Is my RAM bottlenecking my system?

da233

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 3, 2007
Messages
303
I have a P4 3.2, 1 gig of DDR333 dual channel, 7200 rpm sata HD, and an HD 3850 agp card which I recently bought.

Yes, I know the P4 is the main bottleneck of my system but, how much would upgrading the RAM to 2 gigs or more improve my gaming frames?

In TF2, for example... I seem to have a hard time running the game with High textures. If I were to run around a corner into a new room, my game would slow down considerably for a second (as if it were "loading" the new textures) and then the game would run better after that new area gets "loaded". Same goes for almost all other games.

Is this a sign of a processor bottleneck or a memory bottleneck?
 
By the way, I'm running Vista so that doesn't really help the RAM situation either :p

Regardless though, the only thing I care to know is whether or not getting more ram will improve my gaming frames noticeably, because I'm 100% sure my video card isn't being pushed to it's full potention (I should be able to run TF2 with near max settings with that card)
 
DDR333? Is that DDR3 or DDR2 333MHz?

Lol. I can't even fathom playing TF2 on your system, to be honest. You must be working your system pretty hard to run TF2 on your computer.

Your ram and graphics card probably bottleneck TF2 a decent amount. Graphics card depends more on your resolution (or monitor size) and the graphics details settings.

Conclusion: Yes, more ram would probably help. But your system overall could use a boost. (EDIT) Particularly if you are running Vista.
 
Eh, it's DDR1 :(

I don't have money for a full upgrade right now and I'm planning on sticking with this system until the affordable Nehalem processors come out.

The funny thing is that I can play CoD4 in 1680x1050 (my monitors native res) with medium settings and get 30-40 frames, however TF2 is giving me major trouble.

I already explained to you how it was acting, the game feels like it's getting lagged when I turn into a new room or something and it would lag for a second to load the new textures, after that, the fps goes back up to a playable rate until I move into another area and the process repeats itself.

My question is simply, does this sound like a processor or memory bottleneck?
 
Upgrading your ram might help a bit but I doubt it. You need a new system. Source games in particular are very CPU dependent and that P4 just doesn't cut it.
 
The Source engine isn't a RAM hog, IIRC, so I doubt it would help much. See if you can borrow another 1GB of RAM from a friend to try it out. :p
 
Keep in mind that I'm using Vista. I just checked a moment ago and with no programs running, my task manager shows that 770 mb's of ram are used up.

Obviously, I know I will get some kind of improvement with TF2 when I'm using a high resolution and high textures, but the question is, how much of an improvement should I expect?
 
K but the question is, how much of an improvement should I expect?

From what? A RAM upgrade or CPU upgrade?

RAM upgrade, probably not that much. CPU upgrade, big improvement. IIRC, TF2 is a bit heavy on the CPU. I see 50% CPU usage on the Gaming Rig in my sig.
 
CPU upgrade is kind of out of the question because that would require me to get a new motherboard (i think).

When you say "probably not that much", how much do you mean? I'm running TF2 at around 20fps at 1440x900, and something as little as a 10 fps boost would make the game from "kind of playable" to "completely playable" for me.

How exactly do I identify between whether the cpu or memory is bottlenecking my system? Already explained how my games are... I get smooth frames most of the time but whenever I turn into a new area (with new textures that need to be loaded), that's when my system starts choking up and the fps goes down for a bit.
 
No way are you going to get a 50% increase from adding more ram. You need a new CPU, as me and Danny said source games are very CPU intensive. If it only gets really bad when you go into new areas you only have one option till you upgrade the CPU, you're going to have to start camping more :D
 
On second thought, a RAM upgrade would help. However I can't say with any uncertainty how much of a FPS improvement you'll see. But considering that a quick game of TF2 took close to 800MB of RAM on my system, a RAM upgrade for you would not hurt.
 
dude i upgraded my computer, but before i had a p4 3.2 ghz with a geforce fx 5600(fail). I ran all my settings pretty much on low but it worked fine. I only had 1.5 gigs of ram but i did have xp. I had cheap value ram 333mhz
 
Back
Top