Last Year's iPhones Get Controversial Processor Throttling Feature

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
According to an update on the company’s official iPhone Battery and Performance support page, Apple will, like previous models, throttle the processor of the iPhone 8 and X when their batteries degrade to a certain point to prevent unexpected shutdown. Users were furious when this practice came to light last year, but due to all of that controversy, iOS 11.3 has an option for turning the feature off.

This practice of throttling older devices recently resulted in a €5 million ($5.7 million) fine for Apple in an antitrust case brought by Italy’s competition and market authority, the Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato (AGCM). It objected to Apple slowing down its phones without telling customers or giving them the ability to return to a previous version of the software.
 
Much ado about nothing.

Better to throttle than cause immediate shutdowns like most other phones. Once batteries degrade, the internal resistance goes up and the voltage drops more during load transients, which can cause nuisance triggering of critical battery shutdown.
 
Are you telling me I-phone X models are already having the batteries degrade?

Jeeze

Batteries start to degrade as soon as you use them for the first time...


Curious as to the life expectancy of these iPhone batteries before they get to that point, didn't see it in the article.

Well I can tell you my Note 4 battery started turning off by itself around 30% and it was only 12 months old.

Its a way of the world, accept it. At least Apple are trying to get more useful life from the phones.
 
I SUPPOSE its something that they are announcing it now, instead of doing it covertly like before.
Still a fucktard of a company though
 
Probably one of the smartest features ever implemented in a phone, but some jackass somewhere saw in a benchmark his phone was now 5% slower so he had to go all nerd-rage.

But thanks to him I got my "mostly OK" battery replaced for super cheap. 2-year phone and my battery still had 60% life.
 
Much ado about nothing.

Better to throttle than cause immediate shutdowns like most other phones. Once batteries degrade, the internal resistance goes up and the voltage drops more during load transients, which can cause nuisance triggering of critical battery shutdown.
No, better to notify users that their battery needs replaced instead of silent bullshit features designed to encourage people to just but a new phone.
 
Why is this news? I thought this shit was baked into iOS at this point. I know that for a long time I could check my battery health on my 8+. I just assumed throttling was also in the cards down the line.

That said, my phone is just over a year old and 93% so I can’t imagine what people are doing to their batteries to already have to worry about this.
 
Why is this news? I thought this shit was baked into iOS at this point. I know that for a long time I could check my battery health on my 8+. I just assumed throttling was also in the cards down the line.

That said, my phone is just over a year old and 93% so I can’t imagine what people are doing to their batteries to already have to worry about this.
because it gets clicks, no one cares about android crap but if you mention anything Apple the views/clicks skyrockets.
 
As long as it is publicized, can be turned off or better yet adjusted, then it is a good thing. Not as good as easy to replace batteries, but a good thing. Heck, if it isn't already an option, add one to throttle full time for those occasions when longer battery life is better then full CPU performance.
 
As long as it is publicized, can be turned off or better yet adjusted, then it is a good thing. Not as good as easy to replace batteries, but a good thing. Heck, if it isn't already an option, add one to throttle full time for those occasions when longer battery life is better then full CPU performance.

Yeah, just be honest about the function and give your customers some degree of control over it and it actually does become a feature.
 
Why is this news? I thought this shit was baked into iOS at this point. I know that for a long time I could check my battery health on my 8+.
It's not news. This was part of iOS 11.3...back in March when it was announced (that's when the article was dated, too).

But nonetheless, buckle in because you know the shitstorm that's coming...
 
Are you telling me I-phone X models are already having the batteries degrade?

Jeeze

God I hate this article.

ALL the phones have this shit on them, even my brand new XS. Some fucktard saw a comment in code and got pissed apple didn't want to explain themselves to some blogger and is making a scene.

This technology is there. If your phone looks like the battery is degrading, it'll do what it can to mask it unless you override that function explicitly. The battery will degrade based on charge cycles and heat. You can be like me and have had an iphone 6 that wasn't getting throttled at ~4 years old, or you can be cycling the battery near 100% multiple itmes a day in which case.. yeah a 1 year old iphone X may be a near the point it needs to be throttled to avoid shutdowns from voltage sag.
 
No, better to notify users that their battery needs replaced instead of silent bullshit features designed to encourage people to just but a new phone.

At least Apple will replace batteries for you. Try taking a Nexus 6P or HTC phone to some shady mall shop, 50% chance they can't get it back together because the main structural component is glue.
 
