Kentucky Senate: Computer Programming Satisfies Foreign-Language Requirement

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Every other state in the union needs to step up and follow Kentucky's lead on this.

The Kentucky Senate passed a bill Tuesday that would count computer programming classes toward fulfilling foreign-language requirements in public schools. The goal is to enhance programming skills, enabling more Kentucky students to land high-paying jobs in the growing computer industry, said Sen. David Givens, the bill’s sponsor.
 
I had a typing class count as an art credit. It was either that or theatre or painting and I knew I would be using computer (PC's weren't common then). Teacher throught I was there to hit on chicks, though, which wasn't my original idea.
 
The real problem sounds like their cirriculum is so f'up with touchy feely world citizen crap, they don't have room for a programming class.
 
I wish I could have taken any programming languages during high school to fulfill the foreign language requirement. I have 7 years of French through middle and high school, and you know how often I speak, write, or read it? Never at all. Did the experience increase my intellect? Maybe ;).
 
The real problem sounds like their cirriculum is so f'up with touchy feely world citizen crap, they don't have room for a programming class.
State requirements for Foreign Language education in middle / high school have been around forever. I had to take Spanish in middle school and that was 15 years ago. Not that I have a problem with it, but teaching computer science instead of Spanish or French is probably a wise educational decision.
 
I would prefer to require both computer and foreign language classes. I had four years of Latin in high school, and I earned a BS in Computer Science. I enjoyed both equally (plus my wife was a Latin teacher for many years).

I look at all these other countries where the students learn their own language and usually English, and Americans should be able to do so as well. Computer programming and foreign languages are two very different courses and shouldn't be lumped together. There is no reason why students can't do both.
 
I wish I could have taken any programming languages during high school to fulfill the foreign language requirement. I have 7 years of French through middle and high school, and you know how often I speak, write, or read it? Never at all. Did the experience increase my intellect? Maybe ;).
If it makes you feel better, I haven't used PASCAL or Fotran since high school, either :|
 
Hmm... Now one must also learn to code in the proper accent for the country the code will be released in!! :D

Or in a Kentucky accent for that matter...
 
State requirements for Foreign Language education in middle / high school have been around forever. I had to take Spanish in middle school and that was 15 years ago. Not that I have a problem with it, but teaching computer science instead of Spanish or French is probably a wise educational decision.
I understand this, but I suspect there's more mandated courses that have no real utility to most people than when I went to school.
 
I remember my mom telling me that when she took shorthand in HS they counted it as a foreign language.
 
I understand this, but I suspect there's more mandated courses that have no real utility to most people than when I went to school.
utility comes from technical/vocational schools

our education system is based on a liberal arts tradition (not leftist politics as some people conflate those two because they trip over the word "liberal"). education, according to this tradition, is to expand one's horizons and expose them to things they would otherwise not bother to learn about.

for example, while everyone has to take the core classes (the three r's: math, reading, writing), not everyone will take drawing. but some will. and some of those will enjoy it and become graphical artists and others will enjoy it and become animators, and some will not enjoy it and next time take computer science. some of those will become programmers and some of those will become engineers. some of the students taking foreign language will enjoy it and become translators and some of them will go on to be experts in international law or immigration lawyers.

or we could train people to work (vocational school) in factories and other blue collar jobs that no longer exist, by and large, in our country as a solid base of employment opportunity.
 
Not sure if this is actually a good idea. It will definitely promote programming language classes, which I think is a good thing. However, it does this at the expense of foreign conversational language classes. The two subjects are both languages in name, but the type of learning they provide is different.

And before many other people relay their experience of taking a foreign conversational language classes, and then never using the language... It's not just about learning a language to actually use that language. The process of learning a foreign language has been shown to increase cognitive ability in general. It is not just about the direct practical use of another language.

Both a foreign conversational language and a programming language should be required in the curriculum.
 
So we're now admitting that learning a language need not require attaining the ability to communicate with people of another culture? Fantastic. Let's change Phys Ed class to be an entirely classroom experience where you learn facts and figures about healthy lifestyles, instead of actually doing any physical activity.
 
I don't know if promoting CS at the expense of language is a good idea, but if they added it as a regular part of curriculum then that would be a good step, HS education's already dumbed down enough as is these days.
 
Can't speak for Kentucky but since most schools around here only offer Spanish in high school I'm 100% for something like this. Now if there were actually useful choices such as Mandarin, Russian or even Hindi I might feel differently.
 
