Is there any reason to go modular?

arkk

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
175
I see that most people with higher end systems stray away from modular PSU's, and the vast majority of recommendations here are not modular units.

Is it the situation that as long as you have a decent case with a bottom mounted PSU, the reduced amount of cables is simply overrated? Or is it just the price differential between the two does not make up for the convenience of modular cabling?

I am just trying to come to a decision about whether to go modular for a new i7 build or stick with something like an ES-800, or even a 620HX.

Any advice appreciated, thanks.
 
Personal preference. Some will pay the price premium to reduce the amount of cable clutter in their systems, others don't deem it a very valuable feature.

Modular psu's generally don't have the best price/performance ratio. When I make recommendations to people on here looking to spend as little as possible but still get a good psu, I don't even take that factor into account. If it is, cool, if not, it's irrelevant unless they ask.

For me, personally, I really like minimizing the cables and clutter.
 
Yeah modular PSUs do have a poor price to performance ratio with quality modular PSUs costing roughly $30 to $60 more than their non-modular counterparts.

I personally love my 520HX and its modular cables. However, when I bought it back in 2007, it was one of the few PSUs in the price and wattage range actually worth buying, modular or not.

EDIT: Oh forgot to add: Since I ended up using most of the cables anyway, the modular cables was only useful for a year or two. So personally, if I had to choose between a non-modular PSU of higher wattage VS a modular PSU of lower wattage, with both PSUs of high quality and same price, I'd go with the non-modular PSU.
 
My 1000HX Corsair has one Fixed mobo power cable, one cpu power cable and two pcie cables. Only other cable I needed was a SATA from the Modular side and that my friends is nice without all that other clutter. I will never go back to none modular PSU's again.
 
My 1000HX Corsair has one Fixed mobo power cable, one cpu power cable and two pcie cables. Only other cable I needed was a SATA from the Modular side and that my friends is nice without all that other clutter. I will never go back to none modular PSU's again.

Same for me except I use the Antec 1000 Quattro. I don't know what I would do with all of the extra cables if it was not modular.
 
Personal preference and varying needs. Personally, I went with PC Power and Cooling 750w (red one) because many people recommended it and it was well priced. That was the ultimate decision for me. Next time, I may go modular since I don't like all the cable clutter, but price and recommendations may trump that. Just depends.
 
The reason to do it is less cables in the case, and easier management of the cables you do have. This can be important if you get something like a 1000 watt supply which will normally have a ton of cables, and you don't have a ton of devices.

The reason not to do it is just cost. Because of the extra hardware to have connectors, they cost more.
 
Never going to non modular. Corsair 620 HX for 80 back when it first came out was a killer deal >:)
 
Once you go modular, you never go back. Clutter sucks, and unused wires only hinder airflow and/or cable management.
 
personaly i don't like modular as i can hide my excess very well and i don't want added resistances from the extra connections.

 
personaly i don't like modular as i can hide my excess very well and i don't want added resistances from the extra connections.
The added resistance is completely negligible. Any decent PSU will compensate for it.
 
compensate for what? im talking about possible burnt connectors or another failure point.

I'm talking about any lost voltage due to the additional resistance. Since the resistance is what you mentioned, I assumed you were talking about reduced voltage as a result of that. And there is very little chance of a modular connector failing or burning up. It's about as likely as a molex connector on a non-modular PSU doing the same thing.
 
I'm talking about any lost voltage due to the additional resistance. Since the resistance is what you mentioned, I assumed you were talking about reduced voltage as a result of that. And there is very little chance of a modular connector failing or burning up. It's about as likely as a molex connector on a non-modular PSU doing the same thing.

i can see where u think i was talking about voltage. the chance of a molex connector failing is higher than u think. in my experience with thousands of military computers i have seen it happen plenty of times. less connectors less chance of failing.

u can get what u want but i chose non modular for the reasons above.

 
i can see where u think i was talking about voltage. the chance of a molex connector failing is higher than u think. in my experience with thousands of military computers i have seen it happen plenty of times. less connectors less chance of failing.

u can get what u want but i chose non modular for the reasons above.
Fair enough. Everyone has their preferences.
 
I like the modular ones, I was concerned about added resistances due to the connections, but the Corsair ones at least have very nice, tight fitting plugs. The price per watt tho is quite a bit more :(
 
Back
Top