Left 4 Dead - 360 or PC?

Which platform are you going to purchase Left 4 Dead for?

  • Xbox 360

    Votes: 14 9.9%
  • PC

    Votes: 121 85.2%
  • Not buying - Zombies are teh suck

    Votes: 7 4.9%

  • Total voters
    142

slugl1fe

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
379
I'm an avid PC Gamer but the multiplayer coop is a pretty compelling reason for me to buy this game for the 360 (play with roommate / visiting friends). The other thing to consider - price is $44.95 on Steam for PC (no tax) vs. $59.99 on 360 w/ additional tax.

What do you guys think?
 
the game doesnt seem very demanding on PC's (its based on the source engine) so as long as your friends have a half decent comp they can play coop with you.

one of the big reasons im going PC, is mods/maps.

People have already figured out how to export some maps from other games (TF2 for example) to L4D, and while they dont work 100% the fact it took little effort to do makes me happy, and make sme realise this game is goign to have tons of mods, and mods = replayability :D
 
the game doesnt seem very demanding on PC's (its based on the source engine) so as long as your friends have a half decent comp they can play coop with you.


This is actually one of the reasons I will probably buy it for the 360; the visual differences on PC vs. 360 won't be as pronounced as something like CoD4 or Fallout 3. PC will definitely look better, but since the graphics / performance don't really matter, other factors (like the comfort of my couch, coop etc) take precedence.

I do hear you about the mods though - that is an interesting point.
 
Being able to have custom maps and mods will be the only thing that will keep L4D fresh for me. Otherwise my interest would stagnate fairly quickly.
 
This is actually one of the reasons I will probably buy it for the 360; the visual differences on PC vs. 360 won't be as pronounced as something like CoD4 or Fallout 3. PC will definitely look better, but since the graphics / performance don't really matter, other factors (like the comfort of my couch, coop etc) take precedence.

I do hear you about the mods though - that is an interesting point.

for me, my computer chair is much more comfertable, I have a decent leather chair, but the big one is having surround sound all around you (I have my rear speakers on stands about 1-2 feet away from my head) positioned for just my comp chair makes it alot more imersive for me.

And while yes I have surround on my tv/xbox as well its set up for an entire couch and doesn't imerse you as well lol.

That and i can turn off my lights in my comp room, where as I have to leave lights on in the living room for my wife/kid, and having the lights off makes all the diff to me in these games lol.
 
I'm going to end up getting it on both platforms, but I'll mainly play the 360 version since I know a lot of other people who are getting the 360 version and also the convenience of playing on the couch.
 
I thought about this one as well and I am going to get it for the 360 because I have a lot of friends online who are going to buy it for that platform. If more people I knew played it on the PC I would buy it there.
 
PC because:

1. My 21" Silicon graphics CRT monitor is perfect for this dark game, 1600x1200@85hz with full AA and AF looks nice.
2. Mouse/KB so I can spin around and fend off the horde efficiently
3. e8400@4ghz + ati 4870 running the game at highest detail with no slowdowns ever.
4. Sennheiser 280 pro headphones to block out my loud PC and immerse me in the game
 
PC, because of the following:

Xbox player:
"OMG! Zombie behind me!"
*push analog stick to the right*
*3 seconds later*
"Damn, I'm dead"

PC player:
"OMG! Zombie behind me!"
*wrist snap action*
"BOOM HEADSHOT!"
 
I'm still on the fence about buying it for the Xbox 360, and I have both pc and console. The primary reason is the lack of support since the Orange Box was released a year ago. Valve blames Microsoft, but at the same time I see many free DLC's accross various titles. All I know is the end result is the xbox 360 has yet to received any of the updates the PC has, including fixes, balancing fixes, new weapons, and new maps. What ever was shipped on disk a year ago is what the game contains. Just for kicks I beleive last march is when they announced new updates coming for orange box and here we are with still nothing.

I'm hoping that with L4D that it will be different. The devolopers are promising updates on a more regular basis compared to orange box, but at the same time this won't be the first time a developer promisses something prior to release and retracts that comment shortly after the majority of sales have passed.

BTW, if you buy it on amazon you can get the xbox version for 48.99 (5$ instant rebate) on the checkout screen. I have it preordered but I'm very tempted to cancel because of the above.
 
This game looks like hell on a controller, its too fast, faster than UT3 and that was terrible on consoles.
 
After playing Halo 3 on the Xbox, I think I would be better contented to pick up the PC version of this game.
Post #9 best describes my particular reasoning.
 
This game does perform very well on a PC. I have slightly above average hardware and at 8xMSAA 16xAF and maxed detail @1440x900 and get 85FPS average.
 
Going with X360 version only because my lame sauce friends only have Xbox360s. :mad:
 
PC, because of the following:

Xbox player:
"OMG! Zombie behind me!"
*push analog stick to the right*
*3 seconds later*
"Damn, I'm dead"

PC player:
"OMG! Zombie behind me!"
*wrist snap action*
"BOOM HEADSHOT!"

LoL, that made me laugh.
 
pc because i dont have a 360, although all my lame friends have a 360 :(
ill still find some people to play online with consistenly though
 
I played some l4d demo on a friend's 360 last night and oh man are the graphics terrible in comparison to a halfway decent pc.
 
Its good on the 360, but I bought it for my PC for the community and console aspects.
 
