Left 4 Dead plauged with problems?

Frostex

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
2,143
First impressions of this game are just OMG....not good!

OK this is the way it appears to work...theres no server browser (er?)

You just click to join a game and it searches for a lobby, it then throws you into a random lobby, if you're first in, you're the "leader" and can chose the settings for the game, others join and when you have enough of a team the leader can start the game.

At that point the lobby searches for a server to play on....thats right, AFTER the wait and putting up with newbs who are leaders and cant find the "start" button right under their nose, at that point it finds a server...which is just retarded...

First major problem, about 9 out of 10 times you fail to connect to the server, it retrys 15 times a process you cannot escape back to the menu from, so you guessed it, if it's one of the 9 times you have to sit and wait for it to time out :rolleyes:

Second major problem is, servers with passwords dont ask for them until everyone has "loaded" or connected to the server, after the lobby wait that is...theres no way I can immediately see that rules out passworded servers, which is just...retarded :rolleyes:

Thrid major problem is obviously finding the server seperately from the lobby doesnt gurantee all people can connect to that server even though they could connect to the lobby, so even if YOU get into the game, it doesnt mean the other 3 will.

Fourth major problem, lag...I have a business broadband connection and ping about 7ms to decent 100 tick CSS servers, yet the 2 games i've managed to join (in apporx 20-30 join attempts) I've lagged badly in both.

Fifth major problem...crash, I've crashed within 5 minutes of gameplay.

Seriously valve, what the fuck? How could you possibly after all this time not have ironed out all this crap? Whats with the crap lobby system, this is easily the worst method of connecting to games I've ever seen, they've taken away the functionally complete server browser and made it practically impossible to find a good server.

Anyway the 4-5 minutes of gameplay I've played so far were...well...not brilliant, first game i joined mid round and was lumped with a character who had picked a sniper rifle kind of like the awp, which agaist hordes and hordes of fast running zombies is next to useless...

Not impressed at all, if the final game releases like this, they have big BIG problems.
 
You can view the server list by typing "openserverbrowser" if you want to look at it that way.

I'm pretty sure there's a reason for the lobby system. It's not anything like CS. It's not a game where you can just join and spawn like it's not gonna really affect the team dynamics.

If it kept to the server browser like the others, the games would be interrupted with people joining/leaving every minute. The point of the lobby is to start off a campaign from the beginning with a starting group and hopefully to the end with the same group of people (maybe less if someone leaves). There are still kinks and bumps but they still have a while to get feedback from people playing the demo.
 
Please also remember that people usually hosting the server are running it off their own computer/connection, not your business connection.
 
Please also remember that people usually hosting the server are running it off their own computer/connection, not your business connection.

Yeah and if we had a PROPER server browser I could arrange the games by latency time adn put all the stupid wanky ones right at the bottom where they belong, no such option here (although i've just read about the server browser command which im going to try)

I'm pretty sure there's a reason for the lobby system. It's not anything like CS. It's not a game where you can just join and spawn like it's not gonna really affect the team dynamics.

Thats why they've added a button to join currently running games?

That makes exactly zero sense.

Valve have seriously dropped the ball on this one, big time.

*edit*

haha, oh and if you alt tab while waiting for the server connection to time out for 15 retrys that you cant skip, when you alt tab back into the game the "OK" button is off the screen adn you cant get back to the menu without ctrl alt del

haha :rolleyes:

*edit 2*

Just joined another lobby, tried to connect, and it errord saying i needed to be in the lobby to join, ROFL :rolleyes:

*edit 3*

If you cancel the server search, say you've been sitting there for about 60 seconds and it's not found a server for your lobby, it doesn't re-activate any of the buttons so all you can do is leave the lobby and have to start a new one LOL :rolleyes:
 
Try the server browser command, should work. I'll probably be purchasing a server to host, maybe some [H]ers can populate it? ;)
 
Try the server browser command, should work. I'll probably be purchasing a server to host, maybe some [H]ers can populate it? ;)

Of course.