I don't know if it's a good idea either but I would totally jump on the opportunity.
 
Can't speak for Kentucky but since most schools around here only offer Spanish in high school I'm 100% for something like this. Now if there were actually useful choices such as Mandarin, Russian or even Hindi I might feel differently.

Right, because Spanish is only the second-most spoken language in the world, still ahead of English. Who would need to learn that?
 
Right, because Spanish is only the second-most spoken language in the world, still ahead of English. Who would need to learn that?

Point me to a single Spanish speaking country that the economic potential of China or Russia or even India .... oh wait there isn't one.
 
Hit submit too quickly and can't edit my post ...

If you're not planning your children's education based on potential economic return then you're doing it wrong.
 
I can't imagine where you live in the US that would allow you to ignore the potential economic return of being bilingual in Spanish.
 
Point me to a single Spanish speaking country that the economic potential of China or Russia or even India .... oh wait there isn't one.

So I guess countries like Mexico, Spain, and Brazil can all go fuck themselves. They're only in the top 15 countries by GDP. Who fuckin cares, rite? :cool:
 
I can't imagine where you live in the US that would allow you to ignore the potential economic return of being bilingual in Spanish.
I know. :(

In Los Angeles, there are a lot of jobs where you won't even be considered if you don't speak Spanish because you're unable to communicate with a huge portion of the population (and their clientele) that doesn't speak English. They'll hire a bilingual Hispanic (even if their English skills are sub-par) over an American-born caucasian (whose native language is English) because they don't speak Spanish.
 
C++, VB and HTML were science credits in my HS. I can see why they'd put it in with language, but I don't think it should replace any sort of traditional language requirement.
 
So I guess countries like Mexico, Spain, and Brazil can all go fuck themselves. They're only in the top 15 countries by GDP. Who fuckin cares, rite? :cool:

I suggest you research Spain's current economic woes before you emigrate. Unless you're planning on entering the drug trade I'm not sure what economic opportunities you think exist in Mexico. As for Brazil ... they speak Portuguese not Spanish. Nice try.

There are little to no economic opportunities for US high school aged children in these countries. The same cannot be said of China, Russia and India. Further down the road there may be opportunity in other South American countries as the political climate there changes but those changes, if they occur, will impact the elementary and middle school students of today.

Today's high school students would benefit as much from Icelandic as they would from Spanish probably more so.
 
Point me to a single Spanish speaking country that the economic potential of China or Russia or even India .... oh wait there isn't one.


California. One of the world's largest economies, and Spanish is very pertinent to the real world here.


This "ruling" is silly though. I'm all for teaching kids programming, and if it were up to me I would require it. But how does this fulfill a foreign language requirement? This is a great way of keeping our youth behind the world's educational standards.
 
Now all they have to do is redefine the meaning of foreign.
According to Coca-Cola, there is no such thing as a foreign language in the United States anyway. :D

"Oh Beautiful sodi baba noh putas, America, America, oramijihiztan yacht tier from sea to shining ahkbaaar!"
 
I can't imagine where you live in the US that would allow you to ignore the potential economic return of being bilingual in Spanish.
Hispanics are mostly bilingual:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/8/8e/US_Race_Household_Income.png

Look at the economic opportunities involving business with China, and Asian-American income in the US. Seems to make a lot more sense to take Mandarin than Spanish. Spanish would have been great to know back in 1650... now, meh. Its not an international business language and not a growing developing market with a lot of opportunities.
 
Schools should require BOTH. I'm tired of people who have no ability to deal with trivial issues on their phone/tablet because they don't even understand the fundamentals of programming. If you would take a few courses you would quickly understand the most probably way to deal with the issue because you can begin to understand where the programmer may have been coming from.

They should also require courses on how to type simple questions into Google so i can stop sending links from lmgty.com
 
If you would take a few courses you would quickly understand the most probably way to deal with the issue because you can begin to understand where the programmer may have been coming from.

People don't understand how to solve problems, so they don't understand when a problem has been solved how to work backwards to understand the solution. What schools are teaching people is how to solve a specific set of problems. What really needs to be taught in schools is how to solve problems generally.

Language is an excellent example of that. Rather than teaching people a specific language, they should teach people techniques for how to learn languages generally. Once you've figured out how to learn a few languages (programming or foreign) picking up more becomes trivial.
 
I find this amusing because a friend of mine, who has only recently gotten deep into college, once asked me what foreign language would be most useful. He was really leaning towards Chinese. I told him he'd be best off learning a programming language.

