Is Left 4 Dead Getting Ripped Off?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Today must be "idea theft day" and no one told me. This is the second news story about someone ripping off someone else's idea and it isn't even lunch time yet. :eek:

The demo for Yakuza: Of The End shows some of the zombies that appear in the game. They seem to be either homages or very blatant rip-offs of the Left 4 Dead zombies. In the Yakuza game, there's a L4D-type "Boomer" zombie called "Metabo" (referring to metabolic syndrome), a L4D-type "Tank" zombie called "Dekamacho" (big macho) and a L4D-type "Witch" zombie called "Nakionna" (crying lady). The Witch zombie continues crying when she appears, until she's disturbed.
 
Guy in an unregulated Asian country copying a popular American item so he can make a quick buck illegally, nothing out of the ordinary here........ if it happens in Japan, they always make it look very lame / anime like the other 2 bajillion super-lame, repetitive anime games that the japs put out.

All I have to say is it definitely won't sell but to maybe a few guys who don't get out of their house much, that's a given
 
You'll probably be able to romance the zombies and pilot mechs for no logical reason.
 
I don't think its fair to make that assumption until the games out.
 
isn't the crying girl type "spirit" originally Japanese in origin? Ringu? Other ones I don't think were original to the L4D franchise, but I could be wrong.
 
isn't the crying girl type "spirit" originally Japanese in origin? Ringu? Other ones I don't think were original to the L4D franchise, but I could be wrong.

Yeah, it's a Japanese thing, and I was actually all prepared to say 'Zombies looks zombies from other games? Not surprised' but the article actually shows they copied it without differences. The big fat zombie has pustules on both games that look identical. Both almost look like they share geometric models for the tank character.

I usually think 'So and so copied so and so' is BS, but in this case I think it's a bit too obvious one did in fact look at what the other did before making their own creation.
 
Even the icons for the moltov, health pack and weapons slots on the HUD are identical! If this pisses me off, I can't imagine how the people who actually made L4D feel.
 
Agree, the models look like less work was put into changing them than even a regular modder would do.
 
lol the textures do look better though ;) The boomer is fatter than ever.
 
Hmm
Zombies movies?: Started in US
Zombie Games?: Started in Japan? Was the first one resident evil//house of the dead in Japan? Or are we willing to count like Hugo Halloween's House of Horrors(really old-game) for the 386, etc? Aka old-dos based games?

In any case, I think L4D in itself only came into existence because of the popularity of the zombie-genre which was been greatly driven by Resident evil games, products, tv shows, movies, etc. So L4D may be a bit of a copy of other games. Really though, the idea that people come in differnet sizes and therefore zombies will seems pretty ...standard. What? There are petite guys/girls, medium size? such as athletic or a little chubby and then large sized people? Therefore zombies would come in all three forms? Shocking!
 
Guy in an unregulated Asian country copying a popular American item so he can make a quick buck illegally, nothing out of the ordinary here........ if it happens in Japan, they always make it look very lame / anime like the other 2 bajillion super-lame, repetitive anime games that the japs put out.

All I have to say is it definitely won't sell but to maybe a few guys who don't get out of their house much, that's a given

Angry much kid?
 
Hmm
Zombies movies?: Started in US
Zombie Games?: Started in Japan? Was the first one resident evil//house of the dead in Japan? Or are we willing to count like Hugo Halloween's House of Horrors(really old-game) for the 386, etc? Aka old-dos based games?

In any case, I think L4D in itself only came into existence because of the popularity of the zombie-genre which was been greatly driven by Resident evil games, products, tv shows, movies, etc. So L4D may be a bit of a copy of other games. Really though, the idea that people come in differnet sizes and therefore zombies will seems pretty ...standard. What? There are petite guys/girls, medium size? such as athletic or a little chubby and then large sized people? Therefore zombies would come in all three forms? Shocking!

The models are very similar looking but who really gives a shit? l4d copied the success of zombie mods.
 
Well, Left 4 Dead was just a rip off of Killing Floor, so it all works out in the end. :)
 
Guy in an unregulated Asian country copying a popular American item so he can make a quick buck illegally, nothing out of the ordinary here........ if it happens in Japan, they always make it look very lame / anime like the other 2 bajillion super-lame, repetitive anime games that the japs put out.

It's 2011, not 1942....

Jap is an English abbreviation of the word "Japanese". Today it is generally regarded as an ethnic slur, although English-speaking countries differ in the degree to which they consider the term offensive. In the United States, Japanese Americans have come to find the term controversial or offensive, even when used as an abbreviation.[1] In the past, Jap was not considered primarily offensive; however, during and after the events of World War II, the term became derogatory.[2]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jap
 
Not like we ever ripped those Asians off of any of their ideas... like pokemon to digimon... pshhh that's a coincidence they sound the same, it's not like they have the same exact concept or anything...
 
Technically,isn't every movie or game that feature flesh eating zombies rip-offs of "Night of the Living Dead"?
 
Technically,isn't every movie or game that feature flesh eating zombies rip-offs of "Night of the Living Dead"?

L4D doesn't have flesh eating zombies. It's more like the rage virus in 28 Days Later. That's why they are called "infected" not zombies. Just thought I'd point that out
 
I guess there is a pretty key distinction to be made there. Demonic forces reanimating the dead vs. a virus that causes zombie-like behavior and appearance.
 
All I have to say is it definitely won't sell but to maybe a few guys who don't get out of their house much, that's a given
That series is VERY VERY popular here. Oh and it's fun as hell too.
 
I've played more L4D than I probably should have, and ... WOW that's really a blatant rip-off ! It's one thing to copy an idea, but they've brazenly copied a lot of artwork and models. How hard-up for work would one have to be to be involved in such a shameful rip-off that probably won't make a dime anyway ? Disgusting.
 
Back
Top