OP - you make a lot of good points. But the game itself is fun (when you get it going).
 
IMO the only way to make this work is through a ranking system similar to Company of Heroes. If I am a kickass player I do not want to play with a bunch of newbs.
 
IMO the only way to make this work is through a ranking system similar to Company of Heroes. If I am a kickass player I do not want to play with a bunch of newbs.

Supposedly it has a matchmaking system in the final game.

However after seeing how bad this all is put together, I'd be very surprised if matchmaking works well, if at all.

Been at this about 2 hours now and I've not completed the demo yet due to technical reasons, crap browser and buggy crashing game or servers dying, kicking people out, resetting etc.
 
Supposedly it has a matchmaking system in the final game.

However after seeing how bad this all is put together, I'd be very surprised if matchmaking works well, if at all.

I wouldn't just drop faith in Valve yet. The game itself is pretty damn amazing so I don't think Valve is dumb enough to not have this fixed in the final release.
 
I can understand your frustration, but its still just a demo not the whole game
 
Funniest thing is when you get your friends and finally find a server and you get "Password Required" :p but yeah I trust valve will get rid of this system because it will KILL custom content which is the only reason i paid $45 for this game
 
sounds like the Halo 3 crap system.. no thanks.. the most frustrating thing about Halo3 is how it sets up games and the inability to select your server the classic way..
 
yeah this seems like a system for a console just thrown on to PC... I don't get it
 
As siad there is a server browser in the game if you open the console and type openserverbrowser in the console to open it. To use it click on the custom tab to view games. Some games seem to only let you join if you;re in the game lobby.


The main problem im having is with crashes, it will randomly lockup with repeating audio forcing me to ctrl alt del. Its an amazingly fun game besides that.
 
http://www.left4dead411.com/news/2008/11/server-browser-available/

Valve hears the complaints and is working on something. This was one of the main purposes of releasing the demo early to a [relatively] small group of users before release.

I had one crash, but when I got to the desktop it was a driver error. Not sure if it's L4D's fault. I've gotten in 2 online games so far and its a friggin blast. I love how my team meshed within a minute or two. We actually lost one person to a tank, and then 2 minutes later I found him in a closet somewhere. He was like "wow, how'd you do that?" lol.

I think they will get this stuff sorted out rather quickly and everything will be fine.
 
Had problems at first, working fine now. Having a blast. I'm sure they'll implement custom server browser eventually, once enough people complain. Main thing is the game though.
 
Seriously, they should stop with the console-like bullshit. L4D shoulda been a pure PC game release. Only b/c of the simultaneous 360 release is it dumbed down with "auto" server joining. Seriously, what a joke.
 
As siad there is a server browser in the game if you open the console and type openserverbrowser in the console to open it. To use it click on the custom tab to view games. Some games seem to only let you join if you;re in the game lobby.


The main problem im having is with crashes, it will randomly lockup with repeating audio forcing me to ctrl alt del. Its an amazingly fun game besides that.

Yep, but almost all servers disalow joining from the browser at the moment since thats the default behaviour it seems.

I'm crashing constantly with looping audio, I've had to switch my audio over to a pair of USB headphones which have the sound device built in, otherwise completing more than 2-5 minutes of gameplay is impossible.

Also hosting a LAN server seems to crash or have all 3 team mates all time out at the same time, both on my machine and on other peoples, so clearly that doesn't work either.

Seriously, they should stop with the console-like bullshit. L4D shoulda been a pure PC game release. Only b/c of the simultaneous 360 release is it dumbed down with "auto" server joining. Seriously, what a joke.

Yup, essentially.
 
You guys should be grateful that Valve is actually listening to input from beta testers/players. I've beta tested many games where we would test, report, and nothing gets changed in retail DESPITE many reports of said issue/problem. Cut Valve some slack, they've yet to make a totally failure game and so far its shaping up to be great. Now if it's like this during retail, then we have a problem.
 
