Judge Allows Serving Divorce Papers On Facebook

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like Facebook is becoming the go-to place to serve legal papers. We told you this stuff was going to get out of hand back when they started doing it in the UK. :(

In a landmark ruling, Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Matthew Cooper is allowing a nurse named Ellanora Baidoo to serve her elusive husband with divorce papers via a Facebook message.
 
Doesn't sound that crazy to me.

Serving papers usually just serves the purpose of having evidence that the other party has received them.

This is achievable via electronic means.
 
This is good, I'm actually quite surprised the judge wasn't an out of touch stoneager who doesn't understand tech and todays world.

Facebook has a "verified seen" feature when sending private messages, not to mention it is sent instantly to every device a user has Facebook enabled on, there's no way anyone can say "I didn't receive your notice" BS many try to do. You can't have the same benefits doing it the old way by killing a tree, writing the same message on paper, driving to a post office (wasting gas), waiting days for it to be delivered (by vehicle wasting more gas), only to not know if the person received it or not.
 
Man where was this ruling 3 years ago when I was trying to serve papers to a scumbag who was avoiding a lawsuit against them.
 
The dude is wearing body armor in the FB photo that is on the article web site. LOL.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041530305 said:
Doesn't sound that crazy to me.

Serving papers usually just serves the purpose of having evidence that the other party has received them.

This is achievable via electronic means.

I have never had a Facebook Account. My question would be, when you send someone a message via Facebook, do you always, under all circumstances, receive confirmation of delivery, and more importantly, do you receive a guaranteed acknowledgement that it was read, particularly if one has been blocked, un-friended, whatever? When it comes to serving someone papers, they must actually be confirmed as received. It's not enough to say you tried.
 
I have never had a Facebook Account. My question would be, when you send someone a message via Facebook, do you always, under all circumstances, receive confirmation of delivery, and more importantly, do you receive a guaranteed acknowledgement that it was read, particularly if one has been blocked, un-friended, whatever? When it comes to serving someone papers, they must actually be confirmed as received. It's not enough to say you tried.

My brother 'got served' via email, to the lawyer, which in turn lawyer never read (for real, did not expect an email, but papers in the mail being a lawyers office and all you know).. so he and lawyer never made the date, and of course lost.
 
The dude is wearing body armor in the FB photo that is on the article web site. LOL.

At least he's ready for the zombies. Dude also has a killer last name: "Blood-Dzraku."

Who would want a divorce for that kind of badassery?? :p:D
 
I have never had a Facebook Account. My question would be, when you send someone a message via Facebook, do you always, under all circumstances, receive confirmation of delivery, and more importantly, do you receive a guaranteed acknowledgement that it was read, particularly if one has been blocked, un-friended, whatever? When it comes to serving someone papers, they must actually be confirmed as received. It's not enough to say you tried.
Actually in a FB message it does show when the message was seen. Thats how I have gotten my boy before when I have sent him a FB message and he tries to claim he didn't see it, I show him my end of it and it shows what time he seen it, lol.
 
I have never had a Facebook Account. My question would be, when you send someone a message via Facebook, do you always, under all circumstances, receive confirmation of delivery, and more importantly, do you receive a guaranteed acknowledgement that it was read, particularly if one has been blocked, un-friended, whatever? When it comes to serving someone papers, they must actually be confirmed as received. It's not enough to say you tried.

It goes into the "other" mail box, so it's less likely to be read. But, if it is, it verifies that it was 'read'.

I can see a lot of scams doing this now. Pretty soon, it'll be ignored as there will be so many spam/scam notices that are similar to it.
 
Spot on about the scams, its true. Electronically serving someone? Okay, this is viable. However, it can't just be some random fucking message, even with a "read receipt". For instance, how about confirming the identity of the reader? Can someone say - my girlfriend opened my facebook account and clicked the message off, never telling me? How about if someone has several facebook accounts with their name - which is real? Or much worse, how about someone who DOESN'T have a facebook account? What if whomever wants to serve me finds out I don't have a facebook account, creates one in my name, logs in and says I read it? Sure, I may fight it eventually in court, if I have the money and time (ie getting someone to pull IP records etc... trying to prove the account is NOT mine ec..), but in our current faux-justice system I'd be as likely to never know I was served, have a judgement against me when I don't show up, and then have to unfuck that situation if even possible.

There's a reason that serving someone has required someone to dress up as a pizza delivery or courier service, physically touch the correct person and tell them "you've been served" then swear to it under penalty it is the right person, which has to be confirmed etc. There's no good way to do this online at the moment that is secure enough, especially when you can be served by some third party or independent private civilian. This will only go badly at current.
 
I have never had a Facebook Account. My question would be, when you send someone a message via Facebook, do you always, under all circumstances, receive confirmation of delivery, and more importantly, do you receive a guaranteed acknowledgement that it was read, particularly if one has been blocked, un-friended, whatever? When it comes to serving someone papers, they must actually be confirmed as received. It's not enough to say you tried.
If the respondent can't be located then one can publicly serve the notice as long as the claimant convinces the court that it was sufficient. In a civil proceeding this can be accomplished via notice in the local newspaper, for example. In a divorce proceeding, if there are no children or property to contest, it can be as simple as posting the proceeding in the court house.
 
