Kickstarter Is Not a Store

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Ladies and gentlemen, Kickstarter would like to announce that it is not a store. I repeat, Kickstarter is not a store. Oh yeah, they changed a bunch of rules too.

It's hard to know how many people feel like they're shopping at a store when they're backing projects on Kickstarter, but we want to make sure that it's no one. Today we're introducing a number of changes to reinforce that Kickstarter isn’t a store — it’s a new way for creators and audiences to work together to make things. We’d like to walk you through these changes.
 
Bound to happen and I'm just surprised it didn't happen sooner. A lot of idiots out there think it's just another e bay. I don't understand people who think they are going to get a off the rack, polished product. It's like donating to charity, folks. Why is this so hard for people to get?
 
Eh, not quite charity. They usually are supposed to get something back.
 
I grasp it isn't a store. I like the product kickstarters and have backed several. Kickstarter likes to pretend it's geared towards the artistic. However, I couldn't give a crap about the 1283679213641283764283748383rd photo-essay coffee table book listed on it in the last week. How is a a rendering of a potential product more misleading than some images in a plea to fund a vacation with a camera to someplace bohemian using a couple of photos that may or may not belong to the actual person who will receive the check? In the majority of cases, it is also unclear what quality of print or book you will receive for your donation.

You are backing someone's idea. I have no problem with standards for disclosure, but kickstarter needs to stop playing thought police on whose ideas are creative enough to be called creative.
 
■Product simulations are prohibited. Projects cannot simulate events to demonstrate what a product might do in the future. Products can only be shown performing actions that they’re able to perform in their current state of development.
■Product renderings are prohibited. Product images must be photos of the prototype as it currently exists.

Shall be harder for some of the scam projects to fool the idiots now. :D
 
lol product simulations are prohibited?

wow that really kills what people usually pay for in kickstarter. people usually want to see thoughts of the end goal of a product before supporting it.
 
all the kickstarters should go on shark tank.

I enjoy that show a lot better than reading though kickstarter
 
It's not a store,

It's a laughable scam.

We'll see in 2-3 years when all these funded games and projects horribly fail with absolutely no return to their "investors" other than lame excuses.

Am I cynical? Maybe. But given the current track record, it's a road that doesn't lead much to anywhere.
 
It's not a store,

It's a laughable scam.

We'll see in 2-3 years when all these funded games and projects horribly fail with absolutely no return to their "investors" other than lame excuses.

Am I cynical? Maybe. But given the current track record, it's a road that doesn't lead much to anywhere.

Out of the over 30,000 funded projects, which were scams and which failed?
 
Why is this a difficult concept to grasp?

It is an investment, not a sale. Like all investments, there is a degree of risk.
 
It's not a store,

It's a laughable scam.

We'll see in 2-3 years when all these funded games and projects horribly fail with absolutely no return to their "investors" other than lame excuses.

Am I cynical? Maybe. But given the current track record, it's a road that doesn't lead much to anywhere.

I'm curious why the vocal opponents are so vehemently opposed to KS ... I can understand why someone wouldn't want to give money personally to a KS project but some people seem offended by the whole process ... I have only given to one project so far (Grim Dawn) and probably will give to the Obsidian project before it ends but I have wasted more money on a crappy dinner sometimes ... I think it is an interesting concept and it's probably too early to tell how it will play out but many of the game projects are coming from gaming professionals ... there is no reason to doubt that they won't release a product of some kind ... it might suck horribly but hey it won't be the first time I have bought a game that blows and it probably won't be the last time either ... and none of those other purchases were from KS ;) :cool:
 
I got more faith in indie game developers delivering than say.....making x blog video bout x topic.
 
A step in the right direction I think. Sometimes I wonder about some of the projects that are on there. Nothing but renderings and concept art about a completely nonexistent product that's probably nothing but a pipe dream.

I'm curious why the vocal opponents are so vehemently opposed to KS ... I can understand why someone wouldn't want to give money personally to a KS project but some people seem offended by the whole process ...

I see the same types of comments in any thread related to Kickstarter, and always by the same people. I think some people just have a need to complain and be agreed with or something. I just tend to ignore it because I think it's about on the same level as trolling, because it really serves no purpose other than attempting to derail the threads.

Just like members from the anti-Steam brigade that feel the need to crap on every thread remotely related to Steam because 'LOL DRM' or whatever.
 
It's not a store,

It's a laughable scam.

We'll see in 2-3 years when all these funded games and projects horribly fail with absolutely no return to their "investors" other than lame excuses.

Am I cynical? Maybe. But given the current track record, it's a road that doesn't lead much to anywhere.

Lot of people would disagree with you on that.

your "Laughable scam" is a tool for people to fund a project that otherwise might never see the light of day. that's all it is. what people make of it is up to them. When companies like Reaper Miniatures raise millions to expand it's product line, that's a creative use of kickstarter by an already successful business.

Then you have Lunatik and it's Tiktok, a very smart little Ipod nano holder, that got a hella jump in the marketplace because of kickstarter.

That's not to say a lot of people are not using Kickstarter to make Vaporware and bilk people out of money, but you take the same risks investing in the stockmarket, you have to weigh the risk versus the reward and use your damn brain.

Just because you, personally, don't like it, doesn't mean it's a scam.
 
Their rule about no more renders would have likely killed the Ouya or what ever the hell it was called. The android game box. If they were only allowed to show the proto board it would have likely been one ugly SOB and no one would have wanted that. I think KS just needs to reafirm with people that its not a store and that in the real world some times projects fail and investors loose their money.
 
Their rule about no more renders would have likely killed the Ouya or what ever the hell it was called. The android game box. If they were only allowed to show the proto board it would have likely been one ugly SOB and no one would have wanted that. I think KS just needs to reafirm with people that its not a store and that in the real world some times projects fail and investors loose their money.

Remember that we live in the same society that must put warning labels on knives and sharp objects asking us to not poke ourselves in the eye with them (personally I thought that was why you bought sharp objects ... the dull ones just don't seem to get the dust out of my eye well :D ) ... I think the lack of rendering is targeted at that same audience ;)
 
The general concept of Kickstarter seems like a great new way of micro-funding projects.

Apple started in Jobs garage, however, Job's dad knew a guy from Klein-Perkins who invested the $200,000+ it took to make the transition from a handmade prototype in a garage, to an actual product in a real factory. Still a "start up", but an actual business.

This micro-investing mechanism is a way for all the people who don't have a wealthy venture capitalist friend to get their project out of the "garage".

Personally I was considering a project to raise the money to pay for a patent ($10K), and to make a working prototype ($100K) of something I've invented. But I don't think under the new rules it will be possible. It is an energy storage device as an alternative to batteries for electric cars... not something where an actual unit delivered to a pledge would even make sense. Perhaps a proportional fraction of licensing fee's upon completion, kicked(starter)back might make sense. But I don't think it would be allowed under the rules.
 
Back
Top