It's a Valve game. There are going to be loads of updates, skins, maps, and other mods/dlc available for the game.

The PC community will be larger. Xbox360 owners won't play it long term simply because it's not Gears of War 2, CoD 4, CoD 5, or Halo 3.

The game looks impossible to play on a controller. The devs admitted to dumbing down the AI and reducing the number of ambush attacks on 360, because of the slow response w/ joysticks. They did include a 180 degree quick turn

The only argument *for* the 360 version is that it'll be easier to get online with for beginners. People with routers will find it especially difficult on the PC. I spent about two hours helping my friend get his router configured properly... it's generally a bad idea to use a hardware or software firewall when gaming, but for some reason this game *hates* them. If you can't disable your firewall because your router sucks, configure DMZ for your PC.


I own both, and I'm planning to buy it at a discounted price for PC. If enough of my console playing friends get the game, I may rent it just to play with them.
 
eeeks...Dare I say...this game isn't that fun?

Well, I downloaded the demo and played through it. I got to say, I was expecting more. I can't put my finger on it, but it just didn't keep my attention. Graphics not great, movement was off, zombies..retarded...well yeah their zombies so not sure what I was expecting.

So now I'm not sure if I'm getting it. The Co op is the huge push, but playing GoW2 is taking care of that fix.
 
eeeks...Dare I say...this game isn't that fun?

Well, I downloaded the demo and played through it. I got to say, I was expecting more. I can't put my finger on it, but it just didn't keep my attention. Graphics not great, movement was off, zombies..retarded...well yeah their zombies so not sure what I was expecting.

So now I'm not sure if I'm getting it. The Co op is the huge push, but playing GoW2 is taking care of that fix.

Turn up the difficulty. "Normal" mode is a walk in the park with three human players.

I can see where you're conflicted on purchasing the game though. It doesn't seem like it has a ton of replay value.
 
Seems like one of those games where fast aim is going to REALLY come in handy. Based upon how the source engine has performed with other games, I bet it doesn't need a strong PC to run really well, too.
I'm pretty happy in going with Fallout 3 on the 360, but this one's PC all the way. An optimized engine and a game that needs twitchy aiming has the PC written all over it.
 
Lately I've been buying 360 games over their PC versions (like Fallout 3) but I think I'm getting L4D on the PC. I had a blast last night and although I need to try it on the 360, I think being able to aim more accurately is important since friendly fire can get you killed fast.
 
eeeks...Dare I say...this game isn't that fun?

Well, I downloaded the demo and played through it. I got to say, I was expecting more. I can't put my finger on it, but it just didn't keep my attention. Graphics not great, movement was off, zombies..retarded...well yeah their zombies so not sure what I was expecting.

So now I'm not sure if I'm getting it. The Co op is the huge push, but playing GoW2 is taking care of that fix.

:confused::confused::confused:...and an extra :eek:....

shame on you! I hope the pc gods descend from their heaven and punish thee...lol

Why is this even a poll? Funny console owners:p

Do we share the same mind or what?! My thoughts exactly lol!

Valve has shown their greatness once again!

The Co-Op action has been non-stop fun for me! I do not understand how anyone could merely dislike this game...
 
The PC version is cheaper and I like Steam (no DVD!).
Also, Mouse + Keyboard combo is king for FPS.
 
Ok, when I started this poll I had only briefly played the PC demo. Got a chance to play the 360 version tonight, and I have to say that I am 100% going to buy it on Steam. The port feels exactly like what it is: a PC game on the 360.
 
PC, definitely... though I don't touch consoles anymore anyway, so perhaps a moot point.

Level of visual quality will still have some difference, as well as performance. Doesn't push hardware such as Fallout 3 etc., but it definitely does raise the temps a bit more than previous Valve titles. It does look better and more realistic than HL2 (which I still think looks great), plus there are many AI on-screen at once, so it's a little more "hefty" than HL2 etc.

As long as Valve does something about the multicore CPU issues many people have been having. You can get around it, but it's seriously irritating. Otherwise, I couldn't be looking forward to it more.
 
this is the source engine, and this game requires fast aiming. Controller+fps=ewww
 
Though I like using mouse/kb most of all, in this game, you could still get by with a controller, because if you're positioned correctly and your team is covering their zones in a zombie rush you won't have to do quick flicks, just cover a specific area. coordinated teamplay > mouse/kb or controller.
 
never buy games on the console they are the scurge of the devil pcs are much better i finally got my console playing friend to the pc side with this game
 
Lots of console hate, that's always cute, and lame-ass, but whatever. I'm surprised people are getting so worked up over this game.

I'm not buying it on either right now. In all honesty, I think it's kind of lame, of course that's just my opinion.

Maybe I was expecting more, but I will either pick it up for $30 or less to play with friends on the 360 after this holiday season has come and gone, or maybe on the PC as an impulse buy if Steam ever runs a deal on it for like $20.
 
Though I like using mouse/kb most of all, in this game, you could still get by with a controller, because if you're positioned correctly and your team is covering their zones in a zombie rush you won't have to do quick flicks, just cover a specific area. coordinated teamplay > mouse/kb or controller.

it's easier to position yourself correctly with mouse/kb :p

mouse/kb+coordinated teamplay>controller+coordinated teamplay

.`, PC>Console
 
Cancelled my pre-order after playing the demo. The price should drop pretty quick after the holidays and It will be nice to see if they really support the console version.
 
Back
Top