I thought the purpose of a demo was to make people want to buy the game?
 
I can understand your frustration, but its still just a demo not the whole game

This is what people said about the UT3 beta demo. Fortunately this is Valve we are talking about and not Epic.
 
I thought the purpose of a demo was to make people want to buy the game?

Not when EARLY access of the demo is granted to people who already purchased the game. I'm pretty sure the strategy here was to release early access to us, to test it out and work out any major issues [such as lack of server browsing], fix it or at least try to fix it, and THEN release the demo to everyone, in order to entice them to purchase.

Makes some sense, right?
 
No it doesn't make sense at all, theres no room for further development in that time, maybe 1-2 minor bug tweaks but essentially theres not enough time to fix anything major, the entire server browser system being rubbish (broken), its quite worrying.
 
No it doesn't make sense at all, theres no room for further development in that time, maybe 1-2 minor bug tweaks but essentially theres not enough time to fix anything major, the entire server browser system being rubbish (broken), its quite worrying.

I can see both sides of the argument about the server browser though. PC users want a browser that has robust features like the TF2 and CS browsers so that they can filter out all the stuff they want. On the other hand, matchmaking would keep similar skilled people together.

besides the fact that browsing for servers will likely put you into maps that are already in progress, which means a lot of the time you won't be playing a full campaign, you'll just be dumped into one already running. That can cause problems too. I personally would be fine if they leave the matchmaking and just make it work a bit better, so that you get good servers and no one is lagging out [which seems to be happening more today as more ded servers show up]. I think it's more of an issue for server owners wanting to play on their own server, rather than having the system choose for them.

I'm confident Valve will find a way to make it work for everyone.
 
If this was a beta, then I want my money back! BETAs and DEMOs aren't supposed to cost $45!
 
You guys should be grateful that Valve is actually listening to input from beta testers/players. I've beta tested many games where we would test, report, and nothing gets changed in retail DESPITE many reports of said issue/problem. Cut Valve some slack, they've yet to make a totally failure game and so far its shaping up to be great. Now if it's like this during retail, then we have a problem.

goood voice of reason!
 
There's a reason it's a demo. Because it will suck, performance wise. The fact that it even worked was a miracle.

To demonstrate Valve's excellence in problem solving and quick turnaround time, as I was playing the demo last night, I noticed that the game was causing the steam client to run a lot of CPU time. As I realized the issue, BAM, Valve came out with an update, FOR THE DEMO. And in the update news was the exact issue I noticed. They are are pros. They could have easily have just applied it to the final release, but they made sure the demo had it as well.

They know their shit. And 11 days is plenty for them to fix the issues. Have faith, people. Don't let the bad press fool you.

Regarding the server browser, it's only a command away, so what the problem? Their setup is for players that aren't technical to the point that they know what a server browser is. But all the tools are still there. You can still join any server you want.
 
Uh, you guys? the problem IS that it is retail. Its a demo of a full product, not a beta. Stop giving them excuses for realeasing an unfinished or poorly planned out product. If they wanted a beta, they should have HAD a beta. I'm glad valve listens to their customers, but this sorta stuff should have been sorted out MONTHS ago, not two weeks before retail. exessive patching is bad, and pre-launch launch patches just to get a server browser? I'm tired of paying for a beta test that sure looks like its going to last past the launch date. Sure its no hellgate london, but cmon valve, I expected better.
 
TThey know their shit. And 11 days is plenty for them to fix the issues. Have faith, people. Don't let the bad press fool you.

Lol what press? I saw this over my friend's shoulder FIRST-HAND. There is no fucking press involved, this is empirical, first-hand experience from users. East Coasters never really had a chance to play the patched demo, so my words may be kinder _if and only if_ it shows substantial improvement.
 
