Is it worth $100 to....

foamfoot

n00b
Joined
Jan 25, 2007
Messages
3
pick-up a Bad Axe 2 and an e6600 over the P5B-Deluxe and a e6400.

It seems the general consensus is that the 6600 is not worth the $100 price difference over the 6400. However, after weeks of reading and watching prices on Newegg and Mwave the Bad Axe 2 has gone down to where its almost cheaper than the Asus. I can get the Bad Axe 2 and 6600 for 504 from MWave or the P5B-D and 6400 for 401 from newegg.

From what I've read, the 6600 really shines on the 975 platform while the 6400 would be best on the 965 - my (possibly flawed) reasoning for not going 6400 and Bad Axe 2. If it matters, running 2 gig Firestix pc2-6400 and an 8800 GTS. System will be used for Hi-Res gaming on a 21" LCD.

Thanks in advance for any feedback. I've been a lurker for years and this is my 3rd system being built with the help of you guys mostly through the search engine.
 
100% go for the E6600/BadAxe setup... you'll have better performance not only from the extra cache in newer games coming like Supreme Commander, but also the 975X/E6600 really shine together. Obviously, you also get the higher multiplier/binning on the E6600, which is important for the lower-FSB-overclock-typically 975X boards (they still outperform the 965 clock-for-clock). I had the same dilemma around when the Conroes were first coming out, between a 965/E6400 or a 975X/E6600... I flip-flopped a few times, and finally decided to shell out the extra money for the more powerful setup. From the benches I've seen, and how well this setup performs, I'm glad I did :). Remember, you can't upgrade CPU cache.

My specs, if you're curious are:

Asus P5W DH Deluxe (975X, ATX motherboard) @ 380FSB
eVGA 8800GTS @ stock (fiddling on overclocking still)
E6600 Conroe @ 3.42ghz/core
2GB OCZ Platinum XTC (first revision) 2x1GB sticks DDR2-800 (PC2-6400)

along with opticals, HDD's, etc., all crammed into an X-Qpack I modded to accept ATX instead of only mATX boards. It performs beautifully :D!
 
yeah I think I'd get that.

Though I personally probably wouldn't have been looking at the P5B Deluxe since you can get other boards for cheaper that overclock just as well. Like the DS3 or P5B-E. So the difference for me would be more like $150 between the options.

Well you can see what I went with from my sig. Though I got an early week 24 e6600 which doesn't overclock that great.
:( ( 3Ghz easily with a little extra juice, 3.2Ghz with lots of volts, most newer chips are doing these clocks at default!)

my set up: http://www.crowdcontrolusa.com/overclock/shizzy3.html
 
Back
Top