'Killer Robots' Could Be Outlawed

"What we are talking about however is fully-automated machines that can select targets and kill them without any human intervention. And that is something we should all be very worried about."

Google unveiled Google Defense Systems this morning...

terminator.jpg
 
Neat story, totally unrealistic and unbelievably naive though.

Didn't Libya just gas a bunch of rebels, illegally?

This is one of those deals where doing what is illegal will give you a huge military advantage over everyone who doesn't do the same thing. The only way to win this game is not be the guy that get's caught.
 
Murder is already illegal, so it should apply to robots, too. Nothing to worry about, guys. Murder doesn't happen because it's outlawed.
 
So when killer robots realize we outlawed them they will just seek to outlaw us. Purging us from the planet except the ones they need to use as a power source for their batteries.
 
Fuck that. I for one welcome our robot overlords with open arms.

And while you are being vein fed,your overlord will rule your ass with their cold hard steely rods forever more(sounds republican like don't you think?)
 
And while you are being vein fed,your overlord will rule your ass with their cold hard steely rods forever more(sounds republican like don't you think?)

I was sort of hoping for a fem-bot overlord. A gentle one that's too proud to see me work.

That would show my wife!
 
The sad state is this isn't about "Terminator" type machines. This is aimed squarely at US drones, and how some of them are getting to be quite autonomous.

The US is really making a push towards drones for a variety of reasons, and the UN (or those who are pushing this) do not want the US to have this military advantage. The upside is the US does have permanent veto power, even if I don't agree with it.
 
The sad state is this isn't about "Terminator" type machines. This is aimed squarely at US drones, and how some of them are getting to be quite autonomous.

The US is really making a push towards drones for a variety of reasons, and the UN (or those who are pushing this) do not want the US to have this military advantage. The upside is the US does have permanent veto power, even if I don't agree with it.

Yeah, there's a pretty big upside to that drone program too, I know they make for terrible press and there's no doubt that innocent people get hurt. More innocent people get hurt when war has to be declared on entire countries that are sheltering the nut jobs though.

It's a complicated issue that I'm really glad I'm not the one making the decisions on.
 
Funny, the US doesn't seem to care what the UN bans or asks us to sign against you know, slavery and abuse of minors, because the US doesn't believe it needs to listen to any foreign powers. Not that I have a problem with the US's attitude considering China, Russia and some others pretty much have the run of things now.
 
We don't have killer robots in the Terminator sense of the word, but we have smart drones that hunt targets using AI to determine the best route to a target and even working on self guided jet fighters (so I guess Hunter Killers from the Terminator sense of the word).
 
sry double post, I just remembered this.

We even had an AI controlled drone go AWOL and decide to go after someone completely random and the Air Force was forced to shoot it down before it crossed in to an allies air space.

http://blogs.airspacemag.com/daily-planet/2009/09/robot-airplane-goes-awol-gets-shot-down/

...looks like we had more drones go AWOL since that incident, including one over US soil. Maybe the Terminator films had something.
 
Neat story, totally unrealistic and unbelievably naive though.

Didn't Libya just gas a bunch of rebels, illegally?

This is one of those deals where doing what is illegal will give you a huge military advantage over everyone who doesn't do the same thing. The only way to win this game is not be the guy that get's caught.

well this goes beyond that, the UN has authorized attacking various nations, so it supports live soldiers killing other people, but oh we have to keep robots from doing it. WTF?!?!


The sad state is this isn't about "Terminator" type machines. This is aimed squarely at US drones, and how some of them are getting to be quite autonomous.

The US is really making a push towards drones for a variety of reasons, and the UN (or those who are pushing this) do not want the US to have this military advantage. The upside is the US does have permanent veto power, even if I don't agree with it.

Exactly.

While the article lists many items that could potentially be covered it fails to address computerized counter sniper and counter battery systems which have been are already in limited use that can automatically return fire on a target which fires into it's sensor field.

Sounds like a bunch of countries that don't have advanced tech trying to hold back those that do.

I'm curious, does the UN have a "law" against hijacking planes full of civilians and crashing them into towers full of civilians?
 
Also there is a noticeable delay in using drones due to the time it takes the signal to be received. Banning "killer robots" could also fall under the guise of, person at console sees target tells drone to kill target, and it has some automated routine to recalculate direction/speed/etc in real time without the use of an operator.
 
No way will the US agree to that.

I have a better idea, lets ban killer humans.
 
No way will the US agree to that.

I have a better idea, lets ban killer humans.