I am unfortunately of a slightly older generation where I had to take French, which has been useless, although I did take Latin for personal edification. The latter was actually more useful. I also taught myself Spanish many years later because I live in the US, and I know people still lean towards Mandarin as the end-all, but let's get real. If there is ever a universal language it will be manufactured.
 
State requirements for Foreign Language education in middle / high school have been around forever. I had to take Spanish in middle school and that was 15 years ago. Not that I have a problem with it, but teaching computer science instead of Spanish or French is probably a wise educational decision.
Try just under 30 years. It started not all that long after I got out of HS.
 
I think that they should still require some foriegn language, it helps you understand english, and still has great educational qualities, maybe 1 year of programming and 1 year of foreign language.
 
Try just under 30 years. It started not all that long after I got out of HS.

Before 1920 most secondary education, whether private or public, emphasized college entry for a select few headed for college. Proficiency in Greek and Latin was emphasized

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_education_in_the_United_States

Even the Greek schools studied Latin in addition to Greek in 384 BC

Harvard College, which traces its history to 1636, had as its primary purpose the training of Latin school graduates for the ministry.
 
and when you learn Latin, you learn the roots of several other modern languages.
 
Right, because Spanish is only the second-most spoken language in the world, still ahead of English. Who would need to learn that?

Actually English is the second most spoken language in the world. While Spanish is ahead of English for spoken primary languages, there's significantly people in the world who speak English as a secondary language.
 
oh, and my high school had a requirement of 2 years of foreign language/fine arts. So I took art, drawing, and other similar classes for a couple years. Can't draw for shit, but if I took Spanish doubt I could speak it for shit either
 
Hispanics are mostly bilingual:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/8/8e/US_Race_Household_Income.png

Look at the economic opportunities involving business with China, and Asian-American income in the US. Seems to make a lot more sense to take Mandarin than Spanish. Spanish would have been great to know back in 1650... now, meh. Its not an international business language and not a growing developing market with a lot of opportunities.
we aren't talking about spanish speakers learning english but rather english speakers learning a second language.

and claiming that spanish as a second language in the current US climate is useless if an idiotic statement, at best. my Chinese partner, fluent in both mandarin and cantonese, is adamant about our children learning *both* mandarin and spanish. in her field, social work, if you can't at least speak rudimentary spanish you might as well not apply. but then again in the midwest it might not seem like a big deal. I have no idea. never been and would never go to the midwest. on either coast, from north to south, you'll need to at least understand spanish to have any sort of chance in obtaining a job over someone else who actually is bilingual in spanish.

mandarin may be important in business circles (although when I was in high school German was the big One) but for day to day life Spanish is where it's at in the US. the census data is about as clear as it gets in terms of whether spanish or mandarin is going to be something you want to learn while living and working inside the US.

as an aside, high schools aren't teaching mandarin, nor russian or arabic (which is really what people should be arguing for if we're going to be hinging this on purely economic opportunities. If you want to be a fed making 6 figures fluency in arabic would be an insta-hire in current climate). typical choices in high school languages, unless going to a specialized school like a magnet program like mine where one could learn russian, are spanish, french, and german. of those three spanish is the only sane choice in terms of vocational applicability.

I mean it's fun to talk about the 1600's but in reality Mexico, whose citizens speak spanish is about a half hour away from one of the largest economies in the world.
 
Computer programming should be a requirement, and it should NOT count as foreign language. That should be its own requirement. They have plenty of filler classes in school like study hall, there is no need to separate them. I took both. Come to think of it I am not sure I missed much of anything in school and I didn't do any extra classes or night classes or anything. So what exactly are these kids doing with all their time that they are supposed to be in school and can't be bothered to take both?

The other thing is schools need to start exploiting online learning to allow people to select whatever language they desire. Its tiring how you realize your schools chosen languages were all set up and selected for, probably at the federal level. When I was a kid they were trying to get us all to learn Japanese because they thought that was so important because the Japanese were going to own everything in America. Well we see how that went. Now they are trying to force kids to learn Chinese. But none of them have the choice to learn Indian, Portuguese, or Swahili or another African language that will give them a real edge in life. Instead like so many they will just be another one of the kids who knows Chinese. There's no diversity in the system and chances are just like Japanese by the time these kids hit the workforce the Chinese economy will have plateaued and everyone will be talking about Africa or Vietnam or something.

I also took French, what a waste of a language, but it taught me a lot about languages, and made it much easier for me to learn other languages on my own.
 
Back
Top