Way to freak out. As several others have said, its just the demo. Whats more, its not really even the "public" demo in a sense because only those who have preordered can play it, not just anyone. Besides, its valve, they're already releasing patches. A lot of games have rough starts, the important thing is that they get resolved quickly, which steam facilitates.
 
Uh, you guys? the problem IS that it is retail. Its a demo of a full product, not a beta. Stop giving them excuses for realeasing an unfinished or poorly planned out product. If they wanted a beta, they should have HAD a beta. I'm glad valve listens to their customers, but this sorta stuff should have been sorted out MONTHS ago, not two weeks before retail. exessive patching is bad, and pre-launch launch patches just to get a server browser? I'm tired of paying for a beta test that sure looks like its going to last past the launch date. Sure its no hellgate london, but cmon valve, I expected better.

I'd consider it more of a beta than a demo. Demos are indicative of the final product, and made to convince people to buy the game. that's what the demo release on the 11th is for. This "demo" is being given to people who have already purchased. they aren't trying to convince them to buy, they are trying to get all these bugs and quirks worked out.

At least, this is how I see it. I could be completely wrong though.
 
As another mentioned they've already released two updates for it, the second listed improvements to MP although I've not tried MP since that patch came on late last night.

I think two weaks is a perfectly reasonable timeframe to make some good progress on tweaking matchmaking and other MP issues, much moreso than if there were issues with the maps/gameplay.

Bottom line is when you're actually in there playing it's great fun, so fingers crossed everything gets ironed out.
 
I can see where if you aren't playing with friends this can be an issue. Last night i had a great time playing with some buddies. I hope the brouser is tweaked to be more like all the other steam games, where you can join easily. I did have a issue where i crashed and had to be invited to the server instead of being able to join on my own..:rolleyes: for some reason it said my friend was in an game i couldn't join.

The other issue i see is people wanting to buy a server but not having much control over who and how people join. There was an update that allowed admins to tweak their server so that is good but it needs to be "easier" to do then some command hacks. I think i'll wait a bit before renting a server.


I have to also add that it seems more like a beta then a demo. I hope they can straighten out the brouser issues because everything else is solid. Played a little andvanced and expert and we got our asses kicked. Isn't there even a impossible mode too. Can't wait for retail!:D
 
This is what people said about the UT3 beta demo.

Hah hah I remember that. Here comes the big tweak to that ridiculous toy server browser... wait for it.... YAY a slightly smaller font! Now it's a PC game!

I still can't believe they actually released that menu system on a PC game, especially given the game's history and how much they actually devolved the product that was one of the greatest PC games ever made. Bastards.

Oh well I'm sure that's been talked about so sorry for going OT.
 
yeah this seems like a system for a console just thrown on to PC... I don't get it
Seems that way.

You guys should be grateful that Valve is actually listening to input from beta testers/players.
Grateful? You've completely forgotten that people pre-ordered the game to get early access to the demo, have you?

People paid $45 for this. When you pay $45 for a game, you aren't grateful that the developer is working to resolve issues, you demand that they resolve issues.

And this isn't a beta -- this is a demo. We are not beta testers.

...the entire server browser system being rubbish (broken), its quite worrying.
It's possible they have an alternative system in place that simply isn't implemented or is otherwise "locked". Doing the early demo release may be a means of testing the waters, so to speak. If they determine that it's just a no-go, no-win situation, they could drop back to the traditional server browser system and try and iron out any issues with the matchmaking system.

If it's as bad as you describe, I have a very hard time believing that they don't know it has so many flaws and doesn't deliver the kind of experience anyone wants. That's my thought, anyway.
 
I can see both sides of the argument about the server browser though. PC users want a browser that has robust features like the TF2 and CS browsers so that they can filter out all the stuff they want. On the other hand, matchmaking would keep similar skilled people together.

Actually, it seems uncessary to need a normal browser like for only 4 player, what they have is a good idea, as I said before, it's just incredibly poorly implimented.
 
Back
Top