That totally depends on how the user treats the battery. Each time you go under 15% you're damaging your battery, and this is even moreso if you hit 0%. It's the nature of lithium batteries.

Exactly, and Lithium Ion / LiPo batteries have barely gotten any better in 15 years. Every phone uses the same shit just different capacity. I don't know why people don't understand that.
 
This is why you need to have swappable batteries and not built in ones...

Woah there, that's pretty extreme. Replaceable battery.

Unfortunately any dream of that coming back has been killed with "premium materials" and waterproofing. I don't get my phone wet, I have never replaced a phone due to water damage.

I will say, at least Apple has their own service centers and will replace your battery with an OEM battery, and the phone goes back together. I have had a lot of issues with various Android phones because the phones are difficult to reassemble or you can't even get an OEM battery so you need to gamble on low quality replacements.
 
Much ado about nothing.

Better to throttle than cause immediate shutdowns like most other phones. Once batteries degrade, the internal resistance goes up and the voltage drops more during load transients, which can cause nuisance triggering of critical battery shutdown.
Are you even for real? Let's say ford sneaks into your garage and installs an "update" on your car that will prevent it form going over 55mph, it is the same damn thing. Much ado about nothing my ass.

Not to mention if a phone starts shutting down unexpectedly after 1-2 years that is a damn design flaw, which apple should inform their customers about and replace batteries in a damn recall! Not sneak around installing throttling on devices.
 
Are you even for real? Let's say ford sneaks into your garage and installs an "update" on your car that will prevent it form going over 55mph, it is the same damn thing. Much ado about nothing my ass.

Not to mention if a phone starts shutting down unexpectedly after 1-2 years that is a damn design flaw, which apple should inform their customers about and replace batteries in a damn recall! Not sneak around installing throttling on devices.
Not even close to the same thing.

Ignoring the fact that cars *are* sold with electronic speed limitations that aren't published or user-controlled, a relevant analogy would be if Ford had installed a feature where the car would go into limp mode instead of stranding someone on the side of the road. Apple didn't cap the phones to run slower, they implemented a mechanism that slows the "throttle" when it's running out of "gas." In fact, VW does this with their eGolfs and rather than get all up in arms that I can't floor my car until it literally stops moving in the middle of the road the car's ability to self-regulate discharge through any means necessary (shutting off comfort controls, reducing speed, and eventually going into "turtle" mode, which is like creeping along at 5 or 10 miles per hour...I've only done that once LOL) is generally seen as a good thing by the owners for what I would hope are obvious reasons.

Besides, M76, aren't you upset at Blizzard for Diablo: Immortal? Who games on their phones, right? Throttling doesn't have any impact on phone calls.
 
This is a good thing. I have an android for my personal phone BUT I unfortunately "own" an apple phone for work. It is literally only used for ... work calls, email, onetime pass...
The longer this thing stays "active" between chargers the better for myself
 
Are you even for real? Let's say ford sneaks into your garage and installs an "update" on your car that will prevent it form going over 55mph, it is the same damn thing. Much ado about nothing my ass.

Not to mention if a phone starts shutting down unexpectedly after 1-2 years that is a damn design flaw, which apple should inform their customers about and replace batteries in a damn recall! Not sneak around installing throttling on devices.

Ford does....

Lots of them do. Biggest one I remember that was somewhat recent was with the mustang, limited top speed, but not due to gearing or power, 100% electronic, people found out how to remove this in the ECU and people starting doing it.....Come to find out the driveshaft was not rated for those speeds and could self destruct one of the joints causing serious damage and risk to the driver. Not the first or last speed governor on a car for any number of reasons, the 186MPH speed limit on motorcycles was also very well known.

1-2 years of phone use is a lot, as most phones are used or on/charging 24/7, they are some of the most used and abused batteries out there. Now, I do think phones need much bigger batteries, or removable ones at least for reasons like this. But I also understand Apple doing this to keep it's older phones stable over time, they are also good with updating older phones, something Android has gotten better with (at least Google phones), but could still improve on.
 
Well my V30 was bought at launch and from 6am this morning when I took it off the charger till now 4:23 its down to 95%

This sucker last a long time unless I'm using my daydream and Bluetooth headset.

So if the iphone beast are losing charge by the end of the day I would pay the 80$ and replace the battery.
 
Back
Top