Labels, Game Developers Feud Over Fees

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I have no idea why I act so surprised when I hear stuff like this. Honestly, how many people are “shocked” to hear that record labels are trying to shake down game developers for higher fees to use music in their games?

As such, it's hard to blame Warner Music Group chairman/CEO Edgar Bronfman Jr. for wanting a bigger slice of that pie. During a conference call with Wall Street analysts to discuss the label's fiscal third-quarter operating results last month, Bronfman lambasted the "paltry" per-song licensing fees labels get when making their content available in music games and warned that Warner would stop licensing to them if the model did not change.
 
Boo Hoo we don't like the agreement we signed so now we want more money or you get nothing from us. I understand this is business but the music industry cries so much does anyone really care about them anymore. Exactly how many artists would come off of the track lists if Warner did pull their support?
 
Quite sad to hear about this, the music industry shouldn't even hold a candle to the freaking game development industry about this. Not with their track history at the very least, just another CEO squeezing another cent out.
 
I love how the Music industry always wants more and more every month. Isn't the RIAA rich enough?
 
I guess the record industry, or at least the moron mouthing off here, doesn't realize that that vast majority of the game industry doesn't need their specific music for games. Sure, it's used sometimes but for the most part, it's not necessary. Sure, there are exceptions like Guitar Hero and the like, but that is a small fraction of games.

Licensing music to the game industry is basically free money as well as free publicity. It's stupid to get greedy about it.

 
Though, yes, the crappy deals Bronfman/Warner signed for Guitar Hero and Rock Band are their own fault, I actually have to side with Bronfman on this one. Unlike the deals where record companies charge a one time fee for use in a movie or similar work, the music in Guitar Hero/Rock band is not incidental to the game. In fact, it's an integral part of the game. Without the highly familiar tunes, these games would not anywhere as near as popular. Who the hell wants to pretend they're nailing the riff from some studio musician's generic performance? A royalty rate not unlike record companies charge for tunes used on compilation albums would not be out of the question.
 
Guitar Hero could have bombed and the record companies wouldn't have given a shit.

Why should the makers of Guitar Hero pay more royalties now that their investment risk has paid off?

If the game had been a total bomb, no one would have given them their money back, so why do they have to pay entities who had no risk in the original investment?

I'd rape the selfish pricks a new one.
 
The next Guitar Hero will be just as popular if they use non-RIAA labels and indie bands. F*** the crooks at the RIAA..
 
This sounds a lot like the guy that was the main voice actor in GTA 4... He wanted more money after the game sold so well....

I guess it's the thing to do now? Everyone involved in the game should reap some type of profit sharing?

How about the games that flop? Are these voice actors and music execs gonna pay money to the developer when their game flops?

...didn't think so.
 
I guess the record industry, or at least the moron mouthing off here, doesn't realize that that vast majority of the game industry doesn't need their specific music for games. Sure, it's used sometimes but for the most part, it's not necessary. Sure, there are exceptions like Guitar Hero and the like, but that is a small fraction of games.

Licensing music to the game industry is basically free money as well as free publicity. It's stupid to get greedy about it.
I genuinely concur; on another perspective, if the music industry backs off due to the game industry not faltering to their demands, this could potentially mean more jobs for composers for required music? I could be thinking about it in the wrong perspective though.
 
To be honest, I'm not a huge fan of the specific songs they picked on Guitar Hero.

Why not come up with an algorithm that allows the game to read your favorite mp3's off of a thumb-drive and derive the guitar notes off of the actual track? It can't be THAT difficult...but then again WTF do I know...

I agree that I wouldn't have cared if they used no-name Indie music instead. It's not like I need to hear Alice Cooper's "Schools Out" one more time before I die.
 
This sounds a lot like the guy that was the main voice actor in GTA 4... He wanted more money after the game sold so well....

I guess it's the thing to do now? Everyone involved in the game should reap some type of profit sharing?

How about the games that flop? Are these voice actors and music execs gonna pay money to the developer when their game flops?

...didn't think so.

There's a difference though. Voice actors get paid jack and shit to begin with, unless they've established themselves in Hollywood first. (i.e. Eddie Murphy for Shrek) And chances are they're not in Hollywood because they don't have the Hollywood looks. Seriously. Point out to me one famous plug ugly woman in Hollywood that's winning awards left and right for the movies she's starred in.
 
There's a difference though. Voice actors get paid jack and shit to begin with, unless they've established themselves in Hollywood first. (i.e. Eddie Murphy for Shrek) And chances are they're not in Hollywood because they don't have the Hollywood looks. Seriously. Point out to me one famous plug ugly woman in Hollywood that's winning awards left and right for the movies she's starred in.

America Ferrera

Where's my cookie?
 
Has anybody told them that the RIAA's bargaining position is unbelieveably weak? From what I've heard, the original Guitar Hero used cover bands.

There is a fixed "shall licence" fee attached to song writers. The developers pay the fee to the song writer, hire a cover band, and put the cover in the game. I think its done in movies as well, in Star Trek IV the music the punk on the bus is listening to is covered (well, it's punk: you need to slap a few guitar strings, hit the drums, and scream into the mike).
 
Though, yes, the crappy deals Bronfman/Warner signed for Guitar Hero and Rock Band are their own fault, I actually have to side with Bronfman on this one. Unlike the deals where record companies charge a one time fee for use in a movie or similar work, the music in Guitar Hero/Rock band is not incidental to the game. In fact, it's an integral part of the game. Without the highly familiar tunes, these games would not anywhere as near as popular. Who the hell wants to pretend they're nailing the riff from some studio musician's generic performance? A royalty rate not unlike record companies charge for tunes used on compilation albums would not be out of the question.

Except for the fact that Guitar Hero and games like it has renewed interest in the music included in it. The RIAA companies that have licensed their music to these music games have benefited greatly. It is not a one sided deal at all since there are periphery benefits to the RIAA in the form of increased interest in music they own the distribution rights to. The games publishers are paying the RIAA to advertise their songs. If that's not a steal, I don't know what is.

They should just skip the RIAA and go where the real music is. There are huge numbers of independents that have decent music and would be more than willing to license it for peanuts.
 
Back
Top