LCD Monitors That Scale For Consoles

Volucris

Gawd
Joined
Oct 16, 2005
Messages
748
So right now I have a Soyo 24" P-MVA, Samsung 226BW, and a Viewsonic VX924. None of them scale correctly for use with my Xbox 360. What I am looking for is an LCD monitor that does scale correctly for once. I have about $300 and would like find an LCD that could mainly be used for playing my Xbox 360 with the correct aspect ratio. It's a pain in the ass to play with a distorted image.

If anyone has recommendations for a LCD monitor that can scale a 16:9 image CORRECTLY, please post some info.


Thank you.
 
LG might have some weird monitors for you,

When I say "weird" I mean they are hybrid monitor/TV models that I've seen around at Canadian Brick/mortar places. They should be available elsewhere too.

The M228WA-BM seems to be a monitor with a digital tuner that has all of the modes that the higher 24" models have that allow 16:9 over HDMI... Mainly there is an "ARC" menu that has options for scaling or preserving 16:9 content.

Apparently the L226WA does as well. I've seen Youtube videos with a PS3 running on it that is clearly displaying black bars top and bottom.

You may want to check those out.

Should be cheap.

10e
 
It would actually be very helpful (maybe sticky?) to list the known 22" and 24" monitors that can do 1:1 and scale PS3 and Xbox 360 image accurately.
 
I totally agree,

In my experiences using consoles over VGA, HDMI, or DVI I have seen a number of monitors which can do good scaling with 720p, 1080i, and 1080p resolutions, as well as some that do a good job with 480p.

For example, the BenQ FP241VW I have does a very good job with PS3 over component and DVI/HDMI and Xbox 360 over VGA, component and HDMI. The G2400W is almost as good, except at 1920x1080 over VGA it stretches the image to 16:10 (1920x1200). Otherwise it is also quite good.

Another thing is overscan. Some monitors will cut off the outside of the image, up to 5%. Some (like the G2400W) will only do 1%. But the BenQs both have the advantage of allowing overscan on/off (with the newer firmwares).

My Westinghouse L2410NM does a great job as well over all connections, and only allows the user to turn on overscan via a "zoom" option in the OSD. Also very good.

Other monitors are a crapshoot. Some will do overscan over HDMI with video sources, but not PC sources (as they autodetect). Some will do weird stretching (Samsung 2493HM) of 1080p and overscan parts of the image (cut it off).

We should create an "A/V sticky" to evaluate how monitors display A/V sources. It's a burgeoning market and there are both 22" and 24" monitors that work well.

Funny enough the LG's I've tried work far better than Samsungs even though both companies are well versed with TV technology.

Sorry for the rant, but your post was a good idea.

10e

It would actually be very helpful (maybe sticky?) to list the known 22" and 24" monitors that can do 1:1 and scale PS3 and Xbox 360 image accurately.
 
Back
Top