how capitalism works than anything. I'm not anti-capitalism, but it is what it is. I understand how in a perfect world Intel would come out and be 100% honest, but can they really afford to do that in the word we actually live in? Who takes the blame if their honesty causes their stock price to go even lower and more people who wouldn't otherwise have half a clue what is going on to choose AMD next time? It might seem like their dishonesty will cost them, but the reality is that hardware enthusiasts like us on this forum are a very tiny minority. Most people will believe Intel's statement. And quite honestly, 99% of the people on here will still buy Intel, regardless of any lies made, as long as they are still faster in games. I would also.
 
But all my mining rigs run their crappy CPUs! Ok not all I tossed Ryzen in a few when I thought burst coin was relevant and when I wasn't sure if Crypto would take off so I would at least have a good setup for LAN gaming with kids...and I hate waiting on G44XX series CPUs to boot.

But now I get to patch multiple systems, I wonder if there will be a crypto heist reported from this.
 
I remember when they sold CPUs with the TSX "feature". Then later disabled it with a microcode update after figuring out it didn't work.
 
I think Intel's statements are more just a matter of how capitalism works than anything. I'm not anti-capitalism, but it is what it is. I understand how in a perfect world Intel would come out and be 100% honest, but can they really afford to do that in the word we actually live in? Who takes the blame if their honesty causes their stock price to go even lower and more people who wouldn't otherwise have half a clue what is going on to choose AMD next time? It might seem like their dishonesty will cost them, but the reality is that hardware enthusiasts like us on this forum are a very tiny minority. Most people will believe Intel's statement. And quite honestly, 99% of the people on here will still buy Intel, regardless of any lies made, as long as they are still faster in games. I would also.

Yup. Pretty messed up incentives we've constructed, but you're not wrong (though personally my next CPU will be back to AMD).
 
PR blurbs have F-all to do with anything. OF COURSE Intel is downplaying it publicly. They aren't interested in being utterly devoured by lawyers so no, do not expect any admission they messed up. It would be insanity to do so in the US legal system.

And rest assured, the design team is being set on fire right now, and not going home until they have the best fix possible.
 
I'm so glad we have Linus at the helm of Linux. Someone that isn't a corporate shill. It really bothers me that so many people are scared to be frank like him. We need to be more like Linus, and HardOCP, ready to call people out, but also ready to listen.
 
I think Intel's statements are more just a matter of how capitalism works than anything. I'm not anti-capitalism, but it is what it is. I understand how in a perfect world Intel would come out and be 100% honest, but can they really afford to do that in the word we actually live in? Who takes the blame if their honesty causes their stock price to go even lower and more people who wouldn't otherwise have half a clue what is going on to choose AMD next time? It might seem like their dishonesty will cost them, but the reality is that hardware enthusiasts like us on this forum are a very tiny minority. Most people will believe Intel's statement. And quite honestly, 99% of the people on here will still buy Intel, regardless of any lies made, as long as they are still faster in games. I would also.

You are right, people don't worry about ethics any more. It would not even matter if Intel could make their CPU's better by selling drugs on the side. People just don't care as long as they get the best end of the stick. Sorry to hear hear that you also don't worry if companies lie to compete better.

Whether it is selling drugs or lying, it is still immoral and not OK. Why do we condone "smaller" sins as if it is OK? We should stop supporting companies that lie - at least as far a possible. If you can lie, you can murder as well!!!
 
Last edited:
What is even more sad, is that all major news companies are supporting Intel in this and making AMD look bad. This whole Spectre thing is used to take away the focus from Meltdown. It is sad to see how far down the drain the world has gone. Brothers protect brothers, it is a real mafia going on. It is ugly to see that truth no longer matters. The average Joe will just continue on non-the-wiser.

Even companies will be ignorant enough to believe the lies. Sad indeed.
 
What is even more sad, is that all major news companies are supporting Intel in this and making AMD look bad. This whole Spectre thing is used to take away the focus from Meltdown. It is sad to see how far down the drain the world has gone. Brothers protect brothers, it is a real mafia going on. It is ugly to see that truth no longer matters. The average Joe will just continue on non-the-wiser.

Even companies will be ignorant enough to believe the lies. Sad indeed.

Spectre is the kind of intrusion that cannot really be stopped but can easily be mitigated with regular OS updates and BIOS/microcode, Meltdown on the other hand is the severe one as it is no longer just an intrusion but a full breakdown of security policies and loss of data. I don't think the media have been on Intels side, most have been against it and rightfully so, investors also seem to be concerned with Intel dropping nearly 3 points over a day.
 
Back
Top