Or go one better... and just kill those killer humans! No tree hugging hippies or brain dead hipster-milk-comes-from-the-shop decisions! ;)
 
Yeah, there's a pretty big upside to that drone program too, I know they make for terrible press and there's no doubt that innocent people get hurt. More innocent people get hurt when war has to be declared on entire countries that are sheltering the nut jobs though.

It's a complicated issue that I'm really glad I'm not the one making the decisions on.

Drones should be a precision instrument but when you use them with the finesse of a dumb artillary shell, it will cause harm like one. To use them with precision you need intel and for intel you need allies on the ground you don't throw away like used Kleenex (Shakil Afridi). And we've been using drones for a while and suddenly they got messy 3-4 years ago, I don't think that's a coincidence.
 
It's a far cry from their original role which was limited to recon.
 
In other, more tragic news...

... while we worry about robots killing us, enslaving us or turning us into their organic batteries...

... a Roomba-like bot has committed suicide.

http://kotaku.com/tragic-robot-suicide-stuns-small-town-1464850323

Poor little guy probably couldn't take it anymore seeing the whole world was growing more and more paranoid of its robotic brethren, and decided to end its own mechanical little life.
The home-owner had put the small robot on the work surface to clean up some spilled cereal. Once the robot had done its job it was switched off but left on the kitchen sideboard.

The 44-year-old house owner, together with his wife and son, then left the house and were not home when the robot set off.

Somehow it seems to have reactivated itself and made its way along the work surface where it pushed a cooking pot out of the way and basically that was the end of it.
It pretty quickly started to melt underneath and then stuck to the kitchen hotplate. It then caught fire. By the time we arrived, it was just a pile of ash.
 
My take of this is "Could Be" => "Currently Isn't"

So, if anyone asks for me, i'll be crafting my army of Killer Robots, 100% legal

;)
 
My take of this is "Could Be" => "Currently Isn't"

So, if anyone asks for me, i'll be crafting my army of Killer Robots, 100% legal

;)

Totally possible actually. Because the hardware cost has come down so much, hobbyists have been tinkering with Arduino based multirotors. I can't find the video right now but it was a demo of a home built multirotor with the ability to identify and track purely through visual id. No barcodes, no GPS, no beacons, no QRCode. To make up for the lack of CPU power, it had a datalink with the computer at the groundstation doing the data crunching.

Another multirotor project had it navigating the terrain and can even tell how far they are not by lasers, or infrared, but simply by having two cameras to give it stereo vision. Same deal, it's data linked to a groundstation.

What really made them stand out is the fact that they didn't have multi million dollar contracts, or university grants, they're made by regular people that tinker in their basement as a hobby. And the code they're built on is open source.

So if you wanted to, you can very well have a dozen of them patrolling your yard rather inexpensively (relatively speaking) and all you need is a PC in the house to act as the brain.
 
And while you are being vein fed,your overlord will rule your ass with their cold hard steely rods forever more(sounds republican like don't you think?)

I will take the bait... but it was the Democrat who raised taxes to pay for said robot in exchange for the health care bill passing.

Both parties suck.
 
...and decide to go after someone completely random...

Umm, this is just a little humor on your part right?

I know, I know, I'm wrapped a little too tight. They destroyed the drone so no one could get their hands on the tech, not because it was going to go attack someone all on it's own, other then maybe a freak kamikaze thing.
 
Once killer robots are outlawed, only outlaws will have KILLER ROBOTS!

FIGHT FOR YOUR RIGHTS TO KILLER ROBOTS!!
 
So if you wanted to, you can very well have a dozen of them patrolling your yard rather inexpensively (relatively speaking) and all you need is a PC in the house to act as the brain.

Those would be defensive robots!, i want Killer Robots!, ones who may want to, maybe, skin it's victim to make it's perfect meatbag suit!... or Meatbag Furniture!

Maybe i should try and program some to be Humanitarians somehow, just as there are some who run on urine... others should prolly try and go for the Hunter of the Most Dangerous Game title!

:p :)
 
Neat story, totally unrealistic and unbelievably naive though.

Didn't Libya just gas a bunch of rebels, illegally?

This is one of those deals where doing what is illegal will give you a huge military advantage over everyone who doesn't do the same thing. The only way to win this game is not be the guy that get's caught.

Syria, not Libya.

As for the topic: looks like whoever enforces this ban is going to have a busy year at the Department of Defense.
 
Your right, Syria.

Naaa, Autonomous robots isn't really our thing, we prefer ours to have operators.
 
Back
Top