Leave Six Strikes Alone!

I'm not. But, what is stopping people from doing that, aside from money? Class action? Even if no lawsuit was filed, but tens of thousands of additional 'violations' were processed that were not legitimate? Would that force them to change their methods?

BTW: These are hypothetical responses. I won't sue them. I would probably join a group to download 'fakes' to help stop the frivolous sending of notices and shutoffs. But, this is all in theory. Hell, none of it could work for all I know. Stop taking everything so literal. Damn, I'm gonna go postal (not really. That was just another statement with no meaning. Please don't read any more into it than that....).

So you're going to spend money and try to prove damages? Good luck with that.

That's why they're *not* suing you for that. They're notifying the ISP that you're infringing. That's not a DMCA notice. As far as I'm aware, ISP's are going along with this six-strikes system by choice and not because the law is forcing them to.

If you want to turn around and sue the person who sent the notices(you'll probably never actually be able to find out exactly who that was), go for it. You'll accomplish nothing and waste a lot of your own time and money doing it, but feel free.
 
I don't care what the message says. They have to prove that IP is me. Period. I am not an ip. Good luck with that.
 
I don't care what the message says. They have to prove that IP is me. Period. I am not an ip. Good luck with that.

Sadly, I don't think the ISP cares. They don't take the customers input on these. It's all the notices. If they get 6 (warranted or not), they shut you off. Apparently, they were paid off somewhere.
 
I can tell you the same thing others have. I worked for Comcast at one point and the only customers who had similar service issues were those on an overloaded node. Of course adding another costs big money and why do that if the customers sit there content with a fraction of he service they subscibe for while still getting a full monthly payment from you.

I actually had a TWC Level 3 Tech Support lie to me. He claimed the node wasn't overloaded even though it was (The Duck Test works here; if you are getting slow downs only during peak hours and you have an excellent signal and you are on a DOCSIS 3.0 Modem that is channel bonding, then it is a node issue). I found them much more cooperative when I informed them that I also controlled the purse strings on my employer's fiber optic Internet connection; an Internet connection which costs more in one month than most people pay in a year.
 
an Internet connection which costs more in one month than most people pay in a year.

So do our awesomely fast 4 bonded T-1's. :D

Tech support tries to do the least work they can and move on to the next ticket ASAP. Even if they know it is their problem, as long as it's 'working', it's good on their end.
 
I like how in this somewhat automated copyright infringement noticed provided via the BitTorrentFreak link earlier in this thread, the copyright violation type is listed as 'null'. Are they trying to say the copy right violation doesn't exist? that the copyright violation is 'void'? It seems like you'd be able to appeal the strike on the basis of they don't even know what type of copyright violation allegedly occurred. 'You did NULL on NULL and should be punished via means of NULL'.
 
I like how in this somewhat automated copyright infringement noticed provided via the BitTorrentFreak link earlier in this thread, the copyright violation type is listed as 'null'. Are they trying to say the copy right violation doesn't exist? that the copyright violation is 'void'? It seems like you'd be able to appeal the strike on the basis of they don't even know what type of copyright violation allegedly occurred. 'You did NULL on NULL and should be punished via means of NULL'.

Automated.... Spam-Bot of infringement notices. Mistakes don't happen. The violation type of 'null' means that it was null-y an infringement. It's French for "A big infringement".
 
I like how in this somewhat automated copyright infringement noticed provided via the BitTorrentFreak link earlier in this thread, the copyright violation type is listed as 'null'. Are they trying to say the copy right violation doesn't exist?
No, that's not what it means. :p

There could be a couple of reasons why 2 lines state "null". One is that the data being merged to generate the email didn't contain any data for that field, and the field defaults to null. There is sufficient data in the other fields to see what, when, how and what party caused the infringement notice to be sent. No, that does not mean that all the other non-null fields become invalid.

Another possibility is that the "Infringement Type" was dropped, column name changed or there is an error in naming the merge field. I'd imagine that a link to the "Reporting Party FAQ" may not exist yet, or hasn't been entered.
 
Well...I know this was emailed to Steve, and he seems to never have [posted it:

There are NEVER false positives with this asinine system:


Six Strikes Firm Flags Game Mods as Copyright Violations
http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Six-Strikes-Firm-Flags-Game-Mods-as-Copyright-Violations-123368

It's amazing how things get distorted in the echo chamber of the internet.

Here's the original story:

Reader David Sutherland emailed us this week about a DMCA notice that he received via his MediaFire account. The notice, which we've included below (including all of the crappy formatting) claimed that he was using MediaFire to host "one of the following files: Downton Abbey, CONTRABAND (2012), GRIMM (2011), House M.D., MAN WITH THE IRON FISTS, THE, The Office."

