I tried both and the PC version is a no brainer
-much better graphics
-fps controls better on PC
-mod community
-likely free updates while 360 version will have to pay
I am getting it for the PC since I can't use the controller efficiently.
I also got the game from Amazon for $31.99 shipped and no tax. should be here 2 days after release.
I played Blacksite:Area51 on my PC and then played the Demo on my 360 and had a very very hard time playing. Aiming is too hard for me with the controller.