Spot on about the scams, its true. Electronically serving someone? Okay, this is viable. However, it can't just be some random fucking message, even with a "read receipt". For instance, how about confirming the identity of the reader? Can someone say - my girlfriend opened my facebook account and clicked the message off, never telling me? How about if someone has several facebook accounts with their name - which is real? Or much worse, how about someone who DOESN'T have a facebook account? What if whomever wants to serve me finds out I don't have a facebook account, creates one in my name, logs in and says I read it? Sure, I may fight it eventually in court, if I have the money and time (ie getting someone to pull IP records etc... trying to prove the account is NOT mine ec..), but in our current faux-justice system I'd be as likely to never know I was served, have a judgement against me when I don't show up, and then have to unfuck that situation if even possible.

There's a reason that serving someone has required someone to dress up as a pizza delivery or courier service, physically touch the correct person and tell them "you've been served" then swear to it under penalty it is the right person, which has to be confirmed etc. There's no good way to do this online at the moment that is secure enough, especially when you can be served by some third party or independent private civilian. This will only go badly at current.
How is any of that more difficult than simply getting your friend to sign the court document stating he or she served your ex or person you're suing?

You're constructing elaborate schemes for a process that isn't particularly difficult to fake or game regardless.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041530305 said:
Doesn't sound that crazy to me.

Serving papers usually just serves the purpose of having evidence that the other party has received them.

This is achievable via electronic means.

Technically, but please show me the existing technology that assures this.

Does facebook ensure that the end user logs in to be notified? Can it guarantee the person logging in is the person who was being served?

Same thing basically goes for email read receipts. They mean nothing.

Same goes for SMS. You know it was delivered, but you can't be guaranteed who actually got it and deleted it. Was the phone lost or stolen?

If they are now suitable in the eyes of the court, why not just simply make mailing them good enough? Or faxing them?
 
Technically, but please show me the existing technology that assures this.

Does facebook ensure that the end user logs in to be notified? Can it guarantee the person logging in is the person who was being served?

Same thing basically goes for email read receipts. They mean nothing.

Same goes for SMS. You know it was delivered, but you can't be guaranteed who actually got it and deleted it. Was the phone lost or stolen?

If they are now suitable in the eyes of the court, why not just simply make mailing them good enough? Or faxing them?
mailing them has always been good enough

and the only thing you need to show the court is a signature from someone, anyone not yourself, attesting that they served the papers. It could be your sister, your uncle pappy, or Mr. IServedPapersYesterday as far as the court is concerned.
 
This is not going to stand...as has been thoughtfully pointed out, the Facebook serve is frightfully amenable to fraud. What a bad ruling, but this is what happens when the unwashed masses try to apply "what they know" to the computer realm...they mess things up badly. The judge should have his rear handed to him--he's not a computer 'expert,' obviously, else he would know why this will never work. Also, if I was Facebook I would make "serving" against my ToS, cutting off any account that tries it. If Facebook doesn't watch itself, there are governmental powers that would like nothing better than to seize/regulate the entire site (hell, with Obama, it's the entire Internet!) Let's keep the Internet cleansed of government meddling and usurpation!
 
If the respondent can't be located then one can publicly serve the notice as long as the claimant convinces the court that it was sufficient. In a civil proceeding this can be accomplished via notice in the local newspaper, for example. In a divorce proceeding, if there are no children or property to contest, it can be as simple as posting the proceeding in the court house.

I thought this was subject to State Law and not all States allowed it.
 
You're right that it would be governed by local court procedural rules rather than federal, but without looking into each jurisdiction I'd hazard a guess if there is a court that doesn't allow public notification it'd be the exception.

And keep in mind that if someone was not able to publicly notify but they didn't want to, or couldn't, notify the person via process server it's always the case as I wrote earlier that one can get someone willing to lie on a piece of paper (or just forge their signature).

Even mailing it and requiring signature doesn't "prove" in the sense that people would use it in this thread that the letter was received by the respondent. It could be anyone signing for the letter.

Point being the courts have never really been that concerned with the possibility of fraudulent notifications or to the extent that they would be concerned certainly haven't done much to thwart it. Not like the court would know unless the person who wasn't served showed up in court at the right time to explain that they weren't served.

Not sure what people are overly concerned about anyway--you can sue people without them being present and you can divorce them the same way, too. Can't stop a divorce just because you don't want it to happen. The guy dodging the papers is being an unnecessary ass anyway.
 
hmm, this sounds kind of familiar :)

interesting the paper said "landmark ruling"

Going back even farther into the past.. from Dec 24, 2012

Serving divorce papers via social media! Pioneering approach drives lawyer to a first: Divorce papers served in California from Facebook Account

Attorney Paul Staley of The Law Office of Paul Staley in San Diego decided to serve a petition for divorce on behalf of his client via Facebook. This is the first time he knows of that an order to have divorce papers served via Facebook has been granted in California.

Apparently, his client’s wife had left the country some twenty years ago and couldn’t be located.. this attorney decided to try and persuade a judge to allow him to serve the summons on the Facebook platform. The judge agreed.

What is "landmark" about this Manhattan decision?? The article doesn't say!!
 
Back
Top