Last I checked the six strikes system was directed at ISPs and end users. Last I checked MediaFire is a CyberLocker, not an ISP. Yet the headline of the article is:

System Used By New Six Strikes CAS, Falsely Identifies Game Mods As NBC TV Shows

So where does the Six Strikes policy come into it?

Of course, we've seen plenty of bogus DMCA takedowns. It happens all the time. But this one is doubly important, because it's from DtecNet, a division of MarkMonitor. MarkMonitor/Dtecnet also just happen to be the company providing the key monitoring for the new "six strikes" Copyright Alert System (CAS).

Wait, but the article said that this takedown was from THE system that's driving the CAS. Well, I find that hard to believe, because:

The Center for Copyright Information employs the services of MarkMonitor (often d/b/a DtecNet) to detect and monitor suspected copyright infringement activity.[7] Although MarkMonitor monitors many infringement venues, the EFF says that at this time, it appears that for purposes of the CAS, the company will only monitor peer-to-peer traffic from public BitTorrent trackers.[8]
A review of MarkMonitor's system for the CAS states that infringement is only considered detected for uploads, when MarkMonitor's BitTorrent client successfully obtains pieces of known-infringing content from a peer in the swarm.[9] The pieces are compared to pieces from an already-downloaded copy of the content, which has already been matched to content samples supplied by the copyright owners.

So if the CAS is only monitoring public torrent trackers, then how can this alert to a CyberLocker be from the CAS? Maybe TechDirt has a source it didn't feel like sharing in the article, but I can't help but observer that making the connection to Six Strikes front and center was a great way to make the article sensational and drive page clicks.

Despite it being confined to one sentence in the original TechDirt article, this gets played up to near-hysterics at the DSLReports link you provided:

That doesn't really bode well for a copyright enforcement system that can now result in users being throttled or losing their broadband connections entirely for a day. Supporters of the new Copyright Alert System (CAS) will of course argue that it's still early, even though we've been seeing these kinds of false-positive DMCA screw ups for a long, long time now. On the plus side, you get to pay $35 to protest your innocence while they slowly figure out that the TV show you downloaded was actually a Skyrim mod.

Until we get to a comment on the story from the OP by a visitor to TechGage called GasBandit:

So what do you have to say about the now infamous mistaken strike issued for a Guild Wars 2 mod?

http://www.dslreports.com/show...

It happened so damn fast after six strikes went active, we'll probably see people getting six of these things by the end of the year.

So over the course of three hops (TechDirt -> DSLReports -> TechGage comment) a MediaFire account suspension that has at best a tenuous connection to Six Strikes gets turned into end users getting "strikes" from their ISP for downloading a game mod. People need to stop, think, read, and know what they're talking about before they speak.

I'm not saying Six Strikes is the correct answer to anything. But I agree with the article from the OP in the general sense that, since last Monday there is now a system in place that gives me six chances before the MPAA can try to sue me out of my home. This did not exist prior to that. I doubt it's going to be 100% accurate (in fact I think that TechGage's 1:6 false positive:genuine alert ratio is extremely optimistic), but I'd rather pay $35 to fight a bogus "strike" than pay a lawyer to fight a bogus lawsuit. And it's in my ISP's best interest to help me fight bogus strikes if they get to the point of mitigation measures, because if they don't I will vote with my wallet for an ISP that doesn't assume I'm a criminal.
 
I'm not saying Six Strikes is the correct answer to anything. But I agree with the article from the OP in the general sense that, since last Monday there is now a system in place that gives me six chances before the MPAA can try to sue me out of my home. This did not exist prior to that.

Yeah, except before there was about a snowball's chance in hell that you would actually get sued, whereas now they can document at least six instances of alleged fermenting and then go after more people.

I honestly don't see how this is "better" in any way.
 
EDIT: fermenting = infringement. I have no idea why it auto-corrected to that...
 
because if they don't I will vote with my wallet for an ISP that doesn't assume I'm a criminal.

LMAO...then you're unlike about 99% of Americans...who have a grand "choice" of one ISP in their city. If you're really "lucky" you have TWO....and odds are both presume you to be a criminal.
 
LMAO...then you're unlike about 99% of Americans...who have a grand "choice" of one ISP in their city. If you're really "lucky" you have TWO....and odds are both presume you to be a criminal.

Sad but true, even guys who go on about how bad some company is and how they'll never buy their games, will probably, at some point, buy their games. Save a couple of people...
 
Yeah, except before there was about a snowball's chance in hell that you would actually get sued
Please. Exorbitant settlements and rulings for copyright infringement are constantly in the news. It's practically a regular monthly event - some single mom or grandmother gets asked to pay millions of dollars for sharing a Justin Bieber song/an episode of Here Comes Honey Boo Boo, and all the same people show up here saying what a racket the MPAA are.
 
Back
Top