Jobs: We Don't Track Anyone, Android Does

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Not to defend Steve Jobs or anything but I have a sneaking suspicion that this e-mail exchange could be fake. I'm not saying Jobs didn't say something this stupid, I'm just saying that it is easy to spoof an e-mail from Jobs. Thanks to Vermillion for the linkage.

Q: Steve, Could you please explain the necessity of the passive location-tracking tool embedded in my iPhone? It’s kind of unnerving knowing that my exact location is being recorded at all times. Maybe you could shed some light on this for me before I switch to a Droid. They don’t track me.

A: Oh yes they do. We don’t track anyone. The info circulating around is false.
 
If he'd supposedly replied with:

We don't. Droid does.

I might have believed it but... that particular response does seem quite uncharacteristic of Mr. Jobs' past answers. And it's not funny at all, not ambiguous like past answers either.

I CALL SHENANIGANS!!! :D
 
If he'd supposedly replied with:

We don't. Droid does.

I might have believed it but... that particular response does seem quite uncharacteristic of Mr. Jobs' past answers. And it's not funny at all, not ambiguous like past answers either.

I CALL SHENANIGANS!!! :D
I concur.

shenanigans.gif
 
If he'd supposedly replied with:

We don't. Droid does.

I might have believed it but... that particular response does seem quite uncharacteristic of Mr. Jobs' past answers. And it's not funny at all, not ambiguous like past answers either.

I CALL SHENANIGANS!!! :D

Android even admitted to it. See for yourself!
 
Right I'm sure. Apple has the "right" to track us...:rolleyes:

Well we all live in the digital age , if you think you still have privacy .. you need to wake up.
 
I think it's not specifically about privacy anymore, 'cause that was a wash 20+ years ago ("1984" be damned). I think it's more along the lines of companies are making money with the data collected, and consumers aren't the ones directly being benefited by the money gained to some degree. Sure it's being done, nobody would really say otherwise - except Steve Jobs, apparently, but only in the context of him pointing the finger at someone else, like Google.

But someone somewhere is making solid bank over this info even in spite of the constant claims of it being "anonymous user or usage data."

And that's enough to get folks hopping mad.
 
If he'd supposedly replied with:

We don't. Droid does.

I might have believed it but... that particular response does seem quite uncharacteristic of Mr. Jobs' past answers. And it's not funny at all, not ambiguous like past answers either.

I CALL SHENANIGANS!!! :D

I also agree...
 
Not to defend Steve Jobs or anything but I have a sneaking suspicion that this e-mail exchange could be fake. I'm not saying Jobs didn't say something this stupid, I'm just saying that it is easy to spoof an e-mail from Jobs. Thanks to Vermillion for the linkage.

Bait n' switch, old as dirt Steve....:D
 
Droid is a mobile device, it is not a mobile OS.

Late to the "Steve Jobs email party" again, eh? :D

When Jobs has responded in the past, he uses a highly ambiguous and yet carefully worded replies meant to jab a hole at whatever the question posed was about so... believe it or not, even in spite of the Droid by Motorola being an actual device, Jobs more than likely would have responded exactly as I suggested.

It's called humor, and sometimes it gets a bit thick around the edges... :p
 
Well my beef is that Android is up and front honest about it asking for your permission for tracking your info. When it's rooted, you can easily terminate the process and uninstall the APK for it. However Apple however is pushing the line going "No big deal, you're part of a cult and you signed your soul away when you bought an iPhone! If you disagree, kill yourself." This just makes me want to encourage people to jailbreak their phones so that they can deactivate this bullshit process in the background.

Now as for WP7, does anyone know if they do this passively similar to Apple apart from location services for maps/weather/news?
 
afaik information is kept on your phone and not sent to apple unlike google
so as long as you keep your device safe with you i don't see the problem.
 
Zarathustra[H];1037166576 said:
Isn't he supposed to be on extended medical leave?

Yeah but its not like he couldnt respond to email from his couch, hospital, or wherever and who at Apple is going to tell Jobs no if he wants to respond to email.
 
Super Troopers from 2001. It is seriously corny but it's hilarious at the same time. If you've ever seen or heard of "Reno 911" on Comedy Central, this is basically the inspiration for that series, iirc.
 
Where does anyone say that Apple is tracking anyone??

As far as I can tell the device/s stores your location data in an accessible file, nowhere have I seen that any group or Apple actually tracks you and accesses the data that is stored in that file.




I'm really curious as to who started the "Apple is tracking us" thing. I understand that someone can get your phone and see where you have been and that is something we all would have liked to be made aware of but it seems to be getting ridiculous.


Shit... if a bunch of people had their iphones stolen then everyone would be bitching because "wtf, they have the ability to track where my phone is but they didn't implement it?? why didn't they set that up?? I bet Apple stole my phone so I would have to buy another one."
 
Ah, think I have seen it just do not remember that scene.

Captain O'Hagan: I swear to God I'm going to pistol whip the next guy who says, "Shenanigans."
Mac: Hey. Farva...what's the name of that restaurant you like with all the goofy shit on the walls and the mozzarella sticks?
Farva: You mean Shenanigans?
Mac: OOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
Thorny: OOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
[as they hand the Captain their pistols]
 
I didn't mean to derail the thread with a movie topic.

I did like that movie though.
 
You didn't derail a thread off-track when the thread is dealing with tracking... funny how that works. ;)
 
Who really gives a fuck if they're tracking us based on whatever we've done using our phones ourselves?

I mean, seriously... Go on to Facebook or Foursquare and check out everybody checking in somewhere. People are advertising it.
 
It's been federally mandated for years that all cell phones in the US must be able to track their position. It's a fake email or he's lying. Droids do it, Blackberrys do it, I-phones do it ect...

Location, emails, texts, messaging. They track it all. Add another layer to it with this so called "Cloud" business.
 
It's been federally mandated for years that all cell phones in the US must be able to track their position. It's a fake email or he's lying. Droids do it, Blackberrys do it, I-phones do it ect...

Location, emails, texts, messaging. They track it all. Add another layer to it with this so called "Cloud" business.

I think he didn't quite lie. It's political-speak. He said WE don't track you. That's true, Apple doesn't. The iPhone just stores your location data. Apple don't give two shits where you are. Google on the other hand would because they stand to gain from gathering your travel habits. Adsense is how they make most of their money.
 
I just read this:

http://www.tomsguide.com/us/barack-obama-cool-phone-president,news-10852.html

And you have to wonder....if this tracking problem is affecting everyone else (and their are numerous websites related to this that prove this to be the case on both the andriod and iPhone platform) it must be possible to track the president as he has both an iPhone and an iPad.
Yes, if you stole his iphone, jailbroke it, and processed the tracking file.

Or...

If you broke into the white house, hacked his computer, hacked the encrypted iPhone backup, and processed the tracking file.

Then you could see the cell towers his iPhone once connected to... oh wait that's not really tracking is it.